Government Investment in Disaster Risk Reduction Based on a Probabilistic Risk Model: A Case Study of Typhoon Disasters in Shenzhen, China

Abstract

In recent years, cost-benefit analysis (CBA) has played an important role in disaster risk reduction (DRR) investment decisions, and now increasing attention is being paid to its application in developing countries. This article discusses government investment choices in DRR against typhoon disasters in Shenzhen, China. While the existing literature mainly focuses on disaster mitigation measures such as structural retrofitting, this study proposes a holistic framework of DRR investments in which structural (windproof retrofitting) and financial (insurance premium subsidies and post-disaster relief) are all taken into account. In particular, intermeasure spillover effects are measured and used in CBA. The results show that insurance premium subsidies yield the highest benefit-cost ratio and should be prioritized in investment. Windproof retrofitting comes in second place in terms of the benefit-cost ratio and can be considered when there is a sufficient budget. These results further confirm the need of a holistic review of government DRR investments to derive policy recommendations, while challenges remain in relation to the probabilistic modeling capacity to support CBA.

Keywords

Cost-benefit analysis / Disaster risk reduction investment / Shenzhen / Typhoon risk model

References

[1] Arrow KJ, Lind RC. Uncertainty and the evaluation of public investment decisions. American Economic Review, 1970, 60(3): 364-378.

[2] Carter WN. Disaster management: A disaster manager’s handbook, 2008, Manila, Philippines: Asian Development Bank

[3] China Insurance Regulatory Commission. 2014. Initiative of Chinese catastrophe insurance institutional design with the promotion of the China insurance regulatory commission. http://www.circ.gov.cn/web/site0/tab5207/info3900215.htm. Accessed 3 Nov 2015 (in Chinese).

[4] Coble KH, Barnett BJ. Why do we subsidize crop insurance?. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 2012, 95(2): 498-504

[5] Freeman, P.K., L.A. Martin, R. Mechler, G. Pflug, and K. Warner. 2003. Disaster risk management: National systems for the comprehensive management of disaster risk and financial strategies for natural disaster reconstruction. Research report for the Inter-American Development Bank. http://pure.iiasa.ac.at/6980/. Accessed 3 Nov 2015.

[6] Glauber JW. Crop insurance reconsidered. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 2004, 86(5): 1179-1195

[7] Gollier C. The economics of risk and time, 2004, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press

[8] Goodwin BK, Smith VH. What harm is done by subsidizing crop insurance?. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 2013, 95(2): 489-497

[9] Hochrainer-Stigler S, Mechler R, Mochizuki J. A risk management tool for tackling country-wide contingent disasters: A case study on Madagascar. Environmental Modelling & Software, 2015, 72: 44-55

[10] Hu WY, Woods T, Bastin S. Consumer acceptance and willingness to pay for blueberry products with nonconventional attributes. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics, 2009, 41(1): 47-60.

[11] IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change). 2012. Managing the risks of extreme events and disasters to advance climate change adaptation. A special report of Working Groups I and II of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, ed. C.B. Field, V. Barros, T.F. Stocker, D.H. Qin, D.J. Dokken, K.L. Ebi, M.D. Mastrandrea, K.J. Mach, G.-K. Plattner, S.K. Allen, M. Tignor, and P.M. Midgley. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

[12] Jonkman SN, Brinkhuis-Jak M, Kok M. Cost benefit analysis and flood damage mitigation in the Netherlands. Heron, 2004, 49(1): 95-111.

[13] Kleindorfer PR, Kunreuther H. The complementary roles of mitigation and insurance in managing catastrophic risks. Risk Analysis, 1999, 19(4): 727-738.

[14] Kobayashi, K., and M. Yokomatsu. 2000. Economic valuation of catastrophe risks: Beyond expected losses paradigms. Paper presented at the Second EuroConference on Global Change and Catastrophe Risk Management: Earthquake Risks in Europe, Laxenburg, Austria, 6–9 July 2000.

[15] Kull D, Mechler R, Hochrainer-Stigler S. Probabilistic cost-benefit analysis of disaster risk management in a development context. Disasters, 2013, 37(3): 374-400

[16] Li Y. Assessment of damage risks to residential buildings and cost-benefit of mitigation strategies considering hurricane and earthquake hazards. Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities, 2012, 26(1): 7-16

[17] Li XY, Fang WH, Lin W. Comparison of interpolation methods for tropical cyclone tracks and their intensity over the northwestern pacific basin. Journal of Beijing Normal University (Natural Science), 2014, 50(2): 111-116 (in Chinese)

[18] Liel AB, Deierlein GG. Cost-benefit evaluation of seismic risk mitigation alternatives for older concrete frame buildings. Earthquake Spectra, 2013, 29(4): 1391-1411

[19] Lin, W. 2014. Typhoon wind hazard analysis of Hainan Island. Master’s thesis, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China (in Chinese).

[20] Lin W, Fang WH. Regional characteristics of the Holland B parameter in the typhoon wind field model for the Northwest Pacific. Tropical Geography, 2013, 33(2): 124-132 (in Chinese)

[21] Linnerooth-Bayer J, Mechler R. Disaster safety nets for developing countries: Extending public-private partnerships. Environmental Hazards, 2007, 7(1): 54-61

[22] Liu K, Wang M, Wang Y. Seismic retrofitting of rural rammed earth buildings using externally bonded fibers. Construction and Building Materials, 2015, 100: 91-101

[23] Liu, Y.B., T. Ye, M. Wang, and W.Y. Hu. 2013. Agricultural producers’ willingness-to-pay for paddy rice insurance in Hunan Province, China: A stated choice experiment analysis. Paper presented at the Association of American Geographers Annual Meeting, 9–13 April 2013, Los Angeles, CA, USA.

[24] Mahul, O., and G. Eugene. 2006. The macro financing of natural hazards in developing countries. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 4075, Washington, DC: World Bank.

[25] Mechler, R. 2005. Cost-benefit analysis of natural disaster risk management in developing countries. Eschborn: Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit (GTZ). http://maail1.mekonginfo.org/assets/midocs/0003131-environment-cost-benefit-analysis-of-natural-disaster-risk-management-in-developing-countries-manual.pdf. Accessed 30 May 2016.

[26] Mechler R. Reviewing estimates of the economic efficiency of disaster risk management: Opportunities and limitations of using risk-based cost-benefit analysis. Natural Hazards, 2016, 81(3): 2121-2147

[27] Mechler R, Hochrainer-Stigler S. Revisiting Arrow-Lind: Managing sovereign disaster risk. Journal of Natural Resources Policy Research, 2014, 6(1): 93-100

[28] Mechler, R., S. Hochrainer, G. Pflug, A. Lotsch, and K. Williges. 2010. Assessing the financial vulnerability to climate-related natural hazards. Background paper to the 2010 world development report. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 5232. Washington, DC: World Bank.

[29] Michel-Kerjan E, Hochrainer-Stigler S, Kunreuther H, Linnerooth-Bayer J, Mechler R, Muir-Wood R, Ranger N, Vaziri P, Young M. Catastrophe risk models for evaluating disaster risk reduction investments in developing countries. Risk Analysis, 2013, 33(6): 984-999

[30] Ministry of Civil Affairs of China Statistical yearbook of civil affairs of China (1986–2011), 2012, Beijing: China Statistics Press (in Chinese)

[31] Nuti C, Vanzi I. To retrofit or not to retrofit?. Engineering Structures, 2003, 25(6): 701-711

[32] Padgett JE, Dennemann K, Ghosh J. Risk-based seismic life-cycle cost-benefit (LCC-B) analysis for bridge retrofit assessment. Structural Safety, 2010, 32(3): 165-173

[33] Rose A, Porter K, Dash N, Bouabid J, Huyck C, Whitehead J, Shaw D, Equchi R Benefit-cost analysis of FEMA hazard mitigation grants. Natural Hazards Review, 2007, 8(4): 97-111

[34] Sherrick BJ, Barry PJ, Ellinger PN, Schnitkey GD. Factors influencing farmers’ crop insurance decisions. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 2004, 86(1): 103-114

[35] Shi PJ. Theory and practice of disaster systems research in a fourth time. Journal of Natural Disasters, 2005, 14(6): 1-7 (in Chinese)

[36] Shi PJ. On the role of government in integrated disaster risk governance: Based on practices in China. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2012, 3(3): 139-146

[37] Shi PJ. The atlas of natural disaster systems of China, 2003, Beijing: Science Press (in Chinese)

[38] Shi PJ. Atlas of natural disaster risk of China, 2011, Beijing: Science Press (in Chinese)

[39] Shi, X.W. 2012. Spatiotemporal characteristics and stochastic modeling of tropical cyclone tracks and their intensity in the NWP Basin. Master’s thesis, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China (in Chinese).

[40] Shi XW, Fang WH. Spatiotemporal characteristics of tropical cyclones in the NWP Basin between 1949 and 2010. Journal of Beijing Normal University (Natural Science), 2015, 51(3): 287-292 (in Chinese)

[41] State Council of the People’s Republic of China Regulation for natural disaster relief, 2009, Beijing: State Council of the People’s Republic of China (in Chinese)

[42] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction). 2015a. Making development sustainable: The future of disaster risk management. Global Assessment Report on Disaster Risk Reduction (GAR). Geneva: UNISDR.

[43] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction) Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction 2015–2030, 2015, Geneva: UNISDR

[44] Vickery PJ, Skerjl PF, Twisdale LA. Simulation of hurricane risk in the United States using empirical track model. Journal of Structural Engineering, 2000, 126(10): 1222-1237

[45] Vickery PJ, Skerjl PF, Steckley AC, Twisdale LA. Hurricane wind field model for use in hurricane simulations. Journal of Structural Engineering, 2000, 126(10): 1203-1221

[46] Viscusi WK, Aldy JE. The value of a statistical life: A critical review of market estimates throughout the world. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 2003, 27(1): 5-76

[47] Wang M, Shi PJ, Ye T, Liu M, Zhou MQ. Agriculture insurance in China: History, experience, and lessons learned. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2011, 2(2): 10-22

[48] Wethli, K. 2013. Benefit-cost analysis for risk management: Summary of selected examples. Document prepared for the world development report 2014. http://siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTNWDR2013/Resources/8258024-1352909193861/8936935-1356011448215/8986901-1380568255405/WDR15_bp_BenefitCost_Analysis_for_Risk_Management_Wethli.pdf. Accessed 30 May 2016.

[49] World Bank World development report 2014 – Managing risk for development, 2014, Washington, DC: World Bank

[50] World Bank/United Nations Natural hazards, unnatural disasters: The economics of effective prevention, 2010, Washington, DC: World Bank

[51] Wu, B.X. 2015. Study on the optimization of government financial expenditure in integrated disaster risk governance. Doctoral thesis, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China (in Chinese).

[52] Wu YL, Li H. Meteorological disaster and its risk assessment in Shenzhen City since 2000. Guangdong Meteorology, 2009, 31(3): 43-45 (in Chinese)

[53] Ye T, Yokomatsu M, Shi PJ, Okada N. Sensarma SR, Sarkar A. Government intervention into the disaster insurance market: Issues and alternatives in Japan and China. Local, regional and international level cooperation in disaster risk management, 2013, New Delhi: Concept Publisher 162-191.