Forensic insights and genetic diversity: unveiling the Yunnan Yi and Qinghai Tibetan groups in China using a Multi-InDel panel

Abstract

Aim: Multi-InDel marker, which exhibits greater genetic diversity than a single InDel locus, hold significant potential for forensic applications. To enhance the detection rate in degraded DNA samples, our laboratory developed a novel Multi-InDel panel comprising 41 Multi-InDel markers. This study aims to verify the forensic efficacy of this Multi-InDel panel in two Chinese minority groups.

Methods: In this study, we assessed the forensic performance of this Multi-InDel panel by genotyping 92 Yunnan Yi (YNY) and 173 Qinghai Tibetan (QHT) individuals, both belonging to Chinese ethnic minorities. We also explored the genetic relationships between these two groups and 28 global reference populations.

Results: The results showed that 40 of the Multi-InDel markers (excluding MI38) exhibited high polymorphism in the YNY and QHT groups, with cumulative probabilities of matching of 2.28 × 10^-26 (YNY) and 5.64 × 10^-26 (QHT), and cumulative probabilities of exclusion of 0.9999995429 (YNY) and 0.9999984549 (QHT), respectively. Full sibling identification accuracies in the YNY and QHT groups, along with seven East Asian reference populations, averaged 98.89%, 96.48%, 90.47%, 78.82%, and 61.83% at likelihood ratio (LR) thresholds of 1, 10, 100, 1,000, and 10,000, respectively. Genetic analyses revealed close affinities between the studied groups and other East Asian populations. Additionally, the Multi-InDel panel effectively distinguished African, East Asian, and European populations.

Conclusion: The Multi-InDel panel demonstrated strong performance in various forensic applications, including individual identification, paternity testing, and full sibling identification in the YNY and QHT groups. Moreover, these two groups exhibited closer genetic relationships with East Asian populations than with other global populations.

Keywords

Multi-InDel / forensic genetics / population genetics / Yunnan Yi group / Qinghai Tibetan group

References

[1] HolmesAS,Hughes-StammS.In-field collection and preservation of decomposing human tissues to facilitate rapid purification and STR typing.Forensic Sci Int Genet2018;36:124-9

[2] SantosNBPD,SilvaAMDS.Allele frequencies and forensic data of 25 STR markers for individuals in Northeast Brazil.Genes2023;14:1185 PMCID:PMC10298256

[3] ChenM,ZhaoJ.Comparison of CE- and MPS-based analyses of forensic markers in a single cell after whole genome amplification.Forensic Sci Int Genet2020;45:102211

[4] PereiraR,PintoN.Straightforward inference of ancestry and admixture proportions through ancestry-informative insertion deletion multiplexing.PLoS One2012;7:e29684 PMCID:PMC3260179

[5] WangM,TangR.Genomic history and forensic characteristics of Sherpa highlanders on the Tibetan Plateau inferred from high-resolution InDel panel and genome-wide SNPs.Forensic Sci Int Genet2022;56:102633

[6] KiddKK,PakstisAJ.Evaluating 130 microhaplotypes across a global set of 83 populations.Forensic Sci Int Genet2017;29:29-37

[7] KiddKK.Criteria for selecting microhaplotypes: mixture detection and deconvolution.Investig Genet2015;6:1 PMCID:PMC4351693

[8] HuangJ,WeiW.A novel method for the analysis of 20 multi-Indel polymorphisms and its forensic application.Electrophoresis2014;35:487-93

[9] FanG,LuoH.Use of multi-InDels as novel markers to analyze 13 X-chromosome haplotype loci for forensic purposes.Electrophoresis2015;36:2931-8

[10] LiuJ,ZhangX.A new set of 20 multi-InDel markers for forensic application.Electrophoresis2022;43:1193-202

[11] SunK,LuoT.Multi-InDel analysis for ancestry inference of sub-populations in China.Sci Rep2016;6:39797 PMCID:PMC5177877

[12] YaoY,YangQ.Development of a multiplex panel with 31 multi-allelic InDels for forensic DNA typing.Int J Legal Med2023;137:1-12

[13] FanGY,HouYP.Detecting a hierarchical genetic population structure via Multi-InDel markers on the X chromosome.Sci Rep2016;6:32178

[14] QuS,XueJ.Multi-indel: a microhaplotype marker can be typed using capillary electrophoresis platforms.Front Genet2020;11:567082 PMCID:PMC7649793

[15] WangF,SongM,XieM.Genetic reconstruction and phylogenetic analysis by 193 Y-SNPs and 27 Y-STRs in a Chinese Yi ethnic group.Electrophoresis2021;42:1480-7

[16] LiuY,JinX.Forensic efficiency estimation of a homemade six-color fluorescence multiplex panel and in-depth anatomy of the population genetic architecture in two Tibetan groups.Front Genet2022;13:880346 PMCID:PMC9184685

[17] ChenM,NieS.Forensic efficiencies of individual identification, kinship testing and ancestral inference in three Yunnan groups based on a self-developed multiple DIP panel.Front Genet2022;13:1057231 PMCID:PMC9845582

