Impacts as Triggers for Weather-Related Decision Making: Observations at the Berlin Fire Brigade Control and Dispatch Center

Abstract

This article presents the results of a series of ethnographic observations at the Berlin fire brigade control and dispatch center during routine and severe weather situations. The weather-related challenges of a fire brigade lie between the anticipation of events and their potential consequences, and the ad hoc reactions to actual impacts of weather. The results show that decisions and actions related to high impact weather are not necessarily motivated by weather warnings alone. Instead, they are reactions to the experience of impacts, for example, an increased number of missions or emergency calls. Impacts are the main trigger for the decision making. Weather is one additional external factor that influences the operational capability of a fire brigade. While commanding officers in a fire brigade control and dispatch center experience weather primarily through technical equipment, verified by ground truth, observations showed that direct personal contact with the regional weather service and colleagues on the ground takes on a greater role in actual severe weather situations. The observations point to the need for increased interagency communication between the emergency services, the weather service, and other organizations to integrate weather information, impacts, and non-weather-related tasks into coherent weather-related decision making.

Keywords

Berlin / Emergency services / Fire brigades / Impact-based emergency response / Interagency communication / Weather-related decision making

References

[1] Apelt M. Jenki M, Ellebrecht N, Kaufmann S. Organizations of emergency and rescue—An introduction from a socio-organizational perspective (Organisationen des Notfalls und der Rettung—Eine Einführung aus Organisationssoziologischer Perspektive). Organizations and experts of emergency in the transformation of technology and culture of fire and rescue services (Organisationen und Experten des Notfalls. Zum Wandel von Technik und Kultur bei Feuerwehr und Rettungsdiensten). Zivile Sicherheit 7, 2014, Berlin: LIT 69-84 (in German)

[2] Apelt M, Tacke V. Apelt M, Tacke V. Introduction (Einleitung). Handbook of organization types (Handbuch Organisationstypen), 2012, Wiesbaden: Springer 7-20 (in German)

[3] Créton-Cazanave L. Warning! The use of meteorological information during a flash-flood warning process. Advances in Science and Research, 2009, 3(1): 99-103

[4] Créton-Cazanave L, Lutoff C. Stakeholders' issues for action during the warning process and the interpretation of forecasts' uncertainties. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2013, 13(6): 1469-1479

[5] Ellebrecht N, Jenki M. Jenki M, Ellebrecht N, Kaufmann S. Organizations and experts of emergency: A research overview (Organisationen und Experten des Notfalls: Ein Forschungsüberblick). Organizations and experts of emergency in the transformation of technology and culture of fire and rescue services (Organisationen und Experten des Notfalls. Zum Wandel von Technik und Kultur bei Feuerwehr und Rettungsdiensten). Zivile Sicherheit 7, 2014, Berlin: LIT 11-48 (in German)

[6] Fine GA. Authors of the storm: Meteorologists and the culture of prediction, 2007, Chicago: University of Chicago Press

[7] Fundel VJ, Fleischhut N, Herzog SM, Göber M, Hagedorn R. Promoting the use of probabilistic weather forecasts through a dialogue between scientists, developers and end-users. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society, 2019, 57(7): 210-231

[8] Kox T, Lüder C, Brune C. Kox T, Gerhold L. Weather warnings in civil protection: Observations at a fire brigade control and dispatch center (Wetterwarnungen im Bevölkerungsschutz: Beobachtung einer Feuerwehrleitstelle). Weather warnings: From extreme event information to communication and action: Contributions from the research project WEXICOM (Wetterwarnungen: Von der Extremereignisinformation zu Kommunikation und Handlung: Beiträge aus dem Forschungsprojekt WEXICOM), 2019, Berlin: orschungsforum Öffentliche Sicherheit, Freie Universität Berlin 87-107 (in German)

[9] Kox T, Lüder C, Gerhold L. Anticipation and response: Emergency services in severe weather situations in Germany. Internation Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2018, 9(1): 116-128

[10] Lauche K. Badke-Schaub P, Hofinger G, Lauche K. New forms of cooperation (Neue Formen der Zusammenarbeit). Human factors—The psychology of secure action in risk sectors (Human factors—Psychologie sicheren Handelns in Risikobranchen), 2012 2 Dordrecht: Springer 205-218 (in German)

[11] Lüder C. Kox T, Gerhold L. Weather as a technology-supported process of knowing (Wetter als technisch vermittelter Wissensprozess). Weather warnings: From extreme event information to communication and action: Contributions from the research project WEXICOM (Wetterwarnungen: Von der Extremereignisinformation zu Kommunikation und Handlung: Beiträge aus dem Forschungsprojekt WEXICOM), 2019, Berlin: Forschungsforum Öffentliche Sicherheit, Freie Universität Berlin 19-41 (in German)

[12] Morss RE, Demuth JL, Lazo JK. Communicating uncertainty in weather forecasts: A survey of the U.S. public. Weather and Forecasting, 2008, 23: 974-991

[13] Pardowitz T. Modelling vulnerability to severe weather. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2018, 18(6): 1617-1631

[14] Potter S, Harrison S, Kreft P. The benefits and challenges of implementing impact-based severe weather warning systems: Perspectives of weather, flood, and emergency management personnel. Weather Climate, and Society, 2021, 13(2): 303-314

[15] Potter S, Kreft P, Milojev P, Noble C, Montz B, Dhellemmes A, Woods RJ, Gauden-Ing S. The influence of impact-based severe weather warnings on risk perceptions and intended protective actions. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2018, 30(Part A): 34-43

[16] Simmer C, Adrian G, Jones S, Wirth V, Göber M, Hohenegger C, Janjic T, Keller J HErZ: The German Hans-Ertel Centre for weather research. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 2016, 97(6): 1057-1068

[17] Taylor AL, Kox T, Johnston D. Communicating high impact weather: Improving warnings and decision making processes. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2018, 30(Part A): 1-4

[18] WMO (World Meteorological Organization) WMO guidelines on multi-hazard impact-based forecast and warning services, 2015, Geneva: WMO

[19] Zhang Q, Li L, Ebert B, Golding B, Johnston D, Mills B, Panchuk S, Potter S Increasing the value of weather-related warnings. Science Bulletin, 2019, 64(10): 647-649