Retracing Realistic Disaster Scenarios from Archival Sources: A Key Tool for Disaster Risk Reduction

Abstract

Disaster scenarios are constructed by integrating natural hazard phenomena and social science sources of information. We profiled 51 natural hazard events of nineteenth century Kashmir that provide insights into the impacts of varying degree of severity that spread through the socioeconomic and political systems, influenced adaptation, and increased the consequences of the resulting disasters. The root cause of these disasters was embedded in the social, natural, and political economic systems of their time, where vulnerabilities overlapped and interacted periodically with successive colonial regimes and acted as tipping points. The combined effect of successive colonial regimes, inept administration, rigid political economy, and natural hazards made the situation go from bad to worse and reduced Kashmir to the depths of distress and subjugation. Over the arc of the nineteenth century, a series of disasters led the Kashmiri population to learn how to live with disasters and minimize risk, bringing about the evolution of social and environmental knowledge. Understanding the natural hazard vulnerability of the Kashmir Valley through archival narratives can help in scenario building to translate findings into formats that reduce related risk now as it did then. The resulting information can be useful for regional design, planning, and policy responses to promote disaster risk reduction.

Keywords

Disaster risk reduction / Historical disasters / Kashmir / Nineteenth-century disasters / Socioeconomic vulnerability

References

[1] Administrative Report of the Punjab and its Dependencies for 1875−1876. 1877. Printed at the Punjab Government Civil Secretariat Press. Lahore, Pakistan.

[2] Administrative Report of the Punjab and its Dependencies for 1878−1879. 1880. Printed at the Punjab Government Civil Secretariat Press. Lahore, Pakistan.

[3] Administrative Report of the Punjab and its Dependencies for 1894–1895. 1896. Printed at the Punjab Government Civil Secretariat Press. Lahore, Pakistan.

[4] Ahmad B, Ahmad S, Alam A, Wang S, Bhat MS. Looking for missing links in Kashmir: An update on nineteenth century seismicity. Seismological Research Letters, 2015, 86(4): 1219-1224

[5] Ahmad B, Alam A, Bhat MS, Ahmad S, Shafi M, Rasool R. Seismic risk reduction through indigenous architecture in Kashmir Valley. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2017, 21: 110-117

[6] Ahmad B, Sana H, Alam A. Macroseismic intensity assessment of 1885 Baramulla earthquake of northwestern Kashmir Himalaya, using the environmental seismic intensity scale (ESI 2007). Quaternary International, 2014, 321: 59-64

[7] Akerkar S. Development of a normative framework for disaster relief: Learning from colonial famine histories in India. Disasters, 2015, 39(S2): S219-S243

[8] Akhtar R. Environment and cholera in Kashmir during nineteenth-century. Indian Journal of History of Science, 2008, 43(2): 211-230.

[9] Anyamba A, Chretien JP, Small J, Tucker CJ, Linthicum KJ. Developing global climate anomalies suggest potential disease risks for 2006–2007. International Journal of Health Geographics, 2006, 5(60): 1-8.

[10] Bamzai, P.N.K. 1962. Socio-economic history of Kashmir: 1846–1925. New Delhi, India: Metropolitan Book Co.

[11] Bankoff G. Comparing vulnerabilities: Toward charting an historical trajectory of disasters. Historical Social Research, 2007, 32(3): 103-114.

[12] Bates CE. A gazetteer of Kashmir, 1873, New Delhi, India: Light & Life Publishers

[13] Bazaz PN. Kashmir in crucible, 1941, Srinagar, Kashmir: Pamposh Publications

[14] Bellew, H.W. 1875. Kashmir and Kashghar: A narrative of the journey of the embassy to Kashghar in 1873–74. London: Trubner & Co. (Palala Press 2015).

[15] Bhat, M.S., B. Ahmad, A. Alam, and A.F. Hakim. 2019. Flood hazard assessment of Kashmir Valley using historical hydrology. Journal of Flood Risk Management 12(51): Article e12521.

[16] Briffa KR, Jones PD, Schweingruber FH, Osborn TJ. Influence of volcanic eruptions on northern hemisphere summer temperature over the past 600 years. Nature, 1998, 393(6684): 450-455

[17] Burton I. Forensic disaster investigation in depth: A new case study model. Environment, 2010, 52(5): 36-41.

[18] Carus-Wilson A. A woman’s life for Kashmir: Irene Petrie, a biography, 1901, New York: Fleming H. Revell

[19] Clemow FG. The geography of disease, 1903, New York: Cambridge University Press

[20] Climo WH. The floods in Kashmir and Srinagar: A new focus of endemic cholera. British Medical Journal, 1893, 2(1702): 396-397

[21] Cole-Dai, J., D.G. Ferris, A.L. Lanciki, J. Savarino, M. Baroni, and M.H. Thiemens. 2009. Cold decade (AD 1810–1819) caused by Tambora (1815) and another (1809) stratospheric volcanic eruption. Geophysical Research Letters 36(22): Article L22703.

[22] Collette, J. 1884. A guide for visitors to Kashmir. Revised by A. Mitra, 1898. Calcutta, India: W. Newman & Co.

[23] Colwell RR. Infectious disease and environment: Cholera as a paradigm for waterborne disease. International Microbiology, 2004, 7(4): 285-289.

[24] Cook ER, Anchukaitis KJ, Buckley BM, D’Arrigo RD, Wright WE, Jacoby GC. Asian monsoon failure and mega drought during the last millennium. Science, 2010, 328(5977): 486-489

[25] Davis M. Late Victorian Holocausts: El Niño famines and the making of the third world, 2001, London: Verso

[26] Dedamari, K.M.A. 1747. Waqat-i-Kashmir. Persian manuscript. Folios 296. Srinagar, India: Research & Publication Division, Library Srinagar, University of Kashmir.

[27] Dev, J.S. 1983. Natural calamities in Jammu and Kashmir. New Delhi, India: Ariana.

[28] Diamond J, Robinson JA. Natural experiments of history, 2010, Cambridge: Harvard University Press

[29] Digby, W. 1890. Condemned unheard: The Government of India and H.H. the Maharaja of Kashmir: A Letter to the Rt. Hon. Sir Ughtred Kay-Shuttleworth. London: Indian Political Agency.

[30] Drew F. The Jummoo and Kashmir territories: A geographical account, 1875, London: Edward Stanford

[31] Elmslie WJ. Seed time in Kashmir: A memoir of William Jackson Elmslie, 1875, London: James Nisbet

[32] Forster G. A journey from Bengal to England, through the northern part of India, Kashmire, Afghanistan, and Persia, and into Russia by the Caspian Sea, 1808, London: Faulder & Sons

[33] Gaillard JC, Kelman I. Bobrowsky PT. Disaster research and policy, history. Encyclopaedia of natural hazards, 2013, Heidelberg, Germany: Springer 160-164

[34] Gergis JL, Fowler AM. How unusual was late 20^th century El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO)? Assessing evidence from tree-ring, coral, ice-core and documentary palaeoarchives, A.D. 1525–2002. Advances in Geosciences, 2006, 6: 173-179

[35] Gergis, J.L., and A.M. Fowler. 2009. History of ENSO events since A.D. 1525: Implications for future climate change. Climatic Change 92(3): 343–387.

[36] Global Hunger Index. 2019. Dublin, Ireland: Concern Worldwide and Welthungerhilfe (WHH).

[37] Gracia-Acosta V. Hoffman SM, Oliver-Smith A. Historical disaster research. Catastrophe and culture: The anthropology of disaster, 2002, Santa Fe, New Mexico: School of American Research Press 49-66.

[38] Grayson DK, Sheets PD. Sheets PD, Grayson DK. Volcanic disasters and the archaeological record. Volcanic activity and human ecology, 1979, London: Academic Press 623-632

[39] Hassan, M. 1959. Kashmir under the Sultans. Srinagar, Kashmir: Ali Mohammad & Sons.

[40] Hügel BC. Notice of a visit to the Himmáleh Mountains and the Valley of Kashmir, in 1835. Journal of the Royal Geographical Society, 1836, 6: 343-349

[41] von Hügel CA. Travels in Kashmir and the Panjab, 1845, London: John Petheram

[42] Hussain TA. On the brink: A report on the climate change and its impact in Kashmir, 2007, Srinagar, India: Books for Change

[43] Ince, J. 1888. Ince’s Kashmir handbook: A guide for visitors, re-written and much enlarged by Joshua Duke. Calcutta, India: Thacker, Spink and Co.

[44] India. Quarter Master General’s Department. Intelligence Branch Gazetteer of Kashmir & Ladak, 1890, Calcutta: Superintendent of Government Printing

[45] IRDR (Integrated Research on Disaster Risk). 2015. The FORIN project: Understanding the causes of disasters. Beijing, China: Integrated Research on Disaster Risk.

