Misuse of Guidelines Could Disadvantage and Harm Patients

References

[1] “World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki: Ethical Principles for Medical Research Involving human Subjects, ” Jama 310 (2013):2191–2194.

[2] B.Sibbald and M.Roland,“Understanding Controlled Trials. Why Are Randomised Controlled Trials Important?, ” Bmj 316 (1998):201.

[3] Y. Y.Tan,V.Papez, W. H.Chang,S. H. Mueller,S.Denaxas, and A. G.Lai,“Comparing Clinical Trial Population Representativeness to Real-world Populations: An External Validity Analysis Encompassing 43 895 Trials and 5 685 738 Individuals Across 989 Unique Drugs and 286 Conditions in England, ” The Lancet Healthy Longevity 3 (2022): e674–e689.

[4] T.Kennedy-Martin,S. Curtis,D.Faries,S.Robinson, and J.Johnston,“A Literature Review on the Representativeness of Randomized Controlled Trial Samples and Implications for the External Validity of Trial Results, ” Trials 16 (2015):495.

[5] J.He,D. R.Morales, and B.Guthrie,“Exclusion Rates in Randomized Controlled Trials of Treatments for Physical Conditions: A Systematic Review, ” Trials 21 (2020):228.

[6] C. T.Rice,S.Barnett,S. P.O’Connell, et al.,“Impact of Gender, Ethnicity and Social Deprivation on Access to Surgical or Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement in Aortic Stenosis: A Retrospective Database Study in England, ” Open Heart 10 (2023): e002373.

[7] R. E.Sherman,S. A.Anderson,G. J.Dal Pan, et al.,“Real-World Evidence—What Is It and What Can It Tell Us?, ” New England Journal of Medicine 375 (2016):2293–2297.

[8] T. J.Hoogeboom and A. M. Jette,“Using Evidence Hierarchies to Find the Best Evidence: A Procrustean Bed?, ” Physical Therapy 101 (2021): pzab235.

[9] Academy of Medical Sciences. Stratified, Personalized or P4 Medicine: A New Direction for Placing the Patient at the Center of Healthcare and Health Education. 2015.

[10] M.Infeld,K.Wahlberg,J.Cicero, et al.,“Effect of Personalized Accelerated Pacing on Quality of Life, Physical Activity, and Atrial Fibrillation in Patients with Preclinical and Overt Heart Failure with Preserved Ejection Fraction: The myPACE Randomized Clinical Trial, ” JAMA Cardiology 8 (2023):213–221.

[11] O. J.Ponce,N.Alvarez-Villalobos,R.Shah, et al.,“What Does Expert Opinion in Guidelines Mean? A Meta-Epidemiological Study, ” Evidence-Based Medicine 22 (2017):164–169,

[12] H. J.Schünemann,Y. Zhang, and A. D.Oxman,“Distinguishing Opinion From Evidence in Guidelines, ” Bmj 366 (2019): l4606.

[13] N.Bogale,S.Priori, A.Gitt,M. Alings,C.Linde, and K.Dickstein,“The European Cardiac Resynchronization Therapy Survey: Patient Selection and Implantation Practice Vary According to Centre Volume, ” Europace 13 (2011):1445–1453.

[14] B.Hurwitz,“How Does Evidence Based Guidance Influence Determinations of Medical Negligence?, ” Bmj 329 (2004):1024–1028.

[15] A.Samanta,M. M.Mello, C.Foster,J. Tingle, and JSamanta,“The Role of Clinical Guidelines in Medical Negligence Litigation: A Shift From the Bolam Standard?, ” Medical Law Review 14 (2006):321–366.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2024 The Author(s). Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine published by Chinese Cochrane Center, West China Hospital of Sichuan University and John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd.