The Importance of Digital Elevation Model Selection in Flood Simulation and a Proposed Method to Reduce DEM Errors: A Case Study in Shanghai

Abstract

Digital Elevation Models (DEMs) play a critical role in hydrologic and hydraulic modeling. Flood inundation mapping is highly dependent on the accuracy of DEMs. Various vertical differences exist among open access DEMs as they use various observation satellites and algorithms. The problem is particularly acute in small, flat coastal cities. Thus, it is necessary to assess the differences of the input of DEMs in flood simulation and to reduce anomalous errors of DEMs. In this study, we first conducted urban flood simulation in the Huangpu River Basin in Shanghai by using the LISFLOOD-FP hydrodynamic model and six open-access DEMs (SRTM, MERIT, CoastalDEM, GDEM, NASADEM, and AW3D30), and analyzed the differences in the results of the flood inundation simulations. Then, we processed the DEMs by using two statistically based methods and compared the results with those using the original DEMs. The results show that: (1) the flood inundation mappings using the six original DEMs are significantly different under the same simulation conditions—this indicates that only using a single DEM dataset may lead to bias of flood mapping and is not adequate for high confidence analysis of exposure and flood management; and (2) the accuracy of a DEM corrected by the Dixon criterion for predicting inundation extent is improved, in addition to reducing errors in extreme water depths—this indicates that the corrected datasets have some performance improvement in the accuracy of flood simulation. A freely available, accurate, high-resolution DEM is needed to support robust flood mapping. Flood-related researchers, practitioners, and other stakeholders should pay attention to the uncertainty caused by DEM quality.

Keywords

Digital elevation models / Dixon criterion / Hydraulic modeling / Shanghai / Urban flooding

References

[1] Aerts JCJH, Botzen WJW, Emanuel K, Lin N, de Moel H, Michel-Kerjan EO. Evaluating flood resilience strategies for coastal megacities. Science, 2014, 344(6183): 473-475

[2] Aguilar FJ, Mills JP, Delgado J, Aguilar MA, Negreiros JG, Pérez JL. Modelling vertical error in LiDAR-derived digital elevation models. ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 2010, 65(1): 103-110

[3] Balica SF, Wright NG, van der Meulen F. A flood vulnerability index for coastal cities and its use in assessing climate change impacts. Natural Hazards, 2012, 64(1): 73-105

[4] Barragán JM, de Andrés M. Analysis and trends of the world's coastal cities and agglomerations. Ocean & Coastal Management, 2015, 114: 11-20

[5] Bates PD, De Roo APJ. A simple raster-based model for flood inundation simulation. Journal of Hydrology, 2000, 236(1): 54-77

[6] Bhuyian M, Kalyanapu A. Accounting digital elevation uncertainty for flood consequence assessment. Journal of Flood Risk Management, 2018, 11(S2): S1051-S1062

[7] Cobby DM, Mason DC, Davenport IJ. Image processing of airborne scanning laser altimetry data for improved river flood modelling. ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 2001, 56(2): 121-138

[8] Cook A, Merwade V. Effect of topographic data, geometric configuration and modeling approach on flood inundation mapping. Journal of Hydrology, 2009, 377(1): 131-142

[9] Coveney S, Fotheringham AS. The impact of DEM data source on prediction of flooding and erosion risk due to sea-level rise. International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 2011, 25(7): 1191-1211

[10] Crippen, R., S. Buckley, P. Agram, E. Belz, E. Gurrola, S. Hensley, M. Kobrick, M. Lavalle, et al. 2016. NASADEM global elevation model: Methods and progress. ISPRS – International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences XLI–B4: 125–128.

[11] Dang, Y., L. Chen, W. Zhang, D. Zheng, and D. Zhan. 2020. How does growing city size affect residents’ happiness in urban China? A case study of the Bohai rim area. Habitat International 97: Article 102120.

[12] Deng J-L, Shen S-L, Xu Y-S. Investigation into pluvial flooding hazards caused by heavy rain and protection measures in Shanghai, China. Natural Hazards, 2016, 83(2): 1301-1320

[13] Dixon WJ. Analysis of extreme values. The Annals of Mathematical Statistics, 1950, 21(4): 488-506

[14] Dovern J, Quaas MF, Rickels W. A comprehensive wealth index for cities in Germany. Ecological Indicators, 2014, 41: 79-86

[15] Du S, Gu H, Wen J, Chen K, Van Rompaey A. Detecting flood variations in Shanghai over 1949–2009 with Mann-Kendall tests and a newspaper-based database. Water, 2015, 7(5): 1808-1824

[16] Du X, Guo H, Fan X, Zhu J, Yan Z, Zhan Q. Vertical accuracy assessment of freely available digital elevation models over low-lying coastal plains. International Journal of Digital Earth, 2016, 9(3): 252-271

[17] Elkhrachy I. Vertical accuracy assessment for SRTM and ASTER Digital Elevation Models: A case study of Najran city, Saudi Arabia. Ain Shams Engineering Journal, 2018, 9(4): 1807-1817

[18] Fang, J., D. Lincke, S. Brown, R. Nicholls, C. Wolff, J. Merkens, J. Hinkel, A. Vafeidis, et al. 2020. Coastal flood risks in China through the 21st century – An application of DIVA. Science of the Total Environment 704: Article 135311.

[19] Fereshtehpour M, Karamouz M. DEM resolution effects on coastal flood vulnerability assessment: Deterministic and probabilistic approach. Water Resources Research, 2018, 54(7): 4965-4982

[20] Fewtrell T, Bates P, Horritt M, Hunter N. Evaluating the effect of scale in flood inundation modelling in urban environments. Hydrological Processes, 2008, 22(26): 5107-5118

[21] Gallant, J. 2011. Adaptive smoothing for noisy DEMs. Geomorphometry 2011, 07–11 September 2011, Redlands, California. https://gis-lab.info/docs/gallant2011_adaptive_smoothing_for_noisy_dems.pdf. Accessed 18 Oct 2021.

[22] Gesch, D. 2018. Best practices for elevation-based assessments of sea-level rise and coastal flooding exposure. Frontiers in Earth Science 6: Article 230.

[23] Gu X, Zhang Q, Singh VP, Song C, Sun P, Li J. Potential contributions of climate change and urbanization to precipitation trends across China at national, regional and local scales. International Journal of Climatology, 2019, 39(6): 2998-3012

[24] Hawker, L., P. Bates, J. Neal, and J. Rougier. 2018. Perspectives on Digital Elevation Model (DEM) simulation for flood modeling in the absence of a high-accuracy open access global DEM. Frontiers in Earth Science 6: Article 233.

[25] Hawker L, Rougier J, Neal J, Bates P, Archer L, Yamazaki D. Implications of simulating global digital elevation models for flood inundation studies. Water Resources Research, 2018, 54: 7910-7928

[26] Holmes KW, Chadwick OA, Kyriakidis PC. Error in a USGS 30-meter digital elevation model and its impact on terrain modeling. Journal of Hydrology, 2000, 233(1): 154-173

[27] Hutchinson MF. A new procedure for gridding elevation and stream line data with automatic removal of spurious pits. Journal of Hydrology, 1989, 106(3–4): 211-232

[28] Jafarzadegan K, Merwade V. A DEM-based approach for large-scale floodplain mapping in ungauged watersheds. Journal of Hydrology, 2017, 550: 650-662

[29] Karamuz, E., R. Romanowicz, and J. Doroszkiewicz. 2020. The use of unmanned aerial vehicles in flood hazard assessment. Journal of Flood Risk Management 13(4): Article e12622.

[30] Kenward T, Lettenmaier DP, Wood EF, Fielding E. Effects of Digital Elevation Model accuracy on hydrologic predictions. Remote Sensing of Environment, 2000, 74(3): 432-444

[31] Kim, Y., Y. Tak, M. Park, and B. Kang. 2020. Improvement of urban flood damage estimation using a high-resolution digital terrain. Journal of Flood Risk Management 13(S1): Article e12575.

[32] Kulp S, Strauss B. Coastal DEM: A global coastal digital elevation model improved from SRTM using a neural network. Remote Sensing of Environment, 2018, 206(2): 231-239

[33] Kulp, S., and B. Strauss. 2019. New elevation data triple estimates of global vulnerability to sea-level rise and coastal flooding. Nature Communications 10(1): Article 4844.

[34] Kyriakidis P, Ashton M, Michael F. Geostatistics for conflation and accuracy assessment of digital elevation models. International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 1999, 13(7): 677-707

[35] Lesser G, Roelvink J, Kester J, Stelling G. Development and validation of a three-dimensional morphological model. Coastal Engineering, 2004, 51(8): 883-915

[36] Lim N, Brandt S. Flood map boundary sensitivity due to combined effects of DEM resolution and roughness in relation to model performance. Geomatics, Natural Hazards and Risk, 2019, 10(1): 1613-1647

[37] Lin, N., R.E. Kopp, B.P. Horton, and J.P. Donnelly. 2016. Hurricane Sandy’s flood frequency increasing from year 1800 to 2100. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113(43): Article 12071.

[38] Mukherjee S, Joshi PK, Mukherjee S, Ghosh A, Garg RD, Mukhopadhyay A. Evaluation of vertical accuracy of open source Digital Elevation Model (DEM). International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation, 2013, 21(1): 205-217

[39] Najibi N, Devineni N. Recent trends in the frequency and duration of global floods. Earth System Dynamics, 2018, 9(2): 757-783

[40] Niu G, Zhao G. Living condition among China’s rural–urban migrants: Recent dynamics and the inland–coastal differential. Housing Studies, 2018, 33(3): 476-493

[41] Pedrozo-Acuña A, Rodríguez-Rincón J, Arganis-Juárez M, Domínguez-Mora R, González Villareal F. Estimation of probabilistic flood inundation maps for an extreme event: Pánuco River, México. Journal of Flood Risk Management, 2015, 8(2): 177-192

[42] Reuter HI, Nelson A, Jarvis A. An evaluation of void-filling interpolation methods for SRTM data. International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 2007, 21(9): 983-1008

[43] Rodriguez E, Morris CS, Belz JE. A global assessment of SRTM performance. Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing, 2006, 72(3): 249-260

[44] Saksena S, Merwade V. Incorporating the effect of DEM resolution and accuracy for improved flood inundation mapping. Journal of Hydrology, 2015, 530: 180-194

[45] Samela C, Troy TJ, Manfreda S. Geomorphic classifiers for flood-prone areas delineation for data-scarce environments. Advances in Water Resources, 2017, 102: 13-28

[46] Sampson, C., A. Smith, P. Bates, J. Neal, and M. Trigg. 2016. Perspectives on open access high resolution Digital Elevation Models to produce global flood hazard layers. Frontiers in Earth Science 3: Article 85.

[47] SAMR (State Administration for Market Regulation). 2008. Statistical interpretation of data – Detection and treatment of outliers in the normal sample. Beijing: SAMR. (in Chinese).

[48] Sanders BF. Evaluation of on-line DEMs for flood inundation modeling. Advances in Water Resources, 2007, 30(8): 1831-1843

[49] Savage J, Pianosi F, Bates P, Freer J, Wagener T. Quantifying the importance of spatial resolution and other factors through global sensitivity analysis of a flood inundation model. Water Resources Research, 2016, 52(11): 9146-9163

[50] Schumann, G., and P. Bates. 2018. The need for a high-accuracy, open-access global DEM. Frontiers in Earth Science 6: Article 225.

[51] SMSB (Shanghai Municipal Statistics Bureau) Shanghai statistical yearbook 2020, 2020, Beijing: China Statistics Press (in Chinese)

[52] Soille, P., J. Vogt, and R. Colombo. 2003. Carving and adaptive drainage enforcement of grid digital elevation models. Water Resources Research 39(12): Article 1366.

[53] Stephens E, Schumann G, Bates P. Problems with binary pattern measures for flood model evaluation. Hydrological Processes, 2014, 28(18): 4928-4937

[54] Surjan, A., G.A. Parvin, Atta-ur-Rahman, and R. Shaw. 2016. Expanding coastal cities: An increasing risk. In Urban disasters and resilience in Asia, ed. R. Shaw, Atta-ur-Rahman, A. Surjan, and G.A. Parvin, 79–90. Amsterdam: Elsevier.

[55] Tachikawa, T., M. Hato, M. Kaku, and A. Iwasaki. 2011. Characteristics of ASTER GDEM version 2. In Proceedings of the 2011 IEEE International Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium, 24–29 July, Vancouver, BC, Canada, 3657–3660.

