Reliability-Based Analysis of a Caisson Breakwater with the Application of Bayesian Inference

Abstract

Caisson breakwaters are mainly constructed in deep waters to protect an area against waves. These breakwaters are conventionally designed based on the concept of the safety factor. However, the wave loads and resistance of structures have epistemic or aleatory uncertainties. Furthermore, sliding failure is one of the most important failure modes of caisson breakwaters. In most previous studies, for assessment purposes, uncertainties, such as wave and wave period variation, were ignored. Therefore, in this study, Bayesian reliability analysis is implemented to assess the failure probability of the sliding of Tombak port breakwater in the Persian Gulf. The mean and standard deviations were taken as random variables to consider dismissed uncertainties. For this purpose, the first-order reliability method (FORM) and the first principal curvature correction in FORM are used to calculate the reliability index. The performances of these methods are verified by importance sampling through Monte Carlo simulation (MCS). In addition, the reliability index sensitivities of each random variable are calculated to evaluate the importance of different random variables while calculating the caisson sliding. The results show that the reliability index is most sensitive to the coefficients of friction, wave height, and caisson weight (or concrete density). The sensitivity of the failure probability of each of the random variables and their uncertainties are calculated by the derivative method. Finally, the Bayesian regression is implemented to predict the statistical properties of breakwater sliding with non-informative priors, which are compared to Goda’s formulation, used in breakwater design standards. The analysis shows that the model posterior for the sliding of a caisson breakwater has a mean and standard deviation of 0.039 and 0.022, respectively. A normal quantile analysis and residual analysis are also performed to evaluate the correctness of the model responses.

Keywords

Breakwater sliding, First-order reliability method (FORM), Aleatory and epistemic uncertainty, Monte Carlo simulation, Sensitivity analyses, Bayesian linear regression (BLR)

References

[1] Akbari H, Taherkhani A. Numerical study of wave interaction with a composite breakwater located on permeable bed. Coast Eng, 2019, 146: 1-13

[2] Box GEP, Tiao GC (1992). Bayesian inference in statistical analysis. John Wily and Sons, Inc., 25–60 https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118033197

[3] CEM (2002). Coastal engineering manual. Part VI - Chapter 5 - Fundamentals of Design. U.S Army Corps Eng.

[4] Chaudhary B, Hazarika H, Ishibashi I, Abdullah A. Sliding and overturning stability of breakwater under combined effect of earthquake and tsunami. Ocean Eng, 2017, 136: 106-116

[5] Cornell CA (1969). Probability-based structural code. Am Concr. Inst-J, 66, 974–985. https://doi.org/10.14359/7446

[6] De-León D, Loza L. Reliability-based analysis of Lázaro Cárdenas breakwater including the economical impact of the port activity. Int J Disaster Risk Reduct, 2019, 40

[7] Der Kiureghian A. First-and second-order reliability methods, 2005, Engineering design reliability: CRC Press, Boca Raton, USA

[8] Faber MH (2007). Risk and safety in civil engineering. Lecture notes. Inst. Struct. Eng., 335. https://doi.org/10.3929/ethz-a-004230964

[9] Faber MH, Sørensen JD (2002). Reliability based code calibration joint committee on structural safety. Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Applications of Statistics and Probability, San Francisco, 1–17

[10] Gardoni P, Der Kiureghian A, Mosalam KM. Probabilistic capacity models and fragility estimates for reinforced concrete columns based on experimental observations. J Eng Mech, 2002, 128: 1024-1038

[11] Ghadirian A, Bredmose H. Investigation of the effect of the bed slope on extreme waves using first order reliability method. Mar Struct, 2019, 67

[12] Goda Y (2010). Random seas and design of maritime structures. In: Advanced Series on Ocean Engineering, Advanced Series on Ocean Engineering. World Scientific. https://doi.org/10.1142/3587

[13] Goda Y, Takagi H. A reliability design method of caisson breakwaters with optimal wave heights. Coast Eng J, 2000, 42: 357-387

[14] Haldar A, Mahadevan S. Probability, reliability, and statistical methods in engineering design, 2000, New York: John Wiley Sons, 138-272

[15] Haukaas T, Der Kiureghian A (2003). Finite element reliability and sensitivity methods for performance-based earthquake engineering. Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center, Technical report No. 2003/14.

