Resilience in Agriculture: Communication and Energy Infrastructure Dependencies of German Farmers

Abstract

Agriculture is subject to high demands regarding resilience as it is an essential component of the food production chain. In the agricultural sector, there is an increasing usage of digital tools that rely on communication and energy infrastructures. Should disruption occur, such strengthened dependencies on other infrastructures increase the probability of ripple effects. Thus, there is a need to analyze the resilience of the agricultural sector with a specific focus on the effects of digitalization. This study works out resilience capacities of the interconnected technologies used in farm systems based on the experiences and opinions of farmers. Information was gathered through focus group interviews with farmers (N = 52) and a survey with participants from the agricultural sector (N = 118). In particular, the focus is put on the digital tools and other information and communication technologies they use. Based on a definition of resilience capacities, we evaluate resilience regarding energy and communication demands in various types of farm systems. Especially important are the resilience aspects of modern systems’ digital communication as well as the poorly developed and nonresilient network infrastructure in rural areas that contrast with the claim for a resilient agriculture. The result is a low robustness capacity, as our analysis concludes with the risk of food production losses.

Keywords

Digitalization of agriculture / Germany / Infrastructure failures / Resilience capacities

References

[1] Aceto G, Botta A, Marchetta P, Persico V, Pescapé A. A comprehensive survey on internet outages. Journal of Network and Computer Applications, 2018, 113: 36-63

[2] Adeel A, Gogate M, Farooq S, Ieracitano C, Dashtipour K, Larijani H, Hussain A. Durrani TS, Wang W, Forbes SM. A survey on the role of wireless sensor networks and IoT in disaster management. Geological disaster monitoring based on sensor networks, 2019, Heidelberg: Springer 57-66

[3] Backman S. Conceptualizing cyber crises. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2021, 29(4): 429-438

[4] Ballani H, Francis P, Zhang X. A study of prefix hijacking and interception in the internet. ACM SIGCOMM Computer Communication Review, 2007, 37(4): 265-276

[5] BMEL (Bundesministerium für Ernährung und Landwirtschaft / Federal Ministry of Food and Agriculture). 2018. Data and facts: Agriculture, forestry, and food industry with fisheries, viticulture, and horticulture (Daten und Fakten: Land-, Forst- und Ernährungswirtschaft mit Fischerei und Wein- und Gartenbau). https://www.bmel.de/SharedDocs/ Downloads/DE/Broschueren/Daten-und-Fakten-Landwirtschaft.html. Accessed 23 Apr 2021 (in German).

[6] Braun A-T, Colangelo E, Steckel T. Farming in the era of Industrie 4.0. Procedia CIRP, 2018, 72: 979-984

[7] Cavallo E, Ferrari E, Bollani L, Coccia M. Attitudes and behaviour of adopters of technological innovations in agricultural tractors: A case study in Italian agricultural system. Agricultural Systems, 2014, 130: 44-54

[8] CCDCOE (The NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence). 2019. Strategic importance of, and dependence on, undersea cables. https://ccdcoe.org/library/publications/strategic-importance-of-and-dependence-on-undersea-cables/. Accessed 1 Nov 2021.

[9] Dainotti, A., C. Squarcella, E. Aben, K.C. Claffy, M. Chiesa, M. Russo, and A. Pescapé. 2011. Analysis of country-wide Internet outages caused by censorship. In Proceedings of the 2011 ACM SIGCOMM on Internet Measurement Conference, 2–4 November 2011, Berlin, Germany. https://doi.org/10.1145/2068816.2068818.

[10] Darnhofer, I. 2021. Resilience or how do we enable agricultural systems to ride the waves of unexpected change? Agricultural Systems 187: Article 102997.

[11] Eurostat. 2016. Agriculture: Labour force by sex, legal status of holding and working time. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-datasets/-/ef_lf_leg. Accessed 1 Nov 2021.

[12] Eurostat. 2018. Of the 10.3 million farms in the EU, two thirds are less than 5 ha in size. Eurostat Newsrelease, 28 June 2018. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/documents/2995521/9028470/5-28062018-AP-EN.pdf. Accessed 6 Mar 2022.

[13] Fecke, W., M. Michels, C.-F. von Hobe, and O. Musshoff. 2018. How do farmers communicate in times of digitization? (Wie kommunizieren Landwirte in Zeiten der Digitalisierung?) Berichte über Landwirtschaft. Zeitschrift für Agrarpolitik und Landwirtschaft 96(2): 1–29 (in German).

