Barriers to Insurance as a Flood Risk Management Tool: Evidence from a Survey of Property Owners

Abstract

By using risk-adjusted price signals to transfer responsibility for property-level flood protection and recovery from governments to property owners, flood insurance represents a key tenet of the flood risk management (FRM) paradigm. The Government of Canada has worked with insurers to introduce flood insurance for the first time as a part of a broader shift towards FRM to limit the growing costs of flooding. The viability of flood insurance in Canada, however, has been questioned by research that disputes the utility of purchasing coverage by property owners. This study tested this assumption by drawing on public opinion survey data to assess factors that influence decisions about the utility of insurance. The findings reveal that Canadians have limited knowledge of flood insurance coverage, exhibit a low willingness-to-pay for both insurance and property-level flood protection measures, and expect governments to shoulder much of the financial burden of flood recovery through disaster assistance.

Keywords

Flood insurance / Flood risk management / Risk-sharing / Willingness-to-pay

References

[1] Affeltranger B. Public participation in the design of local strategies for flood mitigation and control, 2001, Paris: International Hydrological Programme, UNESCO

[2] Begum S, Stive MJF, Hall JW. Flood risk management in Europe: Innovation in policy and practice, 2007, Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer, Netherlands

[3] Birkholz S, Muro M, Jeffrey P, Smith HM. Rethinking the relationship between flood risk perception and flood management. Science of the Total Environment, 2014, 478(1): 12-20.

[4] Botzen WJW, van den Bergh JCJM. Insurance against climate change and flooding in the Netherlands: Present, future and comparison with other countries. Risk Analysis, 2008, 28(2): 413-426.

[5] Botzen WJW, van den Bergh JCJM. Risk attitudes to low-probability climate change risks: WTP for flood insurance. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 2012, 82(1): 151-166.

[6] British Columbia. Emergency Management. 2016. Disaster Financial Assistance (DFA) and residential flood insurance. Victoria, BC: Government of British Columbia. https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/public-safety-and-emergency-services/emergency-preparedness-response-recovery/embc/dfa/residential_flood_insurance.pdf. Accessed 15 Dec 2016.

[7] Bubeck P, Botzen WJW, Kreibich H, Aerts JCJH. Detailed insights into the influence of flood-coping appraisals on mitigation behaviour. Global Environmental Change, 2013, 23(5): 1327-1338.

[8] Calamai L, Minano A. Emerging trends and future pathways: A commentary on the present state and future of residential flood insurance in Canada. Canadian Water Resources Journal, 2017, 42(4): 307-314.

[9] Canadian Underwriter. 2017. Severe weather, nat-cats cause record insurable damage in Canada: IBC/CATIQ. Toronto: Canadian Underwriter. https://www.canadianunderwriter.ca/catastrophes/severe-weather-nat-cats-cause-record-insurable-damage-canada-ibccatiq-1004106311/. Accessed 17 Feb 2018.

[10] Carson RT, Groves T. Incentive and informational properties of preference questions. Environmental and Resource Economics, 2007, 37(1): 181-210.

[11] Casey, M. 2015. Global cost of flooding to increase tenfold by 2030. CBS News. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/global-cost-of-flooding-to-increase-tenfold-by-2030/. Accessed 17 Jan 2017.

[12] CBC News. 2017. Canadian homeowners in the dark about flood risks, study suggests. https://www.cbc.ca/radio/thecurrent/the-current-for-may-5-2017-1.4099475/canadian-homeowners-in-the-dark-about-flood-risks-study-suggests-1.4099513. Accessed 6 May 2017.

[13] Cheng CS, Li Q, Li G, Auld H. Climate change and heavy rainfall-related water damage insurance claims and losses in Ontario, Canada. Journal of Water Resource and Protection, 2012, 4(2): 49-62.

[14] Cheng CS, Li Q, Li G, Auld H. Possible impacts of climate change on daily streamflow and extremes at local scale in Ontario, Canada. Part II: Future projection. Atmospheric and Climate Sciences, 2012, 2: 427-440.

[15] de Moel H, van Alphen J, Aerts JCJH. Flood maps in Europe – Methods, availability and use. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2009, 9(2): 289-301.

[16] DEFRA (Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs). 2017. Flood risk assessment: Local planning authorities. London: DEFRA. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/flood-risk-assessment-local-planning-authorities. Accessed 9 Jun 2019.

[17] Environment and Climate Change Canada. 2013. Flood Damage Reduction Program. https://www.ec.gc.ca/eau-water/default.asp?lang=En&n=0365F5C2-1. Accessed 23 May 2017.

[18] European Commission. 2007. A new EU floods directive – Environment – European Commission. Belgium: European Commission. https://ec.europa.eu/environment/water/flood_risk/. Accessed 20 Jun 2020.

[19] FEMA (Federal Emergency Management Agency). 2017. Map modernization. Washington, DC: FEMA. https://www.fema.gov/map-modernization. Accessed 4 Mar 2020.

[20] Filatova T. Market-based instruments for flood risk management: A review of theory, practice and perspectives for climate adaptation policy. Environmental Science & Policy, 2014, 37(1): 227-242.

[21] Government of Canada. 2018. National Disaster Mitigation Program (NDMP). Ottawa: Government of Canada. https://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/mrgnc-mngmnt/dsstr-prvntn-mtgtn/ndmp/index-en.aspx. Accessed 10 Jan 2020.

[22] Hegger, D., P.P.J. Driessen, M. Wiering, H.F.M.W. van Rijswick, Z.W. Kundzewicz, P. Matczak, A. Crabbé, G.T. Raadgever, et al. 2016. Toward more flood resilience: Is a diversification of flood risk management strategies the way forward? Ecology and Society 21(4): Article 52.

[23] Henstra, D., and J. Thistlethwaite. 2017. Climate change, floods, and municipal risk sharing in Canada. IMFG papers on Municipal Finance and Governance, No. 30. Toronto: Institute on Municipal Finance and Governance. https://munkschool.utoronto.ca/imfg/uploads/373/1917_imfg_no_30_online_final.pdf. Accessed 9 Apr 2020.

[24] Henstra D, Minano A, Thistlethwaite J. Communicating disaster risk? An evaluation of the availability and quality of flood maps. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2019, 19(1): 313-323.

[25] Hudson P, Botzen WJW, Czajkowski J, Kreibich H. Moral hazard in natural disaster insurance markets: Empirical evidence from Germany and the United States. Land Economics, 2017, 92(2): 179-208.

[26] IBC (Insurance Bureau of Canada). The financial management of flood risk: An international review of lessons learned from flood management programs in G8 Countries, 2015, Toronto, ON: IBC

[27] IBC (Insurance Bureau of Canada). 2019. Options for managing flood costs of Canada’s highest risk residential properties. Toronto, ON: IBC. https://www.ibc.ca/on/resources/studies/options-for-managing-flood-costs-of-canada%E2%80%99s-highest-risk-residential-properties. Accessed 5 Jan 2020.

[28] Keating, K., P. May, A. Pettit, and R. Pickering. 2015. Cost estimation for household flood resistance and resilience measures – Summary of evidence. London, UK: Environment Agency. https://evidence.environment-agency.gov.uk/FCERM/Libraries/FCERM_Project_Documents/SC080039_cost_house_resist_and_resilience.sflb.ashx. Accessed 6 Jan 2020.

[29] Kim BJ, Schlesinger H. Adverse selection in an insurance market with government-guaranteed subsistence levels. Journal of Risk and Insurance, 2005, 72(1): 61-75.

[30] Klijn F, Samuels P, Van Os A. Towards flood risk management in the EU: State of affairs with examples from various European countries. International Journal of River Basin Management, 2008, 6(4): 307-321.

[31] Lara A, Saurí D, Ribas A, Pavón D. Social perceptions of floods and flood management in a Mediterranean area (Costa Brava, Spain). Natural Hazards and Earth System Science, 2010, 10(10): 2081-2091.

[32] Lewis T, Nickerson D. Self-insurance against natural disasters. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 1989, 16(3): 209-223.

[33] Lo AY. Household preference and financial commitment to flood insurance in South-East Queensland. Australian Economic Review, 2013, 46(2): 160-175.

[34] Ludy J, Matt Kondolf G. Flood risk perception in lands ‘protected’ by 100-year levees. Natural Hazards, 2012, 61(2): 829-842.

[35] Manitoba. 2017. Disaster financial assistance. Winnipeg, MB: Government of Manitoba. https://www.gov.mb.ca/emo/recover/home/dfa_home.html. Accessed 7 Jan 2019.

[36] Minano, A., and S. Peddle. 2018. Using flood maps for community flood risk communication. Report prepared for Natural Resources Canada. Waterloo, ON: Partners for Action. https://uwaterloo.ca/partners-for-action/sites/ca.partners-for-action/files/uploads/files/using_flood_maps_for_community_flood_risk_communication_24jan18_fnl.pdf. Accessed 20 May 2019.

[37] MMM Group Limited. 2014. National floodplain mapping assessment: Final report. Ottawa, ON: Public Safety Canada.

[38] OAG (Office of the Auditor General of Canada). 2016. Report 2 – Mitigating the impacts of severe weather. Ottawa, ON: Office of the Auditor General of Canada. https://www.oag-bvg.gc.ca/internet/English/parl_cesd_201605_02_e_41381.html#p34. Accessed 15 Jul 2019.

[39] Oulahen G. Flood insurance in Canada: Implications for flood management and residential vulnerability to flood hazards. Environmental Management, 2015, 55(3): 603-615.

[40] Owusu S, Wright G, Arthur S. Public attitudes towards flooding and property-level flood protection measures. Natural Hazards, 2015, 77(2): 1963-1978.

[41] Parker DJ, Priest SJ, Tapsell SM. Understanding and enhancing the public’s behavioural response to flood warning information. Meteorological Applications, 2009, 16(1): 103-114.

[42] PBO (Parliamentary Budget Officer). Estimate of the average annual cost for disaster financial assistance arrangements due to weather events, 2016, Ottawa, ON: Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer

[43] Petrolia D, Landry C, Coble K. Risk preferences, risk perceptions and flood insurance. Land Economics, 2013, 89(2): 227-245.

[44] Public Safety Canada. 2017. 2016–2017 evaluation of the disaster financial assistance arrangements. Ottawa, ON: Government of Canada. https://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/rsrcs/pblctns/vltn-dsstr-fnncl-ssstnc-2016-17/index-en.aspx#s42. Accessed 13 Sept 2019.

[45] Sandink, D. 2013. Open to interpretation. Canadian Underwriter (blog), 1 January 2013. https://www.canadianunderwriter.ca/features/open-to-interpretation/. Accessed 9 Apr 2020.

[46] Sandink, D., P. Kovacs, G. Oulahen, and G. McGillivray. 2010. Making flood insurable for Canadian homeowners: A discussion paper. Toronto, ON: Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction & Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd. https://www.iclr.org/wp-content/uploads/PDFS/making-flood-insurable-for-canadian-homeowners.pdf. Accessed 12 Jan 2019.

[47] Sandink D, Kovacs P, Oulahen G, Shrubsole D. Public relief and insurance for residential flood losses in Canada: Current status and commentary. Canadian Water Resources Journal, 2016, 41(1–2): 220-237.

[48] Sayers P, Yuanyuan L, Galloway G, Penning-Rowsell E, Fuxin S, Kang W, Yiwei C, Le Quesne T. Flood risk management: A strategic approach, 2013, Paris: UNESCO

[49] Seifert I, Botzen WJW, Kreibich H, Aerts JCJ. Influence of flood risk characteristics on flood insurance demand: A comparison between Germany and the Netherlands. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2013, 13(7): 1691-1705.

[50] Shrubsole D. Flood management in Canada at the crossroads. Environmental Hazards, 2000, 2(2): 63-75.

[51] Simonovic SP. Floods in a changing climate: Risk management, 2013, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

[52] Square One Insurance Services. 2016. Square One finds 65% of Canadians wrongfully believe that home insurance protects against flood damage. Vancouver: Square One Insurance Services. https://www.squareoneinsurance.com/inland-flood-protection. Accessed12 Jul 2019.

[53] Terpstra T, Gutteling JM. Households’ perceived responsibilities in flood risk management in The Netherlands. International Journal of Water Resources Development, 2008, 24(4): 555-565.

[54] Thieken AH, Kreibich H, Müller M, Merz B. Coping with floods: Preparedness, response and recovery of flood-affected residents in Germany in 2002. Hydrological Sciences Journal, 2007, 52(5): 1016-1037.

[55] Thieken, A., S. Kienzler, H. Kreibich, C. Kuhlicke, M. Kunz, B. Mühr, M. Müller, et al. 2016. Review of the flood risk management system in Germany after the major flood in 2013. Ecology and Society 21(2): Article 51.

[56] Thistlethwaite J. The emergence of flood insurance in Canada: Navigating institutional uncertainty. Risk Analysis, 2016, 37(4): 744-755.

[57] Thistlethwaite, J., and D. Henstra. 2017. Protection for those who need it most: Sustainable property insurance in high-risk areas. Waterloo, ON: Centre for International Governance Innovation. https://www.cigionline.org/publications/protection-those-who-need-it-most-sustainable-property-insurance-high-risk-areas. Accessed 18 Mar 2019.

[58] Twigger-Ross C, Orr P, Brooks K, Sadaukis R, Deeming H, Fielding J, Harres T, Johnston R Flood resilience community pathfinder evaluation: Final evaluation report, 2015, London, UK: Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs

[59] United Nations The human cost of weather-related disasters 1995–2015, 2015, Geneva: United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction

[60] Wachinger G, Renn O, Begg C, Kuhlicke C. The risk perception paradox—Implications for governance and communication of natural hazards. Risk Analysis, 2013, 33(6): 1049-1065.

[61] Wamsley GL, Schroeder AD. Escalating in a quagmire: The changing dynamics of the emergency management policy subsystem. Public Administration Review, 1996, 56(3): 235-246.

[62] Winsemius HC, Aerts JCJH, van Beek LPH, Bierkens MFP, Bouwman A, Jongman B, Kwadijk JCJ, Ligtvoet W Global drivers of future river flood risk. Nature Climate Change, 2016, 6(4): 381-385.

[63] World Meteorological Organization Risk sharing in flood management, 2013, Geneva: World Meteorological Organization