Disaster Journalism in Print Media: Analysis of the Top 10 Hydrogeomorphological Disaster Events in Portugal, 1865–2015

Abstract

Disaster communication guidelines emphasize that journalists should be aware of past major disasters and draw lessons from the coverage of those events. The press is an important source for the evolution of historical disaster and risk research paradigms over time. This study explored the top 10 damaging hydrogeomorphological events in Portugal selected from the disaster database, which includes events that caused human damages (fatalities, injured, missing, evacuated, and displaced) reported over a period of 151 years (1865–2015) by the Portuguese newspaper Diário de Notícias (DN). News analysis was guided by the news protocol. The analysis of the news published in DN enabled us to identify textual marks that present interconnections in the journalistic coverage and produce discursive standards for these disasters. The textual marks were associated with the hazard and risk paradigms. The discursive standards of DN did not clearly reflect the ruptures in the hazard paradigms. As a rule, the journalistic reports contributed to the naturalization of disasters and the gap in public understanding of risks, by presenting an approach focused on relief actions—ignoring social issues, vulnerability, and population resilience—reducing the discourse of preparedness for future disasters.

Keywords

Disaster journalism / Hydrogeomorphological events / News protocol / Portugal / Print media

References

[1] Antunes MN, Pereira SS, Zêzere JL, Oliveira AE. Journalistic approach of hydro-geomorphological events in the beginning of the industrial press. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2020, 50: Article 101919

[2] Bohensky EL, Leitch AM. Framing the flood: A media analysis of themes of resilience in the 2011 Brisbane flood. Regional Environmental Change, 2014, 14(2): 475-488

[3] Cox RS, Long BC, Jones MI, Handler RJ. Sequestering of suffering: Critical discourse analysis of natural disaster media coverage. Journal of Health Psychology, 2008, 13(4): 469-480

[4] de Marques Oliveria AH. The new history of Portugal: Portugal from monarchy to republic (Portugal da Monarquia para a República. Nova História de Portugal), 1991, Lisbon: Editorial Presença in Portuguese

[5] EM-DAT. 2019. The OFDA/CRED International Disaster Database. CRED crunch 54—Disasters 2018: Year in review. https://www.emdat.be/publications?page=1. Accessed 5 May 2022.

[6] Gerk C, Barbosa M. Journalism, memory and testimony: An analysis of the present time (Jornalismo, Memória e Testemunho: Uma análise do tempo presente). Revista Contracampo, 2018, 37: 150-167 in Portuguese

[7] Gesser-Edelsburg A, Shir-Raz Y. Risk communication and infectious diseases in an age of digital media, 2016, London and New York: Taylor & Francis

[8] Gortner E-M, Pennebaker JW. The archival anatomy of a disaster: Media coverage and community-wide health effects of the Texas A&M bonfire tragedy. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 2003, 22(5): 580-603

[9] Greenberg, J., and T.J. Scanlon. 2016. Old media, new media, and the complex story of disasters. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Natural Hazard Science. Oxford: Oxford University Press. https://oxfordre.com/naturalhazardscience/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780199389407.001.0001/acrefore-9780199389407-e-21. Accessed 10 Jul 2022.

[10] Henriques C. The Lisbon floods of 1967 as a media event at Rádio Clube Português (As inundações de Lisboa de 1967 como acontecimento mediático no Rádio Clube Português). Media & Jornalismo, 2019, 19: 165-181 in Portuguese

[11] Horowitz AC, Bekoff M. Naturalizing anthropomorphism: Behavioral prompts to our humanizing of animals. Anthrozoos, 2007, 20(1): 23-35

[12] Houston JB, Schraedley MK, Worley ME, Reed K, Saidi J. Disaster journalism: Fostering citizen and community disaster mitigation, preparedness, response, recovery, and resilience across the disaster cycle. Disasters, 2019, 43(3): 591-611

[13] Hufschmidt G, Crozier M, Glade T. Evolution of natural risk: Research framework and perspectives. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2005, 5(3): 375-387

[14] Jemphrey A, Berrington E. Surviving the media: Hillsborough, Dunblane and the press. Journalism Studies, 2000, 1(3): 469-483

[15] Knight A. Covering disasters and the media mandate. Media Asia, 2006, 33(1–2): 47-57

[16] Leoni B, Radford T, Schulman M. Disaster through a different lens: Behind every effect, there is a cause: A guide for journalists covering disaster risk reduction, 2011, Geneva: United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction Secretariat (UNISDR)

[17] Mesquita, T. 2019. “Digital first”: Recent changes in Diário de Notícias, Portugal (O digital em primeiro lugar: As mudanças recentes no Diário de Notícias de Portugal). In Gênero, notícia e transformação social, 1st edn., ed. F. Henriques, P. Calvo, L. de Lucena Ito, R. Longhi, L.A. Ogando, and M. Martinez (orgs), 324–334. Aveiro, Portugal: Ria Editorial (in Portuguese).

[18] Murdock G, Petts J, Horlick-Jones T. Pidgeon N, Kasperson RE, Slovic P. After amplification: Rethinking the role of the media in risk communication. The social amplification of risk, 2003, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 156-178

[19] Natenzon CE. Porto CM, e Freitas MF. Vulnerability, uncertainty and participatory disaster planning: The case of catastrophic floods in Argentina (Vulnerabilidad, incertidumbre y planificación participativa de desastres: el caso de las inundaciones catastróficas en Argentina). Environmental issues and vulnerability, 2003, Rio de Janeiro: Fiocruz 57-78 in Portuguese

[20] Newman E, Shapiro B. Clinicians and journalists responding to disasters. Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychopharmacology, 2014, 24: 32-38

[21] OPAS (Organização Pan-Americana da Saúde) Natural disasters and health in Brazil (Desastres Naturais e Saúde no Brasil), 2014, Washington, DC: OPAS in Portuguese

[22] Ophir Y. Coverage of epidemics in American newspapers through the lens of the crisis and emergency risk communication framework. Health Security, 2018, 16(3): 147-157

[23] Ophir Y, Walter D, Arnon D, Lokmanoglu A, Tizzoni M, Carota J, D’Antiga L, Nicastro E. The framing of Covid-19 in Italian media and its relationship with community mobility: A mixed-method approach. Journal of Health Communication, 2021, 26(3): 161-173

[24] Pantti M. Crisis and disaster coverage. The International Encyclopedia of Journalism Studies, 2018

[25] Parida D, Moses S, Rahaman KR. Analysing media framing of cyclone Amphan: Implications for risk communication and disaster preparedness. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2021, 59: Article 102272

[26] Pêcheux M. Semantics and discourse: A critique of the restatement of the obvious (Semântica e discurso: Uma crítica à reafirmação do óbvio), 1995 2 Campinas, Brazil: Ed. Unicamp in Portuguese

[27] Pereira De Souza C. Discurso e memória. Estudos Linguísticos, 2014, 43(3): 1015-1026 in Portuguese

[28] Pereira S, Ramos AM, Rebelo L, Trigo RM, Zêzere JL. A centennial catalogue of hydro-geomorphological events and their atmospheric forcing. Advances in Water Resources, 2018, 122: 98-112

[29] Pereira S, Ramos AM, Zêzere JL, Trigo RM, Vaquero JM. Spatial impact and triggering conditions of the exceptional Hydro-geomorphological event of December 1909 in Iberia. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2016, 16(2): 371-390

[30] Pereira S, Santos PP, Zêzere JL, Tavares AO, Garcia RAC, Oliveira SC. A landslide risk index for municipal land use planning in Portugal. Science of the Total Environment, 2020, 735: Article 139463

[31] Ploughman P. The American print news media ‘construction’ of five natural disasters. Disasters, 1995, 19(4): 308-326

[32] Rinne P, Nygren A. From resistance to resilience: Media discourses on urban flood governance in Mexico. Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 2016, 18(1): 4-26

[33] Sacchi S, Riva P, Brambilla M. When Mother Earth rises up: Anthropomorphizing nature reduces support for natural disaster victims. Social Psychology, 2013, 44(4): 271-277

[34] Santos PP, Pereira S, Zêzere JL, Tavares AO, Reis E, Garcia RAC, Oliveira SC. A comprehensive approach to understanding flood risk drivers at the municipal level. Journal of Environmental Management, 2020, 260: Article 110127

[35] Scanlon J. Detrani JR. Research about the mass media and disaster: Never (well hardly ever) the twain shall meet. Journalism: Theory and practice, 2011, New York: Apple Academic Press 233-269

[36] Scanlon J, Alldred S, Farrell A, Prawzick A. Coping with the media in disasters: Some predictable problems. Public Administration Review, 1985, 45(SI): 123-133

[37] Smith K, Petley DN. Environmental hazards, 2009, New York: Routledge

[38] Solman P, Henderson L. Flood disasters in the United Kingdom and India: A critical discourse analysis of media reporting. Journalism, 2019, 20(12): 1648-1664

[39] Tengarrinha J. The New State in Portugal, the control of the press and the colonial war (O Estado Novo em Portugal, o controle da imprensa e a Guerra Colonial). Brazilian Journal of Media History (Revista Brasileira de História da Mídia), 2016, 5(1): 185-194 in Portuguese

[40] Traquina N. What is journalism (O que é Jornalismo), 2002, Lisbon: Quimera Editores in Portuguese

[41] Trigo R, Ramos C, Pereira S, Ramos A, Zêzere JL. The deadliest storm of the 20th century striking Portugal: Flood impacts and atmospheric circulation. Journal of Hydrology, 2016, 541(A): 597-610

[42] UNISDR (United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction) Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction 2015–2030, 2015, Geneva: UNISDR

[43] Usher N. Recovery from disaster: How journalists at the New Orleans Times-Picayune understand the role of a post-Katrina newspaper. Journalism Practice, 2009, 3(2): 216-232

[44] Verón E. The body of the images (El cuerpo de las imágenes), 2001, Bogotá, Colombia: Norma in Spanish

[45] Verón E. Fragments of a fabric (Fragmentos de um tecido), 2004, São Leopoldo: Unisinos Editores in Portuguese

[46] Zêzere JL, Pereira SS, Santos PP. Fernandes F, Malheiro A, Chaminé HI. A century and half of hydrogeomorphological disasters in mainland Portugal. Advances in natural hazards and hydrological risks: Meeting the challenge, 2020, Cham, Switzerland: Springer 3-6

[47] Zêzere JL, Pereira S, Tavares AO, Bateira C, Trigo RM, Quaresma I, Santos PP, Santos M, Verde J. DISASTER: A GIS database on hydro-geomorphologic disasters in Portugal. Natural Hazards, 2014, 72(2): 503-532