Collaboration Exercises—The Lack of Collaborative Benefits

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to analyze what professional emergency personnel learn during collaboration exercises and the benefits of what they have learned. Observations (n = 19) and semistructured interviews (n = 32) were carried out in conjunction with major exercises held in Sweden (2007–2012). The results show that exercises tend to be based on their own logic, which differs from actual events. Exercise participants believe that they mainly learn single-track, parallel, and path-dependent behavior. The exercises do not facilitate the use of cross-boundary activities. This means that learning, as well as benefits from the exercises for actual events, is limited. The exercises would be more appropriate if those participating had the opportunity to identify weaknesses, try alternative ways, and engage in comprehensive organizational analyses at the conclusion of the exercises. Based on the results of the study, alternative models for collaboration exercises are suggested, with elements that would better develop collaboration and contribute to learning.

Keywords

Ambulance / Collaboration exercises / Emergency personnel / Police / Rescue services / Sweden

References

[1] Alexander DE. Approaches to emergency management teaching at the Master’s level. Journal of Emergency Management, 2013, 13(1): 59-72 10.5055/jem.2013.0128

[2] Alharbi TS, Carlström ED, Ekman I, Olsson L-E. Implementation of person-centred care: Management perspective. Journal of Hospital Administration, 2014, 3(3): 107-120 10.5430/jha.v3n3p107

[3] Andersson A, Carlström ED, Åhgren B, Berlin JM. Managing boundaries at the accident scene—A qualitative study of collaboration exercises. International Journal of Emergency Services, 2014, 3(1): 77-94 10.1108/IJES-02-2013-0003

[4] Appelbaum SH, Wohl L. Transformation or change: Some prescriptions for health care organizations. Managing Service Quality, 2000, 10(5): 279-298 10.1108/09604520010345768

[5] Arthur WB. Anderson PW, Arrow KJ, Pines D. Self-reinforcing mechanisms in economics. The economy as an evolving complex system, the proceedings of the evolutionary paths of the global economy, 1988, Massachusetts: Addisson-Wesley 9-31.

[6] Arthur WB. Dosi G, Freeman C, Nelson R, Silverberg G, Soetes L. Competing technologies: An overview. Technical change and economic theory, 1988, London and New York: Printer Publishers 38-66.

[7] Babu S, Hodges K, Kjonnerod E. Simulations and institutional change: Training US government professionals for improved management of complex emergencies abroad. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 1997, 5(4): 231-240 10.1111/1468-5973.00061

[8] Bergström J, Dahlström N, Henriqson E, Dekker S. Team coordination in escalating situations: An empirical study using Mid-Fidelity simulation. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2010, 18(4): 220-230 10.1111/j.1468-5973.2010.00618.x

[9] Berlin JM, Carlström ED. The 90-second collaboration: A critical study of collaboration exercises at extensive accident sites. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2008, 16(4): 173-181 10.1111/j.1468-5973.2008.00548.x

[10] Berlin JM, Carlström ED. Why is collaboration minimised at the accident scene? A critical study of a hidden phenomenon. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2011, 20(2): 159-171 10.1108/09653561111126094

[11] Berlin JM, Carlström ED. The dominance of mechanistic behaviour: A critical study of emergency exercises. International Journal of Emergency Management, 2013, 9(4): 327-350 10.1504/IJEM.2013.059878

[12] Berlin JM, Carlström ED. Collaboration exercises: What do they contribute?—A study of learning and usefulness. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2015

[13] Blumenthal B, Haspeslagh P. Toward a definition of corporate transformation. Sloan Management Review, 1994, 35(3): 101-106.

[14] Boin, A., P. ’t HartB, E. Stern, and B. Sundelius. 2005. The politics of crisis management: Public leadership under pressure. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

[15] Boin A, Kofman-Bos C, Overdijk W. Crisis simulation: Exploring tomorrow’s vulnerabilities and threats. Simulation & Gaming, 2004, 34(3): 378-393 10.1177/1046878104266220

[16] Borodzicz EP. Risky business: Crisis simulations examined in the context of the safety people, 1997, London: University of London

[17] Borodzicz EP, van Haperen K. Individual and group learning in crisis simulations. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2002, 10(3): 139-147 10.1111/1468-5973.00190

[18] Brattberg E. Coordination for contingencies: Taking stock of post-9/11 homeland security reforms. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2012, 20(2): 77-89 10.1111/j.1468-5973.2012.00662.x

[19] Burgess RG. In the field—An introduction to field research, 1991, London: Routledge

[20] Bush PD. The theory of institutional change. Journal of Economic Issues, 1987, 21(3): 1075-1116

[21] Carlström ED. Strategies for change: Adaptation to new accounting conditions. Journal of Accounting & Organizational Change, 2012, 8(1): 41-61 10.1108/18325911211205739

