Maritime Energy Transition: Future Fuels and Future Emissions

Abstract

The lifecycle greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions (Well-to-Wake) from maritime transport must be reduced by at least 50% in absolute values by 2050 to contribute to the ambitions of the Paris Agreement (2015). A transition from conventional fuels to alternative fuels with zero or lower GHG emissions is viewed as the most promising avenue to reach the GHG reductions. Whereas GHG and toxic pollutants emitted from the use of fossil fuels (heavy fuel oil (HFO) and marine gas/diesel oil (MGO/MDO)) are generally well understood, the emissions associated with the new fuel options are only now being measured and communicated. This review provides an outlook on fuels that could help shipping respond to the decarbonization effort including Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG), Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG), methanol, ammonia, and hydrogen. A quantification of the pollutants associated from the use of these fuels is provided and challenges and barriers to their uptake are discussed.

Keywords

Greenhouse gas / Emissions / Maritime transport / Future fuels / Future emissions / Life-cycle assessment / Energy transition

References

[1] Al-Aboosi FY, El-Halwagi MM, Moore M, Nielsen RB. Renewable ammonia as an alternative fuel for the shipping industry. Current Opinion in Chemical Engineering, 2021, 31: 100670

[2] Altosole M, Benvenuto G, Campora U, Laviola M, Zaccone R. Simulation and performance comparison between diesel and natural gas engines for marine applications. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part M: Journal of Engineering for the Maritime Environment, 2017, 231: 690-704

[3] Anner N (2022) Making the maritime energy transition [WWW Document]. MAN Energy Solutions. URL https://www.man-es.com/discover/making-the-maritime-energy-transition [accessed 8.3.22]

[4] Barbir F, Basile A, Veziroǧlu TN (2016) Compendium of Hydrogen Energy. Woodhead Publishing

[5] Bicer Y, Dincer I (2018) Clean fuel options with hydrogen for sea transportation: A life cycle approach. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 43, 1179–1193. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2017.10.157

[6] Bose PK, Maji D. An experimental investigation on engine performance and emissions of a single cylinder diesel engine using hydrogen as inducted fuel and diesel as injected fuel with exhaust gas recirculation. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2nd International Workshop on Hydrogen, 2009, 34: 4847-4854

[7] Bouman EA, Lindstad E, Rialland AI, Stromman AH. State-of-the-art technologies, measures, and potential for reducing GHG emissions from shipping–A review. Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 2017, 52: 408-421

[8] BP (2021) Energy Outlook 2020 Edition. https://www.bp.com/content/dam/bp/business-sites/en/global/corporate/pdfs/energy-economics/energy-outlook/bp-energy-outlook-2020.pdf

[9] Brinks H, Chryssakis C (2022) Harnessing ammonia as ship fuel - DNV DNV GL. https://www.dnv.com/expert-story/DigitalMagazineDefault [accessed 8.3.22]

[10] Bro K, Pedersen PS. Alternative diesel engine fuels: an experimental investigation of methanol, ethanol, methane and ammonia in a D.I. diesel engine with pilot injection (SAE Technical Paper No. 770794), 1977, Warrendale, PA: SAE International

[11] Brynolf S, Fridell E, Andersson K. Environmental assessment of marine fuels: liquefied natural gas, liquefied biogas, methanol and bio-methanol. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2014, 74: 86-95

[12] Brynolf S, Magnusson M, Fridell E, Andersson K. Compliance possibilities for the future ECA regulations through the use of abatement technologies or change of fuels. Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, Emission Control Areas and their Impact on Maritime Transport, 2014, 28: 6-18

[13] Buhaug Ø, Corbett Endresen Ø, Eyring V, Faber J, Hanayama S, Lee DS, Lee D, Lindstad H, Markowska AZ, Mjelde A, Nelissen D, Nilsen J, Pålsson C, Winebrake JJ, Wu W-Q, Yoshida K (2009) Second IMO GHG study 2009 [WWW Document]. http://www.imo.org/ (accessed 4.20.22)

[14] Burel F, Taccani R, Zuliani N. Improving sustainability of maritime transport through utilization of Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) for propulsion. Energy, 2013, 57: 412-420

[15] Bush D (2022) More countries back net-zero target at IMO [WWW Document]. Lloyd’s List. URL https://lloydslist.maritimeintelligence.informa.com/LL1141205/More-countries-back-net-zero-target-at-IMO. [accessed 6.14.22]

[16] Cecil W (1822) On the application of hydrogen gas to produce a moving power in machinery; with a description of an engine which is moved by the pressure of the atmosphere, upon a vacuum caused by explosions of hydrogen and atmospheric air. Trans. Cambridge Philos. Soc 1, 217

