Umbrella Reviews: Concepts, Methodological Frameworks, and Step-by-Step Implementation

Abstract

The exponential growth of secondary literature has created an imperative for researchers to identify credible and methodologically sound studies within an increasingly complex information landscape. In light of the growing emphasis on evidence-based medicine in both domestic and international contexts, umbrella reviews (URs) have emerged as a critical methodological approach in biomedical research. As an advanced form of tertiary evidence synthesis, URs systematically integrate findings from multiple systematic reviews and meta-analyses, thereby providing a comprehensive evidence base for specific research questions or related fields. This methodological framework enhances the quality of evidence through critically evaluating the validity and reliability of conclusions drawn from secondary or primary studies. The present overview systematically examines the conceptual framework, distinctive characteristics, development process, and methodological quality assessment of URs, with the objective of establishing a theoretical foundation and practical reference for future research in this domain.

Keywords

evidence-based medicine / meta-analysis / systematic review / umbrella review

References

[1] A. P. Siddaway, A. M. Wood, and L. V. Hedges, “How to Do a Systematic Review: A Best Practice Guide for Conducting and Reporting Narrative Reviews, Meta-Analyses, and Meta-Syntheses,” Annual Review of Psychology 70 (2019): 747–770.

[2] D. L. Sackett, W. M. Rosenberg, J. A. Gray, and R. B. Haynes, and W. S. Richardson, “Evidence Based Medicine: What It Is and What It Isn't,” BMJ 312 (1996): 71–72.

[3] Q. Y. Yang, L. Y. Hou, X. Cao, Q. Wang, J. Tian, and L. Ge, “Research Status and Hotspots of Umbrella Review Based on VOSviewer and CiteSpace,” Chinese Journal of Health Management 16 (2022): 401–406.

[4] J. P. A. Ioannidis, “The Mass Production of Redundant, Misleading, and Conflicted Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses,” Milbank Quarterly 94 (2016): 485–514.

[5] R. Kulier, M. D. Onis, A. M. Gülmezoglu, and J. Villar, “Nutritional Interventions for the Prevention of Maternal Morbidity,” International Journal of Gynaecology and Obstetrics 63 (1998): 231–246.

[6] L. A. Bero, R. Grilli, J. M. Grimshaw, E. Harvey, A. D. Oxman, and M. A. Thomson, “Closing the Gap Between Research and Practice: An Overview of Systematic Reviews of Interventions to Promote the Implementation of Research Findings. The Cochrane Effective Practice and Organization of Care Review Group,” BMJ 317 (1998): 465–468.

[7] L. Belbasis, V. Bellou, E. Evangelou, J. P. A. Ioannidis, and I. Tzoulaki, “Environmental Risk Factors and Multiple Sclerosis: An Umbrella Review of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses,” Lancet Neurology 14 (2015): 263–273.

[8] P. E. Bowen and S. Mobarhan, “Evidence From Cancer Intervention and Biomarker Studies and the Development of Biochemical Markers,” American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 62 (1995): 1403S–1409S.

[9] L. Li, J. Tian, H. Tian, R. Sun, Y. Liu, and K. Yang, “Quality and Transparency of Overviews of Systematic Reviews,” Journal of Evidence Based Medicine 5 (2012): 166–173.

[10] E. Aromataris, R. Fernandez, C. M. Godfrey, C. Holly, H. Khalil, and P. Tungpunkom, “Summarizing Systematic Reviews: Methodological Development, Conduct and Reporting of an Umbrella Review Approach,” International Journal of Evidence-Based Healthcare 13 (2015): 132–140.

[11] F. P. Paolo and R. Joaquim, “Ten Simple Rules for Conducting Umbrella Reviews,” Evidence-Based Mental Health 21 (2018): 95–100.

[12] L. Belbasis, V. Bellou, and J. P. A. Ioannidis, “Conducting Umbrella Reviews,” BMJ Medicine 1 (2022): e000071.

[13] H. X. Liu, D. H. Hu, and H. Q. Yin, “Umbrella Review—A New Method Related to Evidence-Based Medical Analysis,” Zhonghua Liu Xing Bing Xue Za Zhi = Zhonghua Liuxingbingxue Zazhi 41, no. 42 (2020): 261–266.

[14] M. Petticrew, “Time to Rethink the Systematic Review Catechism? Moving From ‘What Works’ to ‘What Happens’,” Systematic Reviews 4 (2015): 36.

[15] S. Buchner and D. Riehle, “The Business Impact of Inner Source and How to Quantify It,” ACM Computing Surveys 56 (2023): 1–27.

[16] E. Coiera and S. Liu, “Evidence Synthesis, Digital Scribes, and Translational Challenges for Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare,” Cell Reports Medicine 3 (2022): 100860.

[17] M. Motevalli, “Comparative Analysis of Systematic, Scoping, Umbrella, and Narrative Reviews in Clinical Research: Critical Considerations and Future Directions,” International Journal of Clinical Practice 2025, no. 1 (2025): 1–15.

[18] O. Zawacki-Richter, B. Cefa, and J. Y. H. Bai, “Towards Reproducible Systematic Reviews in Open, Distance, and Digital Education—An Umbrella Mapping Review,” Review of Education 13 (2025): e70031.

[19] J. L. Yin, J. Yang, X. J. Song, et al., “Triglyceride-Glucose Index and Health Outcomes: An Umbrella Review of Systematic Reviews With Meta-Analyses of Observational Studies,” Cardiovascular Diabetology 23 (2024): 177.

[20] N. Liu, R. H. Bao, Y. J. Chang, et al., “Adverse Pregnancy Outcomes and Multiple Cancers Risk in Both Mother and Offspring: An Umbrella Review of Systematic Reviews With Meta-Analyses of Observational Studies,” BMC Medicine [Electronic Resource] 22 (2024): 454.

[21] G. Faulkner, M. J. Fagan, and Lee, “Umbrella Reviews (Systematic Review of Reviews),” International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology 15 (2021): 73–90.

[22] M. Abdellatif, M. N. Dadam, N. T. Vu, et al., “A Step-by-Step Guide for Conducting an Umbrella Review,” Tropical Medicine and Health 53 (2025): 134.

[23] V. Smith, D. Devane, C. M. Begley, and M. Clarke, “Methodology in Conducting a Systematic Review of Systematic Reviews of Healthcare Interventions,” BMC Medical Research Methodology [Electronic Resource] 11 (2011): 15.

[24] S. S. Nayak, E. Amini-Salehi, M. T. Ulrich, et al., “Exploring the Evolution of Evidence Synthesis: A Bibliometric Analysis of Umbrella Reviews in Medicine,” Annals of Medicine and Surgery 87 (2025): 2035–2048.

[25] E. Theodoratou, I. Tzoulaki, L. Zgaga, and J. P. Ioannidis, “Vitamin D and Multiple Health Outcomes: Umbrella Review of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses of Observational Studies and Randomised Trials,” BMJ 348 (2014): g2035.

[26] J. Zhu, X. Yu, Y. Zheng, et al., “Association of Glucose-Lowering Medications With Cardiovascular Outcomes: An Umbrella Review and Evidence Map,” Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology 8 (2020): 192–205.

[27] S. I. Papatheodorou and E. Evangelou, “Umbrella Reviews: What They Are and Why We Need Them,” Methods in Molecular Biology 2345 (2022): 135–146.

[28] H. X. Liu, D. H. Hu, and H. Q. Yin, “[Umbrella Review—A New Method Related to Evidence-Based Medical Analysis],” Zhonghua Liu Xing Bing Xue Za Zhi = Zhonghua Liuxingbingxue Zazhi 41 (2020): 261–266.

[29] P. Goel, “A Perspective Upon Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis,” Journal of Indian Association of Pediatric Surgeons 26 (2021): 139–143.

[30] M. M. Lane, E. Gamage, S. Du, et al., “Ultra-Processed Food Exposure and Adverse Health Outcomes: Umbrella Review of Epidemiological Meta-Analyses,” BMJ 384 (2024): e077310.

[31] E. Calderon Martinez, P. E. Ghattas Hasbun, V. P. Salolin Vargas, et al., “A Comprehensive Guide to Conduct a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis in Medical Research,” Medicine 104 (2025): e41868.

[32] B. Kefale, J. Jancey, A. T. Gebremedhin, et al., “Risk Factors for Neonatal Mortality: An Umbrella Review of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses,” Eclinicalmedicine 88 (2025): 103525.

[33] K. Slim and T. Marquillier, “Umbrella Reviews: A New Tool to Synthesize Scientific Evidence in Surgery,” Journal of Visceral Surgery 159 (2022): 144–149.

[34] J. Martínez-Calderon, “Overviews of Systematic Reviews in Sports and Exercise Medicine: What Are They and Why Are They Important?,” British Journal of Sports Medicine 57 (2023): 1005–1006.

[35] M. Tsagris and K. C. Fragkos, “Umbrella Reviews, Overviews of Reviews, and Meta-Epidemiologic Studies: Similarities and Differences,” in Umbrella Reviews (Springer — International Publisher, 2016).

[36] R. S. Fernandez, A. M. Sharifnia, and H. Khalil, “Umbrella Reviews: A Methodological Guide,” European Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing 24 (2025): 996–1002.

[37] J. Harley, “An Introduction to Umbrella Reviews in Evidence-Based Healthcare Practice,” Nurse Researcher 33, no. 4 (2025): e1965.

[38] G. J. Choi and H. Kang, “Introduction to Umbrella Reviews as a Useful Evidence-Based Practice,” Journal of Lipid and Atherosclerosis 12 (2023): 3–11.

[39] M. Bonczar, P. Ostrowski, A. V. D'Antoni, et al., “How to Write an Umbrella Review? A Step-by-Step Tutorial With Tips and Tricks,” Folia Morphologica 82 (2023): 1–6.

[40] W. Xu, S. Wang, W. Ruan, et al., “Cadmium Exposure and Health Outcomes: An Umbrella Review of Meta-Analyses,” Environmental Research 276 (2025): 121547.

[41] G. Ma, Y. Xu, H. Li, et al., “Dietary Factors and Gestational Diabetes Mellitus: An Umbrella Review,” Trends in Food Science & Technology 138 (2023): 229–237.

[42] C. Stern, J. Li, J. Stone, et al., “Data Analysis and Presentation Methods in Umbrella Reviews/Overviews of Reviews in Health Care: A Cross-Sectional Study,” Research Synthesis Methods (2025): 1–15.

[43] C. J. Gosling, A. Solanes, P. Fusar-Poli, and J. Radua, “Metaumbrella: The First Comprehensive Suite to Perform Data Analysis in Umbrella Reviews With Stratification of the Evidence,” BMJ Mental Health 26 (2023): e300534.

[44] M. G. Antonio, O. Petrovskaya, and F. Lau, “The State of Evidence in Patient Portals: Umbrella Review,” Journal of Medical Internet Research [Electronic Resource] 22 (2020): e23851.

[45] A. Adadi, M. Lahmer, and S. Nasiri, “Artificial Intelligence and COVID-19: A Systematic Umbrella Review and Roads Ahead,” Journal of King Saud University—Computer and Information Sciences 34 (2022): 5898–5920.

[46] A. Ramalho, A. Thabane, T. McKechnie, et al., “Characteristics of Creative Individuals: An Umbrella Review Protocol,” PLoS ONE 19 (2024): e0311851.

[47] A. Adeyemo, A. Coffey, and L. Kingston, “Utilisation of Robots in Nursing Practice: An Umbrella Review,” BMC Nursing 24 (2025): 247.

[48] R. Molani-Gol, A. Dehghani, and M. Rafraf, “Effects of Curcumin/Turmeric Supplementation on the Liver Enzymes, Lipid Profiles, Glycemic Index, and Anthropometric Indices in Non-Alcoholic Fatty Liver Patients: An Umbrella Meta-Analysis,” Phytotherapy Research 38 (2023): 539–555.

[49] Y. Lu, D. Qiao, and G. Mi, “Clinical Impacts of n-3 Fatty Acids Supplementation on Depression Symptoms: An Umbrella Review of Meta-Analyses,” British Journal of Nutrition 131 (2023): 841–850.

[50] J. Yu, J. Wu, B. Liu, K. Zheng, and Z. Ren, “Efficacy of Virtual Reality Technology Interventions for Cognitive and Mental Outcomes in Older People With Cognitive Disorders: An Umbrella Review Comprising Meta-Analyses of Randomized Controlled Trials,” Ageing Research Reviews 94 (2024): 102179.

[51] A. Chew, L. Saigo, and A. U. Yap, “Is There a Comorbid Relationship Between Temporomandibular Disorders and Otologic Signs/Symptoms?: An Umbrella Review,” CRANIO® 43 (2022): 8–21.

[52] S. Neville, S. Napier, J. Montayre, M. Silulu, and E. Tautolo, “The Development, Implementation and/or Sustainability of Age-Friendly Cities and Communities Programmes: Findings From an Umbrella Review,” Journal of Clinical Nursing 34 (2025): 3119–3132.

[53] T. Tülübaş, T. Karakose, and S. Papadakis, “A Holistic Investigation of the Relationship Between Digital Addiction and Academic Achievement Among Students,” European Journal of Investigation in Health, Psychology and Education 13 (2023): 2006–2034.

[54] C. Y. Tan, “Socioeconomic Status and Student Learning: Insights From an Umbrella Review,” Educational Psychology Review 36 (2024): 100.

[55] W. Zhao, Q. Qi, J. Zhou, and X. Luo, “Blockchain-Based Applications for Smart Grids: An Umbrella Review,” Energies 16 (2023): 6147.

[56] S. Morelli, G. D'Avenio, C. Daniele, M. Grigioni, and D. Giansanti, “Under the Tech Umbrella: Assessing the Landscape of Telemedicine Innovations (Telemechron Study),” Healthcare 12 (2024): 615.

[57] S. Negi, A. Mathur, S. Tripathy, et al., “Artificial Intelligence in Dental Caries Diagnosis and Detection: An Umbrella Review,” Clinical and Experimental Dental Research 10 (2024): e70004.

[58] S. Vasić, M. Orošnjak, N. Brkljač, V. Vrhovac, and K. Ristić, “Identification of Criteria for Enabling the Adoption of Sustainable Maintenance Practice: An Umbrella Review,” Sustainability 16 (2024): 767.

[59] S. Malone Gill, O. Hayes, Y. Corcoran, et al., “Protocol for an Umbrella Review of the State-of-Science on Public and Patient Involvement in Health and Social Care Research With Children, Young People and Families,” HRB Open Research 8 (2025): 78.

[60] P. A. Piasecki, T. O. Minkler, C. McGehee, and E. Filho, “Mindfulness in Sport, Exercise, and Performance Psychology: An Umbrella Review and Directions for Future Research,” International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology 18 (2025): 1–24.

[61] B. Singh, H. Bennett, A. Miatke, et al., “Effectiveness of Exercise for Improving Cognition, Memory and Executive Function: A Systematic Umbrella Review and Meta-Meta-Analysis,” British Journal of Sports Medicine 59 (2025): 866–876.

[62] M. Singh, S. Wambua, S. I. Lee, et al., “Autoimmune Diseases and Adverse Pregnancy Outcomes: An Umbrella Review,” Lancet 402 (2023): S84.

[63] C. S. Lin, T. C. Chen, M. C. Verhoeff, F. Lobbezoo, M. Trulsson, and J. L. Fuh, “An Umbrella Review on the Association Between Factors of Oral Health and Cognitive Dysfunction,” Ageing Research Reviews 93 (2024): 102128.

[64] M. Solmi, M. De Toffol, J. Y. Kim, et al., “Balancing Risks and Benefits of Cannabis Use: Umbrella Review of Meta-Analyses of Randomised Controlled Trials and Observational Studies,” BMJ 382 (2023): e072348.

[65] D. Edwards, J. Williams, J. Carrier, and J. Davies, “Technologies Used to Facilitate Remote Rehabilitation of Adults With Deconditioning, Musculoskeletal Conditions, Stroke, or Traumatic Brain Injury: An Umbrella Review,” JBI Evidence Synthesis 20 (2022): 1927–1968.

[66] O. Köhler-Forsberg, V. Stiglbauer, J. Brasanac, W. R. Chae, F. Wagener, and K. Zimbalski, “Efficacy and Safety of Antidepressants in Patients With Comorbid Depression and Medical Diseases,” JAMA Psychiatry 80 (2023): 1196–1207.

[67] H. Donato and M. Donato, “Revisão Das Revisões (Revisões Umbrella): Guia Passo a Passo,” Acta Medica Portuguesa 37 (2024): 547–555.

[68] I. F. M. Roqué, M. Sabater-Martos, and I. Solà, “Umbrella Reviews,” Cirugía Española (English Edition) 102 (2024): 555–557.

[69] A. M. Methley, S. Campbell, C. Chew-Graham, R. McNally, and S. Cheraghi-Sohi, “PICO, PICOS and SPIDER: A Comparison Study of Specificity and Sensitivity in Three Search Tools for Qualitative Systematic Reviews,” BMC Health Services Research [Electronic Resource] 14 (2014): 579.

[70] T. Muka, M. Glisic, J. Milic, et al., “A 24-Step Guide on How to Design, Conduct, and Successfully Publish a Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis in Medical Research,” European Journal of Epidemiology 35 (2020): 49–60.

[71] C. Stern, Z. Jordan, and A. McArthur, “Developing the Review Question and Inclusion Criteria,” American Journal of Nursing 114 (2014): 53–56.

[72] C. Falandry, L. Stefani, L. Andre, et al., “Interventions to Improve Physical Performances of Older People With Cancer Before Complex Medico-Surgical Procedures,” Medicine 99 (2020): e21780.

[73] I. Pérez-Neri, C. Pineda, J. L. Flores-Guerrero, et al., “Adherence to Literature Search Reporting Guidelines in Leading Rheumatology Journals' Systematic Reviews: Umbrella review Protocol,” Rheumatology International 42 (2022): 2135–2140.

