Closing the Gaps in Disaster Management and Response: Drawing on Local Experiences with Cyclone Idai in Chimanimani, Zimbabwe

Abstract

Cyclone Idai in Zimbabwe exposed deficiencies in the country’s disaster management system. This study uses a phenomenological case exploration of the experiences of local residents in Rusitu Valley following cyclone-induced floods that affected the area in March 2019. Through capturing narratives of participants who were recruited through chain referrals, the research intends to understand how local actors, utilizing their local-based response systems, managed to fill in the voids that characterize disaster management practice in Zimbabwe. Results show that the participation of local “heroes” and “Samaritans,” by deploying their social networks, norms, relationships, practices, and modest ingenuity, helped to speed up response times and minimize threats to lives and livelihoods. Documentation of the stories of local actors about their disaster experiences also gives a richer picture of the Cyclone Idai disaster. Although the community response system also facilitated the operation of external disaster management agencies, their premature withdrawal tended to weaken the trust and values existing in the area, and created tensions between the disaster-affected people and other villagers. Given the delays in formal responses by the government and other external relief agencies, the practices of local actors, although spontaneous and largely uncoordinated, offer rich insights into the design and development of disaster management regimes.

Keywords

Cyclone Idai / Flood disaster management / Local knowledge and action / Social networks / Zimbabwe

References

[1] Alexander D. The L’Aquila Earthquake of 6 April 2009 and Italian government policy on disaster response. Journal of Natural Resource Policy Research, 2010, 2(4): 325-342

[2] Allen KM. Community-based disaster preparedness and climate adaptation: Local capacity-building in the Philippines. Disasters, 2006, 30(1): 81-101

[3] Appleby-Arnold S, Brockdorff N, Jakovljev I, Zdravković S. Applying cultural values to encourage disaster preparedness: Lessons from a low-hazard country. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2018, 31: 37-44

[4] Becker P. Dependence, trust, and influence of external actors on municipal urban flood risk mitigation: The case of Lomma Municipality, Sweden. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2018, 31: 1004-1012

[5] Bene, C., R. Godfrey-Wood, A. Newsham, and M. Davies. 2012. Resilience: New Utopia or New Tyranny? Reflection about the potentials and limits of the concept of resilience in relation to vulnerability-reduction programmes. IDS working paper 405. Brighton: Institute of Development Studies.

[6] Bolin R, Stanford L. The Northridge Earthquake: Community-based approaches to unmet recovery needs. Disasters, 1998, 22(1): 21-38

[7] Bongo, P.P., and S.B. Manyena. 2015. From “government” to “governance”: Tensions in disaster-resilience leadership in Zimbabwe. Jàmbá: Journal of Disaster Risk Studies 7(1): Article 188.

[8] Brown, D., R. Chanakira, K. Chatiza, M. Dhliwayo, D. Dodman, M. Masiiwa, D. Muchadenyika, P. Mugabe, and S. Zvigadza. 2012. Climate change impacts, vulnerability and adaptation in Zimbabwe. Climate change working paper 3. London: International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED).

[9] Burningham K, Fielding J, Thrush D. It’ll never happen to me: Understanding public awareness of local flood risk. Disasters, 2008, 32(2): 216-238

[10] Burton I, Kates RW, White GF. The environment as hazard, 1993 2 New York: Guilford Press

[11] Chitamba J, Manjeru P, Chinheya CC, Mudada N, Handiseni M. Plant-parasitic nematodes associated with banana (Musa spp.) in Rusitu Valley, Zimbabwe. Nematropica, 2013, 43(1): 113-118.

[12] Copernicus. 2019. Flood post-event situation. Rusitu Valley, Zimbabwe. https://emergency.copernicus.eu/mapping/system/files/components/EMSR349_05RUSITUVALLEYNORTH_02GRADING_MAP_v1_300dpi.pdf. Accessed 19 Feb 2020.

[13] Davern M, Hachen DS. Social network structure and job mobility. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 2006, 65(2): 269-293

[14] Działek J, Biernacki W, Bokwa A. Neef A, Shaw R. Impact of social capital on local communities’ response to floods in southern Poland. Risks and conflicts: Local responses to natural disasters, 2014, Bingley: Emerald Publishers 185-205.

[15] FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization). 2006. Zimbabwe’s natural regions and farming systems. http://www.fao.org/3/a0395e/a0395e06.htm#bm06. Accessed 29 May 2020.

[16] Grootaert C, Van Bastelaer T. Understanding and measuring social capital: A multidisciplinary tool for practitioners, 2002, Washington, DC: The World Bank

[17] Gwimbi P. Linking rural community livelihoods to resilience building in flood risk reduction in Zimbabwe. Jàmbá: Journal of Disaster Risk Studies, 2009, 2(1): 71-79

[18] Hawkins RL, Maurer K. Bonding, bridging and linking: How social capital operated in New Orleans following Hurricane Katrina. British Journal of Social Work, 2010, 40(6): 1777-1793

[19] Islam R, Walkerden G. Social networks and challenges in government disaster policies: A case study from Bangladesh. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2017, 22: 325-334

[20] Kapucu N. Collaborative emergency management: Better community organising, better public preparedness and response. Disasters, 2008, 32(2): 239-262

[21] Kelman, I. 2019. Axioms and actions for preventing disasters. Progress in Disaster Science 2: Article 100008.

[22] Lunga, W. 2015. The inclusion of indigenous knowledge systems into disaster risk reduction policy: The case of Zimbabwe. Ph.D. thesis. Potchefstroom: North West University.

[23] Manyena SB. The concept of resilience revisited. Disasters, 2006, 30(4): 433-450

[24] Manyena SB, Mavhura E, Muzenda C, Mabaso E. Disaster risk reduction legislations: Is there a move from events to processes?. Global Environmental Change, 2013, 23: 1786-1794

[25] Mararike CG. Survival strategies in rural Zimbabwe: The role of asset, indigenous knowledge and organisation, 2011, Harare: Best Practices Books

[26] McKay JM. Community response to hazard information. Disasters, 1984, 8(2): 118-123

[27] Misra S, Goswami R, Jana R. Social networks in the context of community response to disaster: Study of a cyclone-affected community in coastal West Bengal, India. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2017, 22: 281-296

[28] Molyneux M. Mothers and the service of the new policy agenda: Progresa/Oportunidades, Mexico’s conditional transfer programme. Social Policy and Administration, 2006, 40(4): 425-449

[29] Mugandani R, Wuta M, Makarau A, Chipindu B. Re-classification of agro-ecological regions of Zimbabwe in conformity with climate variability and change. African Crop Science Journal, 2012, 20(2): 361-369.

[30] Oxfam Cyclone Idai in Zimbabwe: An analysis of policy implications for post-disaster institutional development to strengthen disaster risk management, 2019, Oxford: Oxfam International

[31] Preston J, Chadderton C, Kitagawa K, Edmonds C. Community response in disasters: An ecological learning framework. International Journal of Lifelong Education, 2015, 34(6): 727-753

[32] Rajeev MM. Sustainability and community empowerment in disaster management. International Journal of Social Work and Human Services, 2014, 2(6): 207-212.

[33] Simba, F.M. 2018. Zimbabwe’s preparedness in managing meteorological disasters: A case of applying disaster risk management in managing impacts of climate change. Journal of Geography and Natural Disasters 8(3). https://doi.org/10.4172/2167-0587.1000231.

[34] Siyongwana PQ, Heinjie D, Tele A. Vulnerability and coping strategies of low income communities to flood hazards, Missionvale, South Africa. Journal of Human Ecology, 2015, 52(1–2): 104-115

[35] Smith DI, Handmer JW. Urban flooding in Australia: Policy development and implementation. Disasters, 1984, 8(2): 105-117

[36] Speller, G. 2005. Improving community and citizen engagement in flood risk management decision making, delivery and flood response. R and D technical report (SC040033/SR3). Bristol: Environment Agency.

[37] Troy DA, Carson A, Vanderbeek J, Hutton A. Enhancing community-based disaster preparedness with information technology. Disasters, 2008, 32(1): 149-165

[38] Twigg J. The age of accountability?: Future community involvement in disaster reduction. Australian Journal of Emergency Management, 1999, 14(4): 51-58.

[39] Varda DM, Forgette R, Banks D, Contractor N. Social network methodology in the study of disasters: Issues and insights prompted by post-Katrina research. Population Research and Policy Review, 2009, 28(1): 11-29

[40] Yila O, Weber E, Neef A. Neef A, Shaw R. The role of social capital in post-flood response and recovery among downstream communities of the Ba River, Western Viti Levu, Fiji Islands. Risks and conflicts: Local responses to natural disasters, 2013, Bingley: Emerald Publishers 79-107

[41] ZimStat (Zimbabwe National Statistical Agency) Census 2012, Manicaland Province, 2013, Harare: ZimStat

[42] Zubir, S.S., and H. Amirrol. 2011. Disaster risk reduction through community participation. In Management of Natural Resources, Sustainable Development and Ecological Hazards (WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment 148), ed. C.A. Brebbia, and S.S. Zubir, 195–206. Ashurst, New Forest, U.K.: Wessex Institute of Technology Press.