Superior single-atom and single-cluster catalysts towards electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reactions: a theoretical perspective

Abstract

The traditional Haber-Bosch process for ammonia synthesis is both energy-intensive and capital-demanding. Electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) has emerged as a promising, sustainable alternative, with recent advantages highlighting its potential. Single-atom catalysts (SACs) and single-cluster catalysts (SCCs) are promising catalysts for NRR due to their atomically dispersed active sites, maximized atom utilization, and distinctive coordination and electronic structures, all of which facilitate mechanism insights at the atomic level. Benefiting from efficient atom utilization, for example, the ammonia yield rate on Au_1/C₃N₄ is roughly 22.5 times as high as that of supported Au nanoparticles, fully demonstrating the significant advantages of SACs over nanoparticles. In this review, we focus on the theoretical progress in SACs and SCCs for electrocatalyzing NRR, including nitrogenase-like bio-inspired catalysts and other metal-based catalysts. We further examine key adsorption energy and electronic descriptors that enhance our understanding of catalytic performance. Finally, we discuss the remaining challenges and future directions for advancing SACs and SCCs in electrocatalytic NRR applications.

Keywords

Nitrogen reduction reaction / electrocatalysts / single-atom catalysts / single-cluster catalysts / theoretical perspective

References

[1] Abbet S,Heiz U.Acetylene cyclotrimerization on supported size-selected Pd_n clusters (1 ≤ n ≤ 30): one atom is enough!.J Am Chem Soc2000;122:3453-7

[2] Li Y,Yu G,Chen Z.CO catalytic oxidation on iron-embedded graphene: computational quest for low-cost nanocatalysts.J Phys Chem C2010;114:6250-4

[3] Lee DH,Lee WJ,Kim YH.Theory, synthesis, and oxygen reduction catalysis of Fe-porphyrin-like carbon nanotube.Phys Rev Lett2011;106:175502

[4] Qiao B,Yang X.Single-atom catalysis of CO oxidation using Pt₁/FeO_x.Nat Chem2011;3:634-41

[5] Yang XF,Qiao B,Liu J.Single-atom catalysts: a new frontier in heterogeneous.Acc Chem Res2013;46:1740-8

[6] Akri M,Li X.Atomically dispersed nickel as coke-resistant active sites for methane dry reforming.Nat Commun2019;10:5181 PMCID:PMC6858327

[7] Han B,Huang Y.Strong metal-support interactions between Pt single atoms and TiO₂.Angew Chem Int Ed Engl2020;59:11824-9

[8] Jeong H,Kim BS,Han JW.Fully dispersed Rh ensemble catalyst to enhance low-temperature activity.J Am Chem Soc2018;140:9558-65

[9] Wang Y,Scott J,Amal R.Single atom and nanoclustered Pt catalysts for selective CO₂ reduction.ACS Appl Energy Mater2018;1:6781-9

[10] Bai S,Huang B.High-efficiency direct methane conversion to oxygenates on a cerium dioxide nanowires supported rhodium single-atom catalyst.Nat Commun2020;11:954 PMCID:PMC7031227

[11] Sun CN,Lang XY,Jiang Q.Synergistic effect of active sites of double-atom catalysts for nitrogen reduction reaction.ChemSusChem2021;14:4593-600

[12] Wang P,Gao W.Breaking scaling relations to achieve low-temperature ammonia synthesis through LiH-mediated nitrogen transfer and hydrogenation.Nat Chem2017;9:64-70

[13] Guo X,Lin S,Chen Z.Tackling the activity and selectivity challenges of electrocatalysts toward the nitrogen reduction reaction via atomically dispersed biatom catalysts.J Am Chem Soc2020;142:5709-21

[14] Ouyang Y,Bai X,Wang J.Breaking scaling relations for efficient CO₂ electrochemical reduction through dual-atom catalysts.Chem Sci2020;11:1807-13 PMCID:PMC8148381

[15] Chen Z,Yang CC.Atomic (single, double, and triple atoms) catalysis: frontiers, opportunities, and challenges.J Mater Chem A2019;7:3492-515

[16] Galloway JN,Erisman JW.Transformation of the nitrogen cycle: recent trends, questions, and potential solutions.Science2008;320:889-92

[17] Foster S,Duda RD.Catalysts for nitrogen reduction to ammonia.Nat Catal2018;1:490-500