[56] Tachikawa T, Kaku M, Iwasaki A, Gesch D, Oimoen M, Zhang Z, Danielson J, Krieger T ASTER global Digital Elevation Model version 2 – Summary of validation results, 2011, Washington, DC: NASA

[57] Tadono, T., H. Ishida, F. Oda, S. Naito, K. Minakawa, and H. Iwamoto. 2014. Precise global DEM generation by ALOS PRISM. ISPRS Annals of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences II–4: 71–76.

[58] Takagi M. Accuracy of digital elevation model according to spatial resolution. International Archives of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 1998, 32(4): 613-617.

[59] Takaku, J., T. Tadono, K. Tsutsui, and M. Ichikawa. 2016. Validation of "AW3D" global DSM generated from ALOS PRISM. ISPRS Annals of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences III–4: 25–31.

[60] Talchabhadel R, Nakagawa H, Kawaike K, Yamanoi K, Thapa BR. Assessment of vertical accuracy of open source 30m resolution space-borne digital elevation models. Geomatics, Natural Hazards and Risk, 2021, 12(1): 939-960

[61] Vaze J, Teng J, Spencer G. Impact of DEM accuracy and resolution on topographic indices. Environmental Modelling & Software, 2010, 25(10): 1086-1098

[62] Wang J, Gao W, Xu S, Yu L. Evaluation of the combined risk of sea level rise, land subsidence, and storm surges on the coastal areas of Shanghai, China. Climatic Change, 2012, 115(3): 537-558

[63] Wechsler SP. Uncertainties associated with digital elevation models for hydrologic applications: A review. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 2007, 11(4): 1481-1500

[64] Wechsler SP, Kroll CN. Quantifying DEM uncertainty and its effect on topographic parameters. Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing, 2006, 72(9): 1081-1090

[65] Wen K, Xu Y. China meteorological disaster dictionary Shanghai volume, 2006, Beijing: Meteorological Press (in Chinese)

[66] Wong, W., S. Tsuyuki, K. Ioki, and M. Phua. 2014. Accuracy assessment of global topographic data (SRTM & ASTER GDEM) in comparison with lidar for tropical montane forest. In Proceedings of the 35th Asian Conference on Remote Sensing 2014, 27–31 October 2014, Nay Pyi Taw, Myanmar, 722–727.

[67] Yamazaki D, Ikeshima D, Tawatari R, Yamaguchi T, O'Loughlin F, Neal JC, Sampson C, Kanae S, Bates PD. A high-accuracy map of global terrain elevations. Geophysical Research Letters, 2017, 44(11): 5844-5853

[68] Yang Y, Yin J, Ye M, She D, Yu J. Multi-coverage optimal location model for emergency medical service (EMS) facilities under various disaster scenarios: A case study of urban fluvial floods in the Minhang district of Shanghai, China. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2020, 20(1): 181-195

[69] Yin, J., D. Yu, and B. Liao. 2020. A city-scale assessment of emergency response accessibility to vulnerable populations and facilities under normal and pluvial flood conditions for Shanghai, China. Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science. https://doi.org/10.1177/2399808320971304.

[70] Yin J, Yu D, Yin Z, Wang J, Xu S. Multiple scenario analyses of Huangpu River flooding using a 1D/2D coupled flood inundation model. Natural Hazards, 2013, 66(2): 577-589

[71] Yu D, Lane SN. Urban fluvial flood modelling using a two-dimensional diffusion-wave treatment, part 1: Mesh resolution effects. Hydrological Processes, 2006, 20(7): 1541-1565

[72] Yuan Z. Floods and drought in Shanghai, 1999, Nanjing: Hohai University Press (in Chinese)

[73] Zhang K, Gann D, Ross M, Robertson Q, Sarmiento J, Santana S, Rhome J, Fritz C. Accuracy assessment of ASTER, SRTM, ALOS, and TDX DEMs for Hispaniola and implications for mapping vulnerability to coastal flooding. Remote Sensing of Environment, 2019, 225: 290-306

[74] Zhao, G., P. Bates, and J. Neal. 2020. The impact of dams on design floods in the conterminous US. Water Resources Research 56(3): e2019WR025380.