Beyond the Expected—Residual Risk and Cases of Overload in the Context of Managing Alpine Natural Hazards

Abstract

Structural protection measures are designed to protect the population and infrastructure against natural hazards up to a specific predefined protection goal. Extreme events with intensities that exceed the capacity of these protection structures are called “cases of overload” and are associated with “residual risks” that remain after the implementation of protection measures. In order to address residual risks and to reduce the damages from overload events, a combination of structural protection measures with additional, nonstructural measures is required. Based on data collected through a literature review, a questionnaire survey, expert interviews, and an expert workshop we highlight the status quo as well as key challenges of dealing with residual risks and cases of overload in Alpine countries in the context of geohydrological hazards and gravitational mass movements. We present a holistic conceptual framework that describes the relationships of residual risks, cases of overload, and protection goals in the context of both risk governance and integrated risk management. This framework is valuable for decision makers aiming at an improved management of natural hazards that takes adequate account of residual risk and cases of overload in Alpine countries and mountain areas worldwide.

Keywords

Alpine countries / Cases of overload / Integrated risk management / Natural hazards / Residual risk / Risk governance

References

[1] APCC (Austrian Panel on Climate Change). 2014. Austrian progress report on climate change 2014 (Österreichischer Sachstandsbericht Klimawandel 2014). Vienna: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften (in German).

[2] BAFU (Federal Office for the Environment (Bundesamt für Umwelt)). 2016a. From risk analysis to planning of measures—Working basis for flood protection projects (Von der Risikoanalyse zur Massnahmenplanung—Arbeitsgrundlage für Hochwasserschutzprojekte). Bern: BAFU (in German).

[3] BAFU (Federal Office for the Environment (Bundesamt für Umwelt)). 2016b. Protection against mass movement hazards. Enforcement aid for the risk management of landslides, rockfalls and debris flows (Schutz vor Massenbewegungsgefahren. Vollzugshilfe für das Gefahrenmanagement von Rutschungen, Steinschlag und Hangmuren). Bern: BAFU (in German).

[4] Bornstein, C. 2010. Flexible and good-natured protection concepts and structures—An answer to the case of overload and uncertain design bases (Flexible und gutmütige Schutzkonzepte und—bauwerke—Eine Antwort auf den Überlastfall und unsichere Bemessungsgrundlagen). Diploma thesis, Technical University Munich, Germany (in German).

[5] Buchecker M, Ogasa DM, Maidl E. How well do the wider public accept integrated flood risk management? An empirical study in two Swiss Alpine Valleys. Environmental Science & Policy, 2016, 55(2): 309-317

[6] Büchele B, Kreibich H, Kron A, Thieken A, Ihringer J, Oberle P, Merz B, Nestmann F. Flood-risk mapping—Contributions towards an enhanced assessment of extreme events and associated risks. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2006, 6(4): 485-503

[7] Camenzind, R., and R. Loat. 2014. Risk-based spatial planning: Synthesis report on two case studies at communal land use planning level. Bern: National Platform for Natural Hazards, Federal Office for Spatial Development, and Federal Office for the Environment.

[8] EEA (European Environmental Agency). 2009. EEA signals 2009—Key environmental issues facing Europe. Copenhagen: EEA.

[9] EEA (European Environmental Agency). 2010. EEA signals 2010—Biodiversity, climate change and you. Copenhagen: EEA.

[10] EEA (European Environmental Agency). 2017. Climate change adaptation and disaster risk reduction in Europe. Enhancing coherence of the knowledge base, policies and practices. EEA report 15. Copenhagen: EEA.

[11] Einhorn, B., and C. Peisser. 2011. Adaptation of natural risk management in the face of climate change (Adaptation de la gestion des risques naturels face au changement climatique). Contribution to the International Expert Seminar “Adaptation to Climate Change in the Alpine Space”, 25 November 2011, L’Argentière la Béssée, France (in French).

[12] FOCP (Federal Office for Civil Protection). 2014. Integrated risk management—Its importance in protecting people and their livelihoods. Bern: FOCP.