[18] Fu X,Kang Y.Recent advances and challenges of electrochemical ammonia synthesis.Chem Catal2022;2:2590-613

[19] Iqbal MS,Ruan Y.Single-atom catalysts for electrochemical N₂ reduction to NH₃.Rare Met2023;42:1075-97

[20] Shang H.Atomic design of carbon-based dual-metal site catalysts for energy applications.Nano Res2023;16:6477-506

[21] He T,Xia S,Xu G.Experimental and theoretical advances on single atom and atomic cluster-decorated low-dimensional platforms towards superior electrocatalysts.Adv Energy Mater2022;12:2200493

[22] Chen J,Chen J.Heterogeneous two-atom single-cluster catalysts for the nitrogen electroreduction reaction.J Phys Chem C2021;125:19821-30

[23] Yan Z,Xia J.Recent advanced materials for electrochemical and photoelectrochemical synthesis of ammonia from dinitrogen: one step closer to a sustainable energy future.Adv Energy Mater2020;10:1902020

[24] Qu J,Chen H,Wang T.Orbital symmetry matching: achieving superior nitrogen reduction reaction over single-atom catalysts anchored on Mxene substrates.Chinese J Catal2021;42:288-96

[25] Wang T.Achieving industrial ammonia synthesis rates at near-ambient conditions through modified scaling relations on a confined dual site.Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A2021;118:e2106527118

[26] Yao Y,Wang H,Shao M.A spectroscopic study of electrochemical nitrogen and nitrate reduction on rhodium surfaces.Angew Chem Int Ed Engl2020;59:10479-83

[27] Ling C,Li Q,Shi L.New mechanism for N₂ reduction: the essential role of surface hydrogenation.J Am Chem Soc2019;141:18264-70

[28] Abghoui Y.Onset potentials for different reaction mechanisms of nitrogen activation to ammonia on transition metal nitride electro-catalysts.Catal Today2017;286:69-77

[29] Abghoui Y.Computational predictions of catalytic activity of zincblende (110) surfaces of metal nitrides for electrochemical ammonia synthesis.J Phys Chem C2017;121:6141-51

[30] Martín AJ,Pérez-Ramírez J.Electrocatalytic reduction of nitrogen: from haber-bosch to ammonia artificial leaf.Chem2019;5:263-83

[31] Shaw S,Danyal K,Hoffman BM.Nitrite and hydroxylamine as nitrogenase substrates: mechanistic implications for the pathway of N₂ reduction.J Am Chem Soc2014;136:12776-83 PMCID:PMC4160268

[32] Zhao J.Single Mo atom supported on defective boron nitride monolayer as an efficient electrocatalyst for nitrogen fixation: a computational study.J Am Chem Soc2017;139:12480-7

[33] Wang Z,Zhao J.Computational screening of a single transition metal atom supported on the C₂N monolayer for electrochemical ammonia synthesis.Phys Chem Chem Phys2018;20:12835-44

[34] Zhao J,Cai Q.Single transition metal atom embedded into a MoS₂ nanosheet as a promising catalyst for electrochemical ammonia synthesis.Phys Chem Chem Phys2018;20:9248-55

[35] Zhai X,Ge G.The single-Mo-atom-embedded-graphdiyne monolayer with ultra-low onset potential as high efficient electrocatalyst for N₂ reduction reaction.Appl Surf Sci2020;506:144941

[36] Liu S,Gao X.Two-dimensional transition metal porphyrin sheets as a promising single-atom-catalyst for dinitrogen electrochemical reduction to ammonia: a theoretical study.J Phys Chem C2020;124:1492-9

[37] Xu L,Ganz E.Electrocatalytic reduction of N₂ using metal-doped borophene.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2021;13:14091-101

[38] Li C,Wu D,Fan G.Theoretical study of transition metal doped α-borophene nanosheet as promising electrocatalyst for electrochemical reduction of N₂.Comput Theor Chem2022;1213:113732

[39] Ling C,Ouyang Y,Wang J.Single molybdenum atom anchored on N-doped carbon as a promising electrocatalyst for nitrogen reduction into ammonia at ambient conditions.J Phys Chem C2018;122:16842-7

[40] Zhao W,Luo Q.Single Mo₁(Cr₁) atom on nitrogen-doped graphene enables highly selective electroreduction of nitrogen into ammonia.ACS Catal2019;9:3419-25

