Dealing with Multisource Information for Estuarine Flood Risk Appraisal in Two Western European Coastal Areas

Abstract

Estuaries are usually affected by compound flooding triggers that cause diverse territorial damages. While fluvial flood risk assessment frameworks are well established in the literature, integrated management instruments that deal with estuarine flood risk remain incomplete and often lacking. This research presents a methodology to extract relevant information from multiple sources post-event and a database building process that is applied to two contrasting estuaries (the Tagus River estuary in Portugal, and the Shannon River estuary in Ireland) in the Western European coastal area. Overall, a total of 274 documents were analyzed and the information was stored in two databases. Multiple correspondence analysis was applied to extract the most informative and relevant estuarine flood indicators. An integrated estuarine flood risk assessment framework is presented and discussed based on the extracted indicators. The framework is driven by two distinct dimensions (oceanic and hydrographic) and revealed the transversal position of triggers of estuarine floods, reflecting the compounding effects usually present in these areas. The results also highlight two levels of flood risk mostly based on damage typology.

Keywords

Estuarine floods / Estuarine flood indicators / Multiple correspondence analysis / Post-hazard multisource information / Western Europe

References

[1] Andrade, C., H.O. Pires, P. Silva, R. Taborda, and M.C. Freitas. 2006. Coastal zones (Zonas Costeiras). In Climate change in Portugal: Scenarios, impacts and adaptation measures (Alterações climáticas em Portugal. Cenários, impactes e medidas de adaptação), ed. F.D. Santos, and P. Miranda, 169–208. Lisboa: Gradiva (in Portuguese).

[2] Azevedo A, Fortunato AB, Epifânio B, den Boer S, Oliveira ER, Alves FL, Jesus G, Gomes JL An oil risk management system based on high-resolution hazard and vulnerability calculations. Ocean & Coastal Management, 2017, 136: 1-18

[3] Baart F, Bakker MAJ, van Dongeren A, den Heijer C, van Hateren S, Smit MWJ, van Koningsveld M, Pool A. Using 18th century storm-surge data from the Dutch coast to improve the confidence in flood risk estimates. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2011, 11(10): 2791-2801

[4] Benito G, Thorndycraft VR, Rico M, Sánchez-Moya Y, Sopeña A. Palaeoflood and floodplain records from Spain: Evidence for long-term climate variability and environmental changes. Geomorphology, 2008, 101(1–2): 68-77

[5] Benzécri, J.P. 1976. History and prehistory of data analysis. Systematic index (Histoire et préhistoire de l'analyse des données. Indice systématique). Cahiers de l'analyse des données 2(1): 41–53 (in French).

[6] Birkman J. Risk and vulnerability indicators at different scales: Applicability, usefulness and policy implications. Environmental Hazards, 2007, 7(1): 20-31

[7] Bowen GA. Document analysis as a qualitative research method. Qualitative Research Journal, 2009, 9(2): 27-40

[8] Bravo G, Potvin L. Estimating the reliability of continuous measures with Cronbach’s alfa or the intraclass correlation coefficient: Toward the integration of two traditions. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1991, 44(4/5): 381-390

[9] Brunette, M., R. Bourke, M. Hanewinkel, and R. Yousepour. 2018. Adaptation to climate change in forestry: A multiple correspondence analysis (MCA). Forests 9(1): Article 20.

[10] Bühlmann F, David T, Mach A. Political and economic elites in Switzerland. European Societies, 2012, 14(5): 727-754

[11] CADC (Comissão para a Aplicação e o Desenvolvimento da Convenção de Albufeira / Commission for the Application and Development of the Albufeira Convention). 2022. Tagus river hydrographic basin (Bacia Hidrográfica do Tejo). http://www.cadc-albufeira.eu/pt/. Accessed 10 Jan 2022 (in Portuguese).

[12] Carvalho, H. 2017. Multivariate analysis of qualitative data. Using multiple correspondence analysis with SPSS (Análise multivariada de dados qualitativos. Utilização da análise de correspondências múltiplas com o SPSS). Lisboa: Edições Sílabo (in Portuguese).

[13] CRED (Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters). 2022. EM-DAT (The International Disaster Database). https://www.emdat.be/. Accessed 10 Jan 2022.

[14] CSO (Central Statistics Office). 2017. Census 2016 summary results – Part 1. Ireland: Central Statistics Office.

[15] Davidson, N.C., d’A.D. Laffoley, J.P. Doody, L.S. Way, J. Gordon, R. Rey, M.W. Pienkowski, R. Mitchell, and K.L. Duff. 1991. Nature conservation and estuaries in Great Britain. Peterbourough: Nature Conservancy Council.

[16] Di Franco G. Multiple correspondence analysis: One only or several techniques?. Quality and Quantity, 2016, 50(3): 1299-1315

[17] Elliot M, McLusky DS. The need for definition in understanding estuaries. Estuarine Coastal and Shelf Science, 2002, 55(6): 815-827

[18] Fekete A. Social vulnerability (re-)assessment in context to natural hazards: Review of the usefulness of the spatial indicator approach and investigations of validation demands. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2019, 10(2): 220-232

[19] Ferreira, J.P. 2016. How commuting influences urban economies and the environment: A commuting satellite account applied to the Lisbon Metropolitan Area. PhD dissertation. University of Coimbra, Paco das Escolas, Coimbra.

[20] Fortunato A, Li K, Bertin X, Rodrigues M, Miguez BM. Determination of extreme sea levels along the Iberian Atlantic coast. Ocean Engineering, 2016, 111(1): 471-482

[21] Fortunato A, Freire P, Bertin X, Rodrigues M, Ferreira J, Liberato A. A numerical study of the February 15, 1941 storm in the Tagus estuary. Continental and Shelf Research, 2017, 144(15): 50-64

[22] Freire P, Andrade C. Wind-induced sand transport in Tagus estuarine beaches. First results. Aquatic Ecology, 1999, 33(3): 225-233

[23] Freire P, Tavares AO, Sá L, Oliveira A, Fortunato AB, dos Santos PP, Rilo A, Gomes JL A local-scale approach to estuarine flood risk management. Natural Hazards, 2016, 84(3): 1705-1739

[24] Garnier E, Ciavola P, Spencer T, Ferreira O, Armanoli C, McIvor A. Historical analysis of storm events: Case studies in France, England, Portugal and Italy. Coastal Engineering, 2018, 134: 10-23

[25] Gifi A. Nonlinear multivariate analysis, 1996, England: John Wiley & Sons

[26] Guerreiro M, Fortunato AB, Freire P, Rilo A, Taborda R, Freitas MC, Andrade C, Silva T Evolution of the hydrodynamics of the Tagus estuary (Portugal) in the 21^st century. Revista de Gestão Costeira Integrada / Journal of Integrated Coastal Zone Management, 2015, 15(1): 65-80

[27] Guzetti F, Cardinali P, Reichenbach P. The AVI project: A bibliographical and archive inventory of landslides and floods in Italy. Environmental Management, 1994, 18(4): 623-633

[28] Haigh, I., O. Ozsoy, M.P. Wadey, R.J. Nicholls, S.L. Gallop, T. Wahl, and J.M. Brown. 2017. An improved database of coastal flooding in the United Kingdom from 1915 to 2016. Scientific Data 4: Article 170100.

[29] Healy M. The Shannon estuary wetlands complex, Western Ireland: Conservation and conflicts. In Littoral 2002: 6th International Symposium Proceedings: A Multi-disciplinary Symposium on Coastal Zone Research, Management and Planning, 22–26 September 2002. Porto, Portugal, 2002, 2: 229-233.

[30] Healy, M.G., and K.R. Hickey. 2002. Historic land reclamation in the intertidal wetlands of the Shannon estuary, western Ireland. Journal of Coastal Research SI36: 365–373.

[31] Hendry A, Haigh ID, Nicholls RJ, Winter H, Neal R, Wahl T, Joly-Laugel A, Darby SE. Assessing the characteristics and drivers of compound flooding events around the UK coast. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 2019, 23(7): 3117-3139

[32] Hickey K, Healy M. The reclamation of the Shannon estuary inter-tidal flats: A case study of the Clare Slobland Reclamation Company. Irish Geography, 2005, 38(1): 84-95

[33] INE (National Statistics Institute). 2019. Área Metropolitana de Lisboa in figures – 2017. Lisboa: INE (in Portuguese and English).

[34] Jacobs. 2012a. Unit of management 24: Shannon Estuary South. Flood history and key environmental issues. Strategic environmental assessment – Scoping report [consultation draft] – Annex II. Ireland: Office of Public Works. http://shannoncframstudy.jacobs.com/docs/sea/TD_ENVT_0316_V1_C_JAC_Env_Scoping_AnnexII_UoM24_120919.pdf. Accessed 10 Jan 2022.

[35] Jacobs. 2012b. Unit of management 25–26: Shannon Estuary Upper & Lower. Flood history and key environmental issues. Strategic environmental assessment—Scoping report [consultation draft]—Annex III. Ireland: Office of Public Works. http://shannoncframstudy.jacobs.com/docs/sea/TD_ENVT_0317_V1_C_JAC_Env_Scoping_AnnexIII_UoM25-26_120919.pdf. Accessed 10 Jan 2022.

[36] Jacobs. 2012c. Unit of management 27–28: Shannon Estuary North and Mal Bay. Flood history and key environmental issues. Strategic environmental assessment—Scoping report [consultation draft]—Annex IV. Ireland: Office of Public Works. http://shannoncframstudy.jacobs.com/docs/sea/TD_ENVT_0318_V1_C_JAC_EnvScopingAnnexIV_UoM27-28_120919.pdf. Accessed 10 Jan 2022.

[37] Kaplan R, Saccuzzo D. Psychological testing: Principles, applications and issues, 1982, Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole Publishing Company

[38] Krippendorff K. Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology, 2004, Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications

[39] Krippendorff K, Bock M. The content analysis reader, 2009, Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications

[40] Lamb H. Historic storms of the North Sea, British Isles and Northwest Europe, 1991, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

[41] MacClenahan P, McKenna J, Cooper A, O’Kane B. Identification of highest magnitude coastal storm events over western Ireland on the basis of wind speed and duration thresholds. International Journal of Climatology, 2001, 21(7): 829-842

[42] Marôco, J. 2014. Statistical analysis with SPSS (Análise estatística com o SPSS statistics). Pêro Pinheiro, Portugal: ReportNumber (in Portuguese).

[43] Marôco J, Garcia-Marques T. How reliable is Cronbach's Alpha? Old issues and modern solutions? (Qual a fiabilidade do Alpha de Cronbach? Questões antigas e soluções modernas?). Laboratório de Psicologia, 2006, 4(1): 65-90 (in Portuguese)

[44] Mei X, Dai Z, Tang Z, Van Gelder PHAJM. Impacts of historical records on extreme flood variations over the conterminous United States. Journal of Flood Risk Management, 2018, 11(S1): S359-S369

[45] Merz B, Hall J, Disse M, Schumann A. Fluvial flood risk management in a changing world. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2010, 10(3): 509-527

[46] Meulman J. The integration of multidimensional scaling and multivariate analysis with optimal scaling transformations. Psychometrika, 1992, 57(4): 539-565

[47] Meyer V, Becker N, Markantonis V, Schwarze R, van den Bergh JCJM, Bouwer LM, Bubeck P, Ciavola P Review article: Assessing the costs of natural hazards – State of the art and knowledge gaps. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2013, 13(5): 1351-1373

[48] Nguyen TTX, Bonetti J, Rogers K, Woodroffe CD. Indicator-based assessment of climate change impacts on coasts: A review of concepts, methodological approaches and vulnerability indices. Ocean & Coastal Management, 2016, 123: 18-43

[49] Niza C, Silva S, amd M.L. Lima. Occupational accident experience: Association with workers’ accident explanation and definition. Safety Science, 2008, 46: 959-971

[50] Nogueira Mendes, R., R. Ceia, J. Catalão, R. Melo, R. Taborda, and P. Freire. 2013. Cartography and cartographic monitoring of the Tagus intertidal estuary through remote sensing and Landsat 7 ETM images (Cartografia e Monitorização Cartográfica do Intertidal do Estuário do Tejo através de Deteção Remota e imagens de Landsat 7 ETM). In Proceedings of the 2nd Conference on Estuarine and Coastal Morphodynamics (2ª Conferência sobre Morfodinâmica Estuarina e Costeira (MEC)), 9–10 May 2013, Aveiro, Portugal (in Portuguese).

[51] Nunnaly JC. Psychometric theory, 1978, New York: MacGraw-Hill

[52] O’Brien L, Dudley JM, Dias F. Extreme wave events in Ireland: 14680 BP–2012. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2013, 13(3): 625-648

[53] O’Brien L, Renzi E, Dudley JM, Clancy C, Dias F. Catalogue of extreme wave events in Ireland: Revised and updated for 14680 BP–2017. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2018, 18(3): 729-758

[54] OPW (Office of Public Works). 2013. Irish coastal protection study – Phase 4 – Southwest coast. Work packages 2, 3 & 4A – Technical report. https://www.gov.ie/en/collection/572115-irish-coastal-protection-strategy-study-phase-4-south-west-coast/. Accessed 10 Jan 2022.

[55] OPW (Office of Public Works). 2020. Flood info website. OPW national flood information portal. Ireland: Office of Public Works. https://www.floodinfo.ie/. Accessed 10 Jan 2022.

[56] O’Sullivan, A. 2001. Foragers, farmers and fishers in a coastal landscape: An intercultural archaeological survey of the Shannon estuary. Dublin: Royal Irish Academy.

[57] Özyurt G, Ergin A. Improving coastal vulnerability assessments to sea-level rise: A new indicator-based methodology for decision makers. Journal of Coastal Research, 2010, 26(2): 265-273

[58] Pinto, P.J., and M.G. Kondolf. 2016. Evolution of two urbanized estuaries: Environmental change, legal framework, and implications for sea level rise vulnerability. Water 8(11): Article 535.

[59] Pritchard DW. Lauff G. What is an estuary: A physical viewpoint. Estuaries, 1967, Washington, DC: American Association of the Advancement of Science 3-5.

[60] Pye, K., and S.J. Blott. 2014. The geomorphology of UK estuaries: The role of geological controls, antecedent conditions and human activities. Estuarine Coastal and Shelf Science 150(B): 196–214.

[61] Rilo A, Freire P, Nogueira Mendes R, Ceia R, Catalão J, Taborda R, Melo R, Caçador MC Methodological framework for the definition and demarcation of the highest astronomical tide line in estuaries: The case of Tagus Estuary (Portugal) (Metodologia para o traçado da Linha de Máxima Preia-Mar de Águas Vivas Equi-nociais em ambientes de transição: aplicação ao estuário do Tejo (Portugal)). Revista de Gestão Costeira Integrada / Journal of Integrated Coastal Zone Management, 2014, 14(1): 95-107 in Portuguese)

[62] Rilo AR, Tavares A, Freire P, Zêzere JL. The contribution of historical information to flood risk management in the Tagus estuary. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2017, 25: 22-35

[63] Ruocco, A., R.J. Nicholls, I.D. Haigh, and M. Wadey. 2011. Reconstructing coastal flood occurrence combining sea level and media sources: A case study of the Solent, UK since 1935. Natural Hazards 59(3): Article 1773.

