Biological performance of particleboard incorporated with boron minerals

Abstract

We compared resistance to decay, mold fungi, termites and insect larvae of particleboards incorporated with the raw boron minerals ulexite and colemanite to that of particleboards impregnated with the commercial boron preservative zinc borate, or boric acid plus a borax mixture. We also quantified water absorption, thickness swell and boron release of particleboards. Ulexite had the best decay resistance, and colemanite had the best termite resistance. However, ulexite and colemanite were not as effective as zinc borate or the boric acid/borax mixture in preventing mold growth. In general, the boric acid/borax mixture combination was more effective against Anobium larvae than the other treatments. Less boron was released by specimens containing zinc borate and colemanite than by those containing ulexite or the boric acid/borax mixture. In general, water absorption and thickness swell were similar among the different treatments, but both were slightly higher in the ulexite-incorporated specimens. Further mechanical tests will be needed to evaluate the particleboard properties and thereby the compatibility of these boron minerals with various manufacturing processes.

Keywords

Biological resistance / Borax / Boric acid / Colemanite / Particleboard / Ulexite

References

[1] Akbulut T, Kartal SN, Green F III. Properties of medium density fiberboard (MDF) treated with N’-N-(1, 8-Naphthalyl) hydroxylamine (NHA-Na), borax and boric acid. For Prod J, 2004, 54(10): 59-64.

[2] ASTM. ASTM D4445 Standard test method for fungicides for controlling sapstain and mould on unseasoned lumber (laboratory method), 2010, West Conshohocken: ASTM International.

[3] AWPA. AWPA T1-12 use category system: processing and treatment standard, 2012, Alabama: AWPA Birmingham.

[4] Ayrılmış N, Kartal SN, Laufenberg TL, Winandy JE, White RH. Evaluation of physical and mechanical properties, fire, decay, and termite resistance of variously treated oriented strand board (OSB). For Prod J, 2005, 55(5): 74-81.

[5] Barnes HM, Amburgey TL (1993) Technologies for the protection of wood composites. In: Preston AF (ed) Proceedings of the IUFRO symposium on protection of wood-based composite products. Orlando, FL, Forest Products Society, Madison, WI, pp 7–11

[6] Bhatia TK (2002) Use of borate-treated wood as part of an IPM approach for durable and sustainable construction. In: Jones SC, Zhai J, Robinson WMH (eds) Proceedings of the 4th international conference on Urban pests, Charleston, pp 269–276

[7] Birsoy R, Özbaş Ü. Activity diagrams of borates: implications on common deposits. Carbonates Evaporites, 2012, 27: 71-85.

[8] BS EN (1993) BS EN 317 Particleboard and Fiberboard—Determination of Swelling in Thickness after Immersion in Water. BSI—British Standards Institution, BSI London, the UK

[9] BS EN (1997) BS EN 113 Wood preservatives—test method for determining the protective effectiveness against wood destroying Basidiomycetes—determination of the toxic values. BSI—British Standards Institution, BSI London, the UK

[10] BS EN (2005) BS EN 48 wood preservatives. Determination of eradicant action against larvae of Anobium punctatum (De Geer) (Laboratory Method). BSI—British Standards Institution, BSI London, the UK

[11] BS EN (2010) BS EN 312 Particleboards. Specifications. BSI—British Standards Institution, BSI London, the UK

[12] Curling SF, Murphy RJ. The effect of artificial ageing on the durability of wood-based board materials against basidiomycete decay fungi. Wood Sci Technol, 1999, 33: 245-257.

[13] ENV (1995) ENV 1250-2 Wood preservatives. Methods of measuring losses of active ingredients and other preservative ingredients from treated timber part 2: laboratory method for obtaining samples for analysis to measure losses by leaching into water or synthetic sea water. European Committee for Standardization, Brussels, Belgium

[14] Fogel JL, Lloyd JD. Mold performance of some construction products with and without borates. For Prod J, 2002, 52: 38-43.

[15] Freeman MH, McIntyre CR, Jackson J. A critical and comprehensive review of boron in wood preservation. Proc Am Wood Prot Assoc AWPA, 2009, 105: 279-294.

[16] Han G, Cheng W, Manning M, Eloy P. Performance of zinc borate-treated oriented structural straw board against mold fungi, decay fungi, and termites: a preliminary trial. Bioresources, 2012, 7(3): 2986-2995.

[17] Jis K. JIS K 1571 Test methods for determining the effectiveness of wood preservatives and their performance requirements (in Japanese), 2004, Tokyo: Japanese Standards Association.

[18] Jones WA (2002) Biological, mechanical, and physical properties of southern yellow pine flakeboard containing calcium borate, Unpublished Master’s Thesis, Mississippi State University, Mississippi State, MS

[19] Kartal SN. Chung MP. Boron-based wood preservatives and their use. Handbook on borates: chemistry, production and applications, 2009, New York: Nova Science Publishers Inc 329 348

[20] Kartal SN, Imamura Y (2004) The use of boron as wood preservative systems for wood and wood-based composites. In: Proceedings of the 2nd international boron symposium, Eskişehir, Turkey

[21] Kartal SN, Ayrılmış N, Imamura Y. Decay and termite resistance of plywood treated with various fire retardants. Build Environ, 2007, 42(3): 1207-1211.

[22] Kistler RB, Helvacı C (1994) Boron and borates. In: Carr DD (ed) Industrial minerals and rocks (6th ed), Society for Mining, Metallurgy and Exploration Inc., Littleton, Colorado, pp 171–186

[23] Laks PE, Manning MJ (1997) Mobility of zinc borate wood composite preservative. IRG/WP 97-30153. International Research Group on Wood Preservation, Stockholm, Sweden

[24] Laks PE, Palardy RD (1990) The development of borate-containing flakeboard. In: Hamel M, Robertson D (eds) Proceedings of the 1st international conference on wood protection with diffusible preservatives, Proceedings No. 47355, Forest Products Society, Madison, pp 76–79

[25] Laks PE, Quan X, Palardy RD. Hse CY, Tomita B. The effects of sodium octaborate and zinc borate on the properties of isocyanate-bonded wafer-board. Proceedings of the adhesives and bonded wood symposium, 1991, Madison: Forest Products Society 144 157

[26] Lee S-Y, Wu Q. Leachability of zinc borate-modified oriented strand board (OSB). Mokchae Konhak, 2007, 35(5): 46-57.

[27] Morrell JJ. Wood-based composites: what have we learned?. Int Biodeterior Biodegradation, 2002, 49: 253-258.

[28] Murphy RJ, Dickinson DJ, Turner P, Wickens PJ, Hashim R (1993) Vapor boron treatment of wood composites. In: Preston AF (ed) Proceedings of the IUFRO symposium on protection of wood-based composite products. Orlando, FL, Forest Products Society, Madison, WI, pp 49–56

[29] Özdemir Z, Zorlu S, Akyıldız M, Eryılmaz FY. Determination of indicator plants for boron in the Kırka (Eskisehir, Turkey) boron deposit area. Int J Geosci, 2013, 5(1): 77-84.

[30] Smith WR, Wu Q. Durability improvement for structural wood composites through chemical treatments. For Prod J, 2005, 55(2): 8-17.

[31] Tsunoda K. Preservative properties of vapor-boron-treated wood and wood-based composites. J Wood Sci, 2001, 47: 149-153.

[32] Tsunoda K, Watanabe H, Fukuda K, Hagio K. Effects of zinc borate on the properties of medium density fiberboard. For Prod J, 2002, 52(11/12): 62-65.

[33] US Geological Survey Minerals Yearbook 2013. Boron [Advance Release]. US Department of the Interior, US Geological Survey, July 2015, 10 pp. Available at http://minerals.usgs.gov/minerals/pubs/commodity/boron/myb1-2013-boron.pdf

[34] Usta M, Ustaömer D, Kartal SN, Önderal S. Termite resistance of MDF panels treated with various boron compounds. Int J Mol Sci, 2009, 10: 2789-2797.

[35] Verhey S, Laks P, Richter D. Laboratory decay resistance of woodfiber/thermoplastic composites. For Prod J, 2001, 51(9): 44-49.

[36] Winandy JE. Effects of fire retardant retention, borate buffers, retention, and redrying temperature after treatment on thermal-induced degradation. For Prod J, 1997, 47(6): 79-86.

[37] Xu X, Lee S, Wu Y, Wu Q. Borate-treated strand board from southern wood species: resistance against decay and mold fungi. Bioresources, 2013, 8(1): 104-114.