Effect of ausforming on isothermal transformation below the martensite start temperature in NiCrMoV steel: an in-situ neutron diffraction study

Abstract

In-situ neutron diffraction during the thermomechanical controlled processing was employed to investigate the effect of ausforming on isothermal transformation below the martensite start temperature (Ms) in the NiCrMoV steel. After the occurrence of athermal martensitic transformation during cooling of the austenitized sample, the isothermal transformation below the Ms proceeded in two distinct stages: Stage 1, characterized by a rapid transformation rate, and Stage 2, which progressed more slowly. Ausforming suppressed both the athermal martensitic transformation and isothermal transformation in Stage 1 through mechanical stabilization. In contrast, ausforming accelerated the isothermal transformation in Stage 2, likely due to the enhanced carbon diffusion, indicating bainitic transformation characteristics in this stage. The resulting microstructure consisting of tempered martensite, bainite and retained austenite exhibited an excellent strength-ductility balance, achieving an ultimate tensile strength of 1989 MPa, a uniform elongation of 7.1%, and a total elongation of 16%. The present study provides new insights into phase transformation mechanisms below Ms and demonstrates the potential of ausforming-assisted processing for enhancing the mechanical properties of high-strength steels.

Keywords

Ausforming / bainitic transformation / martensitic transformation / in-situ neutron diffraction / microstructure / mechanical properties

References

[1] Ohmori Y,Kunitake T.The mechanical properties of low-carbon low-alloy bainitic steels.ISIJ Int1972;12:146-54

[2] Garcia-mateo C.Ultra-high-strength bainitic steels.ISIJ Int2005;45:1736-40

[3] Singh S.Estimation of bainite plate-thickness in low-alloy steels.Mater Sci Eng: A1998;245:72-9

[4] Caballero FG,Mawella KJA,Brown P.Very strong low temperature bainite.Mater. Sci. Technol2002;18:279-84

[5] García-mateo C.The role of retained austenite on tensile properties of steels with bainitic microstructures.Mater Trans2005;46:1839-46

[6] Ohtani H,Fujishiro Y.Morphology and properties of low-carbon bainite.Metall Trans A1990;21:877-88

[7] Kurdjumov GV.Kinetics of the transformation of austenite into martensite at low temperatures.Dokl Akad Nauk1948;61:83-6Available from: https://chemport-n.cas.org//chemport-n/?APP=ftslink&action=reflink&origin=npg&version=1.0&coi=1%3ACAS%3A528%3ADyaH1MXksFc%3D&md5=028fa2d6d383701e12ceaf69833079f2 (accessed on 2025-8-1)

[8] Thadhani NN.Kinetics of isothermal martensitic transformation.Prog Mater Sci1986;30:1-37

[9] Pati S.Nucleation of the isothermal martensitic transformation.Acta Metallurgica1969;17:189-99

[10] Kajiwara S.Mechanism of isothermal martensitic transformation.Mater Trans, JIM1992;33:1027-34

[11] Lobodyuk VA.Isothermal martensitic transformations.Phys -Usp2005;48:713-32

[12] Hsu TY,Weiye C.Isothermal martensite formation in an AISI 52100 ball bearing steel.Metall Trans A1987;18:1389-94

[13] Kim D,De Cooman BC.Microstructure of low C steel isothermally transformed in the M_s to M_f temperature range.Metall Mater Trans A2012;43:4967-83

[14] Okamoto H.Lower bainite with midrib in hypereutectoid steels.Metall Trans A1986;17:1113-20

[15] Bohemen S MC,Sietsma J.Experimental evidence for bainite formation below M_s in Fe-0.66 C.Scripta Mater2008;58:488-91

[16] Samanta S,Giri S,Kundu S.Formation of bainite below the MS temperature: kinetics and crystallography.Acta Mater2016;105:390-403

[17] Navarro-López A,Sietsma J.Characterization of bainitic/martensitic structures formed in isothermal treatments below the Ms temperature.Mater Charact2017;128:248-56.

[18] Zhao L,Zhou Q.The combining effects of ausforming and below-Ms or above-Ms austempering on the transformation kinetics, microstructure and mechanical properties of low-carbon bainitic steel.Mater Des2019;183:108123

[19] Ravi AM,Sietsma J.Influence of martensite/austenite interfaces on bainite formation in low-alloy steels below Ms.Acta Mater2020;188:394-405

[20] Navarro-lópez A,Sietsma J.Unravelling the mechanical behaviour of advanced multiphase steels isothermally obtained below M.Mater Des2020;188:108484

[21] De-castro D,Vivas J.Examining the multi-scale complexity and the crystallographic hierarchy of isothermally treated bainitic and martensitic structures.Mater Charact2020;160:110127

[22] Shirzadi AA,Pocock L,Withers PJ.Bainite orientation in plastically deformed austenite.Int J Mater Res2009;100:40-5

[23] Tsuzaki K,Tomota Y.Effect of prior deformation of austenite on the γ → ε; martensitic transformation in Fe-Mn alloys.Mater Trans, JIM1991;32:222-8

[24] Maalekian M,Chatterjee S.Mechanical stabilisation of eutectoid steel.Mater Sci Technol2007;23:610-2

