Lattice softening in thermoelectric materials

Abstract

Lattice softening refers to reducing the lattice stiffness of materials by weakening the binding force between atoms, thereby changing the electron and phonon transport characteristics. The advantage of lattice softening compared to other strategies for optimizing the properties of thermoelectric materials is that it can significantly reduce the lattice thermal conductivity by reducing the sound velocity without significantly affecting the electrical properties. Moreover, lattice softening shows a wide range of application potential in other material fields, such as magnetostrictive materials and intermetallic alloys. However, systematic reviews on the causes, effects, and specific applications of lattice softening in thermoelectric materials are still limited. This review introduces the recent progress of lattice softening in thermoelectric materials, focusing on how to achieve it and its mechanism in optimizing thermoelectric performance. Through mechanical strain engineering, chemical doping, and phase transition strategies to achieve lattice softening, one could lower the phonon speed, reduce the lattice thermal conductivity, and optimize the Seebeck coefficient and conductivity. In the outlook section, the potential applications of lattice softening in sustainable energy technologies are explored.

Keywords

Thermoelectric materials / lattice softening / phonon transport / lattice thermal conductivity

References

[1] Tan Z,Yang M.Energy and economic performance comparison of heat pump and power cycle in low grade waste heat recovery.Energy2022;260:125149

[2] Lu X,Shi Z,Lou Y.Recent advances in interface engineering of thermoelectric nanomaterials.Mater Chem Front2023;7:4707-22

[3] Chen Y,Li L.Enlightening thermoelectric mastery: bio-inspired cellulose gel containing eco-friendly deep eutectic solvents.Chem Eng J2024;483:149344

[4] Miao L,Liu C.Comfortable wearable thermoelectric generator with high output power.Nat Commun2024;15:8516 PMCID:PMC11445405

[5] Beretta D,Lanzani G.Organic flexible thermoelectric generators: from modeling, a roadmap towards applications.Sustain Energy Fuels2017;1:174-90

[6] Yang SE,Son JS.Recent progress in 3D printing of Bi₂Te₃-based thermoelectric materials and devices.J Phys Energy2024;6:022003

[7] Muddasar M,Quero Á.Highly-efficient sustainable ionic thermoelectric materials using lignin-derived hydrogels.Adv Compos Hybrid Mater2024;7:863

[8] Li C,Liu C,Xu J.Present and future thermoelectric materials toward wearable energy harvesting.Appl Mater Today2019;15:543-57

[9] Du K.An innovative tubular thermoelectric generator (TTEG) for enhanced waste heat recovery in industrial and automotive applications.Appl Sci2024;14:685

[10] Wang J,Liu Y,Cai R.Harvesting waste heat based on thermoelectric generation to drive LED car lamps.J Therm Anal Calorim2024;149:3427-42

[11] Su H,Lu H.Efficient solar-thermal conversion and thermal energy storage towards personal thermal management and thermoelectric power generation enabled by massive screen printing of carbon nanotube dopped energy storage gels.J Energy Storage2024;76:109782

[12] Lewis NS.Research opportunities to advance solar energy utilization.Science2016;351:aad1920

[13] Chen C,Wu Y.Manipulating hetero-nanowire films for flexible and multifunctional thermoelectric devices.Adv Mater2024;36:e2400020

[14] Han Y,Du Y.Ultrasensitive flexible thermal sensor arrays based on high-thermopower ionic thermoelectric hydrogel.Adv Sci (Weinh)2023;10:e2302685 PMCID:PMC10477880

[15] Gu H,Fu Y.High seebeck coefficient inorganic Ge₁₅Ga₁₀Te₇₅ core/polymer cladding fibers for respiration and body temperature monitoring.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2023;15:59768-75

[16] Gupta A,Pal Y.Effect of thermoelectric materials in electrical and thermal performance of photovoltaic thermal (PVT) collector.IOP Conf Ser: Mater Sci Eng2019;691:012036