[74] T. Y. Lin, K. V. Chang, W. T. Wu, and L. Özçakar, “Ultrasonography for the Diagnosis of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: An Umbrella Review,” Journal of Neurology 269 (2022): 4663–4675.

[75] S. Y. Chang, S. Z. Wang, and H. F. Lee, “The Cultural Difference Between Empowerment and Job Satisfaction Among Nurses: An Umbrella Review,” Applied Nursing Research 82 (2025): 151912.

[76] O. Petrovskaya, F. Lau, and M. Antonio, “Synthesising Evidence on Patient Portals: A Protocol for an Umbrella Review,” BMJ Open 9 (2019): e024469.

[77] H. Hasan, T. Muhammed, J. Yu, et al., “Assessing the Methodological Quality of Systematic Reviews in Radiation Oncology: A Systematic Review,” Cancer Epidemiology 50 (2017): 141–149.

[78] L. Brunelli, A. Sacre, C. Bambra, et al., “Socioeconomic Inequalities in Vaccine Uptake: A Global Umbrella Review,” PLoS ONE 18 (2023): e029468.

[79] W. M. Bramer, M. L. Rethlefsen, J. Kleijnen, and O. H. Franco, “ Optimal Database Combinations for Literature Searches in Systematic Reviews: A Prospective Exploratory Study,” (2017): 245.

[80] Q. J. Cheng, Q. Y. Yang, C. Tian, Y. Lu, Y. Li, and L. Ge, “The Formulation Methods and Steps of Umbrella Review,” Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine 23 (2023): 1457–1464.

[81] M. Ouzzani, H. Hammady, Z. Fedorowicz, and A. Elmagarmid, “Rayyan-A Web and Mobile App for Systematic Reviews,” Systematic Reviews 5 (2016): 210.

[82] D. M. S. Van, K. Tsaioun, A. Bleich, and C. H. C. Leenaars, “Software Tools for Literature Screening in Systematic Reviews in Biomedical Research,” Altex 36 (2019): 508–517.

[83] M. W. D. Matthew, R. Tyler, M. Mark, and W. Barrett, “Reference Managers,” Clinical Spine Surgery 37 (2024): 77–78.

[84] J. D. Harris, C. E. Quatman, M. M. Manring, R. A. Siston, and D. C. Flanigan, “How to Write a Systematic Review,” American Journal of Sports Medicine 42 (2013): 2761–2768.

[85] R. Debora, A. Beatrice, B. Barbara, D. Federica, D. S. Emanuele, and T. Stefano, “Nurse's Bedside Screening of Dysphagia: An Umbrella Review,” Recenti Progressi in Medicina 113 (2022): 361–371.

[86] M. Sentenac, S. Twilhaar, V. Benhammou, et al., “Heterogeneity of Design Features in Studies Included in Systematic Reviews With Meta-Analysis of Cognitive Outcomes in Children Born Very Preterm,” Paediatric and Perinatal Epidemiology 37 (2023): 254–262.

[87] R. Prowse and S. Carsley, “Digital Interventions to Promote Healthy Eating in Children: Umbrella Review,” JMIR Pediatrics and Parenting 4 (2021): e30160.

[88] B. J. Shea, B. C. Reeves, G. Wells, et al., “AMSTAR 2: A Critical Appraisal Tool for Systematic Reviews That Include Randomised or Non-Randomised Studies of Healthcare Interventions, or Both,” BMJ 358 (2017): j4008.

[89] P. Whiting, J. Savović, J. P. T. Higgins, et al., “ROBIS: A New Tool to Assess Risk of Bias in Systematic Reviews Was Developed,” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 69 (2016): 225–234.

[90] A. V. D'Antoni, R. S. Tubbs, A. C. Patti, Q. M. Higgins, H. Tiburzi, and F. Battaglia, “The Critical Appraisal Tool for Anatomical Meta-Analysis: A Framework for Critically Appraising Anatomical Meta-Analyses,” Clinical Anatomy 35 (2022): 323–331.

[91] B. J. Shea, J. M. Grimshaw, G. A. Wells, et al., “Development of AMSTAR: A Measurement Tool to Assess the Methodological Quality of Systematic Reviews,” BMC Medical Research Methodology [Electronic Resource] 7 (2007): 10.

[92] H. Y. Chen, M. Gao, and X. G. Li, “Coffee Intake and Cancer: An Umbrella Review of Meta-Analyses,” Shanghai Journal of Preventive Medicine 35 (2023): 1259–1264.