[46] Jahn, T., and P. Wehling. 1998. Social nature conditions: Contours of a theoretical concept (Gesellschaftliche Naturverhältnisse: Konturen eines theoretischen Konzepts). In Sociology and nature: Theoretical perspectives (Soziologie and Natur: Theoretische Perspektiven), ed. K.-W. Brand, 75–93. Wiesbaden, Germany: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften (Springer) (in German).

[47] Jammu and Kashmir Political. 1889. No. 39.

[48] Jones EJ. Notes on the Kashmir Earthquake of 30^th May 1885. Records of the Geological Survey of India, 1885, 18(3): 153-156.

[49] Kachru, P.B. 1836. Majmu’-ut-Tawarikh. Persian manuscript. Srinagar, India: Research & Publication Division, Srinagar Library, University of Kashmir.

[50] Kelman I, Field J, Kavita S, Bhat GM. Disaster diplomacy in Jammu and Kashmir. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2018, 31: 1132-1140

[51] Khanyari, G.N. 1893. Wajeez-ul-Tawarikh. Persian manuscript. Srinagar, India: Research & Publication Division, Srinagar Library, University of Kashmir.

[52] Khasta, P.H.G. 1888. Guldast-i-Kashmir. New Delhi, India: Kitab Ghar, Billimaran.

[53] Khoihami, P.G.H. 1885. Tarikh-i-Hassan. Persian manuscript. Vols. I–II, folios 511 and 263. Srinagar, India: Research & Publication Division, Srinagar Library, University of Kashmir.

[54] Knight EF. Where three empires meet: A narrative of recent travel in Kashmir, western Tibet, Gilgit and the adjoining countries, 1893, London: Longmans

[55] Koul, A.N. 1710. The Muntakhab-u-Tawarikh. Srinagar, India: Research & Publication Division, Srinagar Library, University of Kashmir.

[56] Koul, P.A. 1925. Geography of Jammu & Kashmir State. Calcutta, India: Thacker, Spink and Co.

[57] Lawrence WR. The Valley of Kashmir, 1895, Oxford: Henry Frowde, Oxford University Press

[58] Leroy SAG. Bobrowsky PT. Historical events. Encyclopaedia of natural hazards, 2011, Heidelberg, Germany: Springer 452-470.

[59] Macnamara FN. Climate and medical topography in their relation to the disease distribution of the Himalayan and sub-Himalayan districts of British India, with reasons for assigning a malarious origin to goitre and some other disease, 1880, London: Longmans, Green & Co

[60] Mander H, Saxena NC. Hunger in the valley: Report on the implementation of food and livelihood schemes of Government in Kashmir, 2009, Department of Social Work: University of Kashmir

[61] McMichael AJ, Woodruff RE, Hales S. Climate change and human health: Present and future risks. Lancet, 2006, 367(9513): 859-869

[62] Miskeen, Mohi-ud-din. 1899. Tarikh-i-Kabir Kashmir. Research & Publication Division, Srinagar Library. Persian manuscript. Vols. I–II, folios 370 and 28.

[63] Mitra, A. 1889. Medical and surgical practices in Kashmir. Lahore, Pakistan.

[64] Moorcroft W, Trebeck G. Travels in the Himalayan Provinces of Hindustan and the Panjab; in Ladakh and Kashmir; in Peshawar, Kabul, Kunduz, and Bokhara; from 1819–1825, 1841, London: John Murray

[65] Neve, A. 1885. The late earthquake in Kashmir. Lancet 126(3236): Article 455.

[66] Neve A. Thirty years in Kashmir, 1913, London: Edward Arnold

[67] Neve A. Tourist guide to Kashmir, Ladakh, Iskhardo, 1913, Lahore, Pakistan: Civil and Military Gazette Press

[68] Neve EF. A brief account of the recent epidemic of cholera in Kashmir. British Medical Journal, 1900, 2(2085): 1705-1706

[69] Neve EF. Beyond the Pir Panjal: Life among the mountains and valleys of Kashmir, 1915, Salisbury Square, London: Church Missionary Society

[70] Neve EF. A crusader in Kashmir, 1928, London: Seeley, Service and Co

[71] Oliver-Smith A. Oliver-Smith A, Hoffman SM. What is a disaster? Anthropological perspectives on a persistent question. The angry earth: Disaster in anthropological perspective, 1999, London: Routledge 18-34

[72] Oliver-Smith A, Hoffman SM. Hoffman SM, Oliver-Smith A. Why anthropologists should study disasters. Catastrophe & culture: The anthropology of disaster, 2002, Santa Fe, New Mexico: School of American Research Press 3-22.

[73] Palerm, A. 1980. Anthropologíay Marxismo. Mexico, D.F.: Centro de Investigaciones superiores del instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia / Editorial Nueva Imagen (in Spanish).

[74] Paremu RK. A history of Sikh Rule in Kashmir, 1977, Srinagar, India: Government Press

[75] Purdon WH. On the trigonometrical survey and physical configuration of the Valley of Kashmir. Journal of the Royal Geographical Society, 1861, 31: 14-30

[76] Quinn, W.H. 1992. A study of Southern Oscillation-related climatic activity for A.D. 622–1900 incorporating Nile River flood data. In El Nino historical and paleoclimatic aspects of the Southern Oscillation, ed. H.F. Diaz, and V. Markgraf, 119–149. New York: Cambridge University Press.

[77] Quinn WH, Neal VT, Antunez De Maylo SE. El Nino occurrences over the past four and a half centuries. Journal of Geophysical Research, 1987, 92(C13): 14449-14461

[78] Rai M. Hindu rulers, muslim subjects: Islam, rights, and the history of Kashmir, 2004, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press

[79] Ram, B. 1891. Census of India: Reports on the Jammu and Kashmir State. Lahore, Pakistan: W. Ball and Co.

[80] Ram, G. 1928. Floods in Jammu and Kashmir. Jammu and Kashmir government flood management report. Published by the State Government.

[81] Ram PB. Report on the administration of the Jammu and Kashmir State for 1892–93, 1895, Jammu, India: Rambir Prakash Press

[82] Riede F. Towards a science of past disasters. Natural Hazards, 2014, 71: 335-362

[83] Riede, F. 2017. Past-forwarding ancient calamities: Pathways for making archaeology relevant in disaster risk reduction research. Humanities 6(4): Article 79.

[84] Schenk GJ. Knoll M, Reith R. Common grounds in early modern disaster experiences? Some remarks on new trends in historical disaster research as part of environmental history and climate history. An environmental history of the early modern period: Experience and perspective, 2014, Zurich: LIT Verlag 11-18.

[85] Schonberg BEV. Travels in India and Kashmir, 1853, London: Huest and Blackett

[86] Shoemaker MM. Indian pages and pictures: Rajputana, Sikkim, the Punjab, and Kashmir, 1912, New York: G.P. Putman Sons

[87] Sufi, G.M.D. 1948. Kashir. Lahore University of Punjab. Vol. II. New Delhi, India: Capital Publishing House.

[88] Suri, S. 1849. Umdat-ut-Tawarikh. Persian manuscript. Srinagar, India: Research & Publication Division, Srinagar Library.

[89] Thorp R. Cashmere misgovernment, 1870, London: Longmans, Green, and Co

[90] Tyndale-Biscoe CE. Thomas Russell Wade: A pioneer in Kashmir, 1921, London: Church Missionary Society

[91] Tyndale-Biscoe CE. Kashmir in sunlight and shade, 1922, London: Seeley, Service and Co

[92] Uppal, H.L. 1955. Book on River Jhelum, data collection section. Srinagar, India: P&P, Floods Division.

[93] UNICEF (United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund) UNICEF annual report, 2019, New York: UNICEF Division of Commission

[94] Vigne GT. Travels in Kashmir, Ladak, Iskardo, the countries adjoining the mountain-course of the Indus, and the Himalaya, north of the Panjab, 1842 2 London: H. Colburn

[95] Wakefield W. The Happy Valley: Sketches of Kashmir and the Kashmiris, 1879, London: S. Low, Marston, Searle, & Rivington

[96] Watts MJ, Bhole HG. The space of vulnerability: The causal structure of hunger and famine. Progress in Human Geography, 1993, 17(1): 69-76

[97] Wingate, A. 1888. Preliminary report of settlement operations in Kashmir and Jammu. Lahore, Pakistan: W. Ball and Co.

[98] Wisner B, Blaikie PP, Cannon T, Davis I. At risk: Natural hazards, people’s vulnerability and disasters, 2004 2 London: Routledge