Measuring Resilience in the Assumed City

Abstract

The malleable nature of both the idea of a city and the idea of resilience raises an important question—why measure? Resilience is assumed to be located in the physical infrastructure of specific places or as a quality of the people located there. For disasters, we are often trying to conceptualize, measure, or render legible resilience in physical structures. But what is it that we are trying to measure, and is the idea of a city reflected in these measurements? If cities are organized around something other than resilience, is resilience their natural by-product? What is necessitating the need for increased—and measured—resilience? Using interpretive policy analysis, we explored five well known disaster resilience frameworks (UNDRR’s Making Cities Resilient Campaign, UN-Habitat’s City Resilience Profiling Programme, The World Bank and GFDRR’s Resilient Cities Program, Arup and The Rockefeller Foundation’s City Resilience Index, and The Rockefeller Foundation’s 100 Resilient Cities) to identify the working definition of “city” and of “resilience.” We conclude that if the demand for cities to become more resilient is an acknowledgment of the risk produced by globalized urbanization, then the call itself is an indictment of the current state of our cities.

Keywords

City planning and design / Disaster governance / Resilience frameworks / Urban theory

References

[1] Alexander D. Resilience and disaster risk reduction: An etymological journey. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2013, 13(11): 2707-2716

[2] Amo-Agyemang C. Decolonising the discourse on resilience. International Journal of African Renaissance Studies, 2021, 16(1): 4-30.

[3] Arup. 2013. Resilient city index. https://www.arup.com/perspectives/publications/research/section/city-resilience-index. Accessed 6 Apr 2022.

[4] Barnett C, Parnell S. Ideas, implementation and indicators: Epistemologies of the post-2015 urban agenda. Environment & Urbanization, 2016, 28(1): 87-98

[5] Bevir M, Rhodes RA. Interpreting British governance, 2003, Abingdon-on-Thames, UK: Routledge

[6] Bonilla, Y. 2020. The coloniality of disaster: Race, empire, and the temporal logics of emergency in Puerto Rico, USA. Political Geography 78: Article 102181.

[7] Bosher L. Built-in resilience through disaster risk reduction: Operational issues. Building Research & Information, 2014, 42(2): 240-254

[8] Bottomore T. The Frankfurt school and its critics, 2002, London: Routledge

[9] Bracke S. Butler J, Gambetti Z, Sabsay L. Bouncing back: Vulnerability and resistance in times of resilience. Vulnerability in resistance, 2016, Durham, NC: Duke University Press 52-75.

[10] Brenner N, Theodore N. Cities and the geographies of “Actually Existing Neoliberalism”. Antipode, 2002, 34(3): 249-279.

[11] Brenner N, Marcuse P, Mayer M. Cities for people, not for profit, 2011, London: Routledge

[12] Brenner N, Peck J, Theodore N. Afterlives of neoliberalism, 2012, London: Bedford Press

[13] Carpenter S, Walker B, Anderies JM, Abel N. From metaphor to measurement: Resilience of what to what?. Ecosystems, 2001, 4(8): 765-781

[14] Castells M. The urban question: A Marxist approach, 1977, Cambridge: MIT Press

[15] Chandler D. Security through societal resilience: Contemporary challenges in the anthropocene. Contemporary Security Policy, 2020, 41(2): 195-214

[16] Cheek W, Chmutina K. “Building Back Better” is neoliberal post-disaster reconstruction. Disasters, 2021

[17] Chmutina K, Lizarralde G, Dainty A, Bosher L. Unpacking resilience policy discourse. Cities, 2016, 58: 70-79

[18] Chmutina K, Sadler N, von Meding J, Abukhalaf AHI. Lost (and found?) in translation: Key terminology in disaster studies. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2020, 30(2): 149-162

[19] Chmutina K, von Meding J. A dilemma of language: “Natural disasters” in academic literature. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2019, 10(2): 283-292

[20] City of Berkeley. 2018. City of Berkeley demographic and economic profile. https://www.cityofberkeley.info/uploadedFiles/Manager/Economic_Development/Attachment3_DemographicandEconomicProfile.pdf. Accessed 5 Apr 2022.

[21] Cuppini N. Enright R, Rossi U. The globalized city as a locus of the political: Logistical urbanization, genealogical insights, contemporary aporias. The urban political, 2018, London: Palgrave Macmillan 65-80

[22] The Data Center. 2020. Who lives in New Orleans and Metro Parishes now? https://www.datacenterresearch.org/data-resources/who-lives-in-new-orleans-now/. Accessed 2 Feb 2022.

[23] Figueiredo, L., T. Honiden, and A. Schumann. 2018. Indicators for resilient cities. OECD Regional Development Working Papers 2018/02. https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/docserver/6f1f6065-en.pdf?expires=1590479668&id=id&accname=guest&checksum=0FB14A2A6B6E0368D2DA1E05ABECD310. Accessed 14 Feb 2022.

[24] Gaillard, J.C., and R. Jigyasu. 2016. Measurement and evidence: Whose resilience for whom? Resilience Development Institute Working paper No. 11. https://www.preventionweb.net/publication/measurement-and-evidence-whose-resilience-whom. Accessed 14 Feb 2022.

[25] Garcia EJ, Vale B. Unravelling sustainability and resilience in the built environment, 2017, London and New York: Routledge

[26] Goldsmith W, Desoto-Duncan A, Durham-Aguillera K. Achieving the unprecedented in New Orleans. The Military Engineer, 2012, 104(678): 50-53.

[27] Harvey D. From managerialism to entrepreneurialism: The transformation in urban governance in late capitalism. Geografiska Annaler, 1989, 71(1): 3-15

[28] Harvey, D. 1996. Cities or urbanization? City 1(1–2): 38–61.

[29] Harvey D. Spaces of capital: Towards a critical geography, 2001, New York: Routledge

[30] Hayek F. Individualism and economic order, 1948, Chicago: University of Chicago Press

[31] Humbert C, Joseph J. Introduction: The politics of resilience: Problematising current approaches. Resilience, 2019, 7(3): 215-223

[32] Joseph J. Variations of governmentality across the Globe: The case of resilience, 2021, London: Routledge

[33] Lefebvre H. The urban revolution, 2003, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press

[34] Levine, S. 2014. Assessing resilience: Why quantification misses the point. ODI Working Paper. London: Humanitarian Policy Group, Overseas Development Institute. https://odi.org/en/publications/assessing-resilience-why-quantification-misses-the-point/. Accessed 2 Feb 2022.

[35] Lizarralde G, Paez H, Lopez A, Lopez O, Bornstein L, Gould K, Herazo B, Munoz L. We said, they said: The politics of conceptual frameworks in disasters and climate change in Colombia and Latin America. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2020, 29(6): 909-928

[36] Logan JR, Molotch HL. Urban fortunes: The political economy of place. 20th, 2007 Anniversary Berkeley, CA: University of California Press

[37] Marlow E, Chmutina K, Dainty A. Interpreting sustainability and resilience in the built environment. International Journal of Disaster Resilience in the Built Environment, 2022

[38] Marx, C., and F. Engels. 1848 (2015 edn.). The communist manifesto. London: Penguin Classics.

[39] Mayena SB. The concept of resilience revisited. Disasters, 2006, 30(4): 434-450

[40] Meerow S, Newell JP, Stults M. Defining urban resilience: A review. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2016, 147: 38-49

[41] Merriam-Webster. n.d. Dictionary by Merriam-Webster: America’s most-trusted online dictionary. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/city. Accessed 14 Feb 2022.

[42] Merrifield A. Metromarxism: A Marxist tale of the city, 2002, London: Routledge

[43] Mirowski P. Never let a serious crisis go to waste: How neoliberalism survived the financial meltdown, 2013, London: Verso

[44] Morrison, S. 2020. An address by the Prime Minister of Australia, 14 January 2020. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QuvPg-9ivoI. Accessed 5 Apr 2022.

[45] Obama, B. 2015. Remarks by the president on the ten year anniversary of Hurricane Katrina. The White House, 27 August 2015. https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/2015/08/28/remarks-president-ten-year-anniversary-hurricane-katrina. Accessed 14 Feb 2022.

[46] O’Keefe P, Westgate K, Wisner B. Taking the naturalness out of natural disasters. Nature, 1976, 260(5552): 566-567

[47] Oliver-Smith T. The Martyred city: Death and rebirth in the Andes, 1986, Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press

[48] Park RE, Burgess EW, McKenzie RD. The city, 1984, Chicago: University of Chicago Press

[49] Peck J. Construction of neoliberal reason, 2010, Oxford: Oxford University Press

[50] Purcell M. Excavating Lefebvre: The right to the city and its urban politics of the inhabitant. Geojournal, 2002, 58: 99-108

[51] Rivera D. Disaster colonialism: A commentary on disasters beyond singular events to structural violence. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 2020, 46(1): 126-135

[52] Robin E, Steenmans K, Acuto M. Harnessing inclusive urban knowledge for the implementation of the New Urban Agenda. Urban Research & Practice, 2019, 12(2): 137-155

[53] The Rockefeller Foundation. 2013. 100 resilient cities. https://www.arup.com/perspectives/publications/research/section/city-resilience-index. Accessed 6 Apr 2022.