[93] J. Xiong and R. X. Chen, “An Introduction to a Measurement Tool to Assess the Methodological Quality of Systematic Reviews/Meta-Analysis: AMSTAR,” Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine 11 (2011): 1084–1089.

[94] R. Perry, A. Whitmarsh, V. Leach, and P. Davies, “A Comparison of Two Assessment Tools Used in Overviews of Systematic Reviews: ROBIS Versus AMSTAR-2,” Systematic Reviews 10 (2021): 273.

[95] M. J. Swierz, D. Storman, J. Zajac, et al., “Similarities, Reliability and Gaps in Assessing the Quality of Conduct of Systematic Reviews Using AMSTAR-2 and ROBIS: Systematic Survey of Nutrition Reviews,” BMC Medical Research Methodology [Electronic Resource] 21 (2021): 261.

[96] D. R. T. Laursen, S. Brorson, A. Lundh, et al., “Critical Reading of Systematic Review Articles,” Ugeskrift for Laeger 186 (2024): 1–11.

[97] Y. Huang, D. Cao, Z. Chen, et al., “Red and Processed Meat Consumption and Cancer Outcomes: Umbrella Review,” Food Chemistry 356 (2021): 129697.

[98] N. Veronese, J. Demurtas, S. Celotto, et al., “Is Chocolate Consumption Associated With Health Outcomes? An Umbrella Review of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses,” Clinical Nutrition 38 (2019): 1101–1108.

[99] A. M. Caplan and L. Caplan, “The GRADE Method,” Rheumatic Diseases Clinics of North America 48 (2022): 589–599.

[100] G. Guyatt, A. D. Oxman, E. A. Akl, et al., “GRADE Guidelines: 1. Introduction—GRADE Evidence Profiles and Summary of Findings Tables,” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 64 (2011): 383–394.

[101] G. H. Guyatt, A. D. Oxman, G. Vist, et al., “GRADE Guidelines: 4. Rating the Quality of Evidence—Study Limitations (Risk of Bias),” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 64 (2011): 407–415.

[102] B. Bandelow, J. Zohar, S. Kasper, and H.-J. Möller, “How to Grade Categories of Evidence,” World Journal of Biological Psychiatry: The Official Journal of the World Federation of Societies of Biological Psychiatry 9 (2009): 242–247.

[103] C. Mendoza Pinto and M. García Carrasco, “Sistema GRADE, Evaluación Sistemática y Transparente,” Reumatología Clínica 14 (2018): 65–67.

[104] L. Ge, B. Pan, J. X. Pan, et al., “An Introduction of AMSTAＲ-2: A Quality Assessment Instrument of Systematic Reviews Including Randomized or Non-Randomized Controlled Trials or Both,” Center for Drug Evaluation 34 (2017): 2095–3593.

[105] J. Radua, V. Ramella-Cravaro, J. P. A. Ioannidis, et al., “What Causes Psychosis? An Umbrella Review of Risk and Protective Factors,” World Psychiatry 17 (2018): 49–66.

[106] L. Belbasis, C. A. Kohler, N. Stefanis, et al., “Risk Factors and Peripheral Biomarkers for Schizophrenia Spectrum Disorders: An Umbrella Review of Meta-Analyses,” Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 137 (2018): 88–97.

[107] V. Bellou, L. Belbasis, I. Tzoulaki, E. Evangelou, and J. P. Ioannidis, “Environmental Risk Factors and Parkinson's Disease: An Umbrella Review of Meta-Analyses,” Parkinsonism & Related Disorders 23 (2016): 1–9.

[108] S. Chinn, “A Simple Method for Converting an Odds Ratio to Effect Size for Use in Meta-Analysis,” Statistics in Medicine 19 (2000): 3127–3131.

[109] C. J. Gosling, S. Cortese, M. Solmi, et al., “MetaConvert: An Automatic Suite for Estimation of 11 Different Effect Size Measures and Flexible Conversion Across Them,” Research Synthesis Methods 16 (2025): 575–586.

[110] L. F. M. Rezende, T. H. Sa, G. Markozannes, et al., “Physical Activity and Cancer: An Umbrella Review of the Literature Including 22 Major Anatomical Sites and 770 000 Cancer Cases,” British Journal of Sports Medicine 52 (2018): 826–833.

[111] J. P. Higgins and S. G. Thompson, “Quantifying Heterogeneity in a Meta-Analysis,” Statistics in Medicine 21 (2002): 1539–1558.

[112] J. Botelho, P. Mascarenhas, J. Viana, et al., “An Umbrella Review of the Evidence Linking Oral Health and Systemic Noncommunicable Diseases,” Nature Communications 13 (2022): 7614.