[25] Gong W,Adachi Y,Kelleher JF.Effects of ausforming temperature on bainite transformation, microstructure and variant selection in nanobainite steel.Acta Mater2013;61:4142-54

[26] Miyamoto G,Takayama N.Quantitative analysis of variant selection in ausformed lath martensite.Acta Mater2012;60:1139-48

[27] Uenishi A.Development of advanced high strength sheet steel for NSaf^TM-AutoConcept.Nippon Steel Sumitomo Met Tech Rep2019;118:1-6Available from: https://www.nipponsteel.com/en/tech/report/pdf/122 (accessed on 2025-8-1)

[28] Gong W,Harjo S,Aizawa K.Effect of prior martensite on bainite transformation in nanobainite steel.Acta Mater2015;85:243-9

[29] Shibata A,Park N.Nature of dynamic ferrite transformation revealed by in-situ neutron diffraction analysis during thermomechanical processing.Scripta Mater2019;165:44-9

[30] Gong W,Tomota Y.Lattice parameters of austenite and martensite during transformation for Fe-18Ni alloy investigated through in-situ neutron diffraction.Acta Mater2023;250:118860

[31] McNaughton WP,Jaffee RI.“Superclean” 3.5 NiCrMoV turbine rotor steel: a status report - Part I: steelmaking practice, heat treatment, and metallurgical properties.J Mater Eng1991;13:9-18

[32] Harjo S,Aizawa K.Current status of engineering materials diffractometer at J-PARC.Mater Sci Forum2011;681:443-8

[33] I. Deformation-induced martensitic transformation and transformation-induced plasticity in steels.Met Sci1982;16:245-53

[34] Oishi-Tomiyasu R,Morishima T.Application of matrix decomposition algorithms for singular matrices to the Pawley method in Z-Rietveld.J Appl Crystallogr2012;45:299-308

[35] Bhadeshia HKDH.The lower bainite transformation and the significance of carbide precipitation.Acta Metall1982;28:1103-14

[36] Ohmori Y,Ueno H,Ohtsubo H.Crystallographic analysis of upper bainite in Fe-9% Ni-C alloys.Mater Trans, JIM1996;37:1665-71

[37] Chang LC.Stress-affected transformation to lower bainite.J Mater Sci1996;31:2145-8

[38] Bhadeshia HKDH. Bainite in Steels; Institute of Materials: London, 1992.

[39] Kawata H,Sugiura N,Takahashi M.Effect of martensite in initial structure on bainite transformation.Mater Sci Forum2010;638-42:3307-12

[40] Toji Y,Raabe D.Effect of Si on the acceleration of bainite transformation by pre-existing martensite.Acta Mater2016;116:250-62

[41] Ribamar GG,Da Silva AK.Austenite carbon enrichment and decomposition during quenching and tempering of high silicon high carbon bearing steel.Acta Mater2023;247:118742

[42] Kulin SA.Isothermal martensite formation in an iron-chromium-nickel alloy.Metals1952;4:258-63

[43] Cohen M,Paranjpe VG. In Thermodynamics in Physical Metallurgy; American Society for Metals: Cleveland, 1950; p 242.

[44] Roitburd AL.The nature of martensitic transformations.Mater Sci Eng1979;39:141-67

[45] Cohen M.Martensitic nucleation-revisited.Mater Trans, JIM1992;33:178-83

[46] Ravi AM,Santofimia MJ.Exploring bainite formation kinetics distinguishing grain-boundary and autocatalytic nucleation in high and low-Si steels.Acta Mater2016;105:155-64

[47] Lin M,Cohen M.Distributed-activation kinetics of phase transformations in steel.Metall Trans A1992;23:2987-98

[48] S. Continuous observation of isothermal martensite formation in Fe-Ni-Mn alloys.Acta Metall1984;32:407-13

[49] Santofimia MJ,Petrov R,Van Der Zwaag S.Influence of interface mobility on the evolution of austenite-martensite grain assemblies during annealing.Acta Mater2009;57:4548-57

[50] Dai Z,Yang Z,Chen H.Elucidating the effect of Mn partitioning on interface migration and carbon partitioning during quenching and partitioning of the Fe-C-Mn-Si steels: modeling and experiments.Acta Mater2018;144:666-78

[51] Aaronson HI,Purdy GR.The incomplete transformation phenomenon in steel.Metall Mater Trans A2006;37:1731-45

[52] Kaufman L.Thermodynamics and kinetics of martensitic transformations.Prog Met Phys1958;7:165-246

[53] Toji Y,Raabe D.Carbon partitioning during quenching and partitioning heat treatment accompanied by carbide precipitation.Acta Mater2015;86:137-47

[54] Celada-Casero C,Santofimia MJ.The role of the austenite grain size in the martensitic transformation in low carbon steels.Mater Des2019;167:107625

[55] Mimkes J.Calculations of dislocation pipe diffusion.J Phys Colloques1979;C6:181-3

[56] Zorgani M,Jahazi M.Microstructural evolution during tempering of an ausformed carbide-free low temperature bainitic steel.Mater Des2021;210:110082

[57] Bhadeshia HKDH,Vitek JM.Stress induced transformation to bainite in Fe-Cr-Mo-C pressure vessel steel.Mater Sci Technol1991;7:686-98