Early Warning Systems: Lost in Translation or Late by Definition? A FORIN Approach

Abstract

Early warning systems (EWSs) are widely considered to be one of the most important mechanisms to prevent disasters around the globe. But as disasters continue to affect countries where EWSs have already been implemented, the striking disaster consequences have led us to reflect on the focus, architecture, and function of the warning systems. Since the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami there has been a rapid rise in the promotion and use of EWSs to minimize disaster losses and damage. However, few researchers have addressed the question of their acceptability as an adaptive measure to the existing exposure conditions. EWSs are far more linked to emergency response and humanitarian crises and accepted technological interventions as solutions than they are to explicitly advance integrated analysis, disaster risk reduction, and policy making. A major flaw of EWSs is that the term “early” has been essentially used in reference to the speed of hazard onset, founded on a physicalist perspective that has encouraged a considerable dependence on technology. In this article we address the need for a clear understanding of the root causes and risk drivers of disaster risk creation, as advanced in the FORIN (forensic investigation of disasters) approach, as a prerequisite for the development of more articulated EWSs that could contribute to disaster risk reduction through policy making and practice, based on integrated and transdisciplinary management, in the interest of sustainable development, and human welfare and well-being.

Keywords

Disaster risk drivers / Disaster root causes / Early warning systems / Forensic disaster investigations / FORIN

References

[1] ABC. 2018. Indonesia tsunami early detection buoys haven’t worked for six years due to “lack of funding”. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-10-01/indonesia-tsunami-early-detection-buoys-broken-for-six-years/10324200. Accessed 22 Apr 2019.

[2] Alcántara-Ayala I. Geomorphology, natural hazards, vulnerability and prevention of natural disasters in developing countries. Geomorphology, 2002, 47(2–4): 107-124

[3] Alcántara-Ayala I. Time in a bottle: Challenges to disaster studies in Latin America and the Caribbean. Disasters, 2019, 43(S1): S18-S27

[4] Alcántara-Ayala I, Oliver-Smith A. Sudmeier-Rieux K, Fernández M, Penna IM, Jaboyedoff M, Gaillard JC. The necessity of early warning articulated systems (EWASs): Critical issues beyond response. Identifying emerging issues in disaster risk reduction, migration, climate change and sustainable development, 2017, Cham, Switzerland: Springer 101-124

[5] Alcántara-Ayala, I., O. Altan, D. Baker, S. Briceño, S. Cutter, H. Gupta, A. Holloway, A. Ismail-Zadeh, et al. 2015. Disaster risks research and assessment to promote risk reduction and management, ICSU-ISSC Ad Hoc Group on disaster risk assessment, ed. A. Ismail-Zadeh, and S. Cutter. Paris: ICSU. http://www.icsu.org/science-for-policy/disaster-risk/documents/DRRsynthesisPaper_2015.pdf. Accessed 28 Sept 2018.

[6] Basher R. Global early warning systems for natural hazards: Systematic and people-centred. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A, 2006, 364(1845): 2167-2182

[7] Benadusi, M., and S. Revet (eds.). 2016. On the witness stand: Environment crises, disasters and social justice. Archivio Antropologico Mediterraneo on Line—Anno XIX (2016), n. 18(2).

[8] Birkland TA. Disasters, catastrophes, and policy failure in the homeland security era. Review of Policy Research, 2009, 26(4): 423-438

[9] Blaikie P, Cannon T, Davis I, Wisner B. At risk: Natural hazards, people’s vulnerability, and disasters, 1994, London: Routledge

[10] Bode B. Disaster, social structure and myth in the Peruvian Andes: The genesis of an explanation. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1977, 293(1): 246-274

[11] Bode B. No bells to toll: Destruction and creation in the Andes, 1989, New York: Scribners

[12] Boettke PJ, Chamlee-Wright E, Gordon P, Ikeda S, Leeson P, Sobel R. The political, economic, and social aspects of Katrina. Southern Economic Journal, 2007, 74(2): 363-376.

[13] Bolin B. Rodríguez H, Quarantelli EL, Dynes RR. Race, class, ethnicity, and disaster vulnerability. Handbook of disaster research, 2006, New York: Springer 113-129.

[14] Boudreau T. The food economy approach: A framework for understanding rural livelihoods. Relief and rehabilitation network paper, 1998, London: Overseas Development Institute

[15] Burby RJ. Hurricane Katrina and the paradoxes of government disaster policy: Bringing about wise governmental decisions for hazardous areas. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 2006, 604(1): 171-191

[16] Burton C, Cutter SL. Levee failures and social vulnerability in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta area. California. Natural Hazards Review, 2008, 9(3): 136-149

[17] Burton I. Forensic disaster investigations in depth: A new case study model. Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development, 2010, 52(5): 36-41.

[18] Burton I. The forensic investigation of root causes and the post-2015 framework for disaster risk reduction. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2015, 12: 1-2

[19] Burton I, Kates RW. The perception of natural hazard in resource management. Natural Resource Journal, 1964, 3(3): 412-441.

[20] Burton I, Kates RW, White GF. The human ecology of extreme geophysical events, 1968, Paper: FMHI Publications 78

[21] Burton I, Kates RW, White GF. The environment as hazard, 1978, New York: Oxford University Press

[22] Cannon T. Varley A. Vulnerability analysis and the explanation of natural disasters. Disasters development and environment, 1994, Chichester: John Wiley 13-30.

[23] Castillo C. Harmonizing FORIN for climate change adaptation and disaster risk management to develop multi-sectoral narratives for Metro Manila. Project report, 2013, Quezon, Philippines: Manila Observatory

[24] Chester DK, Duncan AM, Dibben CJL. The importance of religion in shaping volcanic risk perception in Italy, with special reference to Vesuvius and Etna. Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research, 2008, 172(3–4): 216-228

[25] Comfort LK. Cities at risk: Hurricane Katrina and the drowning of New Orleans. Urban Affairs Review, 2006, 41(4): 501-516

[26] Congleton RD. The story of Katrina: New Orleans and the political economy of catastrophe. Public Choice, 2006, 127(1–2): 5-30

[27] CRED (Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters). 2015. EM-DAT (Emergency Events Database). CRED, Université catholique de Louvain, Belgium. http://emdat.be/human_cost_natdis. Accessed 22 Apr 2019.

[28] CRED (Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters). 2019. EM-DAT (Emergency Events Database). CRED, Université catholique de Louvain, Belgium. https://www.emdat.be/database. Accessed 22 Apr 2019.

[29] Cutter SL, Ismail-Zadeh A, Alcántara-Ayala I, Altan O, Baker DN, Briceño S, Gupta H, Holloway A Global risks: Pool knowledge to stem losses from disasters. Nature, 2015, 522(7556): 277-279

[30] Day JW, Boesch DF, Clairain EJ, Kemp GP, Laska SB, Mitsch WJ, Orth K, Mashriqui H Restoration of the Mississippi Delta: Lessons from Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. Science, 2007, 315(5819): 1679-1684

[31] Day JW, Shaffer G, Britsch L, Reed D, Hawes S, Cahoon D. Pattern and process of land loss in the Mississippi Delta: A spatial and temporal analysis of wetland habitat change. Estuaries, 2000, 23(4): 425-438

[32] Eiser, J.R. 2004. Public perception of risk. Report prepared for Foresight Office of Science and Technology, London.

[33] Eiser JR, Bostrom A, Burton I, Johnston DM, McClure J, Paton D, van der Pligt J, White MP. Risk interpretation and action: A conceptual framework for responses to natural hazards. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2012, 1: 5-16

[34] Elliott JR, Pais J. Race, class, and Hurricane Katrina: Social differences in human responses to disaster. Social Science Research, 2006, 35(2): 295-321

[35] Faustino-Eslava, D.V. 2013. Predictive forensics for averting possible disasters: A FORIN template for tackling issues related to the Valley Fault System and the Angat Dam in Luzon, Philippines. FORIN report. Laguna, Philippines: University of the Philippines, Los Banos.

[36] FEWS NET (Famine Early Warning Systems Network). 2019. FEWS NET homepage. http://fews.net/. Accessed 28 Sept 2018.

[37] Geaghan, K.A. 2011. Forced to move: An analysis of Hurricane Katrina movers 2009 American housing survey: New Orleans. SEHSD working paper number 2011–17, U.S. Census Bureau.

[38] Gugg G. Antronico L, Marincioni F. Anthropology of the Vesuvius Emergency Plan: History, perspectives and limits of a dispositive for volcanic risk government. Natural hazards and disaster risk reduction policies, 2018, Italy: Il Sileno Edizioni 105-123.

[39] Hewitt K. Interpretations of calamity from the viewpoint of human ecology, 1983, Boston: Allen & Unwin

[40] Hewitt K. Hewitt K. The idea of calamity in a technocratic age. Interpretations of calamity from the viewpoint of human ecology, 1983, Boston: Allen & Unwin 3-32.

[41] Hewitt, K., and I. Burton. 1971. The hazardousness of a place: A regional ecology of damaging events. Research Publication 6, Department of Geography, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.

[42] Huang T, Hsiang-Chieh L, Hui-Hsuan Y, Chung-Sheng L. Towards a generic framework for synthesising the societal disturbance from Typhoon Morakot, 2013, Taipei: Science and Technology Center for Disaster Reduction

[43] IRDR (Integrated Research on Disaster Risk). 2013. Integrated research on disaster risk strategic plan 2013–2017, Beijing, China. http://www.irdrinternational.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/IRDR-Strategic-Plan-2013-2017.pdf. Accessed 3 Sept 2019.

[44] Kates RW, Colten CE, Laska S, Leatherman SP. Reconstruction of New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina: A research perspective. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2006, 103(40): 14653-14660

[45] Kim, J.J., and D. Guha-Sapir. 2012. Famines in Africa: Is early warning early enough? Global Health Action 5: Article 18481.

[46] Lauta KC. Disaster law, 2014, Abingdon: Routledge

[47] Lauta, K.C. 2018. Disasters and responsibility. Normative issues for law following disasters. In: Disasters: Core concepts and ethical theories, ed. D. O’Mathúna, V. Dranseika, and B. Gordijn. Advancing Global Bioethics, vol. 11. Cham: Springer.

[48] Lavell, A. 2004. LA RED: Background, training and contribution to the development of concepts, studies and practice in disaster risk and disasters in Latin America: 1980–2004 (La Red: Antecedentes, formación y contribución al desarrollo de los conceptos, estudios y la práctica en el tema de los riesgos y desastres en América Latina: 1980–2004). Panamá: La Red de Estudios Sociales en Prevención de Desastres en América Latina (in Spanish).

[49] Lavell, A., and A. Brenes. 2019. Forensic analysis of the conditions of disaster risk in the 2018 Volcano of Fire (Volcán de Fuego) eruption. Opportunities for the strengthening of disaster risk management in Guatemala: A Study for the World Bank (preliminary version).

[50] Lavell A, Maskrey A. The future of disaster risk management. Environmental Hazards, 2014, 13(4): 267-280

[51] Maskrey, A. (ed.). 1993. Disasters are not natural (Los desastres no son naturales). La Red de Estudios Sociales en Prevención de Desastres en América Latina, LA RED, Bogotá: Tercer Mundo Editores (in Spanish).

[52] Nall, W., and H. Josserand. 1996. The USAID famine early warning system as an “information system”. In Systèmes d’information et questions de développement, ed. J.P. Minvielle. Cahiers de Sciences Humaines 32(4): 903–911.

[53] O’Keefe P, Westgate K, Wisner B. Taking the naturalness out of natural disaster. Nature, 1976, 260(5552): 566-567

[54] Oliver-Smith A. Post-disaster housing reconstruction and social inequality: A challenge to policy and practice. Disasters, 1990, 14(1): 7-19

[55] Oliver-Smith A. The Martyred City: Death and rebirth in the Peruvian Andes, 1992 2 Prospect Heights, IL: Waveland Press

[56] Oliver-Smith, A. 2006. Disasters and forced migration in the 21st century. http://understandingkatrina.ssrc.org/Oliver-Smith/. Accessed 28 Sept 2018.

[57] Oliver-Smith, A., I. Alcántara-Ayala, I. Burton, and A. Lavell. 2016. Forensic Investigations of Disasters (FORIN): A conceptual framework and guide to research. IRDR FORIN publication No. 2. Beijing: Integrated Research on Disaster Risk, ICSU. http://www.irdrinternational.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/FORIN-21.pdf. Accessed 28 Sept 2018.

[58] Oliver-Smith, A., I. Alcántara-Ayala, I. Burton, and A. Lavell. 2017a. Forensic Investigations of Disaster (FORIN): Towards the understanding of root causes of disasters. Policy brief. Beijing: Integrated Research on Disaster Risk, ICSU.

[59] Oliver-Smith A, Alcántara-Ayala I, Burton I, Lavell A. The social construction of disaster risk: Seeking root causes. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2017, 22: 469-474

[60] Pielke RA. Nine fallacies of floods. Climatic Change, 1999, 42(2): 413-438

[61] Rakowsky N, Androsov A, Fuchs A, Harig S, Immerz A, Danilov S, Hiller W, Schröter J. Operational tsunami modelling with TsunAWI—recent developments and applications. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2013, 13(6): 1629-1642

[62] Reed PD. From the freedmen’s bureau to FEMA: A post-Katrina historical, journalistic, and literary analysis. Journal of Black Studies, 2007, 37(4): 555-567

[63] Revet S. Anthropology of a catastrophe: The mudslides of 1999 in Venezuela (Anthropologie d’une catastrophe: les coulées de boue de 1999 au Venezuela), 2007, Paris: Presses Sorbonne Nouvelle (in French)

[64] Rogers, D., and V. Tsirkunov. 2011. Implementing hazard early warning systems. GFDRR WCIDS Report 11-03. https://www.preventionweb.net/files/24259_implementingearlywarningsystems1108.pdf. Accessed 17 Apr 2019.

[65] Rudloff A, Lauterjung J, Münch U, Tinti S. Preface “The GITEWS project (German-Indonesian Tsunami Early Warning System)”. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2009, 9(4): 1381-1382

[66] Salami RO, von Meding J, Giggins H. Antronico L, Marincioni F. The urban political ecology of flood vulnerability in the core area of Ibadan Metropolis, Nigeria. Natural hazards and disaster risk reduction policies, 2018, Italy: Il Sileno Edizioni 36-50.

[67] Save the Children-UK The household economy approach: A resource manual for practitioners, 2000, London: Save the Children-UK

[68] Simpson E. Blame narratives and religious reason in the aftermath of the 2001 Gujarat Earthquake, South Asia. Journal of South Asian Studies, 2011, 34(3): 421-438.

[69] Thomalla F, Larsen RK. Resilience in the context of tsunami early warning systems and community disaster preparedness in the Indian Ocean Region. Environmental Hazards, 2010, 9(3): 249-265

[70] Tucker B, Nelson DR. What does economic anthropology have to contribute to studies of risk and resilience?. Economic Anthropology, 2017, 4(2): 161-172

[71] Twigg J. Zschau J, Küppers AN. The human factor in early warnings: Risk perception and appropriate communications. Early warning systems for natural disaster reduction, 2002, Berlin: Springer 19-26.

[72] UNESCO (United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization) Information guide: Tsunami early warning for broadcasting institutions in Indonesia, 2012, Pairs: UNESCO

[73] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction). 2005. Hyogo framework for action 2005–2015: Building the resilience of nations and communities to disasters. Geneva: UNISDR. https://www.unisdr.org/files/1037_hyogoframeworkforactionenglish.pdf Accessed 14 Apr 2019.

[74] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction). 2009. Terminology on disaster risk reduction. http://www.unisdr.org/files/7817_UNISDRTerminologyEnglish.pdf. Accessed 14 Apr 2019.

[75] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction). 2015. Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction 2015–2030. Geneva: UNISDR. http://www.preventionweb.net/files/43291_sendaiframeworkfordrren.pdf. Accessed 17 Apr 2019.

[76] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction). 2017. Report of the open-ended intergovernmental expert working group on indicators and terminology relating to disaster risk reduction. Geneva: UNISDR. https://www.preventionweb.net/files/50683_oiewgreportenglish.pdf. Accessed 14 Apr 2019.

[77] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction). 2018. Sendai framework anniversary: Reporting underway. https://www.unisdr.org/archive/57495 Accessed 14 Apr 2019.

[78] United Nations. 1994. Yokohama strategy and plan of action for a safer world: Guidelines for natural disaster prevention, preparedness and mitigation. New York: United Nations. http://www.unisdr.org/we/inform/publications/8241. Accessed 28 Sept 2018.

[79] Verdin J, Funk C, Senay G, Choularton R. Climate science and famine early warning. Cautionary tales: Adaptation and the global poor. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, 2005, 360(1463): 2155-2168

[80] Walsh J. Famine early warning closer to reality: Chronic lag in response to food emergencies in Africa spurs use of remote sensing to improve reaction time. Science, 1986, 233(4769): 1145-1147

[81] Walsh J. Famine early warning systems wins its spurs. Science, 1988, 239(4837): 249-250

[82] Wiltshire, A. 2006. Developing early warning systems: A checklist. In Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Early Warning (EWC III), 27–29 March 2006, Bonn, Germany.

[83] WMO (World Meteorological Organization). 2006. Outcome report. Symposium on multi-hazard early warning systems for integrated disaster risk management, 23–24 May 2006, Geneva, Switzerland.

[84] Wisner B, Blaikie P, Cannon T, Davis I. At risk: Natural hazards, people’s vulnerability and disasters, 2004 2 New York: Routledge