Disaster Collaborative Exercises for Healthcare Teamwork in a Saudi Context

Abstract

This study aimed to evaluate the development of healthcare teamwork during and after the collaboration tabletop exercises, through observation and interview methods. Integration and maturity theoretical models were employed to explain the collaborative challenges in teams that may suffer from unequally distributed power, hierarchies, and fragmentation. Using three-level collaboration tabletop exercises and the Command and control, Safety, Communication, Assessment, Treatment, Triage, Transport (CSCATTT) instrument, 100 healthcare workers were observed during each step in the implementation of the CSCATTT instrument using two simulated scenarios. The results show a lack of integration and team maturity among participants in the first scenario, leading to the delayed start of the activity, task distribution, and decision making. These shortcomings were improved in the second scenario. In-depth interviews with 20 participants in the second phase of the study revealed improved knowledge and practical skills, self-confidence, and ability in team building within trans-professional groups in the second scenario, which in concordance with the integration theory, was due to the attempts made in the first scenario. Additionally, there was an improvement in the team’s maturity, which in concordance with the maturity theory, was due to the knowledge and practical skills during scenario plays. These results indicate the importance of continuous tabletop training, and the use of CSCATTT as a collaborative instrument, to promote the development of collaboration and to test the concept of preparedness.

Keywords

Collaboration exercises / Disaster education / Emergency management / Healthcare personnel training / Saudi Arabia / Teamwork

References

[1] Abu Alsuood Y, Youde A. An exploration of cultural factors and their influence on Saudi Arabian university deans’ leadership perceptions and practices. Education Sciences, 2018, 8(2): Article 57

[2] Alahmadi HA. Assessment of patient safety culture in Saudi Arabian hospitals. Quality and Safety in Health Care, 2010, 19(5): e17-e17.

[3] Alamri, A., A.I. Cristea, and M.S. Al-Zaidi. 2014. Saudi Arabian cultural factors and personalized learning. In Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Education and New Learning Technologies, 7–9 July 2014, Barcelona, Spain, 7114–712.‏

[4] Alandijany TA, Faizo AA, Azhar EI. Coronavirus disease of 2019 (COVID-19) in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries: Current status and management practices. Journal of Infection and Public Health, 2020, 13(6): 839-842

[5] Aldulaimi SH. Leadership concept and constructs in Arabic philosophy. Journal of Economic Cooperation & Development, 2019, 40(2): 193-210.

[6] Alenazi TH, BinDhim NF, Alenazi MH, Tamim H, Almagrabi RS, Aljohani SM, Basyouni MH, Almubark RA Prevalence and predictors of anxiety among healthcare workers in Saudi Arabia during the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Infection and Public Health, 2020, 13(11): 1645-1651

[7] Al-Hunaishi W, Hoe VC, Chinna K. Factors associated with healthcare workers’ willingness to participate in disasters: A cross-sectional study in Sana’a. Yemen. BMJ Open, 2019, 9(10): e030547

[8] Al Thobaity A, Alshammari F. Nurses on the frontline against the COVID-19 pandemic: An integrative review. Dubai Medical Journal, 2020, 3(3): 87-92

[9] Andersson A, Carlström E, Berlin JM. Organizing a simulated reality: On exercises with public safety organizations (Organisering Av En fingerad Verklighet: Om ovningar mellan blåljusorganisationer). Nordic Organization Studies, 2013, 15(3): 34-64.

[10] Assbeihat JM. The impact of collaboration among members on team’s performance. Management and Administrative Sciences Review, 2016, 5(5): 248-259.