[54] The Rockefeller Foundation. 2016. 100 resilient cities and The Rockefeller Foundation announce 37 new member cities, reaching 100 city milestone for its global network. New York: Rockefeller Found. https://www.rockefellerfoundation.org/news/100-resilient-cities-rockefeller-foundation-announce-37-new-member-cities-reaching-100-city-milestone-global-network/. Accessed 14 Feb 2022.

[55] Rodin J. The resilience dividend: Being strong in a world where things go wrong, 2014, New York: Public Affairs

[56] Rogers, P. 2015. Researching resilience: An agenda for change. Resilience: International Policies, Practices and Discourses 3(1): 55–71.

[57] Roy A. What is urban about critical urban theory?. Urban Geography, 2015, 37(6): 810-823

[58] Sanchez AX, van der Heijden J, Osmond P. The city politics of an urban age: Urban resilience conceptualisations and policies. Palgrave Communication, 2018, 4(25): 1-12.

[59] Sassen SJ. Cities in a world economy, 2011, London: SAGE Publications

[60] Satterthwaite D. The political underpinnings of cities’ accumulated resilience to climate change. Environment and Urbanisation, 2013, 25(2): 381-391

[61] Schumpeter J. Capitalism, socialism, and democracy, 1942, New York: Harper

[62] Schwartz, J., and M. Schleifstein. 2018. Fortified but still in peril, New Orleans braces for its future. The New York Times, 24 February 2018. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/02/24/us/new-orleans-flood-walls-hurricanes.html, https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/02/24/us/new-orleans-flood-walls-hurricanes.html. Accessed 14 Feb 2022.

[63] Sheller M. Mobility justice: The politics of movement in an age of extremes, 2018, London: Verso

[64] Simone A. People as infrastructure; Intersecting fragments in Johannesburg. Public Culture, 2004, 16(3): 404-429

[65] Sou G. Reframing resilience as resistance: Situating disaster recovery within colonialism. The Geographical Journal, 2021, 188(1): 14-27

[66] UNDRR (United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction). 2010. Making cities resilient campaign. https://www.undrr.org/publication/making-cities-resilient-my-city-getting-ready-campaign-kit. Accessed 5 Apr 2022.

[67] UN-Habitat: United Nations Human Settlements Programme. 2018. City resilience profiling programme. https://unhabitat.org/guide-to-the-city-resilience-profiling-tool. Accessed 5 Apr 2022.

[68] US Census Bureau. 2019. U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts: New York City, New York.. https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/newyorkcitynewyork. Accessed 14 Feb 2022.

[69] Vogelpohl A. Enright R, Rossi U. The politics of consultation in urban development and its encounters with local administration. The urban political, 2018, London: Palgrave Macmillan 171-187

[70] Wachsmuth D. Brenner NJ. City as ideology. Implosions/Explosions: Towards a study of planetary urbanization, 2014, Germany: Jovis 353-371.

[71] Wakefield, S., D. Chandler, and K. Grove. 2021. The asymmetrical anthropocene: Resilience and the limits of posthumanism. Cultural Geographies. July 2021. https://doi.org/10.1177/14744740211029278.

[72] Wang, Y., D. Hulse, J. von Meding, M. Brown, and L. Dedenbach. 2020. Conceiving resilience: Lexical shifts and proximal meanings in the human-centered natural and built environment literature from 1990 to 2018. Developments in the Built Environment 1: Article 100003

[73] Wikipedia. 2022. City. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City. Accessed 19 Mar 2022.

[74] Williams, N.E. 2020. Katrina battered Black New Orleans. Then the recovery did it again. Washington Post, 28 August 2020. https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/katrina-battered-black-new-orleans-then-the-recovery-did-it-again/2020/08/27/193d2420-e7eb-11ea-bc79-834454439a44_story.html. Accessed 14 Feb 2022.

[75] World Bank and Global Facility for Disaster Reduction and Recovery. 2006. Resilient cities program. https://www.gfdrr.org/en/resilient-cities. Accessed 5 Apr 2022.

[76] Zebrowski C. Acting local, thinking global: Globalizing resilience through 100 resilient cities. New Perspectives, 2020, 28(1): 71-78