Placing Islands at Risk: Developmentalism, Militarism, Geopolitics, and the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction

Abstract

Islands have come to be seen as a distinct object of disaster risk and climate change policy and research. This is reflected in the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030 (SFDRR), which specifies Small Island Developing States (SIDS) as in need of specialized policies, attention, and support. This article directs an island studies perspective toward the SFDRR, discussing obstacles to the framework’s implementation in island contexts. Focus is placed on two interrelated sets of issues: (1) problematic aspects of the concepts of “development” as it is applied to islands (particularly in the SIDS category); and (2) international cooperation, militarism, and geopolitics. The study found that although island societies can benefit from the attention brought to them by the SFDRR, the framework engages in rhetoric that may limit island possibilities and potentials while distracting from more fundamental changes that should be made by other state and non-state actors.

Keywords

Climate change / Disasters / Islands / Militarism / Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030 (SFDRR) / Small Island Developing States (SIDS)

References

[1] Armstrong HW, Read R. The non-sovereign territories: Economic and environmental challenges of sectoral and geographic over-specialisation in tourism and financial services. European Urban and Regional Studies, 2021, 28(3): 213-240

[2] Baker R. Public administration in small and island states, 1992, Boulder: Kumarian

[3] Baldacchino G. Island enclaves: Offshoring strategies, creative governance, and subnational island jurisdictions, 2010, Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press

[4] Baldacchino G, Milne DA. Lessons from the political economy of small islands: The resourcefulness of jurisdiction, 2000, London: Palgrave Macmillan

[5] Borazon EQ, De Los Santos MDL, Lee M-T, Yang C-C, Eleazar RN. Resilience-building in small island family-owned accommodation sector. Island Studies Journal, 2023, 18(2): 1-25.

[6] Briguglio L. Small Island Developing States and their economic vulnerabilities. World Development, 1995, 23(9): 1615-1632

[7] Calandra M. Disasta: Rethinking the notion of disaster in the wake of Cyclone Pam. Anthropological Forum, 2020, 30(1–2): 42-54

[8] Chan L-H. Chan L-H, Lee PK. Australia and New Zealand in the Indo-Pacific: How and why the Pacific Islands look to authoritarian China?. China-US great-power rivalry: The competitive dynamics of order-building in the Indo-Pacific, 2024, London: Routledge 65-90

[9] Chibana M. Striving for land, sea, and life: The Okinawan demilitarization movement. Pacific Asia Inquiry, 2013, 4(1): 136-154.

[10] Colgan JD. Climate change and the politics of military bases. Global Environmental Politics, 2018, 18(1): 33-51

[11] Davis S, Munger LA, Legacy HJ. Someone else’s chain, someone else’s road: US military strategy, China’s Belt and Road Initiative, and island agency in the Pacific. Island Studies Journal, 2020, 15(2): 13-35

[12] Duda PI, Kelman I, Glick N. Informal disaster governance. Politics and Governance, 2020, 8(4): 375-385

[13] Espinosa, A. 2020. In the eye of a hurricane there is quiet: Puerto Rico’s fight for aid after Hurricane Maria. George Washington Journal of Energy and Environmental Law 10: Article 91.

[14] Ferdinand M. Subnational climate justice for the French Outre-mer: Postcolonial politics and geography of an epistemic shift. Island Studies Journal, 2018, 13(1): 119-134

[15] Ferdinand M. Decolonial ecology: Thinking from the Caribbean world, 2021, Hoboken: Wiley

[16] Foley A, Brinklow L, Corbett J, Kelman I, Klöck C, Moncada S, Mycoo M, Nunn P Understanding “islandness”. Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 2023, 113(8): 1800-1817

[17] García-López GA. The multiple layers of environmental injustice in contexts of (un)natural disasters: The case of Puerto Rico post-Hurricane Maria. Environmental Justice, 2018, 11(3): 101-108

[18] Gerrard MB. America’s forgotten nuclear waste dump in the Pacific. SAIS Review, 2015, 35(1): 87-97

[19] Gfoellner B. “We are still here holding fast”: Stillness in the wake of Hurricane Irma in Richard Georges’ Epiphaneia. Island Studies Journal, 2023, 18(1): 143-160

[20] Ginoza A, Alexander R, DeLoughrey E, Randall JE, Hatano S, Karimata S. Ginoza A. Prospects for critical island studies. The challenges of island studies, 2020, Berlin: Springer 95-116

[21] Grosfoguel R. Developmentalism, modernity, and dependency theory in Latin America. Nepantla: Views from South, 2000, 1(2): 347-374.

[22] Grydehøj A. Decolonising the economy in micropolities: Rents, government spending and infrastructure development in Kalaallit Nunaat (Greenland). Small States & Territories, 2018, 1: 69-94.

[23] Grydehøj A. Unravelling economic dependence and independence in relation to island sovereignty: The case of Kalaallit Nunaat (Greenland). Island Studies Journal, 2020, 15(1): 89-119

[24] Grydehøj A, Kelman I. Reflections on conspicuous sustainability: Creating Small Island Dependent States (SIDS) through Ostentatious Development Assistance (ODA)?. Geoforum, 2020, 116: 90-97

[25] Grydehøj, A., M.L. Bevacqua, M. Chibana, Y. Nadarajah, A. Simonsen, P. Su, R. Wright, and S. Davis. 2021. Practicing decolonial political geography: Island perspectives on neocolonialism and the China threat discourse. Political Geography 85: Article 102330.

[26] Haug S. A Thirdspace approach to the “Global South”: Insights from the margins of a popular category. Third World Quarterly, 2021, 42(9): 2018-2038

[27] Johansen MP, Ruedig E, Tagami K, Uchida S, Higley K, Beresford NA. Radiological dose rates to marine fish from the Fukushima Daiichi accident: The first three years across the North Pacific. Environmental Science & Technology, 2015, 49(3): 1277-1285

[28] Jonassen, T. 2024. Eruption started again on Reykjanes Peninsula in Iceland. High North News, 8 February 2024. https://www.highnorthnews.com/en/eruption-started-again-reykjanes-peninsula-iceland. Accessed 2 Mar 2024.

[29] Kelman I. Islandness within climate change narratives of Small Island Developing States (SIDS). Island Studies Journal, 2018, 13(1): 149-166

[30] Kelman I. Disaster by choice: How our actions turn natural hazards into catastrophes, 2020, Oxford: Oxford University Press

[31] Kelman I. Islands of vulnerability and resilience: Manufactured stereotypes?. Area, 2020, 52(1): 6-13

[32] Kim J. Settler garrison: Debt imperialism, militarism, and transpacific imaginaries, 2022, Durham: Duke University Press

[33] Kwong Y-H, Wong MYH. International linkages, geopolitics, and the Belt and Road Initiative: A comparison of four island territories. Island Studies Journal, 2020, 15(2): 131-154

[34] Lau Y-Y, Tam K-C, Ng AKY. Ferry services and the community development of peripheral island areas in Hong Kong: Evidence from Cheung Chau. Island Studies Journal, 2022

[35] Le Dé L, Gaillard JC. Aronsson-Storrier M, Dahlberg R. Whose views matter? For a pluralistic approach to understanding disasters. Defining disaster, 2022, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar 123-139.

[36] Li, F., L. Wang, and X. Zhou. 2023. Fulfiling the State duty to cooperate on the discharge of Fukushima nuclear contaminated water: Potential pathways. Marine Policy 150: Article 105546.

[37] Lloréns H. Ruin nation: In Puerto Rico, Hurricane Maria laid bare the results of a long-term crisis created by dispossession, migration, and economic predation. NACLA Report on the Americas, 2018, 50(2): 154-159

[38] Maggio R. I’m sorry, but that’s bribery”: A decolonial perspective from which to study moral economies in the “Chinese Pacific. Island Studies Journal, 2023

[39] Marler TE, Moore A. Military threats to terrestrial resources not restricted to wartime: A case study from Guam. Journal of Environmental Science and Engineering, 2011, 5: 1198-1214.