[11] Berger PL, Luckman T. The social construction of reality, 1991, London: Penguin Books Ltd

[12] Berlin JM. Synchronous work: Myth or reality? A critical study of teams in health and medical care. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 2010, 16(6): 1314-1321

[13] Berlin JM. Common incentives for teamwork—The unspoken contract’s significance. Team Performance Management, 2014, 20(1): 65-80

[14] Berlin JM, Carlström ED. The 20-minute team—A critical case study from the emergency room. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 2008, 14(4): 569-576

[15] Berlin JM, Carlström ED. Collaboration exercises: What do they contribute? A study of learning and usefulness. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2015, 23(1): 11-23

[16] Berlin JM, Carlström ED, Sandberg HS. Models of teamwork: Ideal or not? A critical study of theoretical team models. Team Performance Management, 2012, 18(5–6): 328-340

[17] Bistaraki A, Waddington K, Galanis P. The effectiveness of a disaster training programme for healthcare workers in Greece. International Nursing Review, 2011, 58(3): 341-346

[18] Black N. Why we need observational studies to evaluate the effectiveness of health care. BMJ, 1996, 312(7040): 1215-1218

[19] Borell J, Eriksson K. Learning effectiveness of discussion-based crisis management exercises. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2013, 5: 28-37

[20] Brinkmann S, Kvale S. Interviews: Learning the craft of qualitative research interviewing, 2015 3 Thousand Oaks: Sage Publishing

[21] Buljac-Samardzic M, Doekhie KD, van Wijngaarden JD. Interventions to improve team effectiveness within health care: A systematic review of the past decade. Human Resources for Health, 2020, 18(1): 1-42

[22] Burnett AL, McGuire K. “This is not a drill—Evacuate the building now!” Disaster preparedness at the outpatient surgery department: An experiential lesson. Journal of Pediatric Surgical Nursing, 2020, 9(2): 37-42

[23] Calovi, M. 2018. Healthcare and disaster management: A geographical approach. Doctoral thesis. Scuola Universitaria Superiore Sant’anna, Pisa, Italy.

[24] Cariaso-Sugay J, Hultgren M, Browder BA, Chen JL. Nurse leaders’ knowledge and confidence in managing disasters in the acute care setting. Nursing Administration Quarterly, 2021, 45(2): 142-151

[25] Carpenter J. Interprofessional education for medical and nursing students: Evaluation of a programme. Medical Education, 1995, 29(4): 265-272

[26] Castañer X, Oliveira N. Collaboration, coordination, and cooperation among organizations: Establishing the distinctive meanings of these terms through a systematic literature review. Journal of Management, 2020, 46(6): 965-1001

[27] Dickinson TL, McIntyre RM. Brannick MT, Salas E, Prince C. A conceptual framework for teamwork measurement. Team performance assessment and measurement: Theory, methods, and applications, 1997, Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers 19-43.

[28] Diefenbach T, Sillince JA. Formal and informal hierarchy in different types of organization. Organization Studies, 2011, 32(11): 1515-1537

[29] Dirks KT, Ferrin DL. The role of trust in organizational setting. Organizational Sciences, 2001, 12: 450-467

[30] Finn R. The language of teamwork: Reproducing professional divisions in the operating theatre. Human Relations, 2008, 61(1): 103-130

[31] Finn R, Learmonth M, Reedy P. Some unintended effects of teamwork in healthcare. Social Science & Medicine, 2010, 70(8): 1148-1154

[32] Ghalib ZAQ. The impact of cross-cultural organizations on teamwork performance: A Yemeni perspective. European Journal of Business and Management, 2019

[33] Glantz V, Phattharapornjaroen P, Carlström E, Khorram-Manesh A. Regional flexible surge capacity—A flexible response system. Sustainability, 2020, 12(15): Article 5984

[34] Gooding K, Bertone MP, Loffreda G, Witter S. How can we strengthen partnership and coordination for health system emergency preparedness and response? Findings from a synthesis of experience across countries facing shocks. BMC Health Services Research, 2022, 22(1): 1-19

[35] Grossman R, Campo MS, Feitosa J, Salas E. Cross-cultural perspectives on collaboration: Differences between the Middle East and the United States. Journal of Business Research, 2021, 129: 2-13

[36] Hall P, Weaver L. Interdisciplinary education and teamwork: A long and winding road. Medical Education, 2001, 35(9): 867-875

[37] Hathaway JR, Tarini BA, Banerjee S, Smolkin CO, Koos JA, Pati S. Healthcare team communication training in the United States: A scoping review. Health Communication, 2022, 15: 1-26

[38] Hofstede G. Culture’s consequences: International differences in work-related values, 1984, London: Sage

[39] Hofstede G. Bleichrodt N, Drenth PJD. Empirical models of cultural differences. Contemporary issues in cross-cultural psychology, 1991, San Diego: Swets & Zeitlinger Publishers 4-20.

