A Quick and Practical Approach for Concept-design of Submerged Thin-walled Stiffened Cylinders

Abstract

Goal based and limit state design is nowadays a well-established approach in many engineering fields. Ship construction rules started introducing such concepts since early 2000. However, classification societies’ rules do not provide hints on how to verify limit states and to determine the structural layout of submerged thin-walled stiffened cylinders, whose most prominent examples are submarines. Rather, they generally offer guidance and prescriptive formulations to assess shell plating and stiffening members. Such marine structures are studied, designed and built up to carry payloads below the sea surface. In the concept-design stage, the maximum operating depth is the governing hull scantling parameter. Main dimensions are determined based on the analysis of operational requirements. This study proposes a practical concept-design approach for conceptual submarine design, aimed at obtaining hull structures that maximize the payload capacity in terms of available internal volume by suitably adjusting structural layout and stiffening members’ scantling, duly accounting for robustness and construction constraints as well as practical fabrication issues. The proposed scantling process highlights that there is no need of complex algorithms if sound engineering judgment is applied in setting down rationally the hull scantling problem. A systematic approach based on a computer-coded procedure developed on purpose was effectively implemented and satisfactorily applied in design practice.

Keywords

Submarines / Hull scantling / Concept/preliminary design / Limit state design / Buckling / Optimization / Thin-walled cylinders

References

[1] Aguiari M, Gaiotti M, Rizzo CM. A design approach to reduce hull weight of naval ships. Ship Technology Research, 2021, 69(2): 89-104

[2] American Bureau of Shipping Rules for building and classing, Underwater vehicles, systems and hyperbaric facilities, 2021, New York: American Bureau of Shipping

[3] ANEP (2012) Naval submarine code. International Naval Safety Association

[4] Bijlaard PP. Buckling under external pressure of cylindrical shells evenly stiffened by rings only. J. Aeronaut. Sci., 1957, 24(6): 437-447

[5] Bryant AR (1954) Hydrostatic pressure buckling of a ring-stiffened tube. Naval Construction Research Establishment (NCRE), Report No. 306

[6] BSI 5500 (2009) British standard specification for unfired fusion welded pressure vessels. British Standards Institution

[7] Bureau V (2016) Rules for the Classification of Naval Submarines. n. NR 535 DT R00 E, Paris

[8] de Freitas ASN, Alvarez AA, Ramos R, de Barros EA. Buckling analysis of an AUV pressure vessel with sliding stiffeners. Journal of Marine Science and Engineering, 2020, 8(7): 515

[9] Ding HX, Shen YC. Approximate goal programming model for optimization design of submarine pressure hull structure. Chuan Bo Li Xue/Journal of Ship Mechanics, 2004, 8(2): 79-85

[10] DNV (2018) Rules for classification naval vessels. Edition January 2018, Part 4 Sub-surface ships, Chapter 1 Submarines, Høvik, Norway

[11] Dow R, Ashe G, Broekhuysen J, Doig R, Fredriksen A, Imakita A, Jeon WS, Leguin JF, Liu JH, Pegg N, Silva S, Truelock DW, Viejo F. ISSC Committee V.5: Naval Vessels, 2012, 2012, Hamburg: Schiahrts-Verlag “Hansa” GmbH & Co. KG, Volume 2

[12] ECCS Buckling of steel shells: European Recommendations, 1988, Brussels: European Convention for Constructional Steelwork (ECCS)

[13] Gaiotti M, Ghelardi S, Rizzo CM (2019) Dynamic buckling of composite mast panels of sail ships. Proceedings of the 7^th International Conference on Marine Structures, Dubrovnik, Croatia, 391–399

[14] Gaiotti M, Rizzo CM. Dynamic buckling of masts of large sail ships. Ship & Offshore Structures, 2014, 10(3): 290-301

[15] Gannon L (2010) SSP74: Design of submarine structures. Defence Procurement Agency, Technical Memorandum Defence R&D Canada-Atlantic

[16] TM 2010-246, Canada Ministry of National Defence Graham D Predicting the collapse of externally pressurised ring-stiffened cylinders using finite element analysis. Marine Structures, 2007, 20(4): 202-217

[17] Hughes O, Paik JK. Ship structural analysis and design, 2010, Jersey City, NJ, United States: The Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers

[18] IMO (2015) Focus paper on GBS. International Maritime Organization, Available from https://fdocuments.net/document/focus-paper-on-gbs.html [Accessed on Jun 22, 2022]

[19] IMO (2013) Maritime Committee (MSC) document 78/6/2. International Maritime Organization, Available from www.imo.org [Accessed on Jun 22, 2022]

[20] Kendrick S. Design for external pressure using general criteria. International Journal of Mechanical Science, 1982, 24(4): 209-218

[21] Lloyds Register of Shipping (2021) Submarine assurance framework. London, United Kingdom

[22] Mackay JR (2010) Experimental investigation of the strength of damaged pressure hulls-Phase 1. Available from https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/ADA475270.pdf [Accessed on Jun 22, 2022]

[23] MacKay JR, Smith MJ, van Keulen F, Bosman TN, Pegg NG. Experimental investigation of the strength and stability of submarine pressure hulls with and without artificial corrosion damage. Marine Structures, 2010, 23(3): 339-359

[24] MacKay JR, van Keulen F, Smith MJ. Quantifying the accuracy of numerical collapse predictions for the design of submarine pressure hulls. Thin-Walled Structures, 2011, 49(1): 145-156

[25] Mansour A, Liu D. The principles of naval architecture series, 2008, Jersey City, NJ, United States: The Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers

[26] NASA Buckling of thin-Walled circular cylinders, national aeronautics and space administration, 2019, Virginia, United States: Langley Research Center

[27] Pulos JG, Salerno VL (1961) Axisymmetric elastic deformations and stresses in a ring-stiffened, perfectly circular cylinrical shell under external hydrostatic pressure. David Taylor Model Basin Report

[28] Putelat T, Triantafyllidis N. Dynamic stability of externally pressurized elastic rings subjected to high rates of loading. International Journal of Solids and Structures, 2014, 51(1): 1-12

[29] Ross CTF. Pressure vessels: external pressure technology, 2011, 2nd edition, Cambridge, UK: Woodhead Publishing Ltd., 355-360

[30] Shiomitsu D, Yanagihara D. Elastic local shell and stiffener-tripping buckling strength of ring-stiffened cylindrical shells under external pressure. Thin — Walled Structures, 2020, 148: 106622

[31] Sturm Rolland G (1941) A study of the collapsing pressure of thin-walled cylinders. University of Illinois Bulletin, No. 12, 7–76

[32] Tokugawa T (1929) Model experiments on the elastic stability of closed and cross-stiffened circular cylinders under uniform external pressure. Proceedings of World Engineering Congress, Tokyo, 29, Paper No.651, 249–79, Nihon Kogakkai (Engineering Society of Japan)

[33] von Mises R (1929) Der Kritische Aussendruk für Allseits belastete zylindrische Rohre. Festschrift zum 70 Geburtstag von prof. A. Stodola, STOnoLA-Festschr., Zürich, 418–430

[34] von Sander K, Gunther K (1921) Über das Festigkeitsproblem querver-steifter Hohlzylinder unter allseitig gleichmäßigem Außendruck. Werft und Reederei, 1(8, 9 und 10), 1920 and 2(17), 1921

[35] Windenburg DF, Trilling C (1934) Collapse by instability of thin cylindrical shells under external pressure. http://hdl.handle.net/1721.3/48059 [Accessed on Jun 22, 2022]