Reliability and Validity of Hand-Held Dynamometer and Hand-Held Sphygmomanometer for Testing Shoulder Isometric External and Internal Rotator Muscles Strength

Abstract

Background

Shoulder strength evaluation is a recommended procedure in musculoskeletal rehabilitation.

Aim

To examine hand-held sphygmomanometer (HHS) and hand-held dynamometer (HHD) intra- and inter-rater reliability during isometric shoulder external and internal rotation strength testing in prone rotation position in asymptomatic participants, and to compare these two testing modalities.

Design

Reliability study.

Methods

A total of 20 asymptomatic participants (27.7±7.4 years; 77.1±10.1 kg) attended a strength assessment consisting of HHS and HHD tests. Reliability was assessed using the intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) with 95% confidence intervals (CI), coefficient of variation (CV) with 95%CI, and standard error of measurement (SEM). Pearson correlation and linear regression analysis were used to compare HHS and HHD testing modalities.

Results

“Good” to “excellent” intra (ICC range=0.896 to 0.979) and inter-rater reliability scores (ICC range=0.850 to 0.978) were displayed during both HHS and HHD tests during internal and external rotation strength assessments. Linear relationships between HHS and HHD measures were found, with coefficients of determination (R²) ranging between 0.60 and 0.79.

Conclusion

HHS and HHD resulted to be reliable strength assessment modalities for clinical practice. These assessment modes can be equally valid in assessing intra and inter-limb asymmetries in isometric shoulder rotation strength. The affordability and availability of HHS in ordinary clinical settings can facilitate its implementation in musculoskeletal practice.

Keywords

Sphygmomanometer / Hand-held dynamometer / Reliability / Shoulder

References

[1] Suchomel TJ, Nimphius S, Bellon CR, et al. . The importance of muscular strength: training considerations. Sports Med. 2018, 48: 765-85 2018/01/27

[2] Maestroni L, Read P, Bishop C, et al. . The benefits of Strength Training on Musculoskeletal System Health: practical applications for Interdisciplinary Care. Sports Med. 2020, 50: 1431-50 2020/06/22

[3] Bettariga F, Turner A, Maloney S, Maestroni L, Jarvis P, Bishop C. The effects of training interventions on interlimb asymmetries: a systematic review with meta-analysis. Strength Cond J. 2022;44(5):69–86.

[4] Byram IR, Bushnell BD, Dugger K, et al. . Preseason shoulder strength measurements in professional baseball pitchers: identifying players at risk for injury. Am J Sports Med. 2010, 38: 1375-82

[5] Kwan C-K, Ko M-C, Fu S-C, et al. . Are muscle weakness and stiffness risk factors of the development of rotator cuff tendinopathy in overhead athletes: a systematic review. Therapeutic Adv Chronic Disease. 2021, 12: 20406223211026178

[6] Edouard P, Degache F, Oullion R, et al. . Shoulder strength imbalances as injury risk in handball. Int J Sports Med. 2013, 34: 654-60

[7] Maestroni L, Marelli M, Gritti M, et al. . External rotator strength deficits in non-athletic people with rotator cuff related shoulder pain are not associated with pain intensity or disability levels. Musculoskelet Sci Pract. 2020, 48: 102156

[8] Vigolvino LP, Barros BRS, Medeiros CEB, et al. . Analysis of the presence and influence of Glenohumeral Internal Rotation Deficit on posterior stiffness and isometric shoulder rotators strength ratio in recreational and amateur handball players. Phys Ther Sport. 2020, 42: 1-8

[9] Miller JE, Higgins LD, Dong Y, et al. . Association of Strength Measurement with Rotator Cuff tear in patients with Shoulder Pain: the Rotator Cuff Outcomes Workgroup Study. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2016, 95: 47-56

[10] McLaine SJ, Ginn KA, Fell JW, et al. . Isometric shoulder strength in young swimmers. J Sci Med Sport. 2018, 21: 35-9

[11] Lee SM, Seo YG, Park WH, et al. . Preoperative Rotator muscle strength ratio predicts shoulder function in patients after Rotator Cuff Repair. Orthop J Sports Med. 2020, 8: 2325967119899346-6

[12] McLaine SJ, Bird M-L, Ginn KA, et al. . Shoulder extension strength: a potential risk factor for shoulder pain in young swimmers?. J Sci Med Sport. 2019, 22: 516-20

[13] Hams AH, Evans K, Adams R, et al. . Shoulder internal and external rotation strength and prediction of subsequent injury in water-polo players. Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2019, 29: 1414-20

[14] Hopman K, Krahe L, Lukersmith S, McColl AR, Vine K. Clinical practice guidelines for the management of rotator cuff syndrome in the workplce. The University of New South Wales. 2013. http://rcs.med.unsw.edu.au/rotatorcuffsyndromeguidelines.