[40] Holloway I, Galvin K. Qualitative research in nursing and healthcare, 2017 4 London: Wiley-Blackwell

[41] Hsieh HF, Shannon SE. Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health Research, 2005, 15(9): 1277-1288

[42] Jamshidi H, Jazani RK, Alibabaei A, Alamdari S, Kalyani MN. Challenges of cooperation between the pre-hospital and in-hospital emergency services in the handover of victims of road traffic accidents: A qualitative study. Investigación y educación en enfermería, 2019, 37(1): 70-79.

[43] Joseph S. Gender and citizenship in the Middle East, 2000, Syracuse: Syracuse University Press

[44] Kahn CA, Koenig KL, Schultz CH. Emergency physician disaster deployment: Issues to consider and a model policy. Prehospital and Disaster Medicine, 2017, 32(4): 462-464

[45] Khorram-Manesh A. Learning to respect diversity, gender equality, and collaboration: A childhood agenda or the content of a leadership development program. Disaster, Diversity and Emergency Preparation, 2019, 146: Article 11

[46] Khorram-Manesh A. Flexible surge capacity—Public health, public education, and disaster management. Health Promotion Perspectives, 2020, 10(3): 175-179

[47] Khorram-Manesh A, Berlin J, Carlström E. Two validated ways of improving the ability of decision-making in emergencies; Results from a literature review. Bulletin of Emergency & Trauma, 2016, 4(4): Article 186

[48] Khorram-Manesh A, Lupesco O, Friedl T, Arnim G, Kaptan K, Djalali AR, Foletti M, Ingrasia PL Education in disaster management: What do we offer and what do we need? Proposing a new global program. Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness, 2016, 10(6): 854-873

[49] Khorram-Manesh A, Lönroth H, Rotter P, Wilhelmsson M, Aremyr J, Berner A, Andersson AN, Carlström E. Non-medical aspects of civilian-military collaboration in the management of major incidents. European Journal of Trauma and Emergency Surgery, 2017, 43(5): 595-603

[50] Kouzes J, Posner B. The leadership challenge, 2003 3 San Francisco: Jossey-Bass

[51] Larsson LG, Bäck-Pettersson S, Kylén S, Marklund B, Carlström E. Primary care managers’ perceptions of their capability in providing care planning to patients with complex needs. Health Policy, 2017, 121(1): 58-65

[52] Lozano R, Barreiro-Gen M, Zafar A. Collaboration for organizational sustainability limits to growth: Developing a factors, benefits, and challenges framework. Sustainable Development, 2021, 29(4): 728-737

[53] Magnussen LI, Carlstrøm E, Sørensen JL, Torgersen GE, Hagenes EF, Kristiansen E. Learning and usefulness stemming from collaboration in a maritime crisis management exercise in northern Norway. Disaster Prevention and Management: An International Journal, 2018, 27(1): 129-140

[54] Makaram S. Interprofessional cooperation. Medical Education, 1995, 29: 65-69

[55] McCormack R, Coates G. A simulation model to enable the optimization of ambulance fleet allocation and base station location for increased patient survival. European Journal of Operational Research, 2015, 247(1): 294-309

[56] Melin Emilsson U, Strid AL, Söderberg M. Lack of coordination between health care and social care in multi-professional teamwork—The obstacle for coherent care of older people suffering from multi-morbidity. Journal of Population Ageing, 2020, 15(2): 319-335

[57] Merriam-Webster. 2022. Teamwork. https://www.merriam-webster.com/thesaurus/teamwork. Accessed 18 Nov 2022.