[40] Marwah IS. Provincializing progress: Developmentalism and anti-imperialism in colonial India. Polity, 2019, 51(3): 498-531

[41] Matheson K, Pawson C, Clegg P. Social psychological perspectives on islandness: Identities, vulnerabilities and precarities. Island Studies Journal, 2024

[42] Matti, S., M. Cullen, U. Reichardt, and A. Vigfúsdóttir. 2023. Planned relocation due to landslide-triggered tsunami risk in recently deglaciated areas. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 86: Article 103536.

[43] Mausio A. A South-South tango: China’s soft power relations with Fiji since 1975. Island Studies Journal, 2023, 18(2): 1-26.

[44] McDougall D, Taneja P. Sino-Indian competition in the Indian Ocean island countries: The scope for small state agency. Journal of the Indian Ocean Region, 2020, 16(2): 124-145

[45] Miller MA. A transboundary political ecology of volcanic sand mining. Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 2022, 112(1): 78-96

[46] Mosneaga, A. 2022. Unsustainable development, disasters and displacement: Revisiting the governance challenge. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 79: Article 103172.

[47] Mycoo, M., M. Wairiu, D. Campbell, V. Duvat, Y. Golbuu, S. Maharaj, J. Nalau, P. Nunn, et al. 2022. Small islands. IPCC WGII Sixth Assessment Report hal-03704367. https://hal.science/hal-03704367. Accessed 2 Mar 2024.

[48] Na’puti TR. Disaster militarism and Indigenous responses to Super Typhoon Yutu in the Mariana Islands. Environmental Communication, 2022, 16(5): 612-629

[49] Na’puti TR, Bevacqua ML. Militarization and resistance from Guåhan: Protecting and defending Pågat. American Quarterly, 2015, 67(3): 837-858

[50] Nadarajah Y. From field to theory: Rethinking development studies through study tours. Third World Quarterly, 2023, 44(7): 1472-1488

[51] National Statistical Office. 2021. Population. https://www.nso.gov.pg/statistics/population/#118-118-top-p2. Accessed 5 Mar 2024.

[52] Nielsen KH. Brook R, Dodge M, Hogg J. Atomic urbanism under Greenland’s ice cap. Cold War cities: Politics, culture and atomic urbanism, 1945–1965, 2021, Abingdon: Routledge 182-199.

[53] Nunn PD, Kumar R, Barrowman HM, Chambers L, Fifita L, Gegeo D, Gomese C, McGree S Traditional knowledge for climate resilience in the Pacific Islands. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change., 2024

[54] Park, E. 2024. Sand mining in the Mekong Delta: Extent and compounded impacts. Science of the Total Environment 924: Article 171620.

[55] Perdikaris S, Abadie R, Gonzalez E, Ibrahimpašić E. Politics of prevention in the periphery: The initial response to COVID-19 on Barbuda and Puerto Rico. Island Studies Journal, 2022, 17(1): 66-84

[56] Petzold J, Ratter B. More than just SIDS: Local solutions for global problems on small islands. Island Studies Journal, 2019, 14(1): 3-8

[57] Petzold J, Joe ET, Kelman I, Magnan AK, Mirbach C, Alverio GN, Nunn PD, Ratter BMW Global Adaptation Mapping Initiative Team Between tinkering and transformation: A contemporary appraisal of climate change adaptation research on the world’s islands. Frontiers in Climate, 2023

[58] Ramos-Gutiérrez D, Pagán M. How the people of Vieques evicted the US Navy: A Puerto Rican demilitarization activist reflects on the decades-long struggle to urge US forces to withdraw from the island and the ongoing challenges Viequenses face today. NACLA Report on the Americas, 2023, 55(4): 398-402