[17] Zhang Y,Zhang F.Soft organic thermoelectric materials: principles, current state of the art and applications.Small2022;18:e2104922

[18] Shi XL,Chen ZG.Advanced thermoelectric design: from materials and structures to devices.Chem Rev2020;120:7399-515

[19] He J,Tan X.Synthesis of SnTe/AgSbSe₂ nanocomposite as a promising lead-free thermoelectric material.J Materiomics2016;2:165-71

[20] Zhang C,Li Z.Enhanced thermoelectric performance of solution-derived bismuth telluride based nanocomposites via liquid-phase Sintering.Nano Energy2016;30:630-8

[21] Chen Y,Qin W.Integration of boron nitride into tin-enriched SnSe₂ for a high-performance thermoelectric nanocomposite with optimized electrical transport and mechanical properties.Adv Funct Mater2025;202425050

[22] Liu W,Li L.Grain boundary re-crystallization and sub-nano regions leading to high plateau figure of merit for Bi₂Te₃ nanoflakes.Energy Environ Sci2023;16:5123-35

[23] Gordillo JM,Sierra CD,Fonseca L.Recent advances in silicon-based nanostructures for thermoelectric applications.APL Materials2023;11:040702

[24] Yao G,Wang S.Boosting thermoelectric performance of PbBi₂Te₄ via reduced carrier scattering and intensified phonon scattering.Small2024;20:e2400449

[25] Tan X,Shao H.Improving thermoelectric performance of α-mgagsb by theoretical band engineering design.Adv Energy Mater2017;7:1700076

[26] Yu L,Wang LJ.Band engineering and phonon engineering Effectively improve n-type Mg₃Sb₂ thermoelectric material properties.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2023;15:53594-603

[27] Slade TJ,Wood M.Charge-carrier-mediated lattice softening contributes to high zT in thermoelectric semiconductors.Joule2021;5:1168-82

[28] Hanus R,Rettie AJE.Lattice softening significantly reduces thermal conductivity and leads to high thermoelectric efficiency.Adv Mater2019;31:e1900108

[29] Tan G,Hanus RC.High thermoelectric performance in SnTe-AgSbTe₂ alloys from lattice softening, giant phonon-vacancy scattering, and valence band convergence.ACS Energy Lett2018;3:705-12

[30] Muchtar AR,Tonquesse SL.Physical insights on the lattice softening driven mid-temperature range thermoelectrics of Ti/Zr-inserted SnTe - an outlook beyond the horizons of conventional phonon scattering and excavation of heikes’ equation for estimating carrier properties.Adv Energy Mater2021;11:2101122

[31] Liu M,Zhu J.High-performance CaMg₂Bi₂-based thermoelectric materials driven by lattice softening and orbital alignment via cadmium doping.Adv Funct Mater2024;34:2316075

[32] Shen X,Chen Q.Synergistically optimized thermoelectric properties of Ag_1+xIn₅Se₈ alloys.Inorg Chem Front2019;6:3545-53

[33] Zhong J,Lyu T.Nuanced dilute doping strategy enables high-performance GeTe thermoelectrics.Sci Bull (Beijing)2024;69:1037-49

[34] Tippireddy S,Vikram .Local structural distortions and reduced thermal conductivity in Ge-substituted chalcopyrite.J Mater Chem A2022;10:23874-85

[35] Parashchuk T,Cherniushok O,Wojciechowski KT.High thermoelectric performance of p-type PbTe enabled by the synergy of resonance scattering and lattice softening.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2021;13:49027-42

[36] Chen Y,Wu Y.Giant heterogeneous magnetostriction induced by charge accumulation-mediated nanoinclusion formation in dual-phase nanostructured systems.Acta Materialia2021;213:116975

[37] Guan C,Jiang L.Atomic-scale insights into ω-variants in Galfenol triggered by displacive-diffusive transformation.Mater Design2021;205:109745

[38] Rahman N,Liu X,Yan M.Enhanced magnetostriction of Fe₈₁Ga₁₉ by approaching an instable phase boundary.Scripta Materialia2018;146:200-3