[17] Comer B (2021) Accounting for well-to-wake carbon dioxide equivalent emissions in maritime transportation climate policies. International Council on Clean Transportation. URL https://theicct.org/publication/accounting-for-well-to-wake-carbon-dioxide-equivalent-emissions-in-maritime-transportation-climate-policies/ [accessed 4.20.22]

[18] Cooper D, Gustafsson T (2004) Methodology for calculating emissions from ships: 1. Update of emission factors

[19] Dimitriou P, Kumar M, Tsujimura T, Suzuki Y. Combustion and emission characteristics of a hydrogen-diesel dual-fuel engine. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2018, 43: 13605-13617

[20] Dimitriou P, Tsujimura T. A review of hydrogen as a compression ignition engine fuel. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2017, 42: 24470-24486

[21] DNV (2021) Maritime forecast to 2050 [WWW Document]. https://eto.dnv.com/2021/maritime-forecast-2050/about (accessed 4.20.22)

[22] European Parliament, Council of the European Union (2018) Directive (EU) 2018/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 December 2018 on the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources. Official Journal of the European Union. https://eu-lex.euopa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:32018L2001

[23] Faber J, Hanayama S, Zhang S, Pereda P, Comer B, Hauerhof E, van der Loeff WS, Smith T, Zhang Y, Kosaka HK, Adachi M, Bonello J-M, Galbraith C, Gong Z, Hirata K, Hummels D, Kleijn A, Lee DS, Liu Y, Lucchesi A, Mao X, Muraoka E, Osipova L, Qian H, Rutherford D, Suárez de la Fuente S, Yuan H, Perico CV, Wu L, Sun D, Yoo D-H, Xing H. Fourth Greenhouse Gas Study 2020-Final Report, 2020, London, UK: International Maritime Organization (IMO)

[24] Fridell E, Salberg H, Salo K. Measurements of Emissions to Air from a Marine Engine Fueled by Methanol. J. Marine. Sci. Appl., 2021, 20: 138-143

[25] Fridell E, Salo K. Measurements of abatement of particles and exhaust gases in a marine gas scrubber. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part M: Journal of Engineering for the Maritime Environment, 2016, 230: 154-162

[26] Frigo S, Gentili R. Analysis of the behaviour of a 4-stroke Si engine fuelled with ammonia and hydrogen. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2011 Zing International Hydrogen and Fuel Cells Conference: from Nanomaterials to Demonstrators, 2013, 38: 1607-1615

[27] Gilbert P, Walsh C, Traut M, Kesieme U, Pazouki K, Murphy A. Assessment of full life-cycle air emissions of alternative shipping fuels. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2018, 172: 855-866

[28] Gomes Antunes JM, Mikalsen R, Roskilly AP. An experimental study of a direct injection compression ignition hydrogen engine. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2009, 34: 6516-6522

[29] Gray JT, Dimitroff E, Meckel NT, Quillian RD. Ammonia fuel-engine compatibility and combustion (SAE Technical Paper No. 660156), 1966, Warrendale, PA: SAE International

[30] Gross CW, Kong S-C. Performance characteristics of a compression-ignition engine using direct-injection ammonia–DME mixtures. Fuel, 2013, 103: 1069-1079

[31] Hansson J, Brynolf S, Fridell E, Lehtveer M. The potential role of ammonia as marine fuel—based on energy systems modeling and multi-criteria decision analysis. Sustainability, 2020, 12: 3265

[32] Hansson J, Fridell E, Brynolf S (2020b) On the potential of ammonia as fuel for shipping: a synthesis of knowledge. Lighthouse

[33] Haragopala Rao B, Shrivastava KN, Bhakta HN. Hydrogen for dual fuel engine operation. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 1983, 8: 381-384

[34] Hauschild MZ, Goedkoop M, Guinée J, Heijungs R, Huijbregts M, Jolliet O, Margni M, De Schryver A, Humbert S, Laurent A, Sala S, Pant R. Identifying best existing practice for characterization modeling in life cycle impact assessment. Int J Life Cycle Assess, 2013, 18: 683-697

[35] Herdzik J. Decarbonization of marine fuels—the future of shipping. Energies, 2021, 14: 4311

[36] Holladay JD, Hu J, King DL, Wang Y. An overview of hydrogen production technologies. Catalysis Today, 2009, 139(4): 244-260

[37] IMO (2018) Adoption of the initial IMO strategy on reduction of GHG emissions from ships and existing IMO activity related to reducing GHG emissions in the shipping sector. London, UK

[38] IPCC (2022) Climate Change 2022: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [H.-O. Pörtner, D.C. Roberts, M. Tignor, E.S. Poloczanska, K. Mintenbeck, A. Alegría, M. Craig, S. Langsdorf, S. Löschke, V. Möller, A. Okem, B. Rama (eds.)]. Cambridge University Press. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK and New York, NY, USA, 3056 pp., doi:https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009325844

[39] Jamrozik A, Grab-Rogaliński K, Tutak W. Hydrogen effects on combustion stability, performance and emission of diesel engine. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2020, 45: 19936-19947

[40] Kristenen HO (2015) Energy demand and exhaust gas emissions of marine engines.

