Benefits and Challenges of Resilience and Vulnerability for Disaster Risk Management

Abstract

This article addresses resilience and vulnerability as two prominent concepts within disaster risk science. The authors provide an overview of current uses and benefits of and challenges to resilience and vulnerability concepts for disaster risk management (DRM). The article summarizes the evolution of these concepts and of attempts to define them precisely, and addresses the potential benefits of conceptual vagueness. The usage and conception of resilience and vulnerability within a selection of strategies and legislations in DRM are compared. Complementing this analysis of disaster risk research and management practice, a survey identifies some of the benefits of and challenges to the concepts of resilience and vulnerability as seen by a peer-community. Synthesizing the three approaches, we conclude that a certain conceptual and methodological “haze” prevails, which hampers the transfer of information and findings within disaster risk science, from science to practice, and vice versa. But this vagueness offers opportunities for communication between disaster risk science, policy, and practice. Overall, evaluations of the resilience and vulnerability concepts are lacking, which demands the development of criteria to identify and assess the challenges to and benefits of resilience and vulnerability for DRM.

Keywords

Boundary object / Disaster risk / Policy–science–practice interaction / Risk assessment / Resilience / Vulnerability

References

[1] Alexander DE. Resilience and disaster risk reduction: An etymological journey. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2013, 13(11): 2707-2716 10.5194/nhess-13-2707-2013

[2] Alexander DE. Confronting catastrophe, 2000, New York: Oxford University Press

[3] Anderson MB, Woodrow PJ. Rising from the ashes: Development strategies in times of disaster, 1998, Boulder: Lynne Rienner

[4] Aven T. On some recent definitions and analysis frameworks for risk, vulnerability, and resilience. Risk Analysis, 2011, 31(4): 515-522 10.1111/j.1539-6924.2010.01528.x

[5] Bara, C. 2011. Risk analysis in civil protection (Risiko-und Gefährdungsanalysen im Bevölkerungsschutz). Zurich: Center for Security Studies (CSS), Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule.

[6] Bara, C., and G. Brönnimann. 2011. Focal report 6. Risk analysis. resilience—Trends in policy and research. Zurich: Crisis and Risk Network (CRN), Center for Security Studies (CSS), Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule.

[7] Birkmann, J. (Ed.) 2006. Measuring vulnerability to natural hazards: Towards disaster resilient societies. Tokyo: United Nations University Press.

[8] Birkmann J, Cardona OD, Carreño ML, Barbat AH, Pelling M, Schneiderbauer S, Kienberger S, Keiler M Framing vulnerability, risk and societal responses: The move framework. Natural Hazards, 2013, 67(2): 193-211 10.1007/s11069-013-0558-5

[9] Blaikie P, Cannon T, Davis I, Wisner B. At risk—natural hazards, people’s vulnerability and disasters, 1994 2 London: Routledge

[10] Bohle HG, Downing TE, Watts MJ. Climate change and social vulnerability: Toward a sociology and geography of food insecurity. Global Environmental Change, 1994, 4(1): 37-48 10.1016/0959-3780(94)90020-5

[11] Brand F. S., Jax K.. Focusing the meaning(s) of resilience: Resilience as a descriptive concept and a boundary object. Ecology and Society, 2007, 12(1): 23

[12] Burton, I., R. W. Kates, and G. F. White. 1978. The environment as hazard. 2nd ed. 1993. New York: The Guilford Press.

[13] Cardona OD. Bankoff G, Frerks G, Hilhorst D. The need for rethinking the concepts of vulnerability and risk from a holistic perspective: A necessary review and criticism for effective risk management. Mapping vulnerability—Disasters, development and people, 2004, London: Earthscan 37-51.

[14] Chambers R. Vulnerability: How the poor cope. IDS Bulletin, 1989, 20(2): 1-7 10.1111/j.1759-5436.1989.mp20002001.x

[15] Chambers R, Conway GR. Sustainable rural livelihoods: Practical concepts for the 21th century, 1992, Brighton: Institute for Development Studies, University of Sussex

[16] Cutter SL. Vulnerability to environmental hazards. Progress in Human Geography, 1996, 20(4): 529-539 10.1177/030913259602000407

[17] Cutter SL, Barnes L, Berry M, Burton C, Evans E, Tate E, Webb J. A place-based model for understanding community resilience to natural disasters. Global Environmental Change, 2008, 18(4): 598-606 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2008.07.013

[18] Deeming H. Clarifying resilience: An invited comment. Natural Hazards Observer, 2013, 37(1): 14-16.

