On Evidence-Based Practice in Disaster Risk Reduction

Abstract

Disaster science and scholarship are forever expanding and there are increasing calls to base disaster risk reduction policies on the evidence produced by such work. Using examples and argument, this opinion piece examines the nature of evidence. It defines evidence-based practice and considers how it has developed and become important to disaster risk reduction. A definition of what constitutes evidence is difficult to achieve but it must be made in relation to whether the data and information collected can usefully be interpreted and employed to change things for the better. Case histories from past and present centuries show that evidence can sometimes be argued over endlessly. In other cases it is roundly ignored. In yet other instances, false conclusions derived from evidence can become evidence in their own right. Nevertheless, there are situations in disaster risk reduction in which evidence is sorely needed but is clearly lacking. The effectiveness of counter-terrorism measures is one such area. In conclusion, evidence is valuable, above all if there is willingness to use it to support policy formulation, especially in a simple, transparent manner. Subjective interpretation can never be entirely removed from the use of evidence, and evidence alone will not stimulate the policy formulators to improve their decision making.

Keywords

Case histories / Disaster risk reduction / Evidence-based practice / Policy formulation

References

[1] Alexander DE. Sense and sensibility about terrorism: A European perspective. Integrated Disaster Risk Management Journal, 2011, 1(1): 1-12.

[2] Alexander, D.E. 2012. The “Titanic Syndrome”: Risk and crisis management on the Costa Concordia. Journal of Homeland Security and Emergency Management 9(1): Article 33.

[3] APA Presidential Task Force on Evidence-Based Practice Evidence-based practice in psychology (American Psychological Association). American Psychologist, 2006, 61(4): 271-285.

[4] Architects for Social Housing. 2017. The truth about Grenfell Tower: A report by architects for social housing. London: Architects for Social Housing. https://architectsforsocialhousing.co.uk. Accessed 15 Oct 2019.

[5] Auf der Heide E. The importance of evidence-based disaster planning. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 2006, 47(1): 34-40.

[6] Balmas M. When fake news becomes real: Combined exposure to multiple news sources and political attitudes of inefficacy, alienation, and cynicism. Communication Research, 2012, 41(3): 430-454.

[7] BBC News. 2013. Venice gondola tourist crushed to death. BBC News, 17 August 2013. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-23740922. Accessed 29 Jun 2020.

[8] Bell M. "How is that even possible?" Raising construction regulation from Grenfell Tower. International Construction Law Review, 2018, 35(3): 334-358.

[9] Booth, R. 2021. Company that sold Grenfell panels was warned in 2007 they could kill. The Guardian, 10 March 2021. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/mar/10/company-that-sold-grenfell-panels-was-warned-in-2007-they-could-kill. Accessed 1 Nov 2021.

[10] Carabine E. Revitalising evidence-based policy for the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030: Lessons from existing international science partnerships. PLoS Currents Disasters, 2015

[11] Casagrande M. Stylios C, Floqi T, Marinski J, Damiani L. The progressive regulation of the passage of large cruise ships in Venice: The decision-making proceedings between law and stakeholder pressure. Sustainable development of sea-corridors and coastal waters, 2015, Berlin: Springer 185-195.

[12] Contini D, Gambaro A, Belosi F, De Pieri S, Cairns WRL, Donateo A, Zanotto E, Citron M. The direct influence of ship traffic on atmospheric PM2.5, PM10 and PAH in Venice. Journal of Environmental Management, 2011, 92(9): 2119-2129.

[13] Cutter SL, Ismail-Zadeh A, Alcántara-Ayala I, Altan O, Baker DN, Briceño S, Gupta H, Holloway A Global risks: Pool knowledge to stem losses from disasters. Nature, 2014, 522(7556): 277-279.

[14] Da Mosto J, Morel T, Gibin R, Tonin S, Fracchia F, Agnoletto R, Mattassoglio F, Panzeri L The Venice report: Demography, tourism, financing and change of use of buildings, 2009, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press

[15] Della Porta D, Sberna S, Vannucci A. Centripetal and centrifugal corruption in post-democratic Italy. Italian Politics, 2015, 32(1): 198-217.

[16] Else H. How a torrent of COVID science changed research publishing—in seven charts. Nature, 2020, 588(7839): 553

[17] Fairbrother G, Cashin A, Mekki TE, Graham I, McCormack B. Is it possible to bring the emancipatory practice development and evidence-based practice agendas together in nursing and midwifery?. International Practice Development Journal, 2015, 5(1): 1-11.

[18] Fenton N. Deregulation or democracy? New media, news, neoliberalism and the public interest. Journal of Media and Cultural Studies, 2011, 25(1): 63-72.

[19] Frazer JG. The golden bough: A study in magic and religion, 1890 2 London: Macmillan

[20] French P. What is the evidence on evidence-based nursing? An epistemological concern. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 2002, 37(3): 250-257.

[21] Gaillard JC, Mercer J. From knowledge to action: Bridging gaps in disaster risk reduction. Progress in Human Geography, 2013, 37(1): 93-114.

[22] Green J, Edgerton J, Naftel D, Shoub K, Cranmer SJ. Elusive consensus: Polarization in elite communication on the Covid-19 pandemic. Science Advances, 2020, 6(28): 1-5.

[23] Harvey D. Harvey D. Scientific explanation: The model of natural science. Explanation in geography, 1969, London: Edward Arnold 30-43.

[24] Hayes J. Disaster incubation: Grenfell Tower’s unnecessary lessons. Construction Research and Innovation, 2017, 8(3): 76-79.

[25] Henry NL. Knowledge management: A new concern for public administration. Public Administration Review, 1974, 34(3): 189-196.

[26] Hoard M, Homer J, Manley W, Furbee P, Haque A, Helmkamp J. Systems modelling in support of evidence-based disaster planning for rural areas. International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health, 2005, 208(1–2): 117-125.

[27] Hohmann JM. The elements of adequate housing: Grenfell as violation. Queen Mary Human Rights Law Review, 2019, 5(2): 1-15.

[28] Horton R. The Covid-19 catastrophe, 2021 2 Cambridge: Polity Press

[29] House of Commons Potential risk of fire spread in buildings via external cladding systems, 1999, London: Environment, Transport and Regional Affairs Committee, House of Commons

[30] Ibañez JP, Hatzor YH. Rapid sliding and friction degradation: Lessons from the catastrophic Vajont landslide. Engineering Geology, 2018, 244: 96-106.

[31] Kaul V, Shah VH, El-Serag H. Leadership during crisis: Lessons and applications from the Covid-19 pandemic. Gastroenterology, 2020, 159(3): 809-812.

[32] Kitson A, Harvey G, McCormack B. Enabling the implementation of evidence based practice: A conceptual framework. Quality in Health Care, 1998, 7(3): 149-158.

[33] Lane, B. 2018. Fire safety report (Grenfell Tower fire safety investigation). London: Fire Safety Engineering, Grenfell Tower Inquiry. https://assets.grenfelltowerinquiry.org.uk/documents/Dr%20Barbara%20Lane%20report%20-%20section%2018%20%28Phase%201%20-%20supplemental%29.pdf. Accessed 1 Nov 2021.

[34] Lewis PR. Beautiful railway bridge of the Silvery Tay: Reinvestigating the Tay Bridge Disaster of 1879, 2004, Cheltenham: The History Press

[35] Lum C, Kennedy LW, Sherley A. Are counter-terrorism strategies effective? The results of the Campbell systematic review on counter-terrorism evaluation research. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 2006, 2(4): 489-516.

[36] Mallet R. Great Neapolitan Earthquake of 1857: The first principles of observational seismology, 1862, London: Chapman & Hall for the Royal Society

[37] Mallet R, Mallet JW. The earthquake catalogue of the British Association with the discussion, curves, and maps, etc, 1858, London: Taylor & Francis

[38] McKay AJ, Parekh R, Majeed A. Implications of the imposition of the junior doctor contract in England. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 2016, 109(4): 128-130.