[58] Miller CJ, Kim B, Silverman A, Bauer MS. A systematic review of team-building interventions in non-acute healthcare settings. BMC Health Services Research, 2018, 18(1): 1-21

[59] Morse JM. Qualitative health research: Creating a new discipline, 2012, Walnut Creek: Left Coast Press

[60] Mostafa MM. Attitudes towards women who work in Egypt. Women in Management Review, 2003, 18(5): 252-266

[61] Moussa FL, Moussa M, Sofyani HA, Alblowi BH, Oqdi YA, Khallaf S, Alharbi HS, Albarqi A. Attitudes of critical care nurses towards teamwork and patient safety in Saudi Arabia: A descriptive cross-sectional assessment. Healthcare, 2022, 10(10): Article 1866

[62] Noyes J, Booth A, Flemming K, Garside R, Harden A, Lewin S, Pantoja T, Hannes K Cochrane qualitative and implementation methods group guidance series—Paper 3: Methods for assessing methodological limitations, data extraction, and synthesis, and confidence in synthesized qualitative findings. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2018, 97: 49-58

[63] OCHA (United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs). 2022. Surge capacity. https://www.unocha.org/our-work/coordination/surge-capacity. Accessed 10 Nov 2022.

[64] Oktari RS, Munadi K, Idroes R, Sofyan H. Knowledge management practices in disaster management: Systematic review. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2020, 51: Article 101881

[65] Petrie HG. Do you see what I see? The epistemology of interdisciplinary inquiry. Educational Researcher, 1976, 5(2): 9-15

[66] Phattharapornjaroen P, Carlström E, Khorram-Manesh A. Developing a conceptual framework for flexible surge capacity based on complexity and collaborative theoretical frameworks. Public Health, 2022, 208: 46-51

[67] Phattharapornjaroen P, Glantz V, Carlström E, Dahlén Holmqvist L, Khorram-Manesh A. Alternative leadership in flexible surge capacity—The perceived impact of tabletop simulation exercises on Thai emergency physicians’ capability to manage a major incident. Sustainability, 2020, 12(15): Article 6216

[68] Potter WJ, Levine-Donnerstein D. Rethinking validity and reliability in content analysis. Journal of Applied Communication Research, 1999, 27: 258-284

[69] Reiners, R., and S. Jayhooni. 2022. Evolving pattern candidates for setting up educational online seminars: Findings from the COVID-19 pandemic. In Proceedings of the 27th European Conference on Pattern Languages of Programs (EuroPLop ‘22), 6–10 July 2022, Irsee, Germany, Article 16.

[70] Robertson CJ, Al-Khatib JA, Al-Habib M. The relationship between Arab values and work beliefs: An exploratory examination. Thunderbird International Business Review, 2002, 44(5): 583-601

[71] Rogers DL, Mulford CL. Roger DL, Whetten DA. The historical development. Interorganizational coordination: Theory, research, and implementation, 1985, Ames: Iowa State University Press

[72] Ronchi E, Nilsson D, Kojić S, Eriksson J, Lovreglio R, Modig H, Walter AL. A virtual reality experiment on flashing lights at emergency exit portals for road tunnel evacuation. Fire Technology, 2016, 52(3): 623-647

[73] Rosen MA, DiazGranados D, Dietz AS, Benishek LE, Thompson D, Pronovost PJ, Weaver SJ. Teamwork in healthcare: Key discoveries enabling safer, high-quality care. American Psychologist, 2018, 73(4): 433-450

[74] Ross W, LaCroix J. Multiple meanings of trust in negotiation theory and research: A literature review and integrative model. International Journal of Conflict Management, 1996, 7(4): 314-360

[75] Ruggiano N, Perry TE. Conducting secondary analysis of qualitative data: Should we, can we, and how?. Qualitative Social Work, 2019, 18(1): 81-97

[76] Sammut J, Cato D, Homer T. Major Incident Medical Management and Support (MIMMS): A practical, multiple casualty, disaster-site training course for all Australian health care personnel. Emergency Medicine, 2001, 13(2): 174-180

[77] Sandberg H. Team development on research foundation (En forskningsbas för teamutveckling), 1997, Västerås: Mälardalen University Press (in Swedish)

[78] Sasangohar F, Moats J, Mehta R, Peres SC. Disaster ergonomics: Human factors in COVID-19 pandemic emergency management. Human Factors, 2020, 62(7): 1061-1068

[79] Schmutz JB, Meier LL, Manser T. How effective is teamwork really? The relationship between teamwork and performance in healthcare teams: A systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ Open, 2019, 9(9): Article e028280

[80] Shackleton VJ, Ali AH. Work-related values of managers: A test of the Hofstede model. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 1990, 21(1): 109-118

[81] Sherif V. Evaluating preexisting qualitative research data for secondary analysis. Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung/Forum: Qualitative Social Research, 2018

[82] Simon R, Morarji A, Ganesamurthy K. Disaster management—Hospital perspective. International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews, 2021, 8(1): 390-394.

[83] Sørensen JL, Carlström ED, Torgersen GE, Christiansen AM, Kim TE, Wahlstrøm S, Magnussen LI. The organizer dilemma: Outcomes from a collaboration exercise. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2019, 10(2): 261-269

[84] Sultan MAS, Khorram-Manesh A, Carlström E, Berlin J, Sørensen JL. Impact of virtual disaster collaboration exercises on disaster leadership at hospitals in Saudi Arabia. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2021, 12(6): 879-889

[85] Sultan MAS, Sørensen JL, Carlström E, Mortelmans L, Khorram-Manesh A. Emergency healthcare providers’ perceptions of preparedness and willingness to work during disasters and public health emergencies. Healthcare, 2020, 8(4): Article 442

[86] Sweis RJ, Al-Mansour A, Tarawneh M, Al-Dweik G. The impact of total quality management practices on employee empowerment in the healthcare sector in Saudi Arabia: A study of King Khalid Hospital. International Journal of Productivity and Quality Management, 2013, 12(3): 271-286

[87] Tanco M, Jaca C, Viles E, Mateo R, Santos J. Healthcare teamwork best practices: Lessons for industry. The TQM Journal, 2011, 23(6): 598-610

[88] Tlaiss H, Kauser S. Davidson MJ, Burke RJ, Richardsen AM. Women in management in Lebanon. Women in management worldwide, 2020, London: Routledge 299-315

[89] Weick KE. The vulnerable system: An analysis of the Tenerife air disaster. Journal of Management, 1990, 16(3): 571-593

[90] Wennman I, Wittholt M, Carlström E, Carlsson T, Khorram-Manesh A. Urgent care center in Sweden—The integration of teams and perceived effects. The International Journal of Health Planning and Management, 2019, 34(4): 1205-1216

[91] Whetten DA. Roger DL, Whetten DA. Objectives and issues: Setting the stage. Interorganizational coordination: Theory, research, and implementation, 1985, Ames: Iowa State University Press

[92] WHO (World Health Organization). 2022. East Africa steps up health emergency readiness, response: The East Africa region faces recurrent outbreaks and disasters. Geneva: WHO. https://who-africa.africa-newsroom.com/press/east-africa-steps-up-health-emergency-readiness-response?lang=en. Accessed 18 Oct 2022.

[93] Xyrichis A, Ream E. Teamwork: A concept analysis. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 2008, 61(2): 232-241

[94] Yaseen Z. Leadership styles of men and women in the Arab world. Education, Business and Society: Contemporary Middle Eastern Issues, 2010, 3(1): 63-70

[95] Zajac S, Woods A, Tannenbaum S, Salas E, Holladay CL. Overcoming challenges to teamwork in healthcare: A team effectiveness framework and evidence-based guidance. Frontiers in Communication, 2021, 6: Article 606445