[19] Dombrowsky W.. Resilience—Progress or ideology? (Resilienz—Fortschritt Oder Ideologie?). Notfallvorsorge, 2013, 1: 22-26.

[20] EC (European Commission). 2005. Green paper on a European programme for critical infrastructure protection. COM(2005) 576 final. Brussels. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/site/en/com/2005/com2005_0576en01.pdf.

[21] EC (European Commission). 2006. Communication from the commission on a European programme for critical infrastructure protection. COM(2006) 786 final. Brussels. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/site/en/com/2006/com2006_0786en01.pdf. Accessed 18 March 2014.

[22] EC (European Commission). 2007. Directive on the assessment and management of flood risks. 2007/60/EC. Brussels. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2007:288:0027:0034:en:pdf. Accessed 18 March 2014.

[23] EC (European Commission). 2008. Directive on the identification and designation of European critical infrastructures and the assessment of the need to improve their protection. Brussels. 2008/114/EC. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2008:345:0075:0082:EN:PDF. Accessed 18 March 2014.

[24] EC (European Commission). 2010. The EU internal security strategy in action: Five steps towards a more secure europe. COM(2010) 673 final. Brussels. http://europa.eu/legislation_summaries/justice_freedom_security/fight_against_organised_crime/jl0050_en.htm. Accessed 18 March 2014.

[25] EC (European Commission). 2013. EU strategy on adaptation to climate change. COM(2013) 216 final. Brussels. http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:DKEY=725522:EN:NOT. Accessed 18 March 2014.

[26] European Council Draft internal security strategy for the European Union: “Towards a European security model.” 7120/10, 2010, Brussels: European Council

[27] Fekete A. Spatial disaster vulnerability and risk assessments: Challenges in their quality and acceptance. Natural Hazards, 2012, 61(3): 1161-1178 10.1007/s11069-011-9973-7

[28] Fernando, N. 2010. Forced relocation after the Indian Ocean tsunami, 2004. Case study of vulnerable populations in three relocation settlements in Galle, Sri Lanka. Dissertation, University of Bonn.

[29] Ford J.D., Knight M., Pearce T.. Assessing the “usability” of climate change research for decision-making: A case study of the Canadian International Polar Year. Global Environmental Change, 2013, 23: 1317-1326.

[30] Frommer B. Climate change and the resilient society: Utopia or realistic option for German regions?. Natural Hazards, 2013, 67(1): 99-115 10.1007/s11069-012-0421-0

[31] Fuchs, G., and R. Vogt. 2013. Personal communication. Flood Protection Center, Cologne. May 2013.

[32] Garschagen M. Resilience and organisational institutionalism from a cross-cultural perspective: An exploration based on urban climate change adaptation in Vietnam. Natural Hazards, 2013, 67(1): 25-46 10.1007/s11069-011-9753-4

[33] GFMI (Germany, Federal Ministry of the Interior [Bundesministerium des Innern]). 2011. Protecting Critical Infrastructures – Risk and Crisis Management: A Guide for Companies and Government Authorities (Schutz Kritischer Infrastrukturen – Risiko- und Krisenmanagement. Leitfaden für Behörden und Unternehmen). Berlin: BMI (in German).

[34] GFG (German Federal Government [Bundesregierung der Bundesrepublik Deutschland]). 2008. German Strategy for Adaptation to Climate Change (Deutsche Anpassungsstrategie an den Klimawandel). http://www.bmub.bund.de/en/topics/climate-energy/climate/details-climate/artikel/deutsche-anpassungsstrategie-an-den-klimawandel/?tx_ttnews[swords]=climate&tx_ttnews[backPid]=921&cHash=1e22204c8c1369b5596f84d8f866f298 (in German). Accessed 18 March 2014.

[35] GFG (German Federal Government [Bundesregierung der Bundesrepublik Deutschland]). 2009a. Federal Law on Civil Protection and Disaster Assistance (Gesetz über den Zivilschutz und die Katastrophenhilfe des Bundes–ZSKG). http://www.juris.de/purl/gesetze/_ges/ZSG (in German). Accessed 18 March 2014.

[36] GFG (German Federal Government [Bundesregierung der Bundesrepublik Deutschland]). 2009b. Federal Water Act (Gesetz zur Ordnung des Wasserhaushalts – WHG). http://www.juris.de/purl/gesetze/WHG (in German). Accessed 18 March 2014.