[14] Francis R, Bekera B. A metric and frameworks for resilience analysis of engineered and infrastructure systems. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, 2014, 121: 90-103

[15] Friha O, Ferrag MA, Shu L, Maglaras LA, Wang X. Internet of things for the future of smart agriculture: A comprehensive survey of emerging technologies. IEEE CAA Journal of Automatica Sinica, 2021, 8(4): 718-752

[16] Gerhold, L., S. Wahl, and W.R. Dombrowsky. 2019. Risk perception and emergency food preparedness in Germany. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 37: Article 101183.

[17] Gu, Y., and T. Jing. 2011. The IOT research in supply chain management of fresh agricultural products. In 2011 2nd International Conference on Artificial Intelligence, Management Science and Electronic Commerce, 8–10 August 2011, Deng Feng, China, 7382–7385.

[18] Gurschler, T., J. Großmann, D. Kotarski, C. Teichmann, C. Thim, J. Eichler, J. Göllner, N. Gronau. 2017. Risk assessment of IT security of critical infrastructure – An Analysis of risk assessment within the ITS|KRITIS funding focus (Risikobeurteilung in der IT-Sicherheit Kritischer Infrastrukturen – Eine Analyse der Risikobeurteilung im Förderschwerpunkt ITS|KRITIS). In Proceedings of the 15th German IT Security Congress (Tagungsband zum 15. Deutscher IT-Sicherheitskongress), May 2017, Bonn, Germany, 395–410 (in German).

[19] Harris M. Tech giants race to build orbital internet. IEEE Spectrum, 2018, 55(6): 10-11

[20] Holling CS. Resilience and stability of ecological systems. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 1973, 4(1): 1-23

[21] Jawad, H.M., R. Nordin, S.K. Gharghan, A.M. Jawad, and M. Ismail. 2017. Energy-efficient wireless sensor networks for precision agriculture: A review. Sensors 17(8): Article 1781.

[22] Kitzinger J. Qualitative research: Introducing focus groups. BMJ, 1995, 311(7000): 299-302

[23] Koerhuis, R. 2020. John Deere: ‘We believe in electric tractors. 100%’. https://www.futurefarming.com/Machinery/Articles/2020/3/John-Deere-We-believe-in-electric-tractors-100-552869E. Accessed 8 Jun 2021.

[24] Kontio, J., L. Lehtola, and J. Bragge. 2004. Using the focus group method in software engineering: Obtaining practitioner and user experiences. In Proceedings of 2004 International Symposium on Empirical Software Engineering, 20–20 August 2004, Redondo Beach, CA, USA, 271–280.

[25] Kuntke F, Romanenko V, Linsner S, Steinbrink E, Reuter C. LoRaWAN security issues and mitigation options by the example of agricultural IoT scenarios. Transactions on Emerging Telecommunications Technologies, 2022

[26] Linsner S, Kuntke F, Steinbrink E, Franken J, Reuter C. The role of privacy in digitalization – Analyzing the German farmers’ perspective. Proceedings on Privacy Enhancing Technologies, 2021, 3: 333-349.

[27] Mahdavian, F., S. Platt, M. Wiens, M. Klein, and F. Schultmann. 2020. Communication blackouts in power outages: Findings from scenario exercises in Germany and France. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 46: Article 101628.

[28] Marra M, Pannell DJ, Abadi Ghadim A. The economics of risk, uncertainty and learning in the adoption of new agricultural technologies: Where are we on the learning curve?. Agricultural Systems, 2003, 75(2/3): 215-234

[29] Meuwissen, M.P., P.H. Feindt, A. Spiegel, C.J. Termeer, E. Mathijs, Y. de Mey, R. Finger, A. Balmann, et al. 2019. A framework to assess the resilience of farming systems. Agricultural Systems 176: Article 102656.

[30] Monteil C, Barclay J, Hicks A. Remembering, forgetting, and absencing disasters in the post-disaster recovery process. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2020, 11(3): 287-299

[31] Morgan D. Focus groups as qualitative research, 1997 2 Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications

[32] Moteff, J., C. Copeland, and J. Fischer. 2003. Critical infrastructures: What makes an infrastructure critical? Technical report. Washington, DC: Library of Congress, Congressional Research Service. https://apps.dtic.mil/dtic/ tr/fulltext/u2/a467306.pdf. Accessed xx xxx xxxx.

[33] Ojha T, Misra S, Raghuwanshi NS. Wireless sensor networks for agriculture: The state-of-the-art in practice and future challenges. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 2015, 118: 66-84

[34] Onwuegbuzie AJ, Dickinson WB, Leech NL, Zoran AG. A qualitative framework for collecting and analyzing data in focus group research. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 2009, 8(3): 1-21

[35] O’Rourke TD. Critical infrastructure, interdependencies, and resilience. The Bridge: Linking Engineering and Society, 2007, 37(1): 22-29.

