Impact of Virtual Disaster Collaboration Exercises on Disaster Leadership at Hospitals in Saudi Arabia

Abstract

This study measured the impact of virtual three-level collaboration (3LC) exercises on participants’ perceived levels of collaboration, learning, and utility (CLU) at hospitals in the southern region of Saudi Arabia. Our 3LC exercise is a tabletop training tool used to facilitate disaster education and document CLU. This model enables the practitioner to acquire new knowledge and promotes active learning. An English version of the CLU scale, the validated Swedish survey tool, was applied to 100 healthcare managers or leaders in various positions at both the operational and tactical levels after conducting the 3LC exercises. The response rate was 100%, although not all questions were answered in some cases. The results show that most participants strongly agreed that the exercises focused on collaboration (r ² = 0.767) and that they had acquired new knowledge during the exercises. There was a statistically significant association between participation in the collaboration exercises and perceived learning (r ² = 0.793), as well as between perceived learning and utility (r ² = 0.811). The collaboration exercises enhance the perceived effects of CLU. They also improve the ability of participants to adapt situational strategies to achieve a safer society. Although exercises were conducted virtually, they were well received by the participants and achieved a value M = 4.4 CLU score, which opens up new dimensions in collaboration simulation exercises.

Keywords

Collaboration exercises / Disaster education / Emergency management / Healthcare personnel training / Saudi Arabia

References

[1] Alexander D. Scenario methodology for teaching principles of emergency management. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2000, 9(2): 89-97

[2] Al-Fahad FN. Students' attitudes and perceptions towards the effectiveness of mobile learning in King Saud University, Saudi Arabia. Turkish Online Journal of Educational Technology, 2009, 8(2): 111-119.

[3] Al Thobaity, A., S. Alamri, V. Plummer, and B. Williams. 2019. Exploring the necessary disaster plan components in Saudi Arabian hospitals. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 41: Article 101316.

[4] Al Thobaity A, Williams B, Plummer V. A new scale for disaster nursing core competencies: Development and psychometric testing. Australasian Emergency Nursing Journal, 2016, 19(1): 11-19

[5] Andersson A, Carlstrom ED, Ahgren B, Berlin JM. Managing boundaries at the accident scene—A qualitative study of collaboration exercises. International Journal of Emergency Services, 2014, 3(1): 77-94

[6] Aronoff SC, Evans B, Fleece D, Lyons P, Kaplan L, Rojas R. Integrating evidence based medicine into undergraduate medical education: Combining online instruction with clinical clerkships. Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 2010, 22(3): 219-223

[7] Berlin JM, Carlström ED. The 90-second collaboration: A critical study of collaboration exercises at extensive accident sites. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2008, 16(4): 177-185

[8] Berlin JM, Carlström ED. The 20-minute team—A critical case study from the emergency room. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 2008, 14(4): 569-576

[9] Berlin JM, Carlström ED. Why is collaboration minimized at the accident scene? A critical study of a hidden phenomenon. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2011, 20(2): 159-171

[10] Berlin JM, Carlström ED. The three-level collaboration exercise—Impact of learning and usefulness. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2015, 23(4): 257-265

[11] Boin A, Bynander F. Explaining success and failure in crisis coordination. Geografiska Annaler Series A Physical Geography, 2015, 97(1): 123-135

[12] Boin A, P. 't Hart. Organising for effective emergency management: Lessons from research. Australian Journal of Public Administration, 2010, 69(4): 357-371

[13] Brace N, Kemp R, Snelgar R. SPSS for psychologists: A guide to data analysis using SPSS for Windows, 2006 3 Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers

[14] Brinjee D, Al Thobaity A, Almalki M, Alahmari W. Identify the disaster nursing training and education needs for nurses in Taif City, Saudi Arabia. Risk Management and Healthcare Policy, 2021, 14: 2301-2310

[15] Budd J, Miller BS, Manning EM, Lampos V, Zhuang M, Edelstein M, Rees G, Emery VC Digital technologies in the public-health response to COVID-19. Nature Medicine, 2020, 26(8): 1183-1192

[16] Carter WN. Disaster management: A disaster manager's handbook, 2008, Boston: Springer

[17] Charman S. Blue light communities: Cultural interoperability and shared learning between ambulance staff and police officers in emergency response. Policing and Society, 2013, 24(1): 102-119

[18] Cohen J. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences, 2013, Cambridge, MA: Academic Press

[19] Coppola DP. Introduction to international disaster management, 2006, London: Elsevier

[20] Coughlan M, Cronin P, Ryan F. Survey research: Process and limitations. International Journal of Therapy and Rehabilitation, 2009, 16(1): 9-15

[21] Drennan LT, McConnell A. Risk and crisis management in the public sector, 2007, New York: Routledge

[22] Eisenhardt KM, Graebner ME. Theory building from cases: Opportunities and challenges. Academy of Management Journal, 2007, 50(1): 25-32

[23] Elfaki NK, Abdulraheem I, Abdulrahim R. Impact of e-learning vs traditional learning on student’s performance and attitude. International Journal of Medical Research & Health Sciences, 2019, 8(10): 76-82.

[24] Fattah S, Krüger A, Andersen J, Vigerust T, Rehn M. Major incident preparedness and on-site work among Norwegian rescue personnel—A cross-sectional study. International Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2012, 5(40): 1-7.

[25] Gredler ME. Designing and evaluating games and simulations: A process approach, 1992, Houston: Gulf Professional Publishing

[26] Huxham C, Vangen S. Managing to collaborate – The theory and practice of collaborative advantage, 2005, London: Routledge

[27] Jung K, Song M. Linking emergency management networks to disaster resilience: Bonding and bridging strategy in hierarchical or horizontal collaboration networks. Quality & Quantity, 2015, 49(4): 1465-1483

[28] Kapucu N, Garayev V. Collaborative decision-making in emergency and disaster management. International Journal of Public Administration, 2011, 34(6): 366-375

[29] Khorram-Manesh, A. 2020. Flexible surge capacity–public health, public education, and disaster management. Health Promotion Perspectives 10(3): Article 175.

[30] Khorram-Manesh, A., and F.M. Burkle. 2020. Disasters and public health emergencies—Current perspectives in preparedness and response. Sustainability 12(20): Article 8561.

[31] Khorram-Manesh A, Ashkenazi M, Djalali A, Ingrassia PL, Friedl T, von Armin G, Lupesco O, Kaptan K Education in disaster management and emergencies: Defining a new European course. Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness, 2015, 9(3): 245-255

[32] Khorram-Manesh A, Berlin J, Carlstrom E. Two validated ways of improving the ability of decision-making in emergencies; Results from a literature review. Bulletin of Emergency & Trauma, 2016, 4(4): 186-196.

[33] Khorram-Manesh A, Lupesco O, Friedl T, Arnim G, Kaptan K, Djalali AR, Foletti M, Ingrasia PL Education in disaster management: What do we offer and what do we need? Proposing a new global program. Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness, 2016, 10(6): 854-873

[34] Klabbers, J.H.G. 1999. Three easy pieces: A taxonomy on gaming. In Simulations and games for strategy and policy planning, simulation and gaming yearbook, vol. 7, ed. D. Saunders, and J. Severn. London: Kogan.

[35] Magnussen LI, Carlstrøm E, Sørensen JL, Torgersen GE, Hagenes EF, Kristiansen E. Learning and usefulness stemming from collaboration in a maritime crisis management exercise in Northern Norway. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2018, 27(1): 129-140

[36] Mani ZA, Kuhn L, Plummer V. Common domains of core competencies for hospital health care providers in armed conflict zones: A systematic scoping review. Prehospital and Disaster Medicine, 2020, 35(4): 442-446

[37] Middleton, A.J. 1997. How effective is distance education? International Journal of Instructional Media 24(2): Article 133.

[38] Moynihan DP. Learning under uncertainty: Networks in crisis management. Public Administration Review, 2008, 68(2): 350-365

[39] Oktari, R.S., K. Munadi, and R. Idroes. 2020. Knowledge management practices in disaster management: Systematic review. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 51(2): Article 101881.

[40] Perry RW. Disaster exercise outcomes for professional emergency personnel and citizen volunteers. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2004, 12(2): 64-75

[41] Powley, E.H., and M.E. Nissen. 2012. If you can't trust, stick to hierarchy: Structure and trust as contingency factors in threat assessment contexts. Journal of Homeland Security and Emergency Management 9(1): Article 14.

[42] Raosoft. 2004. Raosoft sample size calculator. http://www.raosoft.com/samplesize.html. Accessed 14 Oct 2021.

[43] Revell A, Wainwright E. What makes lectures 'unmissable'? Insights into teaching excellence and active learning. Journal of Geography in Higher Education, 2009, 33(2): 209-223

[44] Roud E, Gausdal AH. Trust and emergency management: Experiences from the Arctic Sea region. Journal of Trust Research, 2019, 9(2): 203-225

[45] Sagun A, Bouchlaghem D, Anumba CJ. A scenario-based study on information flow and collaboration patterns in disaster management. Disasters, 2009, 33(2): 214-238

[46] Sahu, P. 2020. Closure of universities due to coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19): Impact on education and mental health of students and academic staff. Cureus 12(4): Article e7541.

[47] Sawalha IHS. Collaboration in crisis and emergency management: Identifying the gaps in the case of storm 'Alexa'. Journal of Business Continuity & Emergency Planning, 2014, 7(4): 312-323.

[48] Scholtens A. Controlled Collaboration in disaster and crisis management in the Netherlands, history and practice of an overestimated and underestimated concept. Journal of Contingency and Management, 2008, 16(4): 195-207.

[49] Schwartzstein RM, Roberts DH. Saying goodbye to lectures in medical school—Paradigm shift or passing fad. New England Journal of Medicine, 2017, 377(7): 605-607

[50] Sørensen, J.L., C. Halvorsen, J.P.W Aas, and E. Carlström. 2020. “Share your tools"—A utility study of a Norwegian wildland-fire collaboration exercise. Sustainability 12(16): Article 6512.

[51] Sørensen JL, Magnussen LI, Torgersen GE, Christiansen AM, Carlström E. Perceived usefulness of maritime cross-border collaboration exercises. Arts and Social Sciences Journal, 2018, 9(4): 1-5

[52] Spiceland D, Hawkins C. The impact on learning of an asynchronous active learning course. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 2002, 6(1): 68-75.

[53] Stein J. How institutions learn: A socio-cognitive perspective. Journal of Economic Issues, 1997, 31(3): 729-740

[54] Sultan, M.A.S., A. Khorram-Manesh, E. Carlström, J.L. Sørensen, H.J.A. Sulayyim, and F. Taube. 2020a. Nurses' readiness for emergencies and public health challenges—The case of Saudi Arabia. Sustainability 12(19): Article 7874.

[55] Sultan, M.A.S., J.L. Sørensen, E. Carlström, L. Mortelmans, and A. Khorram-Manesh. 2020b. Emergency healthcare providers' perceptions of preparedness and willingness to work during disasters and public health emergencies. Healthcare 8(4): Article 442.

[56] Tabatabai S. Simulations and virtual learning supporting clinical education during the COVID 19 pandemic. Advances in Medical Education and Practice, 2020, 11: 513-516

[57] Torani S, Majd PM, Maroufi SS, Dowlati M, Sheikhi RA. The importance of education on disasters and emergencies: A review article. Journal of Education and Health Promotion, 2019, 8: 85-94

[58] WHO (World Health Organization). 2017. A strategic framework for emergency preparedness. https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/254883/9789241511827-eng.pdf;jsessionid=F17E52C654D50ADCB045E8F3922AF62D?sequence=1. Accessed 4 Feb 2021.

[59] WHO (World Health Organization). 2021. Risk communication simulation exercises. https://www.who.int/emergencies/risk-communications/simulation-exercises. Accessed 18 Feb 2021.