[37] GFOCD (Germany, Federal Office of Civil Protection and Disaster Assistance [Bundesamt für Bevölkerungsshutz und Katastrophenhilfe]). 2010a. New Strategy for the Protection of the Population in Germany (Neue Strategie zum Schutz der Bevölkerung in Deutschland). In Wissenschaftsforum 4. Bonn: GFOCD. http://www.bbk.bund.de/SharedDocs/Kurzmeldungen/BBK/DE/2011/18011300_Publikation_Neue_Strategie_2_Auflg.html (in German). Accessed 18 March 2014.

[38] GFOCD (Germany, Federal Office of Civil Protection and Disaster Assistance [Bundesamt für Bevölkerungsshutz und Katastrophenhilfe]). 2010b. Method for Risk Analysis in Civil Protection (Methode für die Risikoanalyse im Bevölkerungsschutz). In Wissenschaftsforum 8. Bonn: GFOCD. http://www.bbk.bund.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/BBK/DE/Publikationen/Wissenschaftsforum/Bd8_Methode-Risikoanalyse-BS.html (in German). Accessed 18 March 2014.

[39] GFOCD (Germany, Federal Office of Civil Protection and Disaster Assistance [Bundesamt für Bevölkerungsshutz und Katastrophenhilfe]). 2010c. Estimating Vulnerability of Municipalities in the Case of Floods (Abschätzung der Verwundbarkeit gegenüber Hochwasserereignissen auf kommunaler Ebene). Bonn: GFOCD. http://www.bbk.bund.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/BBK/DE/Publikationen/Praxis_Bevoelkerungsschutz/Band_4_Praxis_BS_Hochwasser-Kommuna-Ebene.html (in German). Accessed 18 March 2014.

[40] GPDRR (Global Platform for Disaster Risk Reduction). 2013a. Chair’s Summary. Fourth session of the global platform for disaster risk reduction. Geneva. http://www.ifrc.org/docs/IDRL/33306_finalchairssummaryoffourthsessionof.pdf. Accessed 21–23 May 2013.

[41] GPDRR (Global Platform for Disaster Risk Reduction). 2013b. High-level dialogue communiqué ahead of the wave: Leading the way to resilience. Fourth session of the global platform for disaster risk reduction. Geneva. http://www.preventionweb.net/files/33281_highlevelcommunique.pdf. Accessed 21–23 May 2013.

[42] Hewitt K. Interpretations of calamity: From the viewpoint of human ecology, 1983, Winchester: Allen & Unwin

[43] Hewitt K. Regions of risk—A geographical introduction to disasters, 1997, Harlow: Addison Wesley Longman

[44] Hinkel J. Indicators of vulnerability and adaptive capacity: Towards a clarification of the science–policy interface. Global Environmental Change: Human and Policy Dimensions, 2011, 21(1): 198-208 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2010.08.002

[45] Holling CS. Resilience and stability of ecological systems. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 1973, 4: 1-23 10.1146/annurev.es.04.110173.000245

[46] Hufschmidt G. A comparative analysis of several vulnerability concepts. Natural Hazards, 2011, 58(2): 621-643 10.1007/s11069-011-9823-7

[47] IFRC (International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies) The long road to resilience. Impact and Cost-Benefit Analysis of Drr in Bangladesh, 2012, Geneva: IFRC

[48] Ionescu C, Klein RJT, Hinkel J, Kumar KSK, Klein R. Towards a formal framework of vulnerability to climate change. Environmental Modeling and Assessment, 2009, 14(1): 1-16 10.1007/s10666-008-9179-x

[49] KatNet (Katastrophennetzwerk). 2012. Resilience and vulnerability – What is the usage of these concepts for disaster management?” Conference, 14–16 November 2012, University of Bonn, Bonn. http://www.katastrophennetz.de/index.php/de/resilienz2012 (in German). Accessed 18 March 2014.

[50] Klein, R.J.T. 2004. Resilience to natural hazards: How useful is this concept? In EVA Working Paper No. 9, DINAS-COAST Working Paper No. 14. Potsdam, Germany: Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research.

[51] Klein RJT. Identifying countries that are particularly vulnerable to the adverse effects of climate change: An academic or a political challenge?. Carbon and Climate Law Review, 2009, 3(3): 284-291.

[52] Klein RJT, Nicholls RJ, Thomalla F. Resilience to natural hazards: How useful is this concept?. Global Environmental Change Part B, 2003, 5(1–2): 35-45 10.1016/j.hazards.2004.02.001

[53] Kuhlicke C. Resilience: A capacity and a myth: Findings from an in-depth case study in disaster management research. Natural Hazards, 2013, 67(1): 61-76 10.1007/s11069-010-9646-y

[54] Lewis J, Kelman I, Kelman I. Places, people and perpetuity : Community capacities in ecologies of catastrophe. ACME: An International E-Journal for Critical Geographies, 2010, 9(2): 191-220.

