Cost-Benefit Analysis of the Wuxikou Integrated Flood Management Project Considering the Effects of Flood Risk Reduction and Resettlement

Abstract

Evaluation of the economic costs and benefits of flood disaster risk management projects is crucial. However, current cost-benefit analyses (CBA) often lack reliable estimates of the expected loss reduction from flood control measures and ignore quantitative assessments of resettlement. To address these limitations, this study incorporated a probabilistic risk analysis method and quantitative resettlement benefits assessment into the CBA framework, using the Wuxikou Integrated Flood Management Project (WIFMP) in Jiangxi Province, China, as a case study. The direct economic benefits of flood control were estimated by integrating hydrological statistics, numerical flood inundation simulation, and quantitative damage analysis with exposure and vulnerability data. Furthermore, the resettlement benefits were quantified by measuring the annual income growth of migrants based on assumptions about household employment. Our analysis shows that the total WIFMP investment is RMB 3546.1 million yuan (USD 1 = RMB 6.976 yuan), including loan principal and interest of 244.4 million yuan, and operations and maintenance of 605.5 million yuan at 2020 prices. Annual project benefits are estimated at 351.3 million yuan in flood risk reduction, 155.7–191.9 million yuan from increased resettlement income, and 42.7 million yuan in power and water revenues. Considering the costs and benefits across the entire project lifecycle, the internal rate of return ranges from 13.7 to 14.2%, and the net present value ranges from 31.8 to 352.6 billion yuan. Through improved benefit estimation methodology, this research enables a more reliable and holistic evaluation of costs and benefits for flood risk management projects. It provides insights for policymakers and practitioners involved in similar projects, contributing to more informed decision making and better allocation of resources in flood disaster risk management.

Keywords

Cost-benefit analysis / Flood management project / Resettlement / Risk reduction

References

[1] Barredo JI. Normalised flood losses in Europe: 1970–2006. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2009, 9(1): 97-104

[2] Botzen WJ, Wouter É, Monteiro F, Estrada GP, Menoni S. Economic assessment of mitigating damage of flood events: Cost–benefit analysis of flood-proofing commercial buildings in Umbria, Italy. Resources, 2017, 42: 585-608.

[3] Boulange, J., N. Hanasaki, D. Yamazaki, and Y. Pokhrel. 2021. Role of dams in reducing global flood exposure under climate change. Nature Communications 12(1): Article 417.

[4] Casajus Valles A, Marin Ferrer M, Poljanšek K, Clark I. Science for disaster risk management 2020—Acting today, protecting tomorrow, 2021, Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union

[5] Cheng, X.T. 2019. Flood risk and flood management policies in China. In Annual report on China’s response to climate change (2017), ed. W. Wang, and Y. Liu, 49–65. Research Series on the Chinese Dream and China’s Development Path. Singapore: Springer.

[6] Dash, P., and J. Sar. 2020. Identification and validation of potential flood hazard area using GIS-based multi-criteria analysis and satellite data-derived water index. Journal of Flood Risk Management 13(3): Article e12620.

[7] Downing T, Shi GQ, Zaman M, Garcia-Downing C. Improving post-relocation support for people resettled by infrastructure development. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 2021, 39: 357-365

[8] FEMA (Federal Emergency Management Agency). 2022. Hazus flood model technical manual, publication Hazus 5.1. Washington, DC: Federal Emergency Management Agency.

[9] Galipeau BA, Ingman M, Tilt B. Dam-induced displacement and agricultural livelihoods in China’s Mekong basin. Human Ecology, 2013, 41: 437-446

[10] Genovese E, Thaler T. The benefits of flood mitigation strategies: Effectiveness of integrated protection measures. AIMS Geosciences, 2020, 6: 459-472

[11] Grossi, P., H. Kunreuther, and C.C. Patel. 2005. Catastrophe modeling: A new approach to managing risk. Springer Science & Business Media 25: 45–64.

[12] Gunatilake, H.M. 2013. Cost-benefit analysis for development: A practical guide. Mandaluyong City, Metro Manila, Philippines: Asian Development Bank.

[13] Hartmann T, Spit T. Legitimizing differentiated flood protection levels—Consequences of the European flood risk management plan. Environmental Science & Policy, 2016, 55: 361-367

[14] Huang, Y.L., W.S. Lin, S. Li, and Y. Ning. 2018. Social impacts of dam-induced displacement and resettlement: A comparative case study in China. Sustainability 10(11): Article 4018.

[15] Husnain. T., B. Muhammad, and S.L. Karnchanapaiboon. 2020. Flood inundation modeling and hazard assessment in Lower Ping River Basin using MIKE FLOOD. Arabian Journal of Geosciences 13(18): Article 934.

[16] JCMG-PMO (Project Management Office of Municipal Government of Jingdezhen City). 2020. Completion report on financial and economic reanalysis of Wuxikou Water Control Project in Jiangxi Province.