[59] Rasheed AA. Small Island Developing States and climate securitisation in international politics: Towards a comprehensive conception. Island Studies Journal, 2023, 18(1): 161-185

[60] Ratter BMW. Geography of small islands, 2018, Cham: Springer

[61] Ruehr S. Beyond the vulnerability/resilience dichotomy: Perceptions of and responses to the climate crisis on Emau Vanuatu. Island Studies Journal, 2022, 17(1): 157-176

[62] Sheng N, Tang UW, Grydehøj A. Urban morphology and urban fragmentation in Macau, China: Island city development in the Pearl River Delta megacity region. Island Studies Journal, 2017, 12(2): 199-212

[63] Shultz JM, Cohen MA, Hermosilla S, Espinel Z, McLean A. Disaster risk reduction and sustainable development for Small Island Developing States. Disaster Health, 2016, 3(1): 32-44

[64] Small Island Developing States. 2024. List of SIDS. https://www.un.org/ohrlls/content/list-sids. Accessed 28 Jun 2024.

[65] Statistics Niue. 2023. Website. https://niuestatistics.nu. Accessed 9 Mar 2024.

[66] Sud N, Sánchez-Ancochea D. Southern discomfort: Interrogating the category of the Global South. Development and Change, 2022, 53(6): 1123-1150

[67] Sultana, F. 2022. The unbearable heaviness of climate coloniality. Political Geography 99: Article 102638.

[68] Telleria J. Can we “transform our world” without affecting international power relations? A political analysis of the United Nations development agenda. Globalizations, 2018, 15(5): 655-669

[69] Temin DM. Development in decolonization: Walter Rodney, Third World developmentalism, and “decolonizing political theory”. American Political Science Review, 2023, 117(1): 235-248

[70] UN-OHRLLS (United Nations – Office of the High Representative for the Least Developed Countries, Landlocked Developing Countries and Small Island Developing States). 2024a. About Small Island Developing States. https://www.un.org/ohrlls/content/about-small-island-developing-states. Accessed 9 Mar 2024.

[71] UN-OHRLLS (United Nations – Office of the High Representative for the Least Developed Countries, Landlocked Developing Countries and Small Island Developing States). 2024b. List of SIDS. https://www.un.org/ohrlls/content/list-sids. Accessed 12 Mar 2024.

[72] UNCED (United Nations Conference on Environment and Development). 1992. Agenda 21. Adopted at United Nations Conference on Environment and Development, 3–14 June 1992, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.

[73] UNCTAD (United Nations Trade & Development). 2022. What makes a SIDS a SIDS? In Development and globalization: Facts and figures 2021—Small Island Developing States DGFF2021, 9–35. New York: United Nations.

[74] UNEP (United Nations Environment Program) UNEP’s assistance in the implementation of the Barbados Programme of Action for the sustainable development of Small Island Developing States (SIDS), 2004, The Hague: UNEP

[75] UNISDR (United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction) Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction 2015–2030, 2015, Geneva: UNISDR

[76] Walshe R, Foley AM. Learning from the archives of island jurisdictions: Why and how island history should inform disaster risk reduction and climate action. Small States & Territories, 2021, 4(2): 205-230.

[77] Wesley-Smith, T., and G. Finin. 2024. US funding delays hurt the Pacific—But there are bigger worries. The Guardian, 29 February 2024. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/feb/29/us-funding-delays-hurt-the-pacific-but-there-are-bigger-worries. Accessed 12 Mar 2024.

[78] Westerling E, Klöck C. Islandness and dependence in Greenland’s climate paradiplomacy: 2009–2021. Small States & Territories, 2023, 6(2): 185-202.

[79] World Conference on Disaster Risk Reduction Hyogo framework for action Building the resilience of nations and communities to disasters, 2005, Geneva: United Nations Inter-Agency Secretariat of the International Strategy for Disaster Reduction