[36] Panteli M, Mancarella P. The grid: Stronger, bigger, smarter? Presenting a conceptual framework of power system resilience. IEEE Power and Energy Magazine, 2015, 13(3): 58-66

[37] Perrin, A., and G. Martin. 2021. Resilience of French organic dairy cattle farms and supply chains to the Covid-19 pandemic. Agricultural Systems 190: Article 103082.

[38] Pfohl, T.N. 2014. Disaster management in Germany: A governance analysis (Katastrophenmanagement in Deutschland: Eine Governance-Analyse). Political science dissertation of Ruprecht Karl University of Heidelberg. Münster: LIT Verlag (in German).

[39] Rademacher Y. Community disaster management assets: A case study of the farm community in Sussex County, Delaware. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2013, 4(1): 33-47

[40] Reuter, C., W. Schneider, and D. Eberz. 2019. Resilient Smart Farming (RSF) – Use of digital technologies in crisis-proof infrastructure (Resilient Smart Farming (RSF) – Nutzung digitaler Technologien in krisensicherer Infrastruktur). In 39. GIL-Jahrestagung in Wien, 18.-9. Februar 2019: Informatik in der Land-, Forst- und Ernährungswirtschaft Fokus: Digitalisierung für landwirtschaftliche Betriebe in kleinstrukturierten Regionen—ein Widerspruch in sich?, ed. A. Meyer-Aurich, M. Gandorfer, N. Barta, et al., 177–182. Esslingen: Gesellschaft für Informatik in der Land-, Forst und Ernährungswirtschaft (in German).

[41] Rizzato, F. 2019. Parts of rural Germany see less than 50% 4G availability. https://www.opensignal.com/2019/07/17/parts-of-rural-germany-see-less-than-50-4g-availability. Accessed 21 Apr 2021.

[42] Schröder, L., and C. Klaue. 2005. Snowed in: Snow chaos in the Münsterland (Eingeschneit: Schneechaos im Münsterland) [Documentary film]. https://www1.wdr.de/fernsehen/heimatflimmern/sendungen/schneechaos-im-muensterland-100.html. Accessed 21 Apr 2021 (in German).

[43] Shang, L., T. Heckelei, M.K. Gerullis, J. Börner, and S. Rasch. 2021. Adoption and diffusion of digital farming technologies – Integrating farm-level evidence and system interaction. Agricultural Systems 190: Article 103074.

[44] Snow, V., D. Rodriguez, R. Dynes, W. Kaye-Blake, T. Mallawaarachchi, S. Zydenbos, L. Cong, I. Obadovic, et al. 2021. Resilience achieved via multiple compensating subsystems: The immediate impacts of COVID-19 control measures on the agri-food systems of Australia and New Zealand. Agricultural Systems 187: Article 103025.

[45] Spykman, O., A. Gabriel, M. Ptacek, and M. Gandorfer. 2021. Farmers’ perspectives on field crop robots – Evidence from Bavaria, Germany. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture 186: Article 106176.

[46] SubCableWorld. 2015. Timeline for CNMI outage. https://www.subcableworld.com/scw-newsfeed/marine-services/timeline-for-cnmi-outage. Accessed 1 Nov 2021.

[47] Sundmaeker H, Verdouw C, Wolfert S, Pérez Freire L. Internet of food and farm 2020. Digitising the Industry, 2016, 49(9): 129-151.

[48] Tendall DM, Joerin J, Kopainsky B, Edwards P, Shreck A, Le QB, Kruetli P, Grant M, Six J. Food system resilience: Defining the concept. Global Food Security, 2015, 6: 17-23

[49] von Hobe, C.-F., M. Michels, W. Fecke, O. Mußhoff, and P.J. Weller von Ahlefeld. 2019. How do farmers communicate in times of digitization? (Wie kommunizieren Landwirte in Zeiten der Digitalisierung?) In 39. GIL-Jahrestagung in Wien, 18 . -9. Februar 2019: Informatik in der Land-, Forst- und Ernährungswirtschaft Fokus: Digitalisierung für landwirtschaftliche Betriebe in kleinstrukturierten Regionen—ein Widerspruch in sich?, ed. A. Meyer-Aurich, M. Gandorfer, N. Barta, et al., 269–274. Esslingen: Gesellschaft für Informatik in der Land-, Forst und Ernährungswirtschaft (in German).

[50] Weltzien C. Digital agriculture – Or why agriculture 4.0 still offers only modest returns. Landtechnik, 2016, 71(2): 66-68.

[51] Wolfert S, Ge L, Verdouw C, Bogaardt M-J. Big data in smart farming – A review. Agricultural Systems, 2017, 153: 69-80

[52] Yalcin, H. 2017. Plant phenology recognition using deep learning: Deep-Pheno. In Proceedings of 2017 6th International Conference on Agro-Geoinformatics, 7–10 August 2017, Fairfax, VA, USA.