[13] Fuchs S, Röthlisberger V, Thaler T, Zischg A, Keiler M. Natural hazard management from a coevolutionary perspective: Exposure and policy response in the European Alps. Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 2017, 107(2): 382-392

[14] Grobicki A, MacLeod F, Pischke F. Integrated policies and practices for flood and drought risk management. Water Policy, 2015, 17(S1): 180-194

[15] Holub M, Fuchs S. Mitigating mountain hazards in Austria—Legislation, risk transfer and awareness building. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2009, 9(2): 523-537

[16] Klinke A, Renn O. The coming age of risk governance. Risk Analysis, 2019

[17] Knight J, Keiler M. McGuire B, Maslin M. Impacts of recent and future climate change on natural hazards in the European Alps. Climate forcing of geological hazards, 2013, London: Wiley-Blackwell 223-249.

[18] Loat R. Risk management of natural hazards in Switzerland, 2010, Bern: Federal Office for the Environment

[19] Löschner, L., M. Herrnegger, B. Apperl, T. Senoner, W. Seher, and H.P. Nachtnebel. 2017. Flood risk, climate change and settlement development. A micro-scale assessment of Austrian municipalities. Regional Environmental Change 17(2): 311–322.

[20] Luhmann L. Risk: A sociological theory, 1993, New York: Aldine de Gruyter

[21] Mosello, B. 2011. Climate change and patterns of governance in Alpine regions. The case of water management in the Aosta and Ossola Valleys. Contribution to the EUSA 12th Biennial International Conference, 3–5 March 2011, Boston, USA.

[22] Nelson DR, Adger WN, Brown K. Adaptation to environmental change: Contributions of a resilience framework. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 2007, 32: 395-419

[23] Permanent Secretariat of the Alpine Convention. 2019. Natural hazard risk governance—Report on the State of the Alps. Alpine signals, special edition 7. Innsbruck, Austria: Permanent Secretariat of the Alpine Convention.

[24] PLANALP (Platform on Natural Hazards of the Alpine Convention) Alpine strategy for adaptation to climate change in the field of natural hazards, 2012, Bern: PLANALP

[25] PLANAT (National Platform for Natural Hazards). 2014. Strategy protection against natural hazards. Security level for natural hazards. Bern: PLANAT.

[26] Polman, N., W. Slee, T. Kluvánková, M. Dijkshoorn, M. Nijnik, V. Gezik, and K. Soma. 2017. Classification of social innovations for marginalized rural areas. SIMRA (Social Innovation in Marginalised Rural Areas). http://www.simra-h2020.eu/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/D2.1-Classification-of-SI-for-MRAs-in-the-target-region.pdf. Accessed 10 Nov 2020.

[27] Renn, O. 2005. White paper on risk governance—Towards an integrative approach. Geneva: IRGC (International Risk Governance Council).

[28] Renn O. Risk governance—Coping with uncertainty in a complex world, 2008, London: Earthscan

[29] Renn O, Sellke P. Risk, society and policy making: Risk governance in a complex world. International Journal of Performability Engineering, 2011, 7(4): 349-366.

[30] Renn O, Klinke A, van Asselt M. Coping with complexity, uncertainty and ambiguity in risk governance: A synthesis. Ambio, 2011, 40(2): 231-246

[31] Schneiderbauer, S., S. Hartmann, C. Dalla Torre, N. Dinkelaker, A. Sankowsky, C. Hoffmann, L. Pedoth, and T. Streifeneder. 2018a. Natural hazards in the Alpine region: Dealing with cases of overload and the residual risk. Munich: Bayarian State Ministry for the Environment and Consumer Protection (Bayerisches Staatsministerium für Umwelt und Verbraucherschutz).

[32] Schneiderbauer S, Berger H, Hartmann S, Rimböck A, Dalla Torre C, Pedoth L. Kanonier A, Rudolf-Miklau F. Dealing with residual risk: Situation analysis and challenges in the Alpine space (Der Umgang mit verbleibendem Risiko: Situationsanalyse und Herausforderungen im Alpenraum). Regional risk governance: Law, policy and practice (Regionale Risiko Governance: Recht, Politik und Praxis), 2018, Vienna: Verlag Österreich 541-553 (in German)

[33] Stoffel M, Tiranti D, Huggel C. Climate change impacts on mass movements—Case studies from the European Alps. Science of the Total Environment, 2014, 493: 1255-1266

[34] Zebisch M, Vaccaro R, Niedrist G, Schneiderbauer S, Streifeneder T, Weiß M, Troi A, Renner K Climate report—South Tyrol (Klimareport—Südtirol), 2018, Bolzano: Eurac Research (in German and Italian)