[41] Liu P,Li Y.Theoretical screening of single atoms anchored on defective graphene for electrocatalytic N₂ reduction reactions: a DFT study.Phys Chem Chem Phys2020;22:9322-9

[42] Niu H,Shao C,Guo Y.Computational screening single-atom catalysts supported on g-CN for N₂ reduction: high activity and selectivity.ACS Sustainable Chem Eng2020;8:13749-58

[43] Li L,Guo Q.Theoretical screening of single-atom-embedded MoSSe nanosheets for electrocatalytic N₂ fixation.J Phys Chem C2019;123:14501-7

[44] Cui Q,Wang W,Du A.Mo-based 2D MOF as a highly efficient electrocatalyst for reduction of N₂ to NH₃: a density functional theory study.J Mater Chem A2019;7:14510-8

[45] Huang Y,Yang L.Graphene–boron nitride hybrid-supported single Mo atom electrocatalysts for efficient nitrogen reduction reaction.J Mater Chem A2019;7:15173-80

[46] Zhou HY,Wen Z.Tuning the catalytic activity of a single Mo atom supported on graphene for nitrogen reduction via Se atom doping.Phys Chem Chem Phys2019;21:14583-8

[47] Ou P,Meng F,Chen Y.Single molybdenum center supported on N-doped black phosphorus as an efficient electrocatalyst for nitrogen fixation.Nanoscale2019;11:13600-11

[48] Qi J,Wei F,Lin S.Design of a high-performance electrocatalyst for N₂ conversion to NH₃ by trapping single metal atoms on stepped CeO₂.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2019;11:47525-34

[49] Gao L,Yu M.A novel phosphotungstic acid-supported single metal atom catalyst with high activity and selectivity for the synthesis of NH₃ from electrochemical N₂ reduction: a DFT prediction.J Mater Chem A2019;7:19838-45

[50] Talib SH,Lu Z.A polyoxometalate cluster-based single-atom catalyst for NH₃ synthesis via an enzymatic mechanism.J Mater Chem A2022;10:6165-77

[51] Li Q,Qiu S.Exploration of iron borides as electrochemical catalysts for the nitrogen reduction reaction.J Mater Chem A2019;7:21507-13

[52] Ma Z,Xiao C.Theoretical screening of efficient single-atom catalysts for nitrogen fixation based on a defective BN monolayer.Nanoscale2020;12:1541-50

[53] Hu J,Wang H.Theoretical screening of single-atom electrocatalysts of MXene-supported 3d-metals for efficient nitrogen reduction.Chinese J of Catal2023;52:252-62

[54] Zhang N,Ma L.Single transition metal atom anchored on g-C₃N₄ as an electrocatalyst for nitrogen fixation: a computational study.Int J Hydrogen Energy2023;48:7621-31

[55] Sahoo SK,Antonietti M,Oschatz M.Electrochemical N₂ reduction to ammonia using single Au/Fe atoms supported on nitrogen-doped porous carbon.ACS Appl Energy Mater2020;3:10061-9 PMCID:PMC7592340

[56] Choi C,Kim N,Kim Y.Suppression of hydrogen evolution reaction in electrochemical N₂ reduction using single-atom catalysts: a computational guideline.ACS Catal2018;8:7517-25

[57] Zhu H,Wei S.Single-metal atom anchored on boron monolayer (β₁₂) as an electrocatalyst for nitrogen reduction into ammonia at ambient conditions: a first-principles study.J Phys Chem C2019;123:4274-81

[58] Feng Z,Chen W.Graphdiyne coordinated transition metals as single-atom catalysts for nitrogen fixation.Phys Chem Chem Phys2020;22:9216-24

[59] Xu Z,Wang M,Liu G.Single atom-doped arsenene as electrocatalyst for reducing nitrogen to ammonia: a DFT study.Phys Chem Chem Phys2020;22:26223-30

[60] Zhang J,Liu B.Coordination engineering of single-atom catalysts for the oxygen reduction reaction: a review.Adv Energy Mater2021;11:2002473

[61] Ikeda T,Osuka A.Synthesis of extremely pi-extended porphyrin tapes from hybrid meso-meso linked porphyrin arrays: an approach towards the conjugation length.Chem Asian J2009;4:1248-56

[62] Nakamura Y,Shinokubo H.A directly fused tetrameric porphyrin sheet and its anomalous electronic properties that arise from the planar cyclooctatetraene core.J Am Chem Soc2006;128:4119-27

[63] Yang L,Wu M,Xiao B.Mo decoration on graphene edge for nitrogen fixation: a computational investigation.Appl Surf Sci2021;568:150867

[64] Patel AM,Siahrostami S,Nørskov JK.Theoretical approaches to describing the oxygen reduction reaction activity of single-atom catalysts.J Phys Chem C2018;122:29307-18

[65] Rodriguez MM,Brennessel WW.N₂ reduction and hydrogenation to ammonia by a molecular iron-potassium complex.Science2011;334:780-3

[66] Wang T,Zhang X.Recent progress of iron-based electrocatalysts for nitrogen reduction reaction.J Mater Sci Technol2023;140:121-34

[67] Li XF,Cheng J.Conversion of dinitrogen to ammonia by FeN₃-embedded graphene.J Am Chem Soc2016;138:8706-9

[68] Li B,Wu Q,Huang B.Coronene-based 2D metal–organic frameworks: a new family of promising single-atom catalysts for nitrogen reduction reaction.J Phys Chem C2021;125:20870-6

[69] Sippel D,Netzer J.A bound reaction intermediate sheds light on the mechanism of nitrogenase.Science2018;359:1484-9

[70] Liu C,Zhang J,Macfarlane DR.Conversion of dinitrogen to ammonia on Ru atoms supported on boron sheets: a DFT study.J Mater Chem A2019;7:4771-6

[71] Yin H,Gan L.Pt-embedded in monolayer g-C₃N₄ as a promising single-atom electrocatalyst for ammonia synthesis.J Mater Chem A2019;7:11908-14

[72] Chen Z,Cabrera CR.Computational screening of efficient single-atom catalysts based on graphitic carbon nitride (g-C₃N₄) for nitrogen electroreduction.Small Methods2019;3:1800368

[73] Wang M,Ma F.Theoretical insights into the mechanism of nitrogen-to-ammonia electroreduction on TM/g-C₉N₁₀.Mol Cataly2023;547:113391

[74] Saeidi N,Sardroodi JJ.Electrochemical reduction of N₂ to NH₃ using a co-atom stabilized on defective N-doped graphene: a computational study.ChemistrySelect2019;4:12216-26

[75] Wu J,Yu YX.Single Nb or W atom-embedded BP monolayers as highly selective and stable electrocatalysts for nitrogen fixation with low-onset potentials.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces2021;13:10026-36

[76] Gao Y,Hao L.Single Nb atom modified anatase TiO₂(110) for efficient electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reaction.Chem Catal2022;2:2275-88

[77] Li Q,Liu C.Computational design of single-molybdenum catalysts for the nitrogen reduction reaction.J Phys Chem C2019;123:2347-52

[78] Jiao D,Cai Q.Coordination tunes the activity and selectivity of the nitrogen reduction reaction on single-atom iron catalysts: a computational study.J Mater Chem A2021;9:1240-51

[79] Wang X.Efficient modulation of the catalytic performance of electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction with transition metals anchored on N/O-codoped graphene by coordination engineering.J Mater Chem A2022;10:1481-96

[80] Tang Y,Cheng X.Single vanadium atom achored on sulfur-doped graphene as an efficient electrocatalyst toward the nitrogen reduction reaction: a computational view.J Phys Chem C2023;127:24574-82

[81] Di Liberto G, Giordano L, Pacchioni G. Predicting the stability of single-atom catalysts in electrochemical reactions.ACS Catal2024;14:45-55

[82] Chu Z,Duan X.Single metal atom anchored on a CN monolayer as an excellent electrocatalyst for the nitrogen reduction reaction.Phys Chem Chem Phys2021;23:2658-62

[83] Song R,Wang M.Theoretical study on P-coordinated metal atoms embedded in arsenene for the conversion of nitrogen to ammonia.ACS Omega2021;6:8662-71 PMCID:PMC8015104

[84] Wang X,Hao W,Zhou J.A novel porous graphitic carbon nitride (g-C₇N₃) substrate: prediction of metal-based π–d conjugated nanosheets toward the highly active and selective electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reaction.J Mater Chem A2022;10:15036-50

[85] Song W,Wang J,He C.Density functional theory study of transition metal single-atoms anchored on graphyne as efficient electrocatalysts for the nitrogen reduction reaction.Phys Chem Chem Phys2021;23:10418-28