[22] Christensen T, Lægreid P, Rykkja LH. After a terrorist attack: Challenges for political and administrative leadership in Norway. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2013, 21(3): 167-177 10.1111/1468-5973.12019

[23] Clarke JN. Transitional coordination in Sudan (2006–08): Lessons from the United Nations Resident Coordinator’s Office. Disasters, 2013, 37(3): 420-441 10.1111/disa.12008

[24] Coombs WT. Ongoing crisis communication. Planning, managing, and responding, 2007, Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications

[25] Corbacioglu S, Kapucu N. Organisational learning and self-adaptation in dynamic disaster environment. Disasters, 2006, 30(2): 212-233 10.1111/j.0361-3666.2006.00316.x

[26] Crichton MT, Ramsay CG, Kelly T. Enhancing organizational resilience through emergency planning: Learning from cross-sectoral lessons. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2009, 17(1): 24-37 10.1111/j.1468-5973.2009.00556.x

[27] David PA. Clio and the economics of QWERTY. American Economic Review, 1985, 75(2): 332-337.

[28] David PA. Garrouste P, Ioannides S. Path dependence, its critics, and the quest for historical economics. Evolution and path dependence in economic ideas. Past and present, 2001, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar 15-40.

[29] Deverell E. Crisis management and learning: Factors that influence authorities’ ability to learn (Krishantering och lärande: Faktorer som påverkar myndigheters förmåga att lära). Kungl Krigsvetenskapsakademiens Handlingar och Tidskrift, 2012, 216(1): 117-130 (in Swedish)

[30] Donahue, A.K., and R.V. Tuohy. 2006. Lessons we don’t learn: A study of the lessons of disasters, why we repeat them, and how we can learn them. Homeland Security Affairs 2(2). http://www.hsaj.org/?fullarticle=2.2.4. Accessed 12 Aug 2014.

[31] Drennan L, McConnell A. Risk and crisis management in the public sector, 2007, New York: Routledge

[32] Fetterman DM. Ethnography—Step by step, 2010, London: Sage Publications

[33] Fink S. Crisis management: Planning for the inevitable, 2002, Lincoln: Universe

[34] Fiol CM, Lyles MA. Organizational learning. Academy of Management Review, 1985, 10(4): 803-813.

[35] Frederickson HG, LaPorte TR. Airport security, high reliability, and the problem of rationality. Public Administration Review, 2002, 62(S1): 33-43 10.1111/1540-6210.62.s1.7

[36] Garud R, Karnøe P. Path dependency and creation, 2001, London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates

[37] GNYHA (Greater New York Hospital Association). 2005. Effective emergency management drills and exercises. Greater New York Hospital Association. http://www.gnyha.org. Accessed 12 Aug 2014.

[38] Golden-Biddle K, Locke K. Composing qualitative research, 1997, Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications

[39] Gredler M. Evaluating games and simulations, a process approach, 1992, London: Kogan Page

[40] Grote G, Weichbrodt JC, Günter H, Zala-Mezö E, Künzle B. Coordination in high-risk organizations: The need for flexible routines. Cognition, Technology & Work, 2009, 11(1): 17-27 10.1007/s10111-008-0119-y

[41] Hammersley M, Atkinson P. Ethnography Principles in practice, 2005, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge

[42] Haydu J. Making use of the past: Time periods as cases to compare and as sequences of problem solving. The American Journal of Sociology, 1998, 104(2): 339-371 10.1086/210041

[43] Hinings CR, Malhotra N. Ebner A, Beck N. Change in institutional fields. The institutions of the market: Organizations, social systems, and governance, 2008, Oxford: Oxford University Press 106-131 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199231423.003.0006

[44] Ingemarsdotter, J., and C. Trané. 2013. Why exercise together?—Toward a common theme and coordination of cross-sectorial exercises (Varför öva tillsammans?—mot en gemensam inriktning och samordning av tvärsektoriella övningar). FOI Totalförsvarets forskningsinstitut. Rapport nr: FOI-R-3679-SE. Stockholm: FOI Totalförsvarets forskningsinstitut (in Swedish).

[45] Johansson C, Åstrom Å, Kauffeldt A, Helldin L, Carlström ED. Culture as a predictor of resistance to change: A study of competing values in a psychiatric nursing context. Health Policy, 2013, 114(2–3): 156-162.