[39] Meacock R, Doran T, Sutton M. What are the costs and benefits of providing comprehensive seven-day services for emergency hospital admissions?. Health Economics, 2015, 24(8): 907-912.

[40] Meacock R, Anselmi L, Kristensen SR, Doran T, Sutton M. Higher mortality rates amongst emergency patients admitted to hospital at weekends reflect a lower probability of admission. Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 2017, 22(1): 12-19.

[41] Melnyk BM, Fineout-Overholt E. Evidence-based practice in nursing and healthcare: A guide to best practice, 2011, New York: Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins

[42] Milne JR. Seismological observations and earth physics. Geographical Journal, 1903, 21(1): 1-22.

[43] Moffat P. The Grenfell Tower fire: A devastated community demands answers. Journal of Health Visiting, 2017, 5(10): 486-488.

[44] Montgomery CA, Wernerfelt B, Balakrishnan S. Strategy content and the research process: A critique and commentary. Strategic Management Journal, 1989, 10(2): 189-197.

[45] Moore-Bick, M. 2019. Grenfell Tower inquiry: Phase 1 report. Report of the public inquiry into the fire at Grenfell Tower on 14 June 2017. Vol. 1. London: UK Government.

[46] Nicola M, Sohrabi C, Mathew G, Kerwan A, Al-Jabir A, Griffin M, Agha M, Agha R. Health policy and leadership models during the Covid-19 pandemic: A review. International Journal of Surgery, 2020, 81: 122-129.

[47] Pak, J. 2015. Malaysia official blames nude tourists for deadly quake. BBC News, 8 June 2015. www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-33058692. Accessed 29 Jun 2020.

[48] Povinec PP, Hirose K, Aoyama M, Tateda Y. Fukushima accident: Ten years after, 2021 2 Amsterdam: Elsevier

[49] Rothkop DJ. The disinformation age. Foreign Policy, 1999, 114(1): 82-96.

[50] Rowley J. The wisdom hierarchy: Representations of the DIKW hierarchy. Journal of Information and Communication Science, 2007, 33(2): 163-180.

[51] Rycroft-Malone J, Seers K, Titchen A, Harvey G, Kitson A, McCormack B. What counts as evidence in evidence-based practice?. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 2004, 47(1): 81-90.

[52] Sackett DL, Rosenberg WMC, Grey JAM, Haynes RB, Richardson WS. Evidence based medicine: What it is and what it isn’t. British Medical Journal, 1996, 312: 71-72.

[53] Schama S. Citizens: A chronicle of the French Revolution, 1990, Harmondsworth, UK: Penguin

[54] Schemmer J. The Cruise City as an area of conflict. Journal for European Ethnology and Cultural Analysis, 2021, 5(2): 169-186.

[55] Teixeira da Silva JA, Tsigaris P, Erfanmanesh M. Publishing volumes in major databases related to Covid-19. Scientometrics, 2021, 126: 831-842.

[56] UN (United Nations) Covid-19 and human rights: We are all in this together, 2020, Geneva: United Nations

[57] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction). 2013. Making cities resilient: Summary for policymakers. A global snapshot of how local governments reduce disaster risk. Geneva: United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction.

[58] Vianello M. Colomb C, Novy J. The No Grandi Navi campaign: Protests against cruise tourism in Venice. Protest and resistance in the tourist city, 2017, Abingdon, UK: Routledge 171-190.

[59] Wenham C. Modelling can only tell us so much: Politics explains the rest. The Lancet, 2020, 395(10233): 1335

[60] Wilson, H.C. 2005. Editorial. Disaster Prevention and Management 14(1). https://doi.org/10.1108/dpm.2005.07314aaa.001.

[61] Zaggia L, Parnell K, Lorenzetti G, Vafeidis AT. Ship-wake induced sediment remobilization: Effects and proposed management strategies for the Venice Lagoon. Ocean and Coastal Management, 2015, 110: 1-11.