A simulation-based probabilistic design method for arctic sea transport systems

Abstract

When designing an arctic cargo ship, it is necessary to consider multiple stochastic factors. This paper evaluates the merits of a simulation-based probabilistic design method specifically developed to deal with this challenge. The outcome of the paper indicates that the incorporation of simulations and probabilistic design parameters into the design process enables more informed design decisions. For instance, it enables the assessment of the stochastic transport capacity of an arctic ship, as well as of its long-term ice exposure that can be used to determine an appropriate level of ice-strengthening. The outcome of the paper also indicates that significant gains in transport system cost-efficiency can be obtained by extending the boundaries of the design task beyond the individual vessel. In the case of industrial shipping, this allows for instance the consideration of port-based cargo storage facilities allowing for temporary shortages in transport capacity and thus a reduction in the required fleet size / ship capacity.

Keywords

cargo ships / cargo vessels / shipping / ice-going ships / risk-based design / goal-based design / ice / LNG

References

[1] AARI Review ice charts for the Arctic Ocean, 2015

[2] Bauch HA, Pavlidis YA, Polyakova YI, Matishov GG, Kog N. Peachora Sea environments: past present, and future. Ber. Polarforsch. Meeresforsch., 1999, 501: 2005

[3] Bergström M, Ehlers S, Erikstad SO, Erceg S, Bambulyak A. Development of an approach towards mission-based design of arctic maritime transport systems. Proc. 33th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering, 2014

[4] Bunkerindex, 2016. Bunker index MDO. [2016-03-15]. http://www.bunkerindex.com/prices/bixfree_1512.php?priceind ex_id=4

[5] Centre for High North Logistics (CHNL), 2015. Admittance criteria and icebreaker tariffs. [2016-03-10]. http://www.arcticlio. com/nsr_tariffsystem

[6] Craig D, 1996. Discrete-Event simulation. Memorial University of Newfoundland. [2015-12-15]. http://www.cs.mun.ca/~donald/ msc/ node11.html

[7] Ehlers S, Erceg B, Jordaan IJ, Taylor R. Structural analysis under ice loads for ships operating in Arctic waters. Proceedings of MARTECH 2014, 2nd International Conference on Maritime Technology and Engineering, 2014, 449-454

[8] Ehlers S, Kujala P. Cost optimization for ice-loaded structures. Analysis and Design of Marine Structures, 2013, London: Taylor & Francis Group, 111-118

[9] Erceg B T R, Ehlers S, Leira BJ. A response comparison of a stiffened panel subjected to rule-based and measured ice loads. Proceeding of the 33rd International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering, 2014, San Francisco: Polar and Arctic Science and Technology

[10] Eriksson P, Haapala J, Heiler I, Leisti H, Riska K, Vainio J. Ships in compressive ice: Description and operative forecasting of compression in an ice field, 2009

[11] Erikstad SO, Ehlers S. Simulation-based analysis of arctic LNG transport capacity, cost and system integrity. Proc. 33th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering, 2014

[12] Exxon Mobile, 2015. Preparing for change in emission controlled areas by 2015. [2016-01-15]. https://www.xxonmobil.com/ MarineLubes-En/your-industry_hot-topics_emission-control-area-2015.aspx

[13] Forsén AC, Kivelä J, Ranki E. The NSR simulation study work package 4: Design of the NSR service ships, 1998, 120-1998

[14] Gritsenko D, Kiiski T. A review of Russian ice-breaking tariff policy on the northern sea route 1991–2014. Polar Record, 2015, 52(2): 144-158

[15] Hagen A, Grimstad A. The extension of system boundaries in ship design. International Journal of Maritime Engineering, 2010, 152: 17

[16] Heideman T, Salmi P, Uuskallio A, Wilkman G. Full-scale ice trials in ridges with the Azipod (Azimuthing PoddedDrive) Tanker Lunni in the Bay of Bothnia in 1996. Proceedings of the Polartech 96 International Conference on Development and Commercial Utilization of Technologies in Polar Regions, 1996

[17] IMO, 2014. Ships face lower sulphur fuel requirements in emission control areas from 1 January 2015. [2015-11-15]. http://www.imo.org/en/MediaCentre/PressBriefings/Pages/44-E CA-sulphur.aspx#.Vr3eeby9jzI

[18] IMO, 2016. International code for ships operating in polar waters (POLAR CODE). MEPC 68/21/Add.1. Annex 10. [2015-11-15]. http://www.imo.org/en/MediaCentre/HotTopics/polar/Documen ts/ POLAR%20CODE%20TEXT%20AS%20ADOPTED.pdf

[19] ISSC, 2015. Arctic technology. International Ship and offshore Structures Congress (ISSC), Committee V.6 report.