[46] Jørgensen D. Participant observation. A methodology for human studies, 1989, London: Sage Publications

[47] Kapucu N. Collaborative emergency management: Better community organising, better public preparedness and response. Disasters, 2008, 32(2): 239-262 10.1111/j.1467-7717.2008.01037.x

[48] Kapucu N, Arslan T, Demiroz F. Collaborative emergency management and national emergency management network. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2010, 19(4): 452-468 10.1108/09653561011070376

[49] Kim H. Improving simulation exercises in Korea for disaster preparedness. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2013, 22(1): 38-47 10.1108/09653561311301961

[50] Klabbers JHG. The exercises planners guide, 1999, London: HMSO

[51] Knudsen T. Economy selection theory. Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 2002, 12: 443-470 10.1007/s00191-002-0126-8

[52] Kvale S. Interviews: An introduction to qualitative research interviewing, 1996, Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications

[53] Lagadec P. Learning processes for crisis management in complex organizations. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 1997, 5(1): 24-31 10.1111/1468-5973.00034

[54] Lalonde C. In search of archetypes in crisis management. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2004, 12(2): 76-88 10.1111/j.0966-0879.2004.00437.x

[55] Lalonde C. The potential contribution of the field of organizational development to crisis management. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2007, 15(2): 95-104 10.1111/j.1468-5973.2007.00508.x

[56] Lalonde C, Roux-Dufort C. Challenges in teaching crisis management: Connecting theories, skills, and reflexivity. Journal of Management Education, 2013, 37(1): 21-50 10.1177/1052562912456144

[57] Lateef F. Simulation-based learning: Just like the real thing. Journal of Emergencies, Trauma and Shock, 2010, 3(4): 348-352 10.4103/0974-2700.70743

[58] Lee Y-I, Trim P, Upton J, Upton D. Large emergency-response exercises: Qualitative characteristics—A survey. Simulation & Gaming, 2009, 40(6): 726-751 10.1177/1046878109334006

[59] Loveluck, C. 1994. Eight propositions and one proposal, edited version of the keynote address given at the 1994 ABSEL/SAGSET Conference in Warwick, England.

[60] Marincioni F, Fraboni R. A baseline assessment of emergency planning and preparedness in Italian universities. Disasters, 2012, 36(2): 291-315 10.1111/j.1467-7717.2011.01259.x

[61] Mason J. Qualitative researching, 1996, London: Sage Publications

[62] McConnell A, Drennan L. Mission impossible? Planning and preparing for crisis. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2006, 14(2): 59-70 10.1111/j.1468-5973.2006.00482.x

[63] McLennan J, Holgate AM, Omodei MM, Wearing AJ. Decision making effectiveness in wildfire teams. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2006, 14(1): 27-37 10.1111/j.1468-5973.2006.00478.x

[64] Mendonça D, Fiedrich F. Training for improvisation in emergency management: Opportunities and limits for information technology. International Journal of Emergency Management, 2006, 3(4): 348-363 10.1504/IJEM.2006.011301

[65] Miles, M., and M. Huberman. 1984/1994. Qualitative data analysis: An expanded sourcebook. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.

[66] Mitroff II, Anagnos G. Managing crisis before they happen: What every executive needs to know about crisis management, 2001, New York: Amacom

[67] Moats JB, Chermack TJ, Dooley LM. Using scenarios to develop crisis managers: Applications of scenario planning and scenario-based training. Advances in Developing Human Resources, 2008, 10(3): 397-424 10.1177/1523422308316456

[68] Moynihan DP. From intercrisis to intracrisis learning. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2009, 17(3): 189-198 10.1111/j.1468-5973.2009.00579.x

[69] Nemeth C, Wears RL, Patel S, Rosen G, Cook R. Resilience is not control: Healthcare, crisis management, and ICT. Cognition, Technology & Work, 2011, 13(3): 189-202 10.1007/s10111-011-0174-7

[70] Palm J, Ramsell E. Developing local emergency management by co-ordination between municipalities in policy networks: Experiences from Sweden. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2007, 15(4): 173-182 10.1111/j.1468-5973.2007.00525.x

[71] Perrow C. Normal accidents. Living with high-risk technologies, 1984, New Jersey: Princeton University Press

[72] Perry RW. Disaster exercise outcomes for professional emergency personnel and citizen volunteers. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2004, 12(2): 64-75 10.1111/j.0966-0879.2004.00436.x

[73] Perry RW, Lindell MK. Preparedness for emergency response: Guidelines for the emergency planning process. Disasters, 2003, 27(4): 336-350 10.1111/j.0361-3666.2003.00237.x

[74] Peterson DM, Perry RW. The impacts of disaster exercises upon participants. Disaster Prevention and Management, 1999, 8(4): 241-254 10.1108/09653569910283879

[75] Petrenj, B., E. Letterie, and P. Trucco. 2011. Towards enhanced collaboration and information sharing towards critical infrastructure resilience: Current barriers and emerging capabilities. The 4th Annual International Conference on Next Generation Infrastructures, Virginia, November 2011.