[64] Santos PP, Tavares AO, Zêzere JL. Risk analysis for local management from hydro-geomorphologic disaster databases. Environmental Science & Policy, 2014, 40: 85-100

[65] Sheehan, T.L., and M.G. Healy. 2006. Sub-recent changes in annual average water level in the Shannon estuary, Western Ireland. Journal of Coastal Research SI39, Vol. 1:193–197.

[66] SIFP (Strategic Integrated Framework Plan for the Shannon Estuary). 2013. An inter-jurisdictional land and marine based framework to guide the future development and management of the Shannon Estuary. Volume 1: Written statement. https://shannonestuarysifp.wordpress.com/sifp-documents/. Accessed 10 Jan 2022.

[67] SPSS (Statistical Package for the Social Sciences). 2020. Confidence interval for Cronbach’s alpha in SPSS. Document number 419613. Last modified 16 April 2020. https://www.ibm.com/support/pages/confidence-interval-cronbachs-alpha-spss. Accessed 10 Jan 2022.

[68] Sweeney J. Regional weather and climates of the British Isles – Part 6: Ireland. Weather, 2014, 69(1): 20-27

[69] Trigo RM, DaCamara CC. Circulation weather types and their impact on the precipitation regime in Portugal. International Journal of Climatology, 2000, 20(13): 1559-1581

[70] Trigo RM, Osborn TJ, Corte-Real J. The North Atlantic Oscillation influence on Europe: Climate impacts and associated physical mechanisms. Climate Research, 2002, 20(1): 9-17

[71] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction) Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030, 2015, Geneva: UNISDR

[72] Vargas CIC, Oliveira FSBF, Oliveira A, Charneca N. Vulnerability analysis of an estuarine beach to inundation: Application to Alfeite Spit (Tagus Estuary) (Análise da vulnerabilidade de uma praia estuarina à inundação: aplicação à restinga do Alfeite (estuário do Tejo)). Revista de Gestão Costeira Integrada / Journal of Integrated Coastal Zone Management, 2008, 8(1): 25-43 in Portuguese)

[73] Vaz, N., M. Mateus, L. Pinto, R. Neves, and J.M. Dias. 2020. The Tagus Estuary as a numerical modeling test bed: A review. Geosciences 10(1): Article 4.

[74] Vis G, Kasse C, Vandenberghe J. Late Pleistocene and Holocene palaeogeography of the Lower Tagus Valley (Portugal): Effects of relative sea level, valley morphology and sediment supply. Quaternary Science Reviews, 2008, 27(17–18): 1682-1709

[75] Wei J, Wei Y, Western A, Skinner D, Lyle C. Evolution of newspaper coverage of water issues in Australia during 1843–201. AMBIO, 2015, 44(4): 319-331

[76] Wheeler, A., and M. Healy. 2001. Coastal landscapes and environmental change in the Shannon estuary. In Foragers, farmers and fishers in a coastal landscape: An intertidal archaeological survey of the Shannon estuary, ed. O’Sullivan, 40–54. Dublin: Royal Irish Academy.

[77] Williams A, Archer D. The use of historical flood information in the English Midlands to improve risk assessment. Hydrological Sciences Journal, 2002, 47(1): 57-76

[78] Wolters M, Kuenzer C. Vulnerability assessments of coastal river deltas – Categorization and review. Journal of Coastal Conservation, 2015, 19(3): 345-368

[79] Wu W, Westra S, Leonard M. Estimating the probability of compound floods in estuarine regions. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 2021, 25: 2821-2841

[80] Zêzere JL, Pereira S, Tavares AO, Bateira C, Trigo RM, Quaresma I, Santos PP, Santos M, Verde J. DISASTER: A GIS database on hydro-geomorphologic disasters in Portugal. Natural Hazards, 2014, 72(2): 503-532