[17] Jiang LP. China—Jiangxi Wuxikou integrated flood management project: P128867—Implementation status and results report: Sequence 02 (English), 2019, Washington, DC: World Bank Group

[18] JMBS (Jingdezhen Municipal Bureau of Statistics) Jingdezhen statistical yearbook, 2015, Beijing: China Statistical Press in Chinese

[19] Kotchen M, Moore M, Lupi F, Rutherford E. Environmental constraints on hydropower: An ex post benefit-cost analysis of dam relicensing in Michigan. Land Economics, 2006, 82(3): 384-403

[20] Liu W, Chen W, Feng Q, Peng C, Kang P. Cost-benefit analysis of green infrastructures on community stormwater reduction and utilization: A case of Beijing, China. Environmental Management, 2016, 58: 1015-1026

[21] Liu Y, Li Y, Wang GF, Yin JF, Zhang ZT, Zhu YY, Li N. Multi-regional indirect economic loss assessmentof “21.7” extreme rainstorm in Henan Province. Journal of Catastrophology, 2022, 37(4): 45-51 in Chinese

[22] Mcdonald B, Webber M, Duan YF. Involuntary resettlement as an opportunity for development: The case of urban resettlers of the Three Gorges project, China. Journal of Refugee Studies, 2008, 21: 82-102

[23] Miyamoto M, Osti R, Okazumi T. Development of an integrated decision-making method for effective flood early warning system. Journal of Disaster Research, 2014, 9: 55-68

[24] NDRC (National Development and Reform Commission). China electric power yearbook, 2014, Beijing: China Electric Power Press in Chinese

[25] NDRC (National Development and Reform Commission), and MWR (Ministry of Water Resources) China electric power yearbook, 2003, Beijing: China Electric Power Press in Chinese

[26] Nobi, M.N. 2022. Cost-benefit analysis of Kaptai dam in Rangamati District, Chittagong, Bangladesh. SSRN Electronic Journal. arXiv:2109.05419v3.

[27] OECD (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development). 2014. Water governance in the Netherlands: Fit for the future? OECD Studies on Water. Pairs: Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development.

[28] Roy B, Remco VE. Integrated ecological, economic and social impact assessment of alternative flood control policies in the Netherlands. Ecological Economics, 2004, 50(1): 1-21.

[29] Saint, G.N., F. Grelot, J.-S. Bailly, and C. Lavergne. 2015. Ranking sources of uncertainty in flood damage modelling: A case study on the cost-benefit analysis of a flood mitigation project in the Orb Delta. France. Journal of Flood Risk Management 8(2): 161–176.

[30] Sun, D.C., J. Huang, H.M. Wang, Z.Q. Wang, and W.Q. Wang. 2017. Risk assessment of urban flood disaster in Jingdezhen City based on analytic hierarchy process and geographic information system. Earth and Environmental Science 82(1): Article 012075.

[31] Tajziehchi, S., A. Karbassi, G. Nabi, C. Yoo, and P. Ifaei. 2022. A cost-benefit analysis of Bakhtiari hydropower dam considering the nexus between energy and water. Energies 15(3): Article 871.

[32] Tullos D, Tilt B, Liermann CR. Introduction to the special issue: Understanding and linking the biophysical, socioeconomic and geopolitical effects of dams. Journal of Environmental Management, 2009, 90: 203-207

[33] Udayakumara E, Gunawardena U. Cost-benefit analysis of Samanalawewa hydroelectric project in Sri Lanka: An ex post analysis. Earth Systems and Environment, 2018, 1(1): 401-412

[34] Wang Y, Hu A. The road of China water development: Retrospect and prospect (1949–050). Journal of Tsinghua University (Philosophy and Social Sciences), 2011, 26(99–112): 162 in Chinese

[35] Wang YJ, Jing C, Jiang T, Zhai JQ, Feng ZQ. Projection of provincial urban and rural population and its influencing factors in China’s mainland (2015–2050). Journal of Nanjing University of Information Science & Technology (Natural Science Edition), 2020, 12(4): 395-405 in Chinese

[36] Wang P, Lassoie JP, Dong SK, Morreale SJ. A framework for social impact analysis of large dams: A case study of cascading dams on the upper-Mekong River, China. Journal of Environmental Management, 2013, 117: 131-140

[37] Wang, Z.Q., H.M. Wang, J. Huang, J.L. Kang, and D. Han. 2018. Analysis of the public flood risk perception in a flood-prone city: The case of Jingdezhen City in China. Water 10(11): Article 1577.

[38] World Bank China – Country partnership strategy for the period FY13–FY16, 2012, Washington, DC: World Bank Group

[39] World Commission on Dams Dams and development: A new framework for decision-making. Environmental Management and Health, 2001, 12(4): 444-445

[40] Xia BQ, Qiang MS, Chen WC, Fan QX, Jiang HC, An N. A benefit-sharing model for hydropower projects based on stakeholder input-output analysis: A case study of the Xiluodu project in China. Land Use Policy, 2018, 73: 341-352