Population and community ecology: past progress and future directions

Abstract

Population and community ecology as a science are about 100 years old, and we discuss here our opinion of what approaches have progressed well and which point to possible future directions. The three major threads within population and community ecology are theoretical ecology, statistical tests and models, and experimental ecology. We suggest that our major objective is to understand what factors determine the distribution and abundance of organisms within populations and communities, and we evaluate these threads against this major objective. Theoretical ecology is elegant and compelling and has laid the groundwork for achieving our overall objectives with useful simple models. Statistics and statistical models have contributed informative methods to analyze quantitatively our understanding of distribution and abundance for future research. Population ecology is difficult to carry out in the field, even though we may have all the statistical methods and models needed to achieve results. Community ecology is growing rapidly with much description but less understanding of why changes occur. Biodiversity science cuts across all these subdivisions but rarely digs into the necessary population and community science that might solve conservation problems. Climate change affects all aspects of ecology but to assume that everything in population and community ecology is driven by climate change is oversimplified. We make recommendations on how to advance the field with advice for present and future generations of population and community ecologists.

Keywords

climate change / community ecology / population ecology / progress

References

[1] AbramsPA (2022). Competition Theory in Ecology. Oxford University Press,Oxford.

[2] AndereggWRL,TrugmanAT, BadgleyG et al. (2020). Climate-driven risks to the climate mitigation potential of forests. Science 368,eaaz7005.

[3] AustinMP (1999a). The potential contribution of vegetation ecology to biodiversity research. Ecography 22,465–484.

[4] AustinMP (1999b). A silent clash of paradigms: Some inconsistencies in community ecology. Oikos 86,170–178.

[5] AustinMP,SmithTM (1989). A new model for the continuum concept. Vegetatio 83,35–47.

[6] BeckerM,HuggardDJ, DickieM et al. (2022). Applying and testing a novel method to estimate animal density from motion-triggered cameras. Ecosphere 13,e4005.

[7] BoonstraR,Andreassen HP,BoutinS et al. (2016). Why do the boreal forest ecosystems of northwestern Europe differ from those of western North America? Bioscience 66,722–734.

[8] BoonstraR,BoutinS, JungTS,Krebs CJ,TaylorS (2018). Impact of rewilding, species introductions and climate change on the structure and function of the Yukon boreal forest ecosystem. Integrative Zoology 13,123–138.

[9] CarpenterSR,MooneyHA, AgardJ et al. (2009). Science for managing ecosystem services: Beyond the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment. PNAS 106,1305–1312.

[10] CastilhoLB,PradoPI (2021). Towards a pragmatic use of statistics in ecology. PeerJ 9,e12090.

[11] CaughleyG (1994). Directions in conservation biology. Journal of Animal Ecology 63,215–244.

[12] CaughleyG,GunnA (1996). Conservation Biology in Theory and Practice. Blackwell Science,Oxford.

[13] ChittyD (1996). Do lemmings commit suicide? Beautiful Hypotheses and Ugly Facts. Oxford University Press,New York.

[14] ChristieAP,AmanoT, MartinPA,Shackelford GE,SimmonsBI,SutherlandWJ (2019). Simple study designs in ecology produce inaccurate estimates of biodiversity responses. Journal of Applied Ecology 56,2742–2754.

[15] ChristieAP,DowneyH, BretagnolleV et al. (2022). Principles for the production of evidence-based guidance for conservation actions. Conservation Science and Practice 4,e579.

[16] CostelloC,OvandoD, ClavelleT et al. (2016). Global fishery prospects under contrasting management regimes. PNAS 113,5125–5129.

[17] DuronQ,ShielsAB, VidalE (2017). Control of invasive rats on islands and priorities for future action. Conservation Biology 31,761–771.

[18] EffordMG,Boulanger J (2019). Fast evaluation of study designs for spatially explicit capture–recapture. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 10,1529–1535.

[19] EltonC,Nicholson M (1942). The ten-year cycle in numbers of the lynx in Canada. Journal of Animal Ecology 11,215–244.

[20] EltonC (1927). Animal Ecology. Sidgwick and Jackson,London.

[21] EltonC (1933). The Canadian snowshoe rabbit enquiry, 1931–32. Canadian Field Naturalist 47,63–69.

[22] EltonCS (1924). Periodic fluctuations in the numbers of animals: Their causes and effects. British Journal of Experimental Biology 2,119–163.

[23] FauteuxD,Gauthier G,BerteauxD (2016). Top-down limitation of lemmings revealed by experimental reduction of predators. Ecology 97,3231–3241.

[24] FerreiraCC,HossieTJ, JenkinsDA et al. (2019). The recovery illusion: What is delaying the rescue of imperiled species? BioScience 69,1028–1034.

[25] FitzgeraldN,BinnyRN, InnesJ et al. (2021). Long-term biodiversity benefits from invasive mammalian pest control in ecological restorations. Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America 102,e01843.

[26] FosterMS (1990). Organization of macroalgal assemblages in the Northeast Pacific: The assumption of homogeneity and the illusion of generality. Hydrobiologia 192,21–33.

[27] FrelichLE,Montgomery RA,ReichPB (2021). Seven ways a warming climate can kill the Southern Boreal Forest. Forests 12,560.

[28] GasawayWC,BoertjeRD, GrangaardDV,Kelleyhouse DG,StephensonRO,LarsenDG (1992). The role of predation in limiting moose at low densities in Alaska and Yukon and implications for conservation. Wildlife Monographs 120,1–59.

[29] GinzburgLR,DamuthJ (2022). The issue isn’t which model of consumer interference is right, but which one is least wrong. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 10,860542.

[30] GinzburgLR,JensenCXJ (2004). Rules of thumb for judging ecological theories. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 19,121–126.

[31] GrimmA,GruberB, HenleK (2014). Reliability of different mark-recapture methods for population size estimation tested against reference population sizes constructed from field data. PLoS ONE 9,e98840.

[32] GrimmV,WisselC (1997). Babel, or the ecological stability discussions: An inventory and analysis of terminology and a guide for avoiding confusion. Oecologia 109,323–334.

[33] HilbornR,FultonEA, GreenBS,Hartmann K,TraceySR (2015). When is a fishery sustainable? Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 72,1433–1441.

[34] HodgesKE (2008). Defining the problem: Terminology and progress in ecology. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 6,35–42.

[35] HodgesKE,KrebsCJ, HikDS,Stefan CI,GillisEA,DoyleCE (2001). Snowshoe hare demography. In: Krebs CJ,Boutin S,Boonstra R, eds. Ecosystem Dynamics of the Boreal Forest: The Kluane Project. Oxford University Press,New York, pp. 141–178.

[36] HoffmannS (2022). Challenges and opportunities of area-based conservation in reaching biodiversity and sustainability goals. Biodiversity and Conservation 31,325–352.

[37] HoneJ,DrakeA, KrebsCJ (2023). Evaluation options for wildlife management and strengthening of causal inference. BioScience 73,48–58.

[38] HoneJ,KrebsCJ (2023). Cause and effect and wildlife management. Journal of Wildlife Management 2023,e22412.

[39] HongP,SchmidB, De LaenderF et al. (2022). Biodiversity promotes ecosystem functioning despite environmental change. Ecology Letters 25,555–569.

[40] JonesHP,HolmesND, ButchartSHM,Tershy BR,KappesPJ (2016). Invasive mammal eradication on islands results in substantial conservation gains. PNAS 113,4033–4038.

[41] JonesJA,Driscoll CT (2022). Long-term ecological research on ecosystem responses to climate change. BioScience 72,814–826.

[42] KearneyB,HilbornR (2022). Solutions to world-wide fisheries problems are mostly local or regional. ICES Journal of Marine Science 79,997–1004.

[43] KeithLB,CaryJR, RongstadOJ,Brittingham MC (1984). Demography and ecology of a declining snowshoe hare population. Wildlife Monographs 90,1–43.

[44] KeltDA,HeskeEJ, LambinX et al. (2019). Advances in population ecology and species interactions in mammals. Journal of Mammalogy 100,965–1007.

[45] KenneyAJ,BoutinS, JungTS,Murray DL,JohnsonN,KrebsCJ (2024). Motion-sensitive cameras track population abundance changes in a boreal mammal community in southwestern Yukon, Canada. Journal of Wildlife Management 88,e22564.

[46] KimmelK,DeeLE, AvolioML,Ferraro PJ (2021). Causal assumptions and causal inference in ecological experiments. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 36,1141–1152.

[47] Krebs CJ,Boutin S,Boonstra R, eds (2001). Ecosystem Dynamics of the Boreal Forest: The Kluane Project. Oxford University Press,New York.

[48] KrebsCJ,BoutinS, BoonstraR et al. (2023). Long-term monitoring in the boreal forest reveals high spatio-temporal variability among primary ecosystem constituents. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 11,1187222.

[49] KrebsCJ,GilbertBS, BoutinS,Sinclair ARE,SmithJNM (1986). Population biology of snowshoe hares. I. Demography of food-supplemented populations in the southern Yukon, 1976–84. Journal of Animal Ecology 55,963–982.

[50] KrebsCJ,WingateI (1976). Small mammal communities of the Kluane Region, Yukon Territory. Canadian Field Naturalist 90,379–389.

[51] LaakeJ,CollierB, MorrisonM,Wilkins R (2011). Point-based mark-recapture distance sampling. Journal of Agricultural, Biological, and Environmental Statistics 16,389–408.

[52] LavergneSG,KrebsCJ, KenneyAJ et al. (2021). The impact of variable predation risk on stress in snowshoe hares over the cycle in North America’s boreal forest: Adjusting to change. Oecologia 197,71–88.

[53] LeggeS,Woinarski JCZ,BurbidgeAA et al. (2018). Havens for threatened Australian mammals: The contributions of fenced areas and offshore islands to the protection of mammal species susceptible to introduced predators. Wildlife Research 45,627–644.

[54] Low-DécarieE,Chivers C,GranadosM (2014). Rising complexity and falling explanatory power in ecology. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 12,412–418.

[55] LuoG,WeiW, DaiQ,RanJ (2020). Density estimation of unmarked populations using camera traps in heterogeneous space. Wildlife Society Bulletin 44,173–181.

[56] MaxwellSL,CazalisV, DudleyN et al. (2020). Area-based conservation in the twenty-first century. Nature 586,217–227.

[57] MayRM (1976). Theoretical Ecology: Principles and Applications. W.B. Saunders Company,Philadelphia, PA.

[58] MayRM (1999). Unanswered questions in ecology. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 354,1951–1959.

[59] McCreaR,KingR, GrahamL,Börger L (2023). Realising the promise of large data and complex models. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 14,4–11.

[60] Moreno-MateosD,AlberdiA, MorriënE,van der PuttenWH,Rodríguez-Uña A,MontoyaD (2020). The long-term restoration of ecosystem complexity. Nature Ecology & Evolution 4,676–685.

[61] Nagy-ReisM,DickieM, CalvertAM et al. (2021). Habitat loss accelerates for the endangered woodland caribou in western Canada. Conservation Science and Practice 2021,e437.

[62] NewmarkWD (1985). Legal and biotic boundaries of Western North American National Parks: A problem of congruence. Biological Conservation 33,197–208.

[63] NewmarkWD (1995). Extinction of mammal populations in Western North American national parks. Conservation Biology 9,512–526.

[64] NicholsJD (2016). And the first one now will later be last: Time-reversal in Cormack–Jolly–Seber models. Statistical Science 31,175–190.

[65] NicholsJD,KendallWL, BoomerGS (2019). Accumulating evidence in ecology: Once is not enough. Ecology and Evolution 9,13991–14004.

[66] NoseworthyJ,BeckleyTM (2020). Borealization of the New England – Acadian Forest: A review of the evidence. Environmental Reviews 28,284–293.

[67] O’DonoghueM (1994). Early survival of juvenile snowshoe hares. Ecology 75,1582–1592.

[68] O’DonoghueM,Slough BG,PooleKG et al. (2010). Cyclical dynamics and behaviour of Canada lynx in northern Canada. In: Macdonald DW,Loveridge AJ, eds. Biology and Conservation of Wild Felids. Oxford University Press,Oxford, pp. 521–536.

[69] PaineRT (1991). Between Scylla and Charybdis: Do some kinds of criticism merit a response? Oikos 62,90–92.

[70] PaineRT (1992). Food-web analysis through field measurement of per capita interaction strength. Nature 355,73–75.

[71] PaineRT,TegnerMJ, JohnsonEA (1998). Compounded perturbations yield ecological surprises. Ecosystems 1,535–545.

[72] PearceN,LawlorDA (2017). Causal inference—so much more than statistics. International Journal of Epidemiology 45,1895–1903.

[73] PearlJ (2009). Causal inference in statistics: An overview. Statistics Surveys 3,96–146.

[74] PetersRH (1991). A Critique for Ecology. Cambridge University Press,Cambridge.

[75] PielouEC (1984). The Interpretation of Ecological Data. Wiley,New York.

[76] PlattJR (1964). Strong inference. Science 146,347–353.

[77] PradelR (1996). Utilization of capture-mark-recapture for the study of recruitment and population growth rate. Biometrics 52,703–709.

[78] PriceK,HoltRF, DaustD (2021). Conflicting portrayals of remaining old growth: The British Columbia case. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 51,742–752.

[79] RoseGA,WaltersCJ (2019). The state of Canada’s iconic Northern cod: A second opinion. Fisheries Research 219,105314.

[80] RosenbergKV,DokterAM, BlancherPJ et al. (2019). Decline of the North American avifauna. Science 366,120–124.

[81] SchindlerDW,HeckyRE, FindlayDL et al. (2008). Eutrophication of lakes cannot be controlled by reducing nitrogen input: Results of a 37-year whole-ecosystem experiment. PNAS 105,11254–11258.

[82] SchradinC (2017). Comparative studies need to rely both on sound natural history data and on excellent statistical analysis. Royal Soociety Open Science 4,170346.

[83] SerrouyaR,SeipDR, HervieuxD et al. (2019). Saving endangered species using adaptive management. PNAS 116,6181–6186.

[84] SinclairARE (1986). Testing multi-factor causes of population limitation: An illustration using snowshoe hares. Oikos 47,360–364.

[85] SinclairARE,ChittyD, StefanCI,Krebs CJ (2003) Mammal population cycles: Evidence for intrinsic differences during snowshoe hare cycles. Canadian Journal of Zoology 81,216–220.

[86] SinclairARE,DublinH, BornerM (1985). Population regulation of Serengeti Wildebeest: A test of the food hypothesis. Oecologia 65,266–268.

[87] SmithJNM,KrebsCJ, SinclairARE,Boonstra R (1988). Population biology of snowshoe hares II. Interactions with winter food plants. Journal of Animal Ecology 57,269–286.

[88] StanturfJA,PalikBJ, WilliamsMI,Dumroese RK,MadsenP (2014). Forest restoration paradigms. Journal of Sustainable Forestry 33,S161–194.

[89] StefanCI,KrebsCJ (2001). Reproductive changes in a cyclic population of snowshoe hares. Canadian Journal of Zoology 79,2101–2108.

[90] SugiharaG,MayR, YeH et al. (2012). Detecting causality in complex ecosystems. Science 338,496–500.

[91] SummerhayesVS,EltonCS (1923). Contributions to the ecology of Spitsbergen and Bear Island. Journal of Ecology 11,214–286.

[92] TilmanD,ReichPB, KnopsJMH (2006). Biodiversity and ecosystem stability in a decade-long grassland experiment. Nature 441,629–632.

[93] Tinsley-MarshallP,Downey H,AdumG et al. (2022). Funding and delivering the routine testing of management interventions to improve conservation effectiveness. Journal for Nature Conservation 67,126184.

[94] TravisJ (2020). Where is natural history in ecological, evolutionary, and behavioral science? American Naturalist 196,1–8.

[95] TurkingtonR (2009). Top-down and bottom-up forces in mammalian herbivore-vegetation systems: An essay review. Botany 87,723–739.

[96] TurkingtonR,McLarenJR, DaleMRT (2014). Herbaceous community structure and function in the Kluane Region. Arctic 67 (Suppl 1), 98–107.

[97] UnderwoodAJ (2000). Experimental ecology of rocky intertidal habitats: What are we learning? Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 250,51–76.

[98] Van NielKP,AustinMP (2007). Predictive vegetation modeling for conservation: Impact of error propagation from digital elevation data. Ecological Applications 17,266–280.

[99] WackernagelM,HanscomL, JayasingheP et al. (2021). The importance of resource security for poverty eradication. Nature Sustainability 4,731–738.

[100] WagnerDL,GramesEM, ForisterML,Berenbaum MR,StopakD (2021). Insect decline in the Anthropocene: Death by a thousand cuts. PNAS 118,e2023989118.

[101] WaltersCJ (2007). Is adaptive management helping to solve fisheries problems? Ambio 36,304–307.

[102] WaltersCJ,MartellSJD (2004). Fisheries Ecology and Management. Princeton University Press,Princeton, NJ.

[103] WanX,HolyoakM, YanC et al. (2022). Broad-scale climate variation drives the dynamics of animal populations: A global multi-taxa analysis. Biological Reviews 97,2174–2194.

[104] WeggeP,MossR, RolstadJ (2022). Annual variation in breeding success in boreal forest grouse: Four decades of monitoring reveals bottom-up drivers to be more important than predation. Ecology and Evolution 12,e9327.

[105] WestgateMJ,LikensGE, LindenmayerDB (2013). Adaptive management of biological systems: A review. Biological Conservation 158,128–139.

[106] WilliamsDR,Balmford A,WilcoveDS (2020). The past and future role of conservation science in saving biodiversity. Conservation Letters 13,e12720.

[107] YenJDL,ThomsonJR, PaganinDM,Keith JM,Mac NallyR (2015). Function regression in ecology and evolution: FREE. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 6,17–26.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2024 The Author(s). Integrative Zoology published by International Society of Zoological Sciences, Institute of Zoology/Chinese Academy of Sciences and John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd.