The Acoustic Ecology of Coastal Dolphins by Assessing the Structural Variability of Sounds and the Influence of Contextual Factors

Abstract

The acoustic ecology of a previously unexamined dolphin population in the Mediterranean was assessed by investigating how sound emissions and acoustic features are influenced by concurrent conditions. Whistles and click-trains emission rates were compared among different environmental, social and behavioural conditions. Structural variability of 3928 good/high-quality vocalizations was analysed in relation to contexts through a two-stage approach. First, two multivariate MANOVA-models were fitted considering the entire set of acoustic parameters extracted from whistles and click trains, to investigate the effect of concomitant factors on the overall acoustic structure of each vocalization. Subsequently, GLMM models were applied to each acoustic feature individually to explore its response to different contextual factors. Emission rates increased significantly with calves and in larger groups, with also a positive effect of socialization on whistles and of muddy/sandy seabed and depth on impulsive sounds. The multivariate approach showed that all contextual factors influenced sounds’ structure, with whistles being strongly affected by behaviour and calves’ presence. The GLMM models highlighted that each acoustic parameter varied differently in response to specific factors, with (1) increasing trends in whistles’ duration and inflection points during interaction with fishery and decreasing ones during socializing, and (2) decreasing inter-click-intervals and increasing click-repetition-rates in larger groups and during interactions with fishery. These results provide new findings on the acoustic plasticity of bottlenose dolphins and a more comprehensive view of the magnitude of the social, environmental and behavioural influence, highlighting how the complexity of the species’ acoustic repertoire has yet to be unravelled at the local level.

Keywords

acoustic repertoire / behaviour / common bottlenose dolphin / environmental factors / Mediterranean Sea / sounds

References

[1] Ardizzone, G. D., A. Belluscio, and A. Criscoli. 2018. “ Lazio Centrale (da Civitavecchia a Torre Astura).” In Atlante Degli Habitat Dei Fondali Marini Del Lazio, edited by G. D. Ardizzone, A. Belluscio and A. Criscoli, 231-270. Rome, Italy: Sapienza Università Editrice.

[2] Au, W. W. L.1993. The Sonar of Dolphins. New York, NY: Springer-Verlag.

[3] Au, W. W. L.2004. “Echolocation Signals of Wild Dolphins.” Acoustical Physics 50: 454-462.

[4] Azzolin, M., A. Gannier, E. Papale, et al. 2021. “Whistle Variability of the Mediterranean Short Beak Common Dolphin.” Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 31: 36-50.

[5] Bates, D., M. Mächler, B. Bolker, and S. Walker. 2015. “Fitting Linear Mixed-effects Models Using lme4.” The Journal of Statistical Software 67, no. 1: 1-48.

[6] Berens McCabe, E. J., D. P. Gannon, N. B. Barros, and R. S. Wells. 2010. “Prey Selection by Resident Common Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) in Sarasota Bay, Florida.” Marine Biology 157: 931-942.

[7] Blomqvist, C., and M. Amundin. 2004. “ High-frequency Burst-pulse Sounds in Agonistic/Aggressive Interactions in Bottlenose Dolphins, Tursiops truncatus.” In Echolocation in Bats and Dolphins, edited by J. Thomas, C. Moss, and M. Vater, 425-431. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.

[8] Branstetter, B. K., and E. Mercado. 2006. “Sound Localization by Cetaceans.” International Journal of Comparative Psychology 19: 26-61.

[9] Burnham, R., and D. Duffus. 2023. “Implication of Altered Acoustic Active Space for Cetacean Species That Result From Soundscape Changes and Noise Additions.” Acoustics 5, no. 2: 444-461.

[10] Buscaino, G., G. Buffa, F. Filiciotto, et al. 2015. “Pulsed Signal Properties of Free-ranging Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) in the Central Mediterranean Sea.” Marine Mammals Science 31, no. 3: 891-901.

[11] Buscaino, G., M. Ceraulo, G. Alonge, et al. 2021. “Artisanal Fishing, Dolphins and Interactive Pingers: A Study From a Passive Acoustic Perspective.” Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 31, no. 8: 2241-2256.

[12] Caruso, G., P. Alaimo Di Loro, M. Mingione, L. Tardella, D. S. Pace, and G. Jona-Lasinio. 2024. “Finite Mixtures in Capture-Recapture Surveys for Modeling Residency Patterns in Marine Wildlife Populations.” Biometrical Journal 66, no. 1: 2200350.

[13] Casoli, E., G. Mancini, D. Ventura, D. S. Pace, A. Belluscio, and G. D. Ardizzone. 2020. “Reteporella spp. Success in the Re-Colonization of Bare Coralligenous Reefs Impacted by Costa Concordia Shipwreck: The Pioneer Species You Did Not Expect.” Marine Pollution Bulletin 161: 111808.

[14] Clark, C. W., A. N. Rice, D. W. Ponirakis, and P. J. Dugan. 2011. “Marine Acoustic Ecologies and Acoustic Habitats: Concepts, Metrics, and Realities.” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 130, no. 4: 2320-2320.

[15] Clark, C. W., W. T. Ellison, B. L. Southall, et al. 2009. “Acoustic Masking in Marine Ecosystems: Intuitions, Analysis, and Implication.” Marine Ecology Progress Series 395: 201-222.

[16] Clay, Z., C. L. Smith, and D. T. Blumstein. 2012. “Food-Associated Vocalizations in Mammals and Birds: What Do These Calls Really Mean?” Animal Behaviour 83, no. 2: 323-330.

[17] Di Nardo, F., R. De Marco, A. Lucchetti, and D. Scaradozzi. 2023. “A WAV File Dataset of Bottlenose Dolphin Whistles, Clicks, and Pulse Sounds During Trawling Interactions.” Scientific Data 10: 650.

[18] Duarte, C. M., L. Chapuis, S. P. Collin, et al. 2021. “The Soundscape of the Anthropocene Ocean.” Science 371, no. 6529: eaba4658.

[19] Dunlop, R., W. L. Gannon, M. Kiley-Worthington, P. S. Hill, A. Wessel, and J. A. Thomas. 2022. “ Vibrational and Acoustic Communication in Animals.” In Exploring Animal Behavior Through Sound, edited by C. Erbe, J. A. Thomas, Vol. 1. 389-417. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing.

[20] Erbe, C., A. Duncan, and K. J. Vigness-Raposa. 2022. “ Introduction to Sound Propagation Under Water.” In Exploring Animal Behavior Through Sound, edited by C. Erbe and J. A. Thomas, Vol. 1. 185-216. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing.

[21] Erbe, C., C. Reichmuth, K. Cunningham, K. Lucke, and R. Dooling. 2016. “Communication Masking in Marine Mammals: A Review and Research Strategy.” Marine Pollution Bulletin 103: 15-38.

[22] Erbe, C., M. L. Dent, W. L. Gannon, et al. 2022. “ The Effects of Noise on Animals.” In Exploring Animal Behavior through Sound, edited by C. Erbe and J. A. Thomas, Vol. 1. 459-506. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing.

[23] Finneran, J. J.2013. “Dolphin “Packet” Use During Long-Range Echolocation Tasks.” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 133, no. 3: 1796-1810.

[24] Forrest, T. G.1994. “From Sender to Receiver: Propagation and Environmental Effects on Acoustic Signals.” American Zoologist 34, no. 6: 644-654.

[25] Gage, S. H., and A. Farina. 2017. “ Ecoacoustics Challenges.” In Ecoacoustics: The Ecological Role of Sounds, edited by A. Farina and S. H. Gage, 313-320. New York: Wiley.

[26] Gannon, D. P., N. B. Barros, D. P. Nowacek, A. J. Read, D. M. Waples, and R. S. Wells. 2005. “Prey Detection by Bottlenose Dolphins, Tursiops Truncatus: An Experimental Test of the Passive Listening Hypothesis.” Animal Behaviour 69, no. 3: 709-720.

[27] Gregorietti, M., E. Papale, M. Ceraulo, et al. 2021. “Acoustic Presence of Dolphins Through Whistles Detection in Mediterranean Shallow Waters.” Journal of Marine Science and Engineering 9, no. 1: 78.

[28] Heiler, J., S. H. Elwen, H. J. Kriesell, and T. Gridley. 2016. “Changes in Bottlenose Dolphin Whistle Parameters Related to Vessel Presence, Surface Behaviour and Group Composition.” Animal Behaviour 117: 167-177.

[29] Heithaus, M. R., A. Frid, A. J. Wirsing, and B. Worm. 2008. “Predicting Ecological Consequences of Marine Top Predator Declines.” Trends in Ecology and Evolution 23, no. 4: 202-210.

[30] Herzing, D. L.2000. “ Acoustics and Social Behavior of Wild Dolphins: Implications for a Sound Society.” In Hearing by Whales and Dolphins, edited by W. W. L. Au, R. R. Fay, and A. N. Popper, 225-272. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.

[31] Herzing, D. L.2014. “Clicks, Whistles and Pulses: Passive and Active Signal Use in Dolphin Communication.” Acta Astronautica 105, no. 2: 534-537.

[32] Hocking, D. P., F. G. Marx, T. Park, E. M. Fitzgerald, and A. R. Evans. 2017. “A Behavioural Framework for the Evolution of Feeding in Predatory Aquatic Mammals.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 284: 20162750.

[33] Janik, V. M., and L. S. Sayigh. 2013. “Communication in Bottlenose Dolphins: 50 Years of Signature Whistle Research.” Journal of Comparative Physiology A 99: 479-489.

[34] Jones, B., M. Zapetis, M. M. Samuelson, and S. Ridgway. 2020. “Sounds Produced by Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops): A Review of the Defining Characteristics and Acoustic Criteria of the Dolphin Vocal Repertoire.” Bioacoustics 29, no. 4: 399-440.

[35] Kaplan, J. D., and D. Reiss. 2017. “Whistle Acoustic Parameters in Atlantic Spotted Dolphins (Stenella frontalis) and Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) in Two Locations in the Bahamas and Comparisons With Other Populations.” Aquatic Mammals 43, no. 4: 364-377.

[36] Killebrew, D., E. Mercado, L. Herman, and A. Pack. 2001. “Sound Production of a Neonate Bottlenose Dolphin.” Aquatic Mammals 27, no. 1: 34-44.

[37] King, S. L., and V. M. Janik. 2015. “Come Dine With Me: Food-Associated Social Signalling in Wild Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus).” Animal Cognition 18: 969-974.

[38] King, S. L., E. Guarino, L. Keaton, L. Erb, and K. Jaakkola. 2016. “Maternal Signature Whistle Use Aids Mother-Calf Reunions in a Bottlenose Dolphin.” Tursiops Truncatus. Behavioural Processes 126: 64-70.

[39] Kiszka, J. J., M. S. Woodstock, and M. R. Heithaus. 2022. “Functional Roles and Ecological Importance of Small Cetaceans in Aquatic Ecosystems.” Frontiers in Marine Science 9: 803173.

[40] Kriesell, H. J., S. H. Elwen, A. Nastasi, and T. Gridley. 2014. “Identification and Characteristics of Signature Whistles in Wild Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) From Namibia.” PLoS ONE 9, no. 9: e106317.

[41] La Manna, G., N. Arrostuto, S. S. Campisi, M. Manghi, N. Fois, and G. Ceccherelli. 2023. “Acoustic Detection of Bottlenose Dolphin Depredation on Nets and Implications for Conservation.” Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 33, no. 2: 179-190.

[42] La Manna, G., N. Rako-Gospić, D. S. Pace, et al. 2022. “Determinants of Variability in Signature Whistles of the Mediterranean Common Bottlenose Dolphin.” Scientific Reports 12: 6980.

[43] La Manna, G., N. Rako-Gospić, G. Sarà, F. Gatti, S. Bonizzoni, and G. Ceccherelli. 2020. “Whistle Variation in Mediterranean Common Bottlenose Dolphin: the Role of Geographical, Anthropogenic, Social, and Behavioural Factors.” Ecology and Evolution 10, no. 4: 1971-1987.

[44] La Manna, G., N. Rako-Gospić, M. Manghi, and G. Ceccherelli. 2019. “Influence of Environmental, Social and Behavioural Variables on the Whistling of the Common Bottlenose Dolphin (Tursiops truncatus).” Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 73: 121.

[45] Lammers, M. O., and J. N. Oswald. 2015. “ Analyzing the Acoustic Communication of dolphins.” In Dolphin Communication and Cognition Past, Present and Future, edited by D. L. Herzing and C. M. Johnson. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/9939.003.0008.

[46] Larsen, O. N., W. L. Gannon, C. Erbe, G. Pavan, and J. A. Thomas. 2022. “ Source-Path-Receiver Model for Airborne Sounds.” In Exploring Animal Behavior through Sound, edited by C. Erbe and J. A. Thomas, Vol. 1. 153-183. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing.

[47] Lewis, R. N., L. J. Williams, and R. T. Gilman. 2021. “The Uses and Implications of Avian Vocalizations for Conservation Planning.” Conservation Biology 35, no. 1: 50-63.

[48] Luís, A. R., L. J. May-Collado, N. Rako-Gospić, et al. 2021. “Vocal Universals and Geographic Variations in the Acoustic Repertoire of the Common Bottlenose Dolphin.” Scientific Reports 11: 11847.

[49] Luís, A. R., M. N. Couchinho, and M. E. dos Santos. 2016. “A Quantitative Analysis of Pulsed Signals Emitted by Wild Bottlenose Dolphins.” PLoS ONE 11, no. 7: e0157781.

[50] MacFarlane, N., V. M. Janik, F. H. Jensen, et al. 2017. “Signature Whistles Facilitate Reunions and/or Advertise Identity in Bottlenose Dolphins.” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 141: 3543.

[51] Madsen, P. T., F. H. Jensen, D. Carder, and S. Ridgway. 2012. “Dolphin Whistles: A Functional Misnomer Revealed by Heliox Breathing.” Biology Letters 8, no. 2: 211-213.

[52] Madsen, P. T., U. Siebert, and C. P. Elemans. 2023. “Toothed Whales Use Distinct Vocal Registers for Echolocation and Communication.” Science 379, no. 6635: 928-933.

[53] Mann, J.1999. “Behavioral Sampling Methods for Cetaceans: A Review and Critique.” Marine Mammals Science 15: 102-122.

[54] Marian, A. D., A. Monczak, B. C. Balmer, L. B. Hart, J. Soueidan, and E. W. Montie. 2021. “Long-Term Passive Acoustics to Assess Spatial and Temporal Vocalization Patterns of Atlantic Common Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) in the May River Estuary, South Carolina.” Marine Mammals Science 37, no. 3: 1060-1084.

[55] Martino, S., D. S. Pace, G. Pedrazzi, S. Moro, and G. Jona-Lasinio. 2021. “Integration of Presence-Only Data From Several Sources: A Case Study on Dolphins' Spatial Distribution.” Ecography 44: 1533-1543.

[56] May-Collado, L. J., and D. Wartzok. 2008. “A Comparison of Bottlenose Dolphin Whistles in the Atlantic Ocean: Factors Promoting Whistle Variation.” Journal of Mammalogy 89, no. 5: 1229-1240.

[57] Miller, J. H., L. Kloepper, G. R. Potty, et al. 2014. “The Effects of pH on Acoustic Transmission Loss in an Estuary.” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 136, no. 4: 2156.

[58] Montgomery, J. C., and C. A. Radford. 2017. “Marine Bioacoustics.” Current Biology 27, no. 11: R502-R507.

[59] Norris, K. S., J. H. Prescott, P. V. Asa-Dorian, and P. Perkins. 1961. “An Experimental Demonstration of Echo-Location Behavior in the Porpoise, Tursiops truncatus (Montagu).” Biological Bulletin 120: 163-176.

[60] Nowacek, D. P.2005. “Acoustic Ecology of Foraging Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus), Habitat-Specific Use of Three Sound Types.” Marine Mammals Science 21, no. 4: 587-602.

[61] Obrist, M. K., G. Pavan, J. Sueur, K. Riede, D. Lusia, and R. Márquez. 2010. “Bioacoustics Approaches in Biodiversity Inventories.” ABC Taxa 8, no. 1: 68-99.

[62] Oestreich, W. K., R. Y. Oliver, M. S. Chapman, M. Go, and M. F. McKenna. 2024. “Listening to Animal Behavior to Understand Changing Ecosystems.” Trends in Ecology & Evolution 39: 961-973.

[63] Oswald, J., S. P. Sugarman, E. L. Ferguson, S. F. Walmsley, and V. M. Janik. 2022. “Bottlenose Dolphin Whistle Repertoires: Size and Stability Over Time.” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 151: A74.

[64] Pace, D. S., and G. Pedrazzi. 2024. “Bottlenose Dolphin Predation on Flathead Grey Mullets Using Barrier Feeding Techniques: A Visual and Acoustic Case Study in the Mediterranean Sea.” Ethology, Ecology and Evolution: 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1080/03949370.2024.2411507.

[65] Pace, D. S., C. Di Marco, G. Giacomini, et al. 2021. “Capitoline Dolphins: Residency Patterns and Abundance Estimate of Tursiops Truncatus at the Tiber River Estuary (Mediterranean Sea).” Biology 10, no. 4: 275.

[66] Pace, D. S., C. Lanfredi, S. Airoldi, et al. 2021. “Trumpet Sounds Emitted by Male Sperm Whales in the Mediterranean Sea.” Scientific Reports 11: 5867.

[67] Pace, D. S., C. Tumino, M. Silvestri, et al. 2022. “Bray-Call Sequences in the Mediterranean Common Bottlenose Dolphin (Tursiops truncatus) Acoustic Repertoire.” Biology 11, no. 3: 367.

[68] Pace, D. S., G. Giacomini, I. Campana, et al. 2019. “An Integrated Approach for Cetacean Knowledge and Conservation in the central Mediterranean Sea Using Research and Social Media Data Sources.” Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 29: 1302-1323.

[69] Pace, D. S., G. Panunzi, A. Arcangeli, S. Moro, G. Jona-Lasinio, and S. Martino. 2022. “Seasonal Distribution of an Opportunistic Apex Predator (Tursiops truncatus) in Marine Coastal Habitats of the Western Mediterranean Sea.” Frontiers in Marine Science 9: 939692.

[70] Pace, D. S., S. Ferri, G. Giacomini, et al. 2022. “Resources and Population Traits Modulate the Association Patterns in the Common Bottlenose Dolphin Living Nearby the Tiber River Estuary (Mediterranean Sea).” Frontiers in Marine Science 9: 935235.

[71] Papale, E., G. Alonge, F. Caruso, et al. 2021. “The Higher, the Closer, the Better? Influence of Sampling Frequency and Distance on the Acoustic Properties of Short-beaked Common Dolphins Burst Pulses in the Mediterranean Sea.” Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 31: 51-60.

[72] Papale, E., M. A. Azzolin, I. Cascão, et al. 2021. “Dolphin Whistles Can be Useful Tools in Identifying Units of Conservation.” BMC Zoology 6: 22.

[73] Papale, E., M. Gamba, M. Perez-Gil, V. M. Martin, and C. Giacoma. 2015. “Dolphins Adjust Species-Specific Frequency Parameters to Compensate for Increasing Background Noise.” PLoS ONE 10, no. 4: e0121711.

[74] Pedrazzi, G., G. Giacomini, and D. S. Pace. 2022. “First Report of Epimeletic and Acoustic Behaviour of Bottlenose Dolphin (Tursiops truncatus) Carrying Dead Calves.” Biology 11, no. 2: 337.

[75] Penar, W., A. Magier, and C. Klocek. 2020. “Applications of Bioacoustics in Animal Ecology.” Ecological Complexity 43: 100847.

[76] Perez-Ortega, B., R. Daw, B. Paradee, E. Gimbrere, and L. J. May-Collado. 2021. “Dolphin-Watching Boats Affect Whistle Frequency Modulation in Bottlenose Dolphins.” Frontiers in Marine Science 8: 618420.

[77] Quick, N. J., and V. M. Janik. 2008. “Whistle Rates of Wild Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus): Influences of Group Size and Behavior.” Journal of Comparative Physiology 122: 305-311.

[78] Rako-Gospić, N., G. La Manna, M. Picciulin, and G. Ceccherelli. 2021. “Influence of Foraging Context on the Whistle Structure of the Common Bottlenose Dolphin.” Behavioural Processes 182: 104281.

[79] Ridgway, S. H., P. W. Moore, D. A. Carder, and T. A. Romano. 2014. “Forward Shift of Feeding Buzz Components of Dolphins and Belugas During Associative Learning Reveals a Likely Connection to Reward Expectation, Pleasure and Brain Dopamine Activation.” Journal of Experimental Biology 217: 2910-2919.

[80] Sargeant, B. L., and J. Mann. 2009. “Developmental Evidence for Foraging Traditions in Wild Bottlenose Dolphins.” Animal Behaviour 78, no. 3: 715-721.

[81] Sayigh, L. S.2014. “ Cetacean Acoustic Communication.” In Biocommunication of Animals, edited by G. Witzany, 275-297. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.

[82] Sayigh, L. S., N. El Haddad, P. L. Tyack, V. M. Janik, R. S. Wells, and F. H. Jensen. 2023. “Bottlenose Dolphin Mothers Modify Signature Whistles in the Presence of Their Own Calves.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 120, no. 27: e2300262120.

[83] Schoeman, R. P., C. Erbe, G. Pavan, R. Righini, and J. A. Thomas. 2022. “ Analysis of Soundscapes as an Ecological Tool.” In Exploring Animal Behavior Through Sound, edited by C. Erbe and J. A. Thomas, Vol. 1. 217-267. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing.

[84] Stein, R. M., and J. L. Rachlow. 2023. “Acoustic Ecology of Terrestrial Mammals: A New Signaller-Receiver Conceptual Framework.” Mammal Review 53, no. 3: 143-157.

[85] Surlykke, A., and P. E. Nachtigall. 2014. “ Biosonar of Bats and Toothed Whales: an overview.” In Biosonar, Springer Handbook of Auditory Research, edited by A. Surlykke, P. E. Nachtigall, R. Fay, and A. Poppe, 1-9. New York, NY: Springer.

[86] Tellechea, J.2020. “Echolocation Inter-click Interval Variation Among Specific Behaviours in Free-Ranging Bottlenose Dolphins From the Coast of Uruguay.” Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 21: 141-149.

[87] Triossi, F., T. Willis, and D. S. Pace. 2013. “Occurrence of Bottlenose Dolphins Tursiops truncatus in Natural Gas Fields of the Northwestern Adriatic Sea.” Marine Ecology 34: 373379.

[88] Tyack, P. L.1998. “ Acoustic Communication Under the Sea.” In Animal Acoustic Communication, edited by S. L. Hopp, M. J. Owren and C. S. Evans, 163-220. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.

[89] Van Opzeeland, I., S. Van Parijs, H. Bornemann, et al. 2010. “Acoustic Ecology of Antarctic Pinnipeds.” Marine Ecology Progress Series 414: 267-291.

[90] Ventura, D., G. Mancini, E. Casoli, et al. 2022. “Seagrass Restoration Monitoring and Shallow-Water Benthic Habitat Mapping Through a Photogrammetry-Based Protocol.” Journal of Environmental Management 304: 114262.

[91] Wood, C. M., H. Klinck, M. Gustafson, et al. 2021. “Using the Ecological Significance of Animal Vocalizations to Improve Inference in Acoustic Monitoring Programs.” Conservation Biology 35, no. 1: 336-345.

[92] Wood, F. G., and W. E. Evans. 1980. “ Adaptiveness and Ecology of Echolocation in Toothed Whales.” In Animal Sonar Systems. NATO Advanced Study Institutes Series, edited by R. G. Busnel and J. F. Fish, 381-425. Boston, MA: Springer.

[93] Zar, J. H.2010. Biostatistical Analysis, 5th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice-Hall.

[94] Zuur, A., E. N. Ieno, N. Walker, A. A. Saveliev, and G. S. Smith. 2009. Mixed Effects Models and Extensions in Ecology With R. New York: Springer Science and Business Media.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2024 The Author(s). Integrative Zoology published by International Society of Zoological Sciences, Institute of Zoology/Chinese Academy of Sciences and John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd.