“What is a Sociologist Doing Here?” An Unconventional People-Centered Approach to Improve Warning Implementation in the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction

Abstract

The Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030 recommends several actions for early warning systems (EWSs). However, there is a lack of information about their means of implementation. This article used institutional ethnography to analyze the 2012–2018 implementation of a national warning system in Brazil. The challenges related to daily activities, and the interdisciplinary works in the four axes of EWSs towards multi-hazard and people-centered approaches are discussed. This national experience is then discussed in the light of the global challenges of EWSs considering two main issues: (1) experiences of implementation and barriers related to people-centered warning systems; and (2) types of national/regional warning systems and hazards/threats that are being monitored as an important input for multi-hazard approaches. There are few multi-hazard warning systems in place and EWSs are focused on hydrometeorological hazards, mainly related to floods. The Sendai Framework needs to improve access to data and information, identify views from the frontline, consider political threats and vulnerabilities, and find ways to talk about disaster risk creation processes at a larger scale.

Keywords

Risk governance / Interdisciplinary research / People-centered warning systems

References

[1] Acosta VG. Risk as social construction and the social production of risk (El riesgo como construcción social y la construcción social de riesgos). Desacatos- Revista de Antropologia Social, 2005, 19: 11-24 (in Spanish)

[2] Agamben G. State of exception, 2005, Chicago: University of Chicago Press

[3] Alcántara-Ayala I, Oliver-Smith A. Sudmeier-Rieux K, Fernández M, Penna IM, Jaboyedoff M, Gaillard JC. The necessity of Early Warning Articulated Systems (EWASs): Critical issues beyond response. Identifying emerging issues in disaster risk reduction, migration, climate change and sustainable development, 2017, London: Springer 101-124.

[4] Alexander, D., and G. Pescaroli. 2019. What are cascading disasters? UCL Open Environment 1: Article 03.

[5] Anderson WA. Bringing children into focus on the social science disaster research agenda. International Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters, 2005, 23(3): 159-175.

[6] Anderson LO, Marchezini V, Morello TF, Cunningham C. Warning system and disaster risk management frameworks for disasters related to forest fires and the challenges for public policies in Brazil (Modelo conceitual de sistema de alerta e de gestão de riscos e desastres associados a incêndios florestais e desafios para políticas públicas no Brasil). Territorium, 2019, 26(1): 43-61 (in Portuguese)

[7] Basher, R. 2006. Global early warning systems for natural hazards: Systematic and people-centred. Philosophical Transactions. Series A, Mathematical, Physical, and Engineering Sciences 364(1845): 2167–2182.

[8] Baudoin MA, Henly-Shepard S, Fernando N, Sitati A, Zommers Z. From top-down to community-centric approaches to early warning systems: Exploring pathways to improve disaster risk reduction through community participation. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2016, 7(2): 163-174.

[9] Bennett D. Five years later: Assessing the implementation of the four priorities of the Sendai framework for inclusion of people with disabilities. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2020

[10] Bonney R, Cooper C, Ballard H. The theory and practice of citizen science: Launching a new journal. Citizen Science: Theory and Practice, 2016, 1(1): 1

[11] Bourdieu P. Language and symbolic power, 1991, Cambridge: Polity Press

[12] Chisadza B, Tumbare MJ, Nhapi I, Nyabeze WR. Useful traditional knowledge indicators for drought forecasting in the Mzingwane Catchment area of Zimbabwe. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2013, 22(4): 312-325.

[13] Cumiskey, L., T. Hoang, S. Suzuki, C. Pettigrew, and M.M. Herrgard. 2015. Youth participation at the third UN World Conference on Disaster Risk Reduction. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science 6(2): 150–163.

[14] Cunha APMA, Marchezini V, Lindoso DP, Saito SM, Alvalá RCS. The challenges of consolidation of a drought-related disaster risk warning system to Brazil. Sustentabilidade em Debate, 2019, 10(1): 43-59.

[15] Dávila D. Flood warning systems in Latin America (Sistemas de alerta temprana ante inundaciones en América Latina), 2016, Lima: Soluciones Prácticas (in Spanish)

[16] Devault ML. Introduction: What is institutional ethnography?. Social Problems, 2006, 53(3): 294-298.

[17] Dombrowsky W. Quarantelli E. Again and again: Is a disaster we call a “disaster”?. What is a disaster? Perspectives on the question, 1998, London and New York: Routledge 19-30.

[18] Domínguez-Calle E, Lozano-Báez S. A literature review of warning systems in Colombia (Estado del arte de los sistemas de alerta temprana en Colombia). Revista de la Academia Colombiana de Ciencias Exactas, Físicas y Naturales, 2014, 38(148): 321-333 (in Spanish)

[19] Donovan K, Suryanto A, Utami P. Mapping cultural vulnerability in volcanic regions: The practical application of social volcanology at Mt Merapi, Indonesia. Environmental Hazards, 2012, 11(4): 303-323.

[20] Dunlap RE, McCright AM. Dunlap RE, Brulle RJ. Challenging climate change: The denial countermovement. Climate change and society: Sociological perspectives, 2015, New York: Oxford University Press 300-332.

[21] Dyball, R., V.A. Brown, and M. Keen. 2009. Towards sustainability: Five strands of social learning. In Social learning towards a sustainable world: Principles, perspectives, and praxis, ed. A.E.J Wals, 181–194. Netherlands: Wageningen Academic Publishers.

[22] FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations). 2010. Countries in protracted crisis: What are they and why do they deserve special attention? Rome, Italy: FAO. https://www.fao.org/3/i1683e/i1683e03.pdf. Accessed 18 Dec 2019.

[23] FAO, IFAD, UNICEF, WFP and WHO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, et al.). 2019. The state of food security and nutrition in the world 2019: Safeguarding against economic slowdowns and downturns. Rome: FAO.

[24] Fearnside PM. Amazon dams and waterways: Brazil’s Tapajós Basin plans. Ambio, 2015, 44(5): 426-439.

[25] Fernandez G, Shaw R. Youth council participation in disaster risk reduction in the Philippines. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2013, 4(3): 126-136.

[26] Foucault M. Security, territory, population: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1977–1978, 2007, New York: Palgrave Macmillan

[27] Gaillard JC, Clave E, Vibert O, Azhari D, Denain JC, Efendi Y, Grancher D, Liamzon CC, Sari DSR, Setiawan R. Ethnic groups' response to the 26 December 2004 earthquake and tsunami in Aceh, Indonesia. Natural Hazards, 2008, 47(1): 17-38.

[28] Gaillard JC, Gorman-Murray A, Fordham M. Sexual and gender minorities in disaster. Gender, Place & Culture, 2017, 24(1): 18-26.

[29] Garcia C, Fearnley CJ. Evaluating critical links in early warning systems for natural hazards. Environmental Hazards, 2012, 11(2): 123-137.

[30] Gibson T, Wisner B. “Let’s talk about you…”: Opening space for local experience, action and learning in disaster risk reduction. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2016, 25(5): 664-684.

[31] Giordano R, Preziosi E, Romano E. Integration of local and scientific knowledge to support drought impact monitoring: Some hints from an Italian case study. Natural Hazards, 2013, 69(1): 523-544.

[32] GNDR (Global Network of Civil Society Organizations for Disaster Reduction). 2019. Views from the frontline 2019. https://www.gndr.org/programmes/views-from-the-frontline/vfl-2019.html. Accessed 5 Nov 2019.

[33] Grasso VF. Zommers Z, Singh A. The state of early warning systems. Reducing disaster: Early warning systems for climate change, 2014, Dordrecht: Springer 109-126.

[34] Guadagno L. Human mobility in the Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2016, 7(1): 30-40.

[35] Hewitt K. Hewitt K. The idea of calamity in a technocratic age. Interpretations of calamity, 1983, Boston: Allen and Unwin 3-32.

[36] Horita FEA, Albuquerque JP, Marchezini V. Understanding the decision-making process in disaster risk monitoring and early-warning: A case study within a control room in Brazil. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2018, 28: 22-31.

[37] Horita FEA, Albuquerque JP, Marchezini V, Mendiondo EM. Bridging the gap between decision-making and emerging big data sources: An application of a model-based framework to disaster management in Brazil. Decision Support Systems, 2017, 97: 12-22.

[38] IFRC (International Federation of the Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies) Community early warning systems: Guiding principles, 2012, Geneva, Switzerland: IFRC

[39] Kelman I. Warning for the 26 December 2004 Tsunamis. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2006, 15(1): 178-189.

[40] Kelman I. Climate change and the Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2015, 6(2): 117-127.

[41] Kelman I, Glantz MH. Zommers Z, Singh A. Early warning systems defined. Reducing disaster: Early warning systems for climate change, 2014, Dordrecht: Springer 89-108.

[42] Klein N. The shock doctrine: The rise of disaster capitalism, 2008, New York: Picador

[43] Latour B, Woolgar S. Laboratory life: The construction of scientific facts, 1986, New Jersey: Princeton University Press

[44] Li X, Jin L, Kan H. Air pollution: A global problem needs local fixes. Nature, 2019, 570(7762): 437-439.

[45] López-García JD, Carvajal-Escobar Y, Enciso-Arango AM. Early warning systems with a participatory approach: Challenges for disaster risk management in Colombia (Sistemas de alerta temprana con enfoque participativo: Un desafío para la gestión del riesgo en Colombia). Revista Luna Azul, 2017, 44: 231-246 (in Spanish)

[46] Lumbroso D, Brown E, Ranger N. Stakeholders' perceptions of the overall effectiveness of early warning systems and risk assessments for weather-related hazards in Africa, the Caribbean and South Asia. Natural Hazards, 2016, 84(3): 2121-2144.

[47] Lund C. Twilight institutions: Public authority and local politics in Africa. Development and Change, 2006, 37(4): 685-705.

[48] Macherera M, Chimbari MJ. A review of studies on community based early warning systems. Jàmbá: Journal of Disaster Risk Studies, 2016

[49] Macherera M, Chimbari MJ. Developing a community-centred malaria early warning system based on indigenous knowledge: Gwanda District, Zimbabwe. Jàmbá: Journal of Disaster Risk Studies, 2016

[50] Maly E, Suppasri A. The Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction at five: Lessons from the 2011 great East Japan earthquake and tsunami. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2020

[51] Marchezini, V., F.E.A. Horita, P.M. Matsuo, R. Trajber, M.A. Trejo-Rangel, and D. Olivato. 2018. A review of studies on Participatory Early Warning Systems (P-EWS): Pathways to support citizen science initiatives. Frontiers in Earth Science 6: Article 184.

[52] Marchezini V, Londe L, Bernardes T, Conceição RS, Santos EV, Saito SM, Soler L, Silva AEP Marchezini V, Wisner B, Londe LR, Saito SM Sistema de alerta de risco de desastres no Brasil: Desafios à redução da vulnerabilidade institucional. Reduction of vulnerability to disasters: from knowledge to action, 2017, São Carlos: Rima Editora 287-310.

[53] Marchezini V, Trajber R, Olivato D, Muñoz V, Oliveira Pereira F, Oliveira Luz AE. Participatory early warning systems: Youth, citizen science, and intergenerational dialogues on disaster risk reduction in Brazil. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2017, 8(4): 390-401.

[54] Maskrey, A. 1993. Disasters are not natural (Los desastres no son naturales). Panamá City: La Red (in Spanish). https://www.desenredando.org/public/libros/1993/ldnsn/LosDesastresNoSonNaturales-1.0.0.pdf. Accessed 13 Oct 2019.

[55] Michoud C, Bazin S, Blikra LH, Derron MH, Jaboyedoff M. Experiences from site-specific landslide early warning systems. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2013, 13(10): 2659-2673.

[56] Mustafa D, Gioli G, Qazi S, Waraich R, Rehman A, Zahoor R. Gendering flood early warning systems: The case of Pakistan. Environmental Hazards, 2015, 14(4): 312-328.

[57] Muzenda-Mudavanhu C, Manyena B, Collins AE. Disaster risk reduction knowledge among children in Muzarabani District, Zimbabwe. Natural Hazards, 2016, 84(2): 911-931.

[58] Nguyen H, Prabhakar SVRK, Shaw R. Adaptive drought risk reduction in Cambodia: Reality, perceptions and strategies. Environmental Hazards, 2009, 8(4): 245-262.

[59] Norambuena RC. A survey of tsunami warning systems in the Southeast Pacific (Diagnóstico de los Sistemas de Alerta Temprana ante Tsunami en el Pacífico Sudeste), 2011, Santiago: DIPECHO (in Spanish)

[60] O’Keefe P, Westgate K, Wisner B. Taking the naturalness out of natural disasters. Nature, 1976, 260: 566-567.

[61] Oliver-Smith, A., I. Alcántara-Ayala, I. Burton, and A. Lavell. 2016. Forensic Investigations of Disasters (FORIN): A conceptual framework and guide to research (2016). IRDR FORIN Publication No.2. Beijing: Integrated Research on Disaster Risk. https://www.irdrinternational.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/FORIN-2-29022016.pdf. Accessed 9 Jul 2019.

[62] Peek L. Children and disasters: Understanding vulnerability, developing capacities, and promoting resilience—An introduction. Children, Youth and Environments, 2008, 18(1): 1-29.

[63] Perry RW. Rodriguez H, Dooner W, Trainor JE. Defining disaster: An evolving concept. Handbook of disaster research, 2018, Cham, Switzerland: Springer 3-22.

[64] Pincha C, Krishna H. Aravanis: Voiceless victims of the Tsunami. Humanitarian Exchange, 2008, 41: 41-43.

[65] Saito SM, Lima GRT, Dias MCA. Evaluation by the end-users of disaster risk warnings in Brazil. Sustentabilidade em Debate, 2019, 10(2): 38-53.

[66] Santha S, Gahana P, Aswin VS. Local knowledge, early warning and coastal hazards: Participatory inquiry among fishworkers in Kerala, India. Action Research, 2014, 12(3): 273-292.

[67] Selby D, Kagawa F. Disaster risk reduction in school curricula: Case studies from thirty countries, 2012, Paris: UNESCO and UNICEF

[68] Sorensen JH. Hazard warning systems: Review of 20 years of progress. Natural Hazards Review, 2000, 1(2): 119-125.

[69] Sorokin P. Man and society in calamity: The effects of war, revolution, famine, pestilence upon human mind, behavior, social organization and cultural life, 1942, New York: E.P. Dutton and Company

[70] Stokoe RM. Putting people at the centre of tornado warnings: How perception analysis can cut fatalities. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2016, 17: 137-153.

[71] Stone, J., J. Barclay, P. Simmons, P.D. Cole, S.C. Loughlin, P. Ramón, and P. Mothes. 2014. Risk reduction through community-based monitoring: The vigías of Tungurahua, Ecuador. Journal of Applied Volcanology 3(1): Article 11.

[72] Thomalla F, Larsen RK. Resilience in the context of tsunami early warning systems and community disaster preparedness in the Indian Ocean Region. Environmental Hazards, 2010, 9(3): 249-265.

[73] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction) Hyogo framework for action 2005–2015: Building the resilience of nations and communities to disasters, 2005, Geneva: UNISDR

[74] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction) Developing early warning systems: A checklist, 2006, Bonn: UNISDR

[75] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction) Global survey of early warning systems: An assessment of capacities, gaps and opportunities towards building a comprehensive global early warning system for all natural hazards, 2006, Geneva: UNISDR

[76] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction) Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction 2015–2030, 2015, Geneva: UNISDR

[77] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction). 2017. Terminology: Basic terms of disaster risk reduction. https://www.unisdr.org/we/inform/terminology#letter-e. Accessed 1 Aug 2019.

[78] Villagrán de León JC. Wisner B, Gaillard JC, Kelman I. Early warning principles and practices. Handbook of hazards and disaster risk reduction and management, 2012, Oxfordshire: Routledge 481-492.

[79] Villagrán de León JC, Pruessner I, Breedlove H. Alert and warning frameworks in the context of early warning systems: A comparative review, 2013, Bonn: United Nations University

[80] Wisner, B. 2016. Vulnerability as concept, model, metric, and tool. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Natural Hazard Science. https://naturalhazardscience.oxfordre.com/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780199389407.001.0001/acrefore-9780199389407-e-25. Accessed 5 Apr 2017.

[81] Wisner B, Blaikie P, Cannon T, Davis I. At risk: Natural hazards, people’s vulnerability and disasters, 2004, London: Routledge

[82] Wisner B, Gaillard JC, Kelman I. Wisner B, Gaillard JC, Kelman I. Framing disaster: Theories and stories seeking to understand hazards, vulnerability and risk. The Routledge handbook of hazards and disaster risk reduction, 2012, London: Routledge 18-34.

[83] WMO (World Meteorological Organization). 2018. Multi-hazard early warning system: A checklist. https://library.wmo.int/doc_num.php?explnum_id=4463. Accessed 1 Dec 2019.

[84] Zia A, Wagner CH. Mainstreaming early warning systems in development and planning processes: Multilevel implementation of Sendai framework in Indus and Sahel. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2015, 6(2): 189-199.