[86] Zhao Y,Li H.Atomically dispersed uranium enables an unprecedentedly high NH₃ yield rate.Nano Lett2022;22:4475-81

[87] Meng Q,Song D,Qin R.Flexible iron clusters promoting ammonia synthesis: a density functional theory prediction.J Phys Chem Lett2024;15:10623-8

[88] Li R.Superiority of dual-atom catalysts in electrocatalysis: one step further than single-atom catalysts.Adv Energy Mater2022;12:2103564

[89] Qian Y,Zhao Y,Yu G.Single vs double atom catalyst for N₂ activation in nitrogen reduction reaction: a DFT perspective.EcoMat2020;2:e12014

[90] Chen ZW,Jiang Q.Single or double: which is the altar of atomic catalysts for nitrogen reduction reaction?.Small Methods2019;3:1800291

[91] Zhang X,Zhang Z.Double-atom catalysts: transition metal dimer-anchored C₂N monolayers as N₂ fixation electrocatalysts.J Mater Chem A2018;6:18599-604

[92] Guo R,Zhang W.Boosting electrochemical nitrogen reduction performance over binuclear Mo atoms on N-doped nanoporous graphene: a theoretical investigation.Molecules2019;24:1777 PMCID:PMC6539356

[93] Zhang Z.g-C₃N₄-supported metal-pair catalysts toward efficient electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction: a computational evaluation.Adv Theory Simul2022;5:2100579

[94] Yang Y,Shan J.Electrocatalytically activating and reducing N₂ molecule by tuning activity of local hydrogen radical.Angew Chem Int Ed Engl2023;62:e202300989

[95] Wu Y,Zhang W.Building up a general selection strategy and catalytic performance prediction expressions of heteronuclear double-atom catalysts for N₂ reduction.J Energy Chem2023;82:375-86

[96] Zheng X,Wang Y.Tuning the electronic structure of transition metals embedded in nitrogen-doped graphene for electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction: a first-principles study.Nanoscale2020;12:9696-707

[97] He T,Du A.Atomically embedded asymmetrical dual-metal dimers on N-doped graphene for ultra-efficient nitrogen reduction reaction.J Catal2020;388:77-83

[98] Li Y,Li C.Atomically dispersed metal dimer species with selective catalytic activity for nitrogen electrochemical reduction.J Mater Chem A2019;7:22242-7

[99] Zheng G,Hao S,Tian Z.Double atom catalysts: heteronuclear transition metal dimer anchored on nitrogen-doped graphene as superior electrocatalyst for nitrogen reduction reaction.Adv Theory Simul2020;3:2000190

[100] Ma D,Liu L.Theoretical screening of the transition metal heteronuclear dimer anchored graphdiyne for electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction.J Energy Chem2021;54:501-9

[101] Cui C,Cheng R,Luo Z.On the nature of three-atom metal cluster catalysis for N₂ reduction to ammonia.ACS Catal2022;12:14964-75

[102] Liu JC,Li Y,Xiao H.Heterogeneous Fe₃ single-cluster catalyst for ammonia synthesis via an associative mechanism.Nat Commun2018;9:1610 PMCID:PMC5913218

[103] Chen ZW,Jiang M.A triple atom catalyst with ultrahigh loading potential for nitrogen electrochemical reduction.J Mater Chem A2020;8:15086-93

[104] Guo R,Liu M.Modulating the coordination environment of active site structure for enhanced electrochemical nitrogen reduction: the mechanistic insight and an effective descriptor.Appl Surf Sci2024;644:158799

[105] Han B,Li F.Fe₃ cluster anchored on the C₂N monolayer for efficient electrochemical nitrogen fixation.Catalysts2020;10:974

[106] Han B.Regulating the electrocatalytic performance for nitrogen reduction reaction by tuning the N contents in Fe₃@N_xC_20-x (x = 0~4): a DFT exploration.J Mater Inf2023;3:24

[107] Chen S,Wang W,Xu L.Prediction of three-metal cluster catalysts on two-dimensional W₂N₃ support with integrated descriptors for electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction.ACS Nano2023:1522-32

[108] Pei W,Yu X.Computational design of spatially confined triatomic catalysts for nitrogen reduction reaction.J Mater Inf2023;3:26