[113] M. Borenstein, J. P. T. Higgins, L. V. Hedges, and R. HR, “Basics of Meta-Analysis: I2 Is Not an Absolute Measure of Heterogeneity,” Research Synthesis Methods 8 (2017): 5–18.

[114] M. W. Langendam, E. A. Akl, P. Dahm, P. Glasziou, G. Guyatt, and H. J. Schunemann, “Assessing and Presenting Summaries of Evidence in Cochrane Reviews,” Systematic Reviews 2 (2013): 81.

[115] M. Borenstein, L. V. Hedges, J. P. T. Higgins, and H. R. Rothstein, “A Basic Introduction to Fixed-Effect and Random-Effects Models for Meta-Analysis,” Research Synthesis Methods 1 (2010): 97–111.

[116] R. Sugathapala, S. Latimer, A. Balasuriya, W. Chaboyer, L. Thalib, and B. M. Gillespie, “Prevalence and Incidence of Pressure Injuries Among Older People Living in Nursing Homes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis,” International Journal of Nursing Studies 148 (2023): 104605.

[117] T. Lei, Z. Jiang, J. Wang, et al., “Genetic Influence of the Brain on Muscle Structure: A Mendelian Randomization Study of Sarcopenia,” Journal of Cachexia, Sarcopenia and Muscle 16 (2024): e13647.

[118] C. M. Isales, C. Ye, W. Zhang, et al., “Influence of the Infrapatellar Fat Pad Resection During Total Knee Arthroplasty: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis,” PLoS ONE 11 (2016): e0163515.

[119] Q. Du and Y. Zhou, “Placebo-Controlled Assessment of Somnolence Effect of Cetirizine: A Meta-Analysis,” International Forum of Allergy & Rhinology 6 (2016): 871–879.

[120] C. J. Lortie and A. Filazzola, “A Contrast of Meta and Metafor Packages for Meta-Analyses in R,” Ecology & Evolution 10 (2020): 10916–10921.

[121] E. Aromataris, R. Fernandez, C. Godfrey, C. Holly, H. Khalil, and P. Tungpunkom, “Methodology for JBI Umbrella Reviews,” in Joanna Briggs Institute Reviewers' Manua (Joanna Briggs Institute, 2014).

[122] O. D. Howes, T. Whitehurst, E. Shatalina, et al., “The Clinical Significance of Duration of Untreated Psychosis: An Umbrella Review and Random-Effects Meta-Analysis,” World Psychiatry 20 (2021): 75–95.

[123] J. P. Ioannidis, M. R. Munafo, P. Fusar-Poli, B. A. Nosek, and S. P. David, “Publication and Other Reporting Biases in Cognitive Sciences: Detection, Prevalence, and Prevention,” Trends in Cognitive Sciences 18 (2014): 235–241.

[124] H. Ashayeri, H. Salehi-Pourmehr, and A. Jafarizadeh, “Calculation of the Overlap in Umbrella Reviews Based on the Sample Size of Primary Studies,” Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine 18 (2025): e70038.

[125] E. Linares-Espinos, V. Hernandez, J. L. Dominguez-Escrig, et al., “Methodology of a Systematic Review,” Actas Urológicas Españolas (English Edition) 42 (2018): 499–506.

[126] F. Naudet, E. Schuit, and J. P. A. Ioannidis, “Overlapping Network Meta-Analyses on the Same Topic: Survey of Published Studies,” International Journal of Epidemiology 46 (2017): 1999–2008.

[127] P. Janiaud, A. Agarwal, I. Tzoulaki, et al., “Validity of Observational Evidence on Putative Risk and Protective Factors: Appraisal of 3744 Meta-Analyses on 57 Topics,” BMC Medicine [Electronic Resource] 19 (2021): 157.

[128] D. Pieper, S. L. Antoine, T. Mathes, Neugebauer, and M. Eikermann, “Systematic Review Finds Overlapping Reviews Were Not Mentioned in Every Other Overview,” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 67 (2014): 368–375.

[129] E. A. Hennessy and B. T. Johnson, “Examining Overlap of Included Studies in Meta-Reviews: Guidance for Using the Corrected Covered Area Index,” Research Synthesis Methods 11 (2020): 134–145.

[130] K. Okoth, J. S. Chandan, T. Marshall, et al., “Association Between the Reproductive Health of Young Women and Cardiovascular Disease in Later Life: Umbrella Review,” BMJ 371 (2020): m3502.

[131] C. Lunny, D. Pieper, P. Thabet, and S. Kanji, “Managing Overlap of Primary Study Results Across Systematic Reviews: Practical Considerations for Authors of Overviews of Reviews,” BMC Medical Research Methodology [Electronic Resource] 21 (2021): 140.

[132] M. Kirvalidze, A. Abbadi, L. Dahlberg, L. B. Sacco, A. Calderón-Larrañaga, and L. Morin, “Estimating Pairwise Overlap in Umbrella Reviews: Considerations for Using the Corrected Covered Area (CCA) Index Methodology,” Research Synthesis Methods 14 (2023): 764–767.

[133] E. A. Hennessy and B. T. Johnson, “Examining Overlap of Included Studies in Meta-Reviews: Guidance for Using the Corrected Covered Area Index,” Research Synthesis Methods 11 (2019): 134–145.

[134] C. Y. Sun, H. R. Zhang, X. Y. Liu, C. Y. Sun, and S. Y. Yan, “Umbrella Review: Evidence-Based Practice for Selecting and Applying the Best Synthesis of Evidence,” Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine 22 (2022): 609–614.

[135] X. Ying, K. I. Bougioukas, D. Pieper, and E. Mayo-Wilson, “Weighted Corrected Covered Area (wCCA): A Measure of Informational Overlap Among Reviews,” Research Synthesis Methods 16 (2025): 701–708.

[136] K. I. Bougioukas, T. Diakonidis, A. C. Mavromanoli, and A. B. Haidich, “ccaR: A Package for Assessing Primary Study Overlap Across Systematic Reviews in Overviews,” Research Synthesis Methods 14 (2022): 443–454.

[137] L. Jiang, Z. Zheng, H. Fang, and J. Yang, “A Generalized Linear Mixed Model Association Tool for Biobank-Scale Data,” Nature Genetics 53 (2021): 1616–1621.

[138] Y. Saigusa, S. Eguchi, and O. Komori, “Generalized Quasi-Linear Mixed-Effects Model,” Statistical Methods in Medical Research 31 (2022): 1280–1291.

[139] W. V. D. Noortgate, J. A. López-López, F. Marín-Martínez, and J. Sánchez-Meca, “Three-Level Meta-Analysis of Dependent Effect Sizes,” Behavior Research Methods 45 (2012): 576–594.

[140] M. Pollock, R. M. Fernandes, A. S. Newton, S. D. Scott, and L. Hartling, “The Impact of Different Inclusion Decisions on the Comprehensiveness and Complexity of Overviews of Reviews of Healthcare Interventions,” Systematic Reviews 8 (2019): 18.

[141] N. Ahmadzai, S. J. Newberry, M. A. Maglione, et al., “A Surveillance System to Assess the Need for Updating Systematic Reviews,” Systematic Reviews 2 (2013): 104.

[142] M. J. Page, D. Moher, P. M. Bossuyt, et al., “PRISMA 2020 Explanation and Elaboration: Updated Guidance and Exemplars for Reporting Systematic Reviews,” BMJ 372 (2021): n160.

[143] D. Pieper and T. Rombey, “Where to Prospectively Register a Systematic Review,” Systematic Reviews 11 (2022): 8.

[144] M. J. Page, J. E. McKenzie, P. M. Bossuyt, et al., “The PRISMA 2020 Statement: An Updated Guideline for Reporting Systematic Reviews,” BMJ 372 (2021): n71.

[145] M. Pollock, R. M. Fernandes, D. Pieper, et al., “Preferred Reporting Items for Overviews of Reviews (PRIOR): A Protocol for Development of a Reporting Guideline for Overviews of Reviews of Healthcare Interventions,” Systematic Reviews 8 (2019): 335.

[146] M. Gates, A. Gates, D. Pieper, et al., “Reporting Guideline for Overviews of Reviews of Healthcare Interventions: Development of the PRIOR Statement,” BMJ 378 (2022): e070849.

[147] C. Saltzman, “New FAI Guidelines: STROBE, MOOSE, PRISMA, CONSORT,” Foot & Ankle International 43 (2022): 1.

[148] L. Hartling, A. Chisholm, D. Thomson, and D. M. Dryden, “A Descriptive Analysis of Overviews of Reviews Published Between 2000 and 2011,” PLoS ONE 7 (2012): e49667.

[149] S. Khangura, K. Konnyu, R. Cushman, J. Grimshaw, and D. Moher, “Evidence Summaries: The Evolution of a Rapid Review Approach,” Systematic Reviews 1 (2012): 10.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2025 The Author(s). Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine published by Chinese Cochrane Center, West China Hospital of Sichuan University and John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd.