Challenges Associated with Creeping Disasters in Disaster Risk Science and Practice: Considering Disaster Onset Dynamics

Abstract

In this article, we set out to reconcile a general conceptualization of disaster temporalities by drawing on the epitome example of a creeping disaster, namely famine. Our argument is driven by the recognition that slowly manifesting disaster impacts pose distinct challenges for decision makers and researchers while there is a tendency for the disaster literature to overlook the role of disaster onset dynamics. More specifically and as a starting point, we identify four key themes that merit particular attention when dealing with creeping disasters: (1) our understanding of disaster as a phenomenon; (2) measurement and operationalization; (3) early warning and response; and (4) disaster management and termination. By integrating conceptual discussions of disaster with famine scholarship—a phenomenon often excluded from mainstream disaster research—this article provides fresh perspectives on disaster science as well as a number of implications for how we think about disaster risk reduction.

Keywords

Disaster response / Early warning / Famine disasters / Slow-onset disasters

References

[1] Ahrens W. Zschau J, Küppers A. Cultural and political obstacles to accepting early warnings of the Aral Sea disaster. Early warning systems for natural disaster reduction, 2003, Berlin: Springer 305-310

[2] Alcántara-Ayala I, Oliver-Smith A. Sudmeier-Rieux K, Fernández M, Penna I, Jaboyedoff M, Gaillard J. The necessity of Early Warning Articulated Systems (EWASs): Critical issues beyond response. Identifying emerging issues in disaster risk reduction, migration, climate change and sustainable development, 2015, Cham: Springer 101-124.

[3] Birkland TA. Focusing events, mobilization, and agenda setting. Journal of Public Policy, 1998, 18(1): 53-74

[4] Boin A, Ekengren M, Rhinard M. Hiding in plain sight: Conceptualizing the creeping crisis. Risk, Hazards & Crisis in Public Policy, 2020, 11(2): 116-138

[5] Boin A, P. ‘t Hart, E. Stern, and B. Sundelius. The politics of crisis management: Public leadership under pressure, 2017 2 Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

[6] Bosher L, Chmutina K, van Niekerk D. Stop going around in circles: Towards a reconceptualisation of disaster risk management phases. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2021, 30(4/5): 525-537

[7] Burton I, Kates RW, White GF. The environment as hazard, 1993 2 New York: Guilford Press

[8] Coetzee C, van Niekerk D. Tracking the evolution of the disaster management cycle: A general system theory approach. Jàmbá: Journal of Disaster Risk Studies, 2012, 4(1): 1-9

[9] Conley B, de Waal A. The purposes of starvation: Historical and contemporary uses. Journal of International Criminal Justice, 2019, 17(4): 699-722

[10] Costella C, Jaime C, Arrighi J, de Prez EC, Suarez P, van Aalst M. Scalable and sustainable: How to build anticipatory capacity into social protection systems. IDS Bulletin: Transforming Development Knowledge, 2017, 48(4): 31-46

[11] DeFalco R. Conceptualizing famine as a subject of international criminal justice: Towards a modality-based approach. University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law, 2017, 38(1): 1113-1187.

[12] DeLeo RA. Anticipatory policymaking: When government acts to prevent problems and why it is so difficult, 2016, London: Routledge

[13] De Waal A. Famine mortality: A case study of Darfur, Sudan 1984–85. Population Studies, 1989, 43(1): 5-24

[14] De Waal A. War and famine in Africa. IDS Bulletin: Transforming Development Knowledge, 1993, 24(4): 33-40

[15] De Waal A. Famine crimes, 1997, London: Villiers Publications

[16] De Waal A. Mass starvation: The history and future of famine, 2018, Cambridge: Polity Press

[17] Devereux S. The new famines: Why famines persist in an era of globalization, 2007, London: Routledge

[18] Dowlah C. The politics and economics of food and famine in Bangladesh in the early 1970s—with special reference to Amartya Sen’s interpretation of the 1974 famine. International Journal of Social Welfare, 2006, 15(4): 344-356

[19] Dynes RR. Expanding the horizons of disaster research. Natural Hazards Observer, 2004, 28(4): 1-2.

[20] Fergusson J. The world’s most dangerous place: Inside the outlaw state of Somalia, 2013, London: Black Swan Publishing

[21] Fritz, C.E. 1961. Disaster. In Contemporary social problems, ed. R.K. Merton, and R. Nisbet, 651–694. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.

[22] Glantz MH. The politics of natural disasters: The case of the Sahel drought, 1976, New York: Praeger

[23] Glantz MH. Creeping environmental problems. The World and I, 1994, 1994: 218-225.

[24] Gráda CÓ. Famine: A short history, 2009, Princeton: Princeton University Press

[25] Hannigan J. Disasters without borders: The international politics of natural disasters, 2013, Cambridge: Polity Press

[26] Healy A, Malhotra N. Myopic voters and natural disaster policy. American Political Science Review, 2009, 103(3): 387-406

[27] Heaton L. Somalia famine relief: A view from Mogadishu, 2012, Washington, DC: The Enough Project

[28] Hewitt K. Hewitt K. The idea of calamity in a technocratic age. Interpretations of calamity: From the viewpoint of human ecology, 1983, Boston: Allen & Unwin 3-32.

[29] Hewitt K. Crash J. Sustainable disasters? Perspectives and power in the discourse of calamity. Power of development, 1995, London: Routledge 115-128.

[30] Howe P. Famine systems: A new model for understanding the development of famines. World Development, 2018, 105(C): 144-155

[31] Howe P, Devereux S. Famine intensity and magnitude scales: A proposal for an instrumental definition of famine. Disasters, 2004, 28(4): 353-372

[32] Hsu, E.L. 2019. Must disasters be rapidly occurring? The case for an expanded temporal typology of disasters. Time & Society 28(3): Article 904921.

[33] IFRC (International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies). 2020. What is a disaster? https://www.ifrc.org/en/what-we-do/disaster-management/about-disasters/what-is-a-disaster/. Accessed 28 Jul 2021.

[34] IPC (Integrated Food Security Phase Classification). 2020. IPC resource 01: Famine classification. Rome: Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC).

[35] IPC (Integrated Food Security Phase Classification). 2021. Famine review of the IPC acute food insecurity analysis. Rome: Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC).

[36] Jaime, H. 2013. The “silent disaster” of local losses. UNISDR working paper prepared for the Global Assessment Report on Disaster Risk Reduction (GAR) 2013. Geneva: UNISDR.

[37] Keen, D. 1993. Famine, needs-assessment and survival strategies in Africa. Oxfam Research Papers 8. Oxford: Oxfam GB.

[38] Keen D. The benefits of famine, 1994, Princeton: Princeton University Press

[39] Kelman I. Pacific island regional preparedness for El Niño. Environment, Development and Sustainability, 2019, 21(1): 405-428

[40] Kelman I. Disaster by choice, 2020, Oxford: Oxford University Press

[41] Kelman I, Glantz MH. Singh S, Zommers Z. Early warning systems defined. Reducing disaster: Early warning systems for climate change, 2014, Dordrecht: Springer 89-108

[42] Kelman I, Field J, Suri K, Bhat GM. Disaster diplomacy in Jammu and Kashmir. International Journal for Disaster Risk Reduction, 2018, 31: 1132-1170

[43] Kruke BI, Olsen OE. Knowledge creation and reliable decision-making in complex emergencies. Disasters, 2012, 36(2): 212-232

[44] Lautze S, Bell W, Alinovi L, Russo L. Early warning, late response (again): The 2011 famine in Somalia. Global Food Security, 2012, 1(1): 43-49

[45] Lewis, J. 1988. On the line: An open letter in response to “Confronting natural disasters, an international decade for natural hazard reduction”. Natural Hazards Observer 7(4): Article 4.

[46] Marcus D. Famine crimes in international law. The American Journal of International Law, 2003, 97(2): 245-281

[47] Marulanda MC, Cardona OD, Barbat AH. Revealing the socioeconomic impact of small disasters in Colombia using the DesInventar Database. Disasters, 2010, 34(2): 552-570

[48] Matthewman S. Disasters, risk and revelation: Making sense of our times, 2015, Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan

[49] Maxwell D, Fitzpatrick M. The 2011 Somalia famine: Context, causes and complications. Global Food Security, 2012, 1(1): 5-12

[50] Maxwell, D., A. Khalif, P. Hailey, and F. Checchi. 2020. Determining famine: Multi-dimensional analysis for the twenty-first century. Food Policy 92: Article 101832.

[51] Meriläinen E, Koro M. Data, disasters, and space-time entanglements. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2021, 12(1): 157-168

[52] Neal DM. Reconsidering the phases of disasters. International Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters, 1997, 15(2): 239-264.

[53] OCHA (United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs). 2011. OCHA and slow-onset emergencies. OCHA Occasional Policy Briefing Series 6. New York: OCHA.

[54] OHCHR (Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights). 2021. Special rapporteur on the right to food. https://www.ohchr.org/en/issues/food/pages/foodindex.aspx. Accessed 28 Jul 2021.

[55] Osmani, S.R. 1993. The entitlement approach to famine: An assessment. WIDER Working Papers 107. Helsinki: United Nations University / World Institute for Development Economics Research (UNU/WIDER).

[56] Patnaik U. Food availability and famine—A longer view. Journal of Peasant Studies, 1991, 19(1): 1-25

[57] Perry RW, Quarantelli EL. What is a disaster? New answers to old questions, 2005, Philadelphia: Xlibris

[58] Quarantelli, E.L. 1991. Disaster research: An entry for an encyclopedia. Preliminary Papers 167. Newark, DE: University of Delaware Disaster Research Center.

[59] Quarantelli EL. Ten criteria for evaluating the management of community disasters. Disasters, 1997, 21(1): 39-56

[60] Quarantelli EL. What is a disaster? Perspectives on the question, 1998, London: Routledge

[61] Quarantelli, E.L. 2000. Emergencies, disasters and catastrophes are different phenomena. Preliminary Papers 304. Newark, DE: University of Delaware Disaster Research Center.

[62] Rosenthal U. Quarantelli EL. Future disasters, future definitions. What is a disaster? Perspectives on the question, 1998, London: Routledge 146-159.

[63] Rubin O. The entitlement approach: A case for framework development rather than demolition: A comment on “Entitlement failure and deprivation: A critique of Sen’s famine philosophy”. The Journal of Development Studies, 2009, 45(4): 621-640

[64] Rubin O. The merits of democracy in famine protection – Fact or fallacy?. The European Journal of Development Research, 2009, 21: 699-717

[65] Rubin O. The political dynamics of voter retrospection and disaster responses. Disasters, 2018, 44(2): 239-261

[66] Rubin O. The precarious state of famine research. The Journal of Development Studies, 2019, 55(8): 1633-1653

[67] Seaman J. Famine mortality in Africa. IDS Bulletin: Transforming Development Knowledge, 1993, 24(4): 27-32

[68] Sen A. Poverty and famines, 1981, Oxford: Oxford University Press

[69] Sen A. Development as freedom, 1999, New York: Knopf

[70] Shaluf IM. An overview on disasters. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2007, 16(5): 687-703

[71] Staupe-Delgado R. Progress, traditions and future directions in research on disasters involving slow-onset hazards. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2019, 28(5): 623-635

[72] Staupe-Delgado, R. 2019b. Overcoming barriers to proactive response in slow-onset disasters. Contributing Paper to GAR 2019. Geneva: UNDRR.

[73] Staupe-Delgado R. Disasters and life in anticipation of slow calamity: Perspectives from the Colombian Andes, 2022, Abingdon: Routledge

[74] Staupe-Delgado R, Kruke BI, Ross RJ, Glantz MH. Preparedness for slow-onset environmental disasters: Drawing lessons from three decades of El Niño impacts. Sustainable Development, 2018, 26(6): 553-563

[75] Tierney, K., and M. Bruneau. 2007. Conceptualizing and measuring resilience: A key to disaster loss reduction. TR News 250 (May–June): 14–17.

[76] Twigg, J. 2004. Disaster risk reduction: Mitigation and preparedness in development and emergency programming. London: Humanitarian Practice Network (HPN), Overseas Development Institute (ODI).

[77] UNDRR (United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction). 2017. Terminology. https://www.preventionweb.net/terminology/view/475 . Accessed 28 Jul 2021.

[78] Viens AM, Littmann J. Is antimicrobial resistance a slowly emerging disaster?. Public Health Ethics, 2015, 8(3): 255-265.

[79] WFP (United Nations World Food Programme). 2021. WFP warns of countdown to catastrophe as acute hunger reaches new peak. https://www.wfp.org/news/wfp-warns-countdown-catastrophe-acute-hunger-reaches-new-peak. Accessed 8 Dec 2021.

[80] Wilhite DA, Glantz MH. Understanding: The drought phenomenon: The role of definitions. Water International, 1985, 10(3): 111-120

[81] Wisner B, Blaikie P, Cannon T, Davis I. At risk: Natural hazards, people’s vulnerability and disasters, 2004 2 London: Routledge

[82] Yamori, K., and J.D. Goltz. 2021. Disasters without borders: The coronavirus pandemic, global climate change and the ascendancy of gradual onset disasters. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 18(6): Article 3299.

[83] Zaidi RZ. Beyond the Sendai indicators: Application of a cascading risk lens for the improvement of loss data indicators for slow-onset hazards and small-scale disasters. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2018, 30: 306-314