Built-in Risk: Linking Housing Concerns and Flood Risk in Subsidized Housing Settlements in Cape Town, South Africa

Abstract

As in many other settings in developing countries, discussions on urban flooding in South Africa tend to focus on informal settlements. There is less attention to poor but formal housing areas, based on the largely untested assumption that the formalization of housing addresses risk. This is at odds with an extensive literature from the housing and developmental sectors that highlights weaknesses in the location and construction of low-income housing, particularly state-subsidized housing. Drawing on research in 10 poor, flood-prone settlements in Cape Town, South Africa, this article explores whether providing housing addresses risk. The results show that flooding remains a challenge in subsidized housing areas and that risk is linked strongly to the buildings themselves. Poorly designed and constructed dwellings perpetuate risk in low-income areas. While divorced conceptually and practically, disaster risk and housing issues are critically linked, and housing concerns must be factored into discussions on flooding in Cape Town and comparable settings elsewhere.

Keywords

Cape Town / Flood risk / Subsidized housing / Urban housing

References

[1] Action Aid International Unjust waters: climate change, flooding and the protection of poor urban communities: experiences from six African countries, 2006, London: Action Aid

[2] Aigbavboa C, Thwala W. Housing experience of South African low-income beneficiaries. The Built and Human Environment Review, 2011, 4: 1-13.

[3] Alexander D. Confronting catastrophe: new perspectives on natural disasters, 2000, New York: Oxford University Press

[4] Anbarci N, Escaleras M, Register C. Earthquake fatalities: the interaction of nature and political economy. Journal of Public Economics, 2005, 89(9–10): 1907-1933 10.1016/j.jpubeco.2004.08.002

[5] Arammbepola NMSI. Ensuring safer shelter and infrastructure in urban built up areas. Asian Disaster Management News, 2007, 13(2): 17-19.

[6] Bahry, M. 2007. The relationship between household livelihood profile and fire and flood-related vulnerability. Honors thesis, University of Cape Town, Cape Town.

[7] Benjamin, A. 2008. Analysing urban flood risk in low-cost settlements of George, Western Cape, South Africa: Investigating physical and social dimensions. Masters thesis, University of Cape Town, Cape Town.

[8] Bolnick, A. 2009. Informal settlement upgrading: towards a people-centred incremental approach. Student research paper, Lund University, Lund.

[9] Bouchard, B., A. Goncalo, M. Susienka, and K. Wilson. 2007. Improving flood risk management in informal settlements of Cape Town. Bachelors thesis, Worcester Polytechnic Institute.

[10] Charlton S. Housing for the nation, the city and the household: competing rationalities as a constraint to reform?. Development Southern Africa, 2009, 26(2): 301-315 10.1080/03768350902899637

[11] Del Mistro R, Hensher D. Upgrading informal settlements in South Africa: Policy, rhetoric and what residents really value. Housing Studies, 2009, 24(3): 333-354 10.1080/02673030902869279

[12] Department of Housing. 2004. Breaking new ground: A comprehensive plan for the development of sustainable human settlements. Pretoria (Tshwane): Government of South Africa (Department of Housing).

[13] DiMP (Disaster Mitigation for Sustainability Program). 2005. August 2004 severe storm: Post flood assessment. Report prepared for the Prepared for Catchments, Stormwater and River Management Directorate, City of Cape Town. Cape Town: DiMP.

[14] DiMP (Disaster Mitigation for Sustainability Program). 2007. Severe weather compound disaster: August 2006 cut-off lows and their consequences in the Southern Cape, South Africa. Report prepared for the Provincial Disaster Management Centre and the Department of Transport and Public Works. Cape Town: DiMP.

[15] DiMP (Disaster Mitigation for Sustainability Program). 2008. Weathering the storm: participatory risk assessments for informal settlements. Cape Town: DiMP.

[16] DiMP (Disaster Mitigation for Sustainability Program). 2009a. Report of a community risk assessment undertaken in DiMP Students in Collaboration with Urban Matters and the Philippi Youth Forum, Cape Town: DiMP.

[17] DiMP (Disaster Mitigation for Sustainability Program). 2009b. Community risk assessment report: Never-Never and Phola Park, Philippi, Cape Town. Cape Town: DiMP.

[18] DiMP (Disaster Mitigation for Sustainability Program). 2009c. Community risk assessment report: Sweet Home Farm. Cape Town: DiMP.

[19] DiMP (Disaster Mitigation for Sustainability Program). 2010. Western Cape risk and development annual review (RADAR). Cape Town: Periperi Publications.

[20] Drivdal, L. 2011a. Report on flooding in the informal settlement, “The Graveyard Pond”, Philippi, Cape Town, 2010–2011. Report prepared for the Flooding in Cape Town under Climate Risk (FliCCR) project, University of Cape Town.

[21] Drivdal, L. 2011b. Report on flooding in the informal settlement, “Egoli”, in Philippi/Schaapkraal, Cape Town, 2010 and 2011. Report prepared for the Flooding in Cape Town under Climate Risk (FliCCR) project, University of Cape Town.

[22] Field A. Discovering statistics using SPSS, 2005 2 London: Sage Publications

[23] Gilbert A. Helping the poor through housing subsidies: lessons from Chile, Colombia and South Africa. Habitat International, 2004, 28(1): 13-40 10.1016/S0197-3975(02)00070-X

[24] Govender T, Barnes JM, Pieper C. Housing conditions, sanitation and associated health risks in selected low-cost housing settlements in Cape Town, South Africa. Habitat International, 2011, 35(2): 335-342 10.1016/j.habitatint.2010.11.001

[25] Hosseini M. On the effect of urban features on human casualty level in large and populated cities. Asian Disaster Management News, 2007, 13(2): 9-10.

[26] Huchzermeyer M. Haferburg C, Ossenbrügge J. Low-income housing and commodified urban segregation in South Africa. Ambiguous restructurings of post-apartheid Cape Town, 2003, Münster: Lit Verlag 115-136.

[27] Ngxubaza, V. 2010. An investigation of the low cost housing process with specific reference to the Mbashe Local Municipality. Masters thesis, Cape Peninsula University of Technology.

[28] Pieterse, E. 2009. Post-apartheid geographies in South Africa: Why are urban divides so persistent? Paper presented at the Interdisciplinary debates on development and cultures: Cities in development—spaces, conflicts and agency, Leuven University, 15 December 2009.

[29] Sakijege T, Lupala J, Sheuya S. Flooding, flood risks and coping strategies in urban informal residential areas: The case of Keko Machungwa, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. Jamba: Journal of Disaster Risk Studies, 2012, 4(1): 1-10.

[30] Smith K, Petley D. Environmental hazards: assessing risk and reducing disaster, 2009 5 London and New York: Routledge

[31] Smith, W. 2008. Isidima: Creating dignified communities. In The state of the province report 2008, 73–85. Cape Town: Office of the Premiere.

[32] Statistics South Africa 2011. General household survey. Nesstar online data tool. http://interactive.statssa.gov.za:8282/webview/. Accessed 26 Nov 2014.

[33] Tomlinson M. Managing the risk in housing delivery: local government in South Africa. Habitat International, 2011, 35(3): 419-425 10.1016/j.habitatint.2010.11.003

[34] Ziervogel, G., and Smit, W. 2009. Learning to swim: Strengthening flooding governance in the city of Cape Town. Paper presented at the 2009 Amsterdam Conference on the Human Dimensions of Global Environmental Change, Amsterdam, 2–4 December 2009.

[35] Zweig, T. 2006. The Cape Town Community Housing Company: The registration of land process in their first eight housing developments and implications for the transfer of ownership to beneficiaries. Research report prepared for the Department of Environmental and Geographical Science, University of Cape Town.