[20] Jordaan IJ, Maes MA, Brown PW, Hermans IP. Probabilistic analysis of local ice pressures. Journal of Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering, 1993, 115: 83-89

[21] Johannessen OM, Alexandrov V, Frolov IY, Sandven S, Pettersson LH, Bobylev LP, Kloster K, Smirnov VG, Mironov YU, Babich NG. Remote sensing of sea ice in the Northern Sea Route: Studies and applications, 2007

[22] Knutsen, 2016. Valencia Knutsen. Knutsen OAS Shipping AS. [2016-01-20]. http://knutsenoas.com/shipping/lng-carriers/valencia/

[23] Lee SK. Combining ice-class rules with direct calculations for design of arctic LNG vessel propulsion, 2008, 17-35

[24] Leppäranta M. The drift of sea ice, 2011, Heidelberg, Berlin: Springer-Praxis

[25] Minin M, 2016. Construction of Sabetta seaport will require unique technologies. Arctic-info. [2016-01-15]. http://www.arcticinfo. com/ExpertOpinion/15-07-2013/construction-of-sabetta-se aport-will-require-unique-technologies

[26] Moore Stephens, 2013. OpCost 2013. Moore Stephens Consulting Ltd.

[27] Niini M, Arpiainen M, Mattsson T. Aurora slim polar research icebreaker. Proceedings of the Arctic Technology Conference, 2012

[28] Nilsen T. Debate on Arctic shipping heats up, 2014

[29] Papanikolaou A. Risk-based ship design-methods, tools and applications, 2009

[30] Rehn CF. Identification and valuation of flexibility in marine systems design, 2015

[31] Riska K. Ice conditions along the north-east passage in view of ship trafficability studies. Proc. 5th International Offshore and Polar Engineering Conference, 1995, 420-427

[32] Riska K. Definition of the new ice class IA Super+. Research Report No. 60, 2009

[33] Riska K, 2010. Ship-ice interaction in ship design: theory and practice. Course Material, NTNU. http://www.eolss.net/sample-chapters/c05/E6-178-44-00.pdf

[34] Romanov IP, 1995. Atlas of ice and snow of the Arctic Basin and Siberian Shelf Seas. Backbone Publishing Company.

[35] Rosneft, 2016. Russia’s Arctic Seas. [2016-05-13]. http://www.rosneft.com/Upstream/Exploration/arctic_seas/

[36] RS, 2015. Rules for the classification and construction of sea-going ships. Russian Maritime Register of Shipping, Vol. 1.

[37] Schartmüller B, Milakovic AS, Bergström M, Ehlers S. A simulation-based decision support tool for Arctic transit transport. Proceedings of the ASME 2015 34th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering, 2015

[38] SINTEF, 2015. SINMOD -A physical -chemical -biological model system. [2016-05-12]. http://www.sinmod.no/images/

[39] Stephenson SR, Laurence CS, Brigham LW, Agnew JA. Projected 21st-century changes to Arctic marine access. Climate Change, 2013, 118(3): 885-899

[40] Stopford M. Marine economics, 1997

[41] Taylor RS, Jordaan IJ, Li L, Sudom D. Local design pressures for structures in ice: analysis of full-scale data. Proceedings of the ASME 2009, 28th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering, 2009, 61-69

[42] Tõns T, Freeman R, Ehlers S, Jordaan IJ. Probabilistic design load method for the Northen Sea Route. Proceedings of the ASME 2015, 34th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering, 2015

[43] Tusiani MD, Shearer G. LNG: a nontechnical guide, 2007

[44] Valkonen J, Riska K. Assessment of the feasibility of the arctic sea transportation by using ship transit simulation. Proc. 33th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering, 2014

[45] Wärtsilä, 2014. Wärtsilä dual fuel engines chosen to power Arc 7 design icebreaking LNG carriers. Press release. [15, 2015-12-15]. http://www.wartsila.com/media/news/10-11-2014-wartsila-dualfuel-engines-chosen-to-power-arc-7-design-icebreaking-lng-carriers

[46] Yamal LNG. About Yamal LNG, 2015

[47] Østreng W, 1999. The natural and societal challenges of the Northern Sea Route. Springer-Science+Business Media.B.V.

[48] Østreng W, Eger KM, Fløistad B, Jørgensen-Dahl A, Lothe L, Mejlænder-Larsen M, Wergeland T. Shipping in Arctic Waters: a comparison of the Northeast, Northwest and Trans Polar Passages, 2013