[16] Holthuijsen LH (2007). Waves in oceanic and coastal waters. Cambridge University Press, New York, 73-104.https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511618536

[17] International Hydrographic Organization (1953). Limits of oceans and seas. International Hydrographic Organization (IHO), Bremerhaven, Pangaea. 20-21.

[18] Jiao G, Moan T. Methods of reliability model updating through additional events. Struct Saf, 1990, 9: 139-153

[19] Kim SW, Suh KD. Evaluation of target reliability indices and partial safety factors for sliding of caisson breakwaters. J Coastal Res, 2011, 64: 622-626

[20] Kim SW, Suh KD. Performance analysis of vertical breakwaters designed by partial safety factor method. J Coast Res, 2013, 65: 296-301

[21] Koç ML. Risk assessment of a vertical breakwater using possibility and evidence theories. Ocean Eng, 2009, 36: 1060-1066

[22] Koç ML, Imren Koç D. A cloud theory based reliability analysis method and its application to reliability problems of breakwaters. Ocean Eng, 2020, 209

[23] Lee CE, Kim SW, Park DH, Suh KD. Target reliability of caisson sliding of vertical breakwater based on safety factors. Coast Eng, 2012, 60: 167-173

[24] Li MS, Hsu CJ, Hsu HC, Tsai LH. Numerical analysis of vertical breakwater stability under extreme waves. J Mar Sci Eng, 2020, 8: 1-15

[25] Liu PL, Der Kiureghian A. Multivariate distribution models with prescribed marginals and covariances. Probabilistic Eng Mech, 1986, 1: 105-112

[26] Mahsuli M, Haukaas T. Computer program for multimodel reliability and optimization analysis. J Comput Civ Eng, 2013, 27: 87-98

[27] Mase H, Tsujio D, Yasuda T, Mori N. Stability analysis of composite breakwater with wave-dissipating blocks considering increase in sea levels, surges and waves due to climate change. Ocean Eng, 2013, 71: 58-65

[28] Nowak A, Collins K (2012). Reliability of structures. McGraw-Hill High. Educ., 50–60

[29] OCDI (2002). Technical standards and commentaries for port and harbor facilities in Japan. The Overseas Coastal Area Development Institute of Japan.

[30] Ota T, Matsumi Y, Kawamura H, Ohno K. Prediction model for change in performance of rubble mound revetment under damage progression. Coastal Engineering Proceedings, 2014, 1(34): 63

[31] Oumeraci H. Review and analysis of vertical breakwater failures - lessons learned. Coast Eng, 1994, 22: 3-29

[32] Oumeraci H, Kortenhaus A, Allsop W, de Groot M, Crouch R, Vrijling H, Voortman H (2001). Probabilistic design tools for vertical breakwaters, CRC Press, Vol2d 1–17.

[33] Radfar S, Shafieefar M, Akbari H, Galiatsatou PA, Mazyak AR. Design of a rubble mound breakwater under the combined effect of wave heights and water levels, under present and future climate conditions. Appl Ocean Res, 2021, 112

[34] Takahashi S (2010). Design of vertical breakwaters. Port and Airport Research Institute (PARI). Japan report No. 34. https://doi.org/10.1142/9789814282413_0004

[35] Toyama S. Application of the reliability design method to the safety of caisson breakwaters against sliding. Technical Note of Port and Harbour Research Institute, 1985, 540: 49

[36] Shimosako K, Takahashi S (1999). Application of deformation-based reliability design for coastal structures - espected sliding distance method of composite breakwaters. Proceedings of the International Conference Coastal Structures, 363–371.

[37] Suh KD, Kim SW, Kim S, Cheon S. Effects of climate change on stability of caisson breakwaters in different water depths. Ocean Eng, 2013, 71: 103-112

[38] Suh KD, Kim SW, Mori N, Mase H. Effect of climate change on performance-based design of caisson breakwaters. J. Waterw. Port. Coast Ocean Eng, 2012, 138: 215-225

[39] Takayama T, Ikeda N. Estimation of sliding failure probability of present breakwaters for probabilistic design. Report of the Port and Harbour Research Institute, 1993, 31(5): 3-32

[40] van der Meer JW. Deterministic and probabilistic design of breakwater armor layers. J. Waterw. Port. Coast Ocean Eng, 1988, 114: 66-80