[39] Guo S,Lu Y,Hu X.Lattice softening enables highly reversible sodium storage in anti-pulverization Bi-Sb alloy/carbon nanofibers.Energy Storage Mater2020;27:270-8

[40] Mizoguchi H,Hosono H.A view on formation gap in transition metal hydrides and its collapse.J Am Chem Soc2021;143:11345-8

[41] Yang J,Ge B.Effect of Zn migration on the thermoelectric properties of Zn₄Sb₃ material.Ceram Int2017;43:15275-80

[42] Zhang D,Liu G.High thermoelectric performance of PbSe via a synergistic band engineering and dislocation approach.Scripta Materialia2024;244:116003

[43] Bai Y,Ouyang T.High thermoelectric performance in the n-type Bi₂S₃/f-MWCNTs nanocomposites prepared by hydrothermal method.Carbon2023;212:118158

[44] Lv HY,Shao DF,Sun YP.Strain-induced enhancement in the thermoelectric performance of a ZrS₂ monolayer.J Mater Chem C2016;4:4538-45

[45] Guo Z,Yin W.Atomistic origin of lattice softness and its impact on structural and carrier dynamics in three dimensional perovskites.Energy Environ Sci2022;15:660-71

[46] Zhang G.Strain effects on thermoelectric properties of two-dimensional materials.Mech Mater2015;91:382-98

[47] Wu Y,Nan P.Lattice strain advances thermoelectrics.Joule2019;3:1276-88

[48] Sprague LW,Song J.Maximizing thermoelectric figures of merit by uniaxially straining indium selenide.J Phys Chem C2019;123:25437-47

[49] Yu C,Zhang Y.Strain engineering on the thermal conductivity and heat flux of thermoelectric Bi₂Te₃ nanofilm.Nano Energy2015;17:104-10

[50] Song X,Gan S.Triaxial strain enhanced thermoelectric performance and conversion efficiency in Tl₃TaSe₄.J Alloys Compd2024;1004:175896

[51] Huang M,Chen C,Heinz TF.Phonon softening and crystallographic orientation of strained graphene studied by Raman spectroscopy.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A2009;106:7304-8 PMCID:PMC2678610

[52] Xu B,Fang Z.Extremely suppressed thermal conductivity of large-scale nanocrystalline silicon through inhomogeneous internal strain engineering.J Mater Chem A2023;11:19017-24

[53] Moure A,Abad B.Thermoelectric skutterudite/oxide nanocomposites: effective decoupling of electrical and thermal conductivity by functional interfaces.Nano Energy2017;31:393-402

[54] Mustafa G,Singh H.Lattice softness regulates recombination and lifetime of carrier in Germanium doped CsPbI₂Br perovskite: first principles DFT and NAMD simulations.J Solid State Chem2023;322:123981

[55] Lee S,Luo T,Tian Z.Resonant bonding leads to low lattice thermal conductivity.Nat Commun2014;5:3525

[56] Hu J,Dong X.Breaking the minimum limit of thermal conductivity of Mg₃Sb₂ thermoelectric mediated by chemical alloying induced lattice instability.Small2023;19:e2301382

[57] Back SY,Kim Y.Enhancement of thermoelectric properties by lattice softening and energy band gap control in Te-deficient InTe_1-δ.AIP Advances2018;8:115227

[58] Zhang Y,Mao W,Zhang J.Balancing structural stability and thermoelectric performance of GeMnTe₂ by manipulating the complexity of cation sublattice.Mater Today Phys2025;52:101693

[59] Zhang C,Dong H.Synergistic enhancement of thermoelectric performance of n-type PbTe by resonant level and single-atom-layer vacancies.Nano Energy2024;126:109615

[60] Zhu H,Nan P.intrinsically low lattice thermal conductivity in natural superlattice (Bi₂)_m(Bi₂Te₃)_n thermoelectric materials.Chem Mater2021;33:1140-8