[55] Lorenz DF. The diversity of resilience: Contributions from a social science perspective. Natural Hazards, 2013, 67(1): 7-24 10.1007/s11069-010-9654-y

[56] Manyena SB. The concept of resilience revisited. Disasters, 2006, 30(4): 434-450 10.1111/j.0361-3666.2006.00331.x

[57] Menoni S, Molinari D, Parker D, Ballio F, Tapsell S. Assessing multifaceted vulnerability and resilience in order to design risk-mitigation strategies. Natural Hazards, 2012, 64(3): 2057-2082 10.1007/s11069-012-0134-4

[58] Miller, F., H. Osbahr, E. Boyd, F. Thomalla, S. Bharwani, G. Ziervogel, B. Walker, J. Birkmann, et al. 2010. Resilience and vulnerability: Complementary or conflicting concepts? Ecology and Society 15(3): Article 11.

[59] Mitchell K. Kirby A. Human dimensions of environmental hazards. Nothing to fear, 1990, Tuscon: University of Arizona Press 131-175.

[60] Mustafa D, Ahmed S, Saroch E, Bell H. Pinning down vulnerability: From narratives to numbers. Disasters, 2011, 35(1): 62-86 10.1111/j.1467-7717.2010.01193.x

[61] Norris F, Stevens S, Pfefferbaum B, Wyche K, Pfefferbaum R. Community resilience as a metaphor, theory, set of capacities and strategy for disaster. American Journal of Community Psychology, 2008, 41(1): 127-150 10.1007/s10464-007-9156-6

[62] OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development). 2013. What does resilience mean for donors? OECD factsheet. http://www.oecd.org/dac/governance-development/risk-resilience.htm. Accessed 18 March 2014.

[63] Oliver-Smith A. Success and failures in post-disaster resettlement. Disasters, 1991, 15(1): 12-23 10.1111/j.1467-7717.1991.tb00423.x

[64] Oliver-Smith A. Varley A. Peru’s five hundred year earthquake: Vulnerability in historical context. Disasters, development and environment, 1994, Chichester: John Wiley and Sons 31-48.

[65] Oliver-Smith A. Hoffman SM, Oliver-Smith A. Theorizing disasters—Nature, power and culture. Catastrophe and culture—The anthropology of disaster, 2002, Santa Fe: School of American Research Press 23-47.

[66] Omand, D. 2013. Building national resilience and crisis management capabilities. Paper presented at the 3rd annual conference of the Institute for risk and disaster reduction, June 2013, University College London, London.

[67] Perrow C. Normal accidents: Living with high-risk technologies, 1984, New York: Basic Books

[68] Park J, Seager TP, Rao PSC, Convertino M, Linkov I. Integrating risk and resilience approaches to catastrophe management in engineering systems. Risk Analysis, 2013, 33(3): 356-367 10.1111/j.1539-6924.2012.01885.x

[69] Renn O, Keil F. Approaching systemic risks (Systemische Risiken. Versuch einer Charakterisierung). GAIA, 2008, 17(4): 349-354.

[70] Renn O, Keil F. What is systemic about systemic risks? (Was ist das Systemische an Systemischen Risiken?). GAIA, 2009, 18(2): 97-99.

[71] Renn O, Schweizer P-J, Dreyer M, Klimke A. Risk: How society handles uncertainty (Risiko: Über den gesellschaftlichen Umgang mit Unsicherheit), 2007, Munich: Oekom Verlag

[72] SFC (Swiss Federal Council). 2012a. Strategy for civil protection 2015+ (Strategie Bevölkerungsschutz und Zivilschutz 2015+). Bern: SFC (in German).

[73] SFC (Swiss Federal Council). 2012b. National strategy for protecting critical infrastructure (Nationale Strategie zum Schutz kritischer Infrastrukturen). Bern: SFC (in German).

[74] SFOCP (Swiss federal office for civil protection). 1995. Guideline KATANOS—Catastrophes and emergencies in Switzerland. A comparative overview (Leitfaden KATANOS—Katastrophen und Notlagen in der Schweiz. Eine vergleichende Übersicht). Bern: SFOCP (in German).

[75] SFOCP (Swiss federal office for civil protection). 2003. Guideline KATARISK—Catastrophes and emergencies in Switzerland. A risk analysis from the perspective of civil Protection (Leitfaden KATARISK—Katastrophen und Notlagen in der Schweiz. Eine Risikobeurteilung aus Sicht des Bevölkerungsschutzes). Bern: SFOCP (in German).