[76] Pope C, Mays N. Qualitative research in health care, 2000, London: BMJ

[77] Powley, E.H., and M.E. Nissen. 2012. If you can’t trust, stick to hierarchy: Structure and trust as contingency factors in threat assessment contexts. Journal of Homeland Security and Emergency Management 9(1). Article 14. doi:10.1515/1547-7355.1986.

[78] Quarantelli EL. Disaster crisis management: A summary of research findings. Journal of Management Studies, 1988, 25(4): 373-385 10.1111/j.1467-6486.1988.tb00043.x

[79] Quinn RE. Beyond rational management. Mastering the paradoxes and competing demands of high performance, 1988, San Francisco: Josey-Bass

[80] Rolfe I, Saunders D, Powell T. Simulations and games for emergency and crisis management, 1998, London: Kogan Press

[81] Rosenthal U. September 11: Public administration and the study of crises and crisis management. Administration & Society, 2003, 35(2): 129-143 10.1177/0095399703035002001

[82] Roux-Dufort C. Is crisis management (only) a management of exceptions?. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2007, 15(2): 105-114 10.1111/j.1468-5973.2007.00507.x

[83] Rutherford M. Thorstein Veblen and the processes of institutional change. History of Political Economy, 1984, 16(3): 341-348 10.1215/00182702-16-3-331

[84] Rykkja LH. Crisis simulations as tools for government control and coordination (Ovelser i Samfunnssikkehet som Styrnings- og samordningsverktoy). Nordiske Organisasjonsstudier, 2010, 12(2): 3-26 (in Norwegian)

[85] Scholtens A. Controlled collaboration in disaster and crisis management in the Netherlands, history and practice of an overestimated and underestimated concept. Journal of Contingency and Management, 2008, 16(4): 195-207 10.1111/j.1468-5973.2008.00550.x

[86] Scott W. Open peer commentaries on accidents in high-risks systems. Technology Studies, 1994, 1(1): 23-25.

[87] Senge P. The fifth discipline, 1990, New York: Doubleday

[88] Sikström S. Forgetting curves: Implications for connectionist models. Cognitive Psychology, 2002, 45(1): 95-152 10.1016/S0010-0285(02)00012-9

[89] Sinclair H, Doyle EE, Johnston DM, Patton D. Assessing emergency management training and exercises. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2012, 21(4): 507-521 10.1108/09653561211256198

[90] Smith D. For whom the bell tolls: Imagining accidents and the development of crisis simulation in organizations. Simulation & Gaming, 2004, 35(3): 347-362 10.1177/1046878104266295

[91] Smith D, Elliott D. Exploring the barriers to learning from crisis: Organizational learning and crisis. Management Learning, 2007, 38(5): 519-538 10.1177/1350507607083205

[92] Sommer M, Njå O. Dominant learning processes in emergency response organizations: A case study of a joint rescue coordination centre. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2012, 20(4): 219-230 10.1111/1468-5973.12003

[93] Sommer M, Braut GS, Njå O. A model for learning in emergency response work. International Journal of Emergency Management, 2013, 9(2): 151-169 10.1504/IJEM.2013.055161

[94] Stein J. How institutions learn: A socio-cognitive perspective. Journal of Economic Issues, 1997, 31(3): 729-740

[95] Thompson D. Leveraging learning to improve disaster management outcomes. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2012, 3(4): 195-206 10.1007/s13753-012-0020-4

[96] Torres RT, Preskill H. Evaluation and organizational learning: Past, present, and future. American Journal of Evaluation, 2001, 22(3): 387-395 10.1177/109821400102200316

[97] Van den Ven AH, Poole MS. Explaining development and change in organizations. Academy of Management Review, 1995, 20(3): 510-540.

[98] Van Nieuwaal, K. 2006. Gas depletion in the Dutch Wadden Sea. Organizing paths—paths of organizing. Paper presented at the EIASM (European Institute for Advanced Studies in Management) Workshop: Organising Paths—Paths of Organising 3rd–4th November in Germany, Berlin. http://www.eiasm.org/frontoffice/event_announcement.asp?event_id=449#1025. Accessed 12 Aug 2014.

[99] Van Nieuwaal K. The institutional survival path—A case study on mechanical cockle fishery and gas extraction in the Dutch Wadden Sea, 2011, Enschede: Ipskamp Drukkers

[100] Van Wart M, Kapucu N. Crisis management competencies. The case of emergency managers in the USA. Public Management Review, 2011, 13(4): 489-511 10.1080/14719037.2010.525034

[101] Watson TJ. Ethnography, reality, and truth: The vital need for studies of ‘how things work’ in organizations and management. Journal of Management Studies, 2011, 48(1): 202-217 10.1111/j.1467-6486.2010.00979.x

[102] Wolcott HF. Ethnography. A way of seeing, 2008, Lanham: Altamira Press