[61] Yang WJ,Park BC.Switching to hidden metallic crystal phase in phase-change materials by photoenhanced metavalent bonding.ACS Nano2022;16:2024-31

[62] Zhang W,Sun S.Metavalent bonding in layered phase-change memory materials.Adv Sci2023;10:2370094 PMCID:PMC10214227

[63] Guarneri L,von Hoegen A.Metavalent bonding in crystalline solids: how does it collapse?.Adv Mater2021;33:e2102356 PMCID:PMC11468997

[64] Sarkar D,Arora R.Metavalent bonding in gese leads to high thermoelectric performance.Angew Chem Int Ed Engl2021;60:10350-8

[65] Pathak R,Dutta P.Impact of pressure on metavalent bonding in bite influencing electronic topological transitions.Angew Chem Int Ed Engl2025;64:e202422652

[66] Liu Y,Nan P.Improved solubility in metavalently bonded solid leads to band alignment, ultralow thermal conductivity, and high thermoelectric performance in SnTe.Adv Funct Mater2022;32:2209980

[67] Wang Y,Cheng Y.Chemical bonding engineering for high-symmetry Cu₂S-based materials with high thermoelectric performance.Mater Today Phys2023;32:101028

[68] Zhu T,Zhang Q.Structural transformation and thermoelectric performance in Ag₂Te_1-xSe_x solid solution.J Alloys Compd2021;871:159507

[69] Rundle J.Layered tin chalcogenides SnS and SnSe: lattice thermal conductivity benchmarks and thermoelectric figure of merit.J Phys Chem C Nanomater Interfaces2022;126:14036-46 PMCID:PMC9421910

[70] Guo F,Zhu J.Suppressing lone-pair expression endows room-temperature cubic structure and high thermoelectric performance in GeTe-based materials.Mater Today Phys2022;27:100780

[71] Shrestha R,Shin S.High-contrast and reversible polymer thermal regulator by structural phase transition.Sci Adv2019;5:eaax3777 PMCID:PMC6910832

[72] Wang Y,Zhu H.Structural phase transition in monolayer MoTe₂ driven by electrostatic doping.Nature2017;550:487-91

[73] Migliorini A,Huminiuc T.Spontaneous exchange bias formation driven by a structural phase transition in the antiferromagnetic material.Nat Mater2018;17:28-35

[74] Xiao C,Li K,Yang J.Superionic phase transition in silver chalcogenide nanocrystals realizing optimized thermoelectric performance.J Am Chem Soc2012;134:4287-93

[75] Singh B,Mittal R.Ab initio molecular dynamics study of 1-D superionic conduction and phase transition in β-eucryptite.J Mater Chem A2018;6:5052-64

[76] Lee S,Huang J.Programmable devices based on reversible solid-state doping of two-dimensional semiconductors with superionic silver iodide.Nat Electron2020;3:630-7

[77] Ruta FL,Sun Z.Surface plasmons induce topological transition in graphene/α-MoO₃ heterostructures.Nat Commun2022;13:3719 PMCID:PMC9240047

[78] Xie Y,Fei F.Tunable optical topological transitions of plasmon polaritons in WTe₂ van der Waals films.Light Sci Appl2023;12:193 PMCID:PMC10409815

[79] Sinha S,Chakraborty A.Berry curvature dipole senses topological transition in a moiré superlattice.Nat Phys2022;18:765-70

[80] Shen X,Hott R.Precursor region with full phonon softening above the charge-density-wave phase transition in 2H-TaSe₂.Nat Commun2023;14:7282 PMCID:PMC10638379

[81] Wang S,Yang J.High thermoelectric performance in Te-free (Bi,Sb)₂Se₃ via structural transition induced band convergence and chemical bond softening.Energy Environ Sci2016;9:3436-47

[82] Yang S,He X.Unlocking ultralow thermal conductivity in α-CuTeI via specific symmetry breaking in Cu sublattice.Adv Funct Mater2025;35:2419776