[76] SFOCP (Swiss federal office for civil protection). 2013. Guideline KATAPLAN—Cantonal risk analysis and prevention (Leitfaden KATAPLAN—Kantonale Gefährdungsanalyse und Vorsorge). Bern: SFOCP (in German).

[77] Star SL, Griesemer JR. Institutional ecology, “translations” and boundary objects: Amateurs and professionals in Berkeley’s museum of vertebrate zoology, 1907–39. Social Studies of Science, 1989, 19(3): 387-420 10.1177/030631289019003001

[78] Strunz S. Is conceptual vagueness an asset? Arguments from philosophy of science applied to the concept of resilience. Ecological Economics, 2012, 76: 112-118 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2012.02.012

[79] Turner BL, Kasperson RE, Matson PA, McCarthy JJ, Corell RW, Christensen L, Eckley N, Kasperson JX A framework for vulnerability analysis in sustainability science. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2003, 100(14): 8074-8079 10.1073/pnas.1231335100

[80] UKCO (United Kingdom, Cabinet Office). 2013. National risk register of civil emergencies (NRR). Cabinet Office UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-risk-register-for-civil-emergencies-2013-edition.

[81] UKG (United Kingdom, Government of). 2004. Civil Contingencies Act. http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2004/36. Accessed 18 March 2014.

[82] UKG (United Kingdom, Government of). 2010. National Security Strategy. Command 7953. https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/61936/national-security-strategy.pdf.

[83] UN (United Nations). 1987. International Decade for Natural Disaster Reduction. A/RES/42/169. http://www.un.org/documents/ga/res/42/a42r169.htm. Accessed 18 March 2014.

[84] UN (United Nations). 1999. Activities of the International Decade for Natural Disaster Reduction. Report of the Secretary-General. A/54/132E/1999/80. http://www.un.org/esa/documents/ecosoc/docs/1999/e1999-80.htm. Accessed 18 March 2014.

[85] UN (United Nations). 2005. International Strategy for Disaster Reduction. A/RES/60/195. http://www.un.org/en/ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol=A/RES/60/195. Accessed 18 March 2014.

[86] UNDRO (United Nations Disaster Relief Organization) Shelter after disaster, 1982, New York: UNDRO, United Nations

[87] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction) Living with risk. A global review of disaster reduction initiatives, 2004, Geneva: UNISDR

[88] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction). 2005. Hyogo framework for action 2005–2015. Building the resilience of nations and communities to disasters. Extract from the final report of the world conference on disaster reduction (A/CONF.206/6). Geneva: UNISDR.

[89] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction). 2010–2011. Hyogo framework for action 2005–2015. Mid-term review. Geneva: UNISDR.

[90] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction) Towards a Post-2015 framework for disaster risk reduction, 2012, Geneva: UNISDR

[91] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction). 2013. Implementation of the Hyogo framework for action. Summary of reports 2007–2013. Geneva: UNISDR.

[92] Vetter A, Schauser I. Adaptation to climate change (Anpassung an den Klimawandel). GAIA, 2013, 22(4): 248-254 (in German)

[93] Vogel C, Moser SC, Kasperson RE, Dabelko GD. Linking vulnerability, adaptation, and resilience science to practice: Pathways, players, and partnerships. Global Environmental Change, 2007, 17(3–4): 349-364 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2007.05.002

[94] Watts MJ, Bohle HG. The space of vulnerability: The causal structure of hunger and famine. Progress in Human Geography, 1993, 17(1): 43-67 10.1177/030913259301700103

[95] Weick KE, Sutcliffe KM. Managing the unexpected: Resilient performance in an age of uncertainty, 2007, San Francisco: Jossey-Bass

[96] White GF, Kates RW, Burton I. Knowing better and losing even more: The use of knowledge in hazards management. Environmental Hazards, 2001, 3(3): 81-92 10.3763/ehaz.2001.0308

[97] Wisner B. Disaster vulnerability: Scale, power and daily life. GeoJournal, 1993, 30(2): 127-140 10.1007/BF00808129

[98] Wisner B, Blaikie P, Cannon T, Davis I. At risk—Natural hazards, people’s vulnerability and disasters, 2004 2 London: Routledge

[99] Zhou HJ, Wang JA, Wan JH, Jia HC. Resilience to natural hazards: A geographic perspective. Natural Hazards, 2010, 53(1): 21-41 10.1007/s11069-009-9407-y

[100] Zolli A, Healy AM. Resilience: Why things bounce back, 2012, New York: Free Press