[41] Lilik GK, Zhang H, Herreros JM, Haworth DC, Boehman AL. Hydrogen assisted diesel combustion. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2010, 35: 4382-4398

[42] Lindstad E (2019) Increased use of LNG might not reduce maritime GHG emissions at all. Transport & Environment (T&E).

[43] Lindstad E, Eskeland GS, Rialland A, Valland A. Decarbonizing maritime transport: the importance of engine technology and regulations for LNG to serve as a transition fuel. Sustainability, 2020, 12: 8793

[44] Lindstad E, Lagemann B, Rialland A, Gamlem GM, Valland A. Reduction of maritime GHG emissions and the potential role of E-fuels. Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 2021, 101: 103075

[45] Lindstad E, Rialland A. LNG and cruise ships, an easy way to fulfil regulations—versus the need for reducing GHG emissions. Sustainability, 2020, 12: 2080

[46] Lu D, Theotokatos G, Zhang J, Zeng H, Cui K. Comparative assessment and parametric optimisation of large marine two-stroke engines with exhaust gas recirculation and alternative turbocharging systems. Journal of Marine Science and Engineering, 2022, 10: 351

[47] MAN B&W ME-LGIP (2020) MAN Energy Solutions. https://www.man-es.com/marine/products/lgip [accessed 4.22.22]

[48] Masood M, Ishrat MM, Reddy AS. Computational combustion and emission analysis of hydrogen-diesel blends with experimental verification. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, ICHS-2005, 2007, 32: 2539-2547

[49] Morch CS, Bjerre A, Gøttrup MP, Sorenson SC, Schramm J. Ammonia/hydrogen mixtures in an SI-engine: Engine performance and analysis of a proposed fuel system. Fuel, 2011, 90: 854-864

[50] Navarro RM, Peña MA, Fierro JLG. Hydrogen production reactions from carbon feedstocks: fossil fuels and biomass. Chem. Rev., 2007, 107: 3952-3991

[51] Nikolaou G, Herzer B, Ure C, Tyler D, Arahata M, Frederiksen N, Hadjipateras P, Solem O, Basaglia R, Hamaguchi T, Perkins T, Neilsen W (2017) LPG for Marine Engines: The Marine Alternative Fuel

[52] Ozawa A, Inoue M, Kitagawa N, Muramatsu R, Anzai Y, Genchi Y, Kudoh Y. Assessing uncertainties of well-to-tank greenhouse gas emissions from hydrogen supply chains. Sustainability, 2017, 9: 1101

[53] Pan H, Pournazeri S, Princevac M, Miller JW, Mahalingam S, Khan MY, Jayaram V, Welch WA. Effect of hydrogen addition on criteria and greenhouse gas emissions for a marine diesel engine. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2014, 39: 11336-11345

[54] Pavlenko N (2020) The climate implications of using LNG as a marine fuel. International Council on Clean Transportation. https://theicct.org/publication/the-climate-implications-of-using-lng-as-a-marine-fuel/ [accessed 4.7.22]

[55] Pearsall TJ, Garabedian CG. Combustion of anhydrous ammonia in diesel engines. SAE Transactions, 1968, 76: 3213-3221

[56] Pochet M, Truedsson I, Foucher F, Jeanmart H, Contino F (2017) Ammonia-Hydrogen Blends in Homogeneous-Charge Compression-Ignition Engine (SAE Technical Paper No. 2017-24-0087). SAE International, Warrendale, PA. https://doi.org/10.4271/2017-24-0087

[57] Rehbein MC, Meier C, Eilts P, Scholl S. Mixtures of ammonia and organic solvents as alternative fuel for internal combustion engines. Energy Fuels, 2019, 33: 10331-10342

[58] Reiter AJ, Kong S-C. Combustion and emissions characteristics of compression-ignition engine using dual ammonia-diesel fuel. Fuel, 2011, 90: 87-97

[59] Reiter AJ, Kong S-C. Demonstration of compression-ignition engine combustion using ammonia in reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Energy Fuels, 2008, 22: 2963-2971