[15] Cools AM, Vanderstukken F, Vereecken F, Duprez M, Heyman K, Goethals N, Johansson F. Eccentric and isometric shoulder rotator cuff strength testing using a hand-held dynamometer: reference values for overhead athletes. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2016;24(12):3838–47. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-015-3755-9.

[16] Riemann BL, Davies GJ, Ludwig L, et al. . Hand-held dynamometer testing of the internal and external rotator musculature based on selected positions to establish normative data and unilateral ratios. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2010, 19: 1175-83 2010/09/21

[17] Nagatomi T, Mae T, Nagafuchi T, et al. . Shoulder manual muscle resistance test cannot fully detect muscle weakness. Knee Surg sports Traumatol arthroscopy: official J ESSKA. 2017, 25: 2081-8 2016/11/23

[18] Ashworth B, Hogben P, Singh N, Tulloch L, Cohen DD. The Athletic Shoulder (ASH) test: reliability of a novel upper body isometric strength test in elite rugby players. BMJ Open Sport Exerc Med. 2018;4(1): e000365. https://doi/org/10.1136/bmjsem-2018-000365.

[19] Stark T, Walker B, Phillips JK, et al. . Hand-held dynamometry correlation with the gold standard isokinetic dynamometry: a systematic review. Pm r. 2011, 3: 472-9 2011/05/17

[20] Dollings H, Sandford F, O’ Conaire E, Lewis JS. Shoulder strength testing: the intra- and inter-tester reliability of routine clinical tests, using the PowerTrack™ II Commander. Shoulder Elbow. 2017;4(2):131–40. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1758-5740.2011.00162.x.

[21] Roy JS, MacDermid JC, Orton B, et al. . The concurrent validity of a hand-held versus a stationary dynamometer in testing isometric shoulder strength. J Hand Ther. 2009, 22: 320-6 quiz 327. 2009/06/30

[22] Holt KL, Raper DP, Boettcher CE, et al. . Hand-held dynamometry strength measures for internal and external rotation demonstrate superior reliability, lower minimal detectable change and higher correlation to isokinetic dynamometry than externally-fixed dynamometry of the shoulder. Phys Ther Sport. 2016, 21: 75-81

[23] Perossa DR, Dziak M, Vernon HT, et al. . The intra-examiner reliability of manual muscle testing of the hip and shoulder with a modified sphygmomanometer: a preliminary study of normal subjects. J Can Chiropr Assoc. 1998, 42: 73-82

[24] Toohey L, De Noronha M, Nunes G. The use of a sphygmomanometer to measure shoulder isometric strength: a validity and reliability study. O uso do esfigmomanômetro para mensurar força isométrica do ombro: um estudo de validade e confiabilidade. Fisioterapia e Movimento. 2017, 30: 585-91

[25] Barbosa A, Intelangelo L, Bordachar D, Fernandes I, Cardoso D, Fernandes I, Porfirio W, Felicio D. Validity and reliability of shoulder strength assessment during scaption, internal rotation and external rotation using an anchored, non-modified sphygmomanometer. Human Movement. 2018;19(2):90–8. https://doi.org/10.5114/hm.2018.74064.

[26] McLaine SJ, Ginn KA, Kitic CM, Fell JW, Bird M-L. The reliability of strength tests performed in elevated shoulder positions using a Handheld Dynamometer. J Sport Rehabil. 2016;25(2):2015-0034. https://doi.org/10.1123/jsr.2015-0034.

[27] Boettcher CE, Ginn KA, Cathers I. Which is the optimal exercise to strengthen supraspinatus?. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2009, 41: 1979-83 2009/10/09

[28] Souza LAC, Martins JC, Moura JB, et al. . Assessment of muscular strength with the modified sphygmomanometer test: what is the best method and source of outcome values?. Braz J Phys Ther. 2014, 18: 191-200 Article

[29] Koo TK, Li MY. A Guideline of selecting and reporting Intraclass correlation coefficients for Reliability Research. J Chiropr Med. 2016, 15: 155-63 2016/03/31

[30] Weir JP. Quantifying test-retest reliability using the intraclass correlation coefficient and the SEM. J Strength Conditioning Res. 2005, 19: 231-40

[31] Turner A, Brazier J, Bishop C, Chavda S, Cree J, Read P. Data analysis for strength and conditioning coaches: using excel to analyze reliability, differences, and relationships. Strength Cond J. 2015; 37(1):76–83.

[32] Borg DN, Bach AJ, O’Brien JL, Sainani KL. Calculating sample size for reliability studies. PM R. 2022;14(8):1018–25.

[33] Bhinderwala S, Bedekar N. Reliability of modified sphygmomanometer for measurement of maximum isometric shoulder muscle strength. Physiotherapy - The Journal of Indian Association of Physiotherapists. 2019, 13: 9-13 Original Article