[109] Pei W,Yu X.Graphitic carbon nitride supported trimeric metal clusters as electrocatalysts for N₂ reduction reaction.J Catal2024;429:115232

[110] Zhang H,Luo Z.MoS₂-supported Fe₂ clusters catalyzing nitrogen reduction reaction to produce ammonia.J Phys Chem C2020;124:6260-6

[111] Anis I,Rather GM.N₂ activation and reduction on graphdiyne supported single, double, and triple boron atom catalysts: a first principles investigation.ChemistrySelect2023;8:e202300993

[112] Wang X,Li B.First principles study of double boron atoms supported on graphitic carbon nitride (g-C₃N₄) for nitrogen electroreduction.Crystals2022;12:1744

[113] Rasool A,Bhat SA.Optimizing the NRR activity of single and double boron atom catalysts using a suitable support: a first principles investigation.Phys Chem Chem Phys2023;25:22275-85

[114] Hu Y,Wei Z,Zhao Y.Recent advances and applications of machine learning in electrocatalysis.J Mater Inf2023;3:18

[115] Lu Y,Zhang Q.Single-atom catalytic N₂ fixation with integrated descriptors on a novel π-π conjugated graphitic carbon nitride (g-C₁₃N₁₅) platform obtained by self-doping design: prediction of ultrahigh activity and desirable selectivity.J Power Sources2024;595:234030

[116] Lv X,Huang B,Frauenheim T.High-throughput screening of synergistic transition metal dual-atom catalysts for efficient nitrogen fixation.Nano Lett2021;21:1871-8

[117] Sun J,Lin Y.Theoretical exploration of the nitrogen fixation mechanism of two-dimensional dual-metal TM₁TM₂@C₉N₄ electrocatalysts.Nanoscale Horiz2023;8:211-23

[118] Sun J,Guan J.Interpretable machine learning-assisted high-throughput screening for understanding NRR electrocatalyst performance modulation between active center and C-N coordination.Energy Environ Mater2024;7:e12693

[119] Zhang S,Zhang P.Accelerated discovery of single-atom catalysts for nitrogen fixation via machine learning.Energy Environ Mater2023;6:e12304

[120] Zhang Y,Ma N.Directly predicting N₂ electroreduction reaction free energy using interpretable machine learning with non-DFT calculated features.J Energy Chem2024;97:139-48

[121] Chen C,Yin W,Yao Y.Single transition metal atom modified MoSe₂ as a promising electrocatalyst for nitrogen fixation: a first-principles study.Chem Phys Lett2021;780:138939

[122] Ma D,Liu L,Jia Y.Computational evaluation of electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction on TM single-, double-, and triple-atom catalysts (TM = Mn, Fe, Co, Ni) based on graphdiyne monolayers.J Phys Chem C2019;123:19066-76

[123] Ren C,Lin W,Huang S.Density functional theory study of single-atom V, Nb, and Ta catalysts on graphene and carbon nitride for selective nitrogen reduction.ACS Appl Nano Mater2020;3:5149-59

[124] Luo Y,Dai Y.Transition metal-modified Co₄ clusters supported on graphdiyne as an effective nitrogen reduction reaction electrocatalyst.Inorg Chem2021;60:18251-9

[125] Liu S.Rational design of highly efficient electrocatalytic single-atom catalysts for nitrogen reduction on nitrogen-doped graphene and g-C₂N supports.J Power Sources2022;535:231449

[126] Wang J,Zhang X.Single transition metal atom anchored on VSe₂ as electrocatalyst for nitrogen reduction reaction.Appl Surf Sci2022;580:152272

[127] Zhang Y,Liu T.Charge and spin communication between dual metal single-atom sites on C₂N sheets: regulating electronic spin moments of Fe atoms for N₂ activation and reduction.J Mater Chem A2022;10:23704-11

[128] Nong W,Huang F.Designing C₃N-supported single atom catalysts for efficient nitrogen reduction based on descriptor of catalytic activity.Carbon2021;182:297-306

[129] Zheng X,Yao Y.Trimetallic single-cluster catalysts for electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction: activity prediction, mechanism, and electronic descriptor.Chem Eng J2021;426:130745

[130] Barlocco I,Liberto GD.Electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction from ab initio thermodynamics: single versus dual atom catalysts.Adv Theory Simul2024;7:2400536