[18] JianH,WangH,LvM.Population genetic analysis of 30 insertion-deletion (INDEL) loci in a Qinghai Tibetan group using the Investigator DIPplex kit.Int J Legal Med2019;133:1039-41

[19] CuiW,YaoH.Forensic characterization and genetic portrait of the Gannan Tibetan ethnic group via 165 AI-SNP loci.Front Biosci2023;28:114

[20] LanQ,LeiF,ZhuB.Systematically exploring the performance of a self-developed multi-InDel system in forensic identification, ancestry inference and genetic structure analysis of Chinese Manchu and Mongolian groups.Forensic Sci Int2023;346:111637

[21] MeiS,CaiM.Exploring the forensic effectiveness and population genetic differentiation by self-constructed 41 multi-InDel panel in Yunnan Zhuang group.Gene2023;860:147180

[22] StephensM,DonnellyP.A new statistical method for haplotype reconstruction from population data.Am J Hum Genet2001;68:978-89 PMCID:PMC1275651

[23] GouyA.STRAF-A convenient online tool for STR data evaluation in forensic genetics.Forensic Sci Int Genet2017;30:148-51

[24] KlingD,EgelandT.Familias 3 - extensions and new functionality.Forensic Sci Int Genet2014;13:121-7

[25] RosenbergNA,WardR.Informativeness of genetic markers for inference of ancestry.Am J Hum Genet2003;73:1402-22 PMCID:PMC1180403

[26] ExcoffierL.Arlequin suite ver 3.5: a new series of programs to perform population genetics analyses under Linux and Windows.Mol Ecol Resour2010;10:564-7

[27] NeiM,TatenoY.Accuracy of estimated phylogenetic trees from molecular data. II. Gene frequency data.J Mol Evol1983;19:153-70

[28] GeorgeD.IBM SPSS statistics 29 step by step: a simple guide and reference. New York: Routledge; 2024.

[29] KumarS,TamuraK.MEGA7: molecular evolutionary genetics analysis version 7.0 for bigger datasets.Mol Biol Evol2016;33:1870-4 PMCID:PMC8210823

[30] PritchardJK,DonnellyP.Inference of population structure using multilocus genotype data.Genetics2000;155:945-59 PMCID:PMC1461096

[31] JakobssonM.CLUMPP: a cluster matching and permutation program for dealing with label switching and multimodality in analysis of population structure.Bioinformatics2007;23:1801-6

[32] RosenbergNA.Distruct: a program for the graphical display of population structure.Mol Ecol Notes2004;4:137-8

[33] YuanX,LanQ.Using two self-developed InDel panels to explore forensic traits and ancestral components in the Hui group.Genomics2024;116:110756

[34] LiuJ,ChengX.DIP-microhaplotypes: new markers for detection of unbalanced DNA mixtures.Int J Legal Med2021;135:13-21

[35] JinXY,ChenC.Ancestry informative DIP loci for dissecting genetic structure and ancestry proportions of Qinghai Tibetan and Tibet Tibetan groups.Mol Biol Rep2020;47:1079-87

[36] ZhaoM,XuH,ZhuB.Unveiling the genetic landscape of high-altitude adaptive ethnic groups with polymorphic markers: implications of comprehensive forensic appraisals and population genetic investigations.Heliyon2023;9:e21229 PMCID:PMC10656254

[37] GuoY,MengH.Population differentiations and phylogenetic analysis of Tibet and Qinghai Tibetan groups based on 30 indel loci.DNA Cell Biol2016;35:787-94

[38] LiL,SongF,HouY.Genetic structure and forensic parameters of 30 InDels for human identification purposes in 10 Tibetan populations of China.Forensic Sci Int Genet2019;40:e219-27

[39] ZhangYD,JinR.Forensic evaluation and population genetic study of 30 insertion/deletion polymorphisms in a Chinese Yi group.Electrophoresis2015;36:1196-201

[40] LiS.Fei Xiaotong's theory on the corridor of the Tibet-Yi minority.Journal of Xizang Minzu University2006;Available from: https://kns.cnki.net/nzkhtml/xmlRead/xml.html?pageType=web&fileName=XZMZ200601000&tableName=CJFDTOTAL&dbCode=CJFD&fileSourceType=1&appId=KNS_BASIC_PSMC&invoice=ZRprB/Q1/qvTSFE5kF+5CV2ekMBbhLFcD7X7v5SpP2VkS8VH3avggmSp5B4WIqPNboZsmj+qLP6lkvmCJwUz+s8vEwhsuxej1slg7zJUOyBkFOQOTMJbNC7idSGkquo7bkVkz2Ek/X1Cgjw08EcwQXCuasvhx15TD1khvPU4iG0= [Last accessed on 21 Jul 2025]

[41] ShiS.Ethnic flows in the Tibetan-Yi corridor throughout history.Int J Anthropol Ethnol2018;2:9

[42] ZhangZ,WangY.The Tibetan-Yi region is both a corridor and a barrier for human gene flow.Cell Rep2022;39:110720

[43] YaoHB,YaoX.The genetic admixture in Tibetan-Yi Corridor.Am J Phys Anthropol2017;164:522-32