[83] Guin SN,Biswas K.The effect of order-disorder phase transitions and band gap evolution on the thermoelectric properties of AgCuS nanocrystals.Chem Sci2016;7:534-43 PMCID:PMC5952868

[84] Shen X,Tung YH.Soft phonon mode triggering fast Ag diffusion in superionic argyrodite Ag₈GeSe₆.Small2023;19:e2305048

[85] Beaulieu S,Tancogne-Dejean N.Ultrafast dynamical Lifshitz transition.Sci Adv2021;7:eabd9275 PMCID:PMC8059938

[86] Jung H,Sung M,Kim J.Quantum-confined lifshitz transition on weyl semimetal T_d-MoTe₂.ACS Nano2024;18:23189-95 PMCID:PMC11363146

[87] Chi Z,Gong Z.Pressure-induced Lifshitz transition in the type-II Weyl semimetal WP2.Mater Today Phys2024;42:101372

[88] Wu W,Du Y.Topological Lifshitz transition and one-dimensional Weyl mode in HfTe₅.Nat Mater2023;22:84-91

[89] Noad HML,Li YS.Giant lattice softening at a Lifshitz transition in Sr₂RuO₄.Science2023;382:447-50

[90] Zhang D,Bai H.Significant average ZT enhancement in Cu₃SbSe₄-based thermoelectric material via softening p-d hybridization.J Mater Chem A2019;7:17648-54

[91] Liang J,Liu C.Realizing a high ZT of 1.6 in N-type Mg₃Sb₂-based Zintl compounds through Mn and Se codoping.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2020;12:21799-807

[92] Tang S,Wu M.Improving thermoelectric performance of asymmetrical Janus 1T-SnSSe monolayer by the synergistic effect of band convergence and crystal lattice softening under strain engineering.Mater Today Phys2022;29:100923

[93] Kim H,Park S.Strategies for manipulating phonon transport in solids.ACS Nano2021;15:2182-96

[94] Zhao Y,Nai MH.Probing the physical origin of anisotropic thermal transport in black phosphorus nanoribbons.Adv Mater2018;30:e1804928

[95] Zhao Y,Kong L.Ultralow thermal conductivity of single-crystalline porous silicon nanowires.Adv Funct Mater2017;27:1702824

[96] Cappai A,Marongiu D.Strong anharmonicity at the origin of anomalous thermal conductivity in double perovskite Cs₂NaYbCl₆.Adv Sci (Weinh)2024;11:e2305861 PMCID:PMC10916569

[97] Jiang B,Liu S.High figure-of-merit and power generation in high-entropy GeTe-based thermoelectrics.Science2022;377:208-13

[98] Han S,Ma J.Strong phonon softening and avoided crossing in aliovalence-doped heavy-band thermoelectrics.Nat Phys2023;19:1649-57

[99] Tan XJ,Shao HZ.Acoustic phonon softening and reduced thermal conductivity in Mg2Si_1-x Sn_x solid solutions.Appl Phys Lett2017;110:143903

[100] Chen Z,Zheng L.(Ho_0.25Lu_0.25Yb_0.25Eu_0.25)₂SiO₅ high-entropy ceramic with low thermal conductivity, tunable thermal expansion coefficient, and excellent resistance to CMAS corrosion.J Adv Ceram2022;11:1279-93

[101] Kucinski TM,Savitzky BH.Direct measurement of the thermal expansion coefficient of epitaxial WSe₂ by four-dimensional scanning transmission electron microscopy.ACS Nano2024;18:17725-34 PMCID:PMC11238620

[102] Onodera Y,Masai H,Okamura S.Formation of metallic cation-oxygen network for anomalous thermal expansion coefficients in binary phosphate glass.Nat Commun2017;8:15449 PMCID:PMC5499210

[103] Kano E,Hayashida M.Substrate and contamination effects on the thermal expansion coefficient of suspended graphene measured by electron diffraction.Carbon2020;163:324-32

[104] Zhang Y,Ge Z.Enhanced thermoelectric performance of Cu_1.8S via lattice softening.Chem Eng J2022;428:131153