[60] Resolution MEPC. 281(70) (2016)–Amendments to the 2014 Guidelines on the Method of Calculation of the Attained Energy Efficiency Design Index (EEDI) For New Ships (Resolution MEPC. 245(66), as Amended by Resolution MEPC. 263(68)) - (Adopted on 28 October 2016). https://imorules.com/MEPCRES_281.70.html [accessed 4.22.22]

[61] Riaz A, Zahedi G, Klemeš JJ. A review of cleaner production methods for the manufacture of methanol. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2013, 57: 19-37

[62] Ryu KH, Zacharakis-Jutz G, Kong S-C. Effects of fuel compositions on diesel engine performance using ammonia-DME mixtures (SAE Technical Paper No. 2013- 01-1133), 2013, Warrendale, PA: SAE International

[63] Shine KP. The global warming potential—the need for an interdisciplinary retrial. Climatic Change, 2009, 96: 467-472

[64] Smith T, Jalkanen J, Anderson B, Corbett J, Faber J, Hanayama S, O’Keeffe E, Parker S, Johansson L, Aldous L, Raucci C, Traut M, Ettinger S, Nelissen D, Lee D, Ng S, Agrawal A, Winebrake J, Hoen M, Pandey A (2014) Third IMO GHG Study 2014: Executive Summary and Final Report

[65] Stenersen D, Thonstad O (2017) GHG and NOx emissions from gas fueled engines

[66] Tadros M, Ventura M, Guedes S. Optimization procedure to minimize fuel consumption of a four-stroke marine turbocharged diesel engine. Energy, 2019, 168: 897-908

[67] Trivyza NL, Rentizelas A, Theotokatos G, Boulougouris E. Decision support methods for sustainable ship energy systems: A state-of-the-art review. Energy, 2022, 239: 122288

[68] UN (2015) United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change: Paris Agreement: FCCC/CP/2015/L.9/Rev.1. New York, USA

[69] UNCTAD (2021). Review of Maritime Transport 2021 [WWW Document]. URL https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/rmt2021_en_0.pdf

[70] US EPA O (2020) AP 42, Fifth Edition, Volume I Chapter 1: External Combustion Sources. https://www.epa.gov/air-emissions-factors-and-quantification/ap-42-fifth-edition-volume-i-chapter-1-external-0 [accessed 4.22.22]

[71] Ushakov S, Stenersen D, Einang PM. Methane slip from gas fuelled ships: a comprehensive summary based on measurement data. J Mar Sci Technol, 2019, 24: 1308-1325

[72] Verhelst S, Sierens R, Verstraeten S. A critical review of experimental research on hydrogen fueled SI engines. SAE Transactions, 2006, 115: 264-274

[73] Wagemakers A, Leermakers C (2012) Review on the effects of dual-fuel operation, using diesel and gaseous fuels, on emissions and performance. SAE technical paper 01-0869.

[74] Warwick N, Griffiths P, Keeble J, Archibald A, Pyle J (2022) Atmospheric implications of increased hydrogen use. Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy

[75] White CM, Steeper RR, Lutz AE. The hydrogen-fueled internal combustion engine: a technical review. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2006, 31: 1292-1305

[76] White J (2022) How fuel-agnostic engine platforms can reduce carbon emissions of commercial transportation. Cummins Inc. https://www.cummins.com/news/2022/03/11/how-fuel-agnostic-engine-platforms-can-reduce-carbon-emissions-commercial [accessed 8.3.22]

[77] Winnes H, Fridell E, Ellis J, Forsman B, Ramsay W, Westermark H (2020) Aftertreatment of methane slip from marine gas engines. Lighthouse

[78] Winnes H, Moldanová J, Anderson M, Fridell E. On-board measurements of particle emissions from marine engines using fuels with different sulphur content. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part M: Journal of Engineering for the Maritime Environment, 2016, 230: 45-54

[79] Woodyard D (2009) Pounder’s Marine Diesel Engines and Gas Turbines - 9th Edition.

[80] World Economic Forum (2022) Fuel of the future: How to realize the potential of hydrogen. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2022/03/hydrogen-decarbonization-climate-change-energy/

[81] Worldwide Emissions Standards (2016) Heavy Duty and Off-Highway Vehicles

[82] Yousefi A, Guo H, Dev S, Liko B, Lafrance S. Effects of ammonia energy fraction and diesel injection timing on combustion and emissions of an ammonia/diesel dual-fuel engine. Fuel, 2022, 314: 122723

[83] Zincir B (2022) Environmental and economic evaluation of ammonia as a fuel for short-sea shipping: A case study. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2022.03.281