Using Double-acting Hydraulic Actuators for Weight Reduction in the Offshore Industry

Abstract

An actuator is a machine or component installed on the top of an industrial valve for automatically moving and controlling the valve. The performance of a valve is largely dependent on its actuator. An actuator can be hydraulic, pneumatic, or electrical. This paper focuses on hydraulic actuators, which are common for large size and high-pressure class ball valves. Hydraulic actuators can be either single-acting (spring return) or double-acting. Single-acting actuators return to safe mode in case of failure. However, double-acting actuators have a fail-as-is function and cannot keep the valves open or closed in case of failure. This research used a combination of theoretical and experimental approaches. The paper discusses two case studies in offshore industry projects in which double-acting hydraulic actuators were selected instead of single-acting, and possible design impacts are discussed. A theoretical review is given in three papers about operating torque for ball valves, optimization of shutdown valve actuator weight, and design and analysis of hydraulic actuators. These three papers were selected for review to connect the valve required torque with actuator sizing and selection, finding practical approaches to optimize the actuator weight as well as develop a theoretical model to calculate the actuator thickness and dimensions for the 38” CL1500 ball valve in the Johan Sverdrup project. The proposed formulas and calculations used for sizing the 38” CL1500 ball valves were validated through a finite element analysis model.

Keywords

Valve automation / Hydraulic actuator / Quarter turn movement / Single acting / Double acting / Offshore Industry

References

[1] American Petroleum Institute (API) Standard for actuator sizing and mounting kits for pipeline valves, 2012, 1st edition, Washington, DC: API

[2] American Petroleum Institute (API) Specification for pipeline and piping valves, 2014, 24th edition, Washington, DC: API

[3] American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Valves—Flanged, threaded, and welding end, 2004, New York, NY: ASME

[4] American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Pipe flanges and flanged fittings, 2017, New York, NY: ASME

[5] Bai Y, Bai Q. Subsea Engineering Handbook, 2012, 1st ed., USA: Elsevier

[6] Boye E, Olabisi I, Emagbetere E. Design and finite element analysis of double-acting, double ends hydraulic cylinder for industrial automation application. American Journal of Engineering Research, 2017, 6(3): 131-138

[7] Det Norske Veritas (DNV) (2000) Subsea joint industry project (JIP). Norway, Hovik

[8] Emerson (2019). Electrical actuators fail to safe position. [Online]. Available from: https://www.spartancontrols.com/applied-technology/valves/isolate/actuation/electric-actuators/fail-to-safe-position/ [access date: 3th of March 2020]

[9] Equinor (2019) Johan Sverdrup. [Online]. Available from: https://www.equinor.com/en/what-we-do/johan-sverdrup.html[access date: 3th of March 2020]

[10] Flowserve 2018) Valve actuation: The when, how, and why of actuator selection. [Online]. Available from: https://www.flowserve.com/sites/default/files/2018-05/(FLS-VA-EWP-00005-EN-EX-US-0518-Actuation_Type_Advantages_LR1.pdf. [access date: 3th of March 2020]

[11] Gokilakrishnan G, Divya S, Rajesh R, Selvakumar V. Operating Torque in ball valves — A review. International Journal for Technological Research in Engineering, 2014, 2(4): 2347-4718

[12] Indelac Controls, Inc. (2014) How to select an actuator. Comprehensive Guide. [Online]. Available from: http://www.indelac.com/pdfs/How-to-Select-an-Actuator-Comprehensive-Guide.pdf [access date: 6th of March 2020]

[13] International Organization of Standards (ISO) Petroleum and natural gas industries—Mechanical integrity and sizing of actuators and mounting kits for pipeline valves, 2011, 1st edition, Geneva, Switzerland: ISO

[14] Kevin H (2019) Know your Pneumatics: single or double-acting? Choosing the right cylinder. [Online]. Available from: http://blog.parker.com/know-your-pneumatics-single-or-double-acting-choosing-the-right-cylinder [access date: 10th of March 2020]

[15] Metalphote of Cincinnati (2018) How to select a valve actuator: Types of valve actuators, appropriate sizing, safety criteria, and more. [Online]. Available from: https://www.mpofcinci.com/blog/how-to-select-a-valve-actuator/#Function [access date: 13th of March 2020]

[16] Nair S (2016) Optimization of Shutdown Valve Weight and Size. Offshore Technology Conference. Paper Number OTC-26499-MS

[17] Nesbitt B. Handbook of Valves and Actuators: Valves Manual International, 2007, Oxford, UK: Elsevier

[18] Pishock D (2016) Choosing between a double-acting and spring return actuator. [Online]. Available from: https://valveman.com/blog/double-acting-vs-spring-return-actuators/ [access date: 15th of March 2020]

[19] Schlumberger (2018) LEDEEN hydraulic actuators and controls. [Online]. Available from: https://www.products.slb.com/valves/brands/ledeen/ledeen-hydraulic-actuators [access date: 15th of March 2020]

[20] Sotoodeh K. Top entry export line valve design considerations. Valve World Magazine., 2015, 20(5): 55-61

[21] Sotoodeh K (2018) Pipeline valves technology, material selection, welding, and stress analysis (a case study of a 30-inch class 1 500 pipeline ball valve). ASME, Journal of Pressure Vessel Technology 140(4), 044001, Paper Number PVT-18-1043. https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4040139

[22] Sotoodeh K (2019a) Valve operability during a fire. ASME, Journal of Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering 141(4), 044001, Paper Number OMAE-18-1093, https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4042073

[23] Sotoodeh K. Subsea and topside offshore valves: a comparison-Part 1. Valve World Magazine., 2019, 24(6): 25-27

[24] Sotoodeh K. Actuator sizing and selection. Springer Nature Applied Science, 2019, Switzerland: Springer, 1 1207