Comparison of the performance of two direct wave energy conversion systems: Archimedes wave swing and power buoy

Abstract

Many wave energy conversion devices have not been well received. The main reasons are that they are too complicated and not economical. However, in the last two decades direct conversion systems have drawn the attention of researchers to their widely distributed energy source due to their simple structure and low cost. The most well-known direct conversion systems presently in use include the Archimedes Wave Swing (AWS) and Power Buoy (PB). In this paper, these two systems were simulated in the same conditions and their behaviors were studied in different wave conditions. In order to verify the simulations, results of the generator of the finite element computations were followed. An attempt was made to determine the merits and drawbacks of each method under different wave conditions by comparing the performance of the two systems. The wave conditions suitable for each system were specified.

Keywords

AWS / PB / direct wave energy conversion / PM linear generator

References

[1] Bredmo A, Falnes J, Lillebekken PM (1995). Conversion of wave energy by twin oscillating water columns. 2nd European Wave Power Conference, Lisbon, 1–5.

[2] Budal K, Falnes J, Kyllingstad A, Oltedal G (1979). Experiments with point absorbers. 1st Symposium on Wave Energy Utilization, Gothenburg, 1–5.

[3] Budal K., Falnes J. Count B.M. Interacting point absorbers with controlled motion. Power from Sea Waves, 1980, New York: Academic Press

[4] Budal K, Falnes J (1982). The Norwegian wave power buoy project. 2nd Symposium on Wave Energy Utilization, Trondheim, 1–5.

[5] Danielsson O., Eriksson M., Leijon M. Study of a longitudinal flux permanent magnet linear generator for wave energy converters. International Journal of Energy Res., 2006, 30: 1130-1145

[6] Danielssonn O, Eriksson M, Leijon M (2006b). Study of a longitudinal flux permanent magnet linear generator for wave energy converters. International Journal Energy Res., 1130–1145.

[7] da Costa J, Sarmento A, Gardner F, Beirao P, Brito-Melo A (2005). Time domain model of the Archimedes Wave Swing wave energy converter. 6th European Wave and Tidal Energy Conference, Glasgow, 91–97.

[8] Falnes J. A review of wave-energy extraction. Marine Structures, 2007, 20(4): 185-201

[9] Falnes J. Ocean waves and oscillating systems, 2002, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

[10] Khalid Mohamed Nor K.M., Arof W., Wijono H.A. Design of a 5kW tubular permanent magnet linear generator. 39th International Universities Conference of Power Engineering (UPEC2004), 2004, 2(6–8): 528-532

[11] Haj Babaei N., Azarmsa S.A. Evaluation of predictive models for wind waves and Introducing a proper Model for Babolsar Coasts. Iranian Journal of Sea Sciences, 2005, 3(1): 15-30

[12] Ivanova I.A., Bernhoff H., Agren O., Leijon M. Simulated generator for wave energy extraction in deep water. Journal of Ocean Engineering, 2005, 32: 1664-1678

[13] Ivanova A.I., Agren O., Bernhoff H., Leijon M. Simulation of wave-energy converter with octagonal linear generator. IEEE Journal of Oceanic Engineering, 2005, 30(3): 619-622

[14] Leijon M., Bernhoff H., Berg M., Ågren O. Economical considerations of renewable electric energy production—especially wave energy. Journal of Renewable Energy, 2003, 28: 1201-1209

[15] Leijon M., Bernhoff H., Ågren O., Isberg J. Multiphysics simulation of wave energy to electric energy conversion by permanent magnet linear generator. IEEE Trans. on Energy Conversion, Piscataway, USA, 2005, 20(1): 219-224

[16] Leijon M., Danielsson O., Eriksson M., Thorburn K., Bernhoff H. An electrical approach to wave energy conversion. Journal of Renewable Energy, 2006, 31: 1309-1319

[17] McCormick ME (1973). Ocean engineering wave mechanics. Wiley, London.

[18] Mueller M.A. Electrical generators for direct drive wave energy converters. Gen. Tran. Dist. IEEE Proc 2002, 2002, 149(4): 446-456

[19] Mueller M.A., Baker N.J. A low speed reciprocating permanent magnet generator for direct drive wave energy converters. Int. Conf. Power Electronics, Machines and Drives, Bath, UK, 2002, 487: 468-473

[20] Mueller M.A., Polinder H., Baker N. Current and novel electrical generator technology for wave energy converters. 7th IEEE International Conference on Electric Machines & Drives2007(IEMDC’07), Antalya, Turkey, 2007, 3–5(2): 1401-1406

[21] Mueller M.A., Baker N.J. A low speed reciprocating permanent magnet generator for direct drive wave energy converters. Int. Conf. Power Electronics, Machines and Drives, 2002, 487: 468-473

[22] Mueller M.A. Electrical generators for direct drive wave energy converters. Proc. Inst. Elect. Eng. Gen., Tran. Dist, 2002, 149(4): 446-456

[23] Mueller MA, Baker NJ, Spooner E (2000). Electrical aspects of direct drive wave energy converter. 4th Eur. Conf. Wave Energy, Aalborg, Denmark, 235–242.

[24] Ohashi S., Matsuzuka T. Basic characteristics of the linear synchronous generator using mechanical vibration. IEEE Trans. Magn., 2005, 41(10): 3829-3831

[25] Polinder H., Damen M.E.C., Gardner F. Design, modeling and test results of the AWS PM linear generator. Euro. Trans. Electr. Power, Wiley, 2005, 15: 245-256

[26] Polinder H, Gardner F, Vriesema V (2000a). Linear PM generator for wave energy conversion in the AWS. ICEM 2000, Espoo, Finland, 1–7.

[27] Polinder H, Gardner F, Vriesema B (2000b). Linear PM generator for wave energy conversion in the AWS. International Conference on Electrical Machines (ICEM), Espoo, Finland, 309–313.

[28] Polinder H., Damen M.E.C., Gardner F. Design, modeling and test results of the AWS PM linear generator. Euro. Trans. Electr. Power, 2005, 15: 245-256

[29] Pinto P. Time domain simulation of the AWS, 2004, Lisbon: Technical University of Lisbon, IST

[30] Rhinefrank K., Agamloh E.B., von Jouanne A., Wallace A.K., Prudell J., Kimble K., Aills J., Schmidt E., Chan P., Sweeny B., Schachera A. Novel ocean energy permanent magnet linear generator buoy. Journal of Renewable Energy, 2006, 31: 1279-1298

[31] Wang J., Jewell G.W., Howe D. A general framework for the analysis and design of tubular linear permanent magnet machines. IEEE Trans. Magn., 1999, 35(3): 1986-2000

[32] Wijono HA, Nor KM (2003). Linear generator: design and simulation. National Power and Energy Conference (PECon), Bangi, Malaysia, 306–311.