Extreme cities and bad places

Abstract

This article considers places where climate change-induced hazards will be particularly important, focusing on two examples, the lagoon location of Venice and the Garonne riverbank location of Bordeaux. The Venice lagoon territory is close to the coast and has a dispersed form of urban development. Our project experiments resulted in the formulation of a series of adaptation strategies to increased disaster risks, including returning current agricultural land and residential areas to their original state as wetlands and marshes before their reclamation during the early decades of the twentieth century. The scenarios introduce space as a relevant variable into the debate about the impact of climate change and adaptation. This article also deals with the recovery of “bad places,” such as the urban blight on the Garonne riverbanks of Bordeaux, and their relationship with sustainability and disaster risks. Increasingly, the emphasis on minimizing energy consumption and promoting recycling forces cities to reuse places of elevated risk. Only very recently in modern urban planning are polluted and risky areas frequently selected for new development projects to reclaim the vast areas of existing brownfields in the name of sustainability. Integrating disaster risk reduction into a new economic and social context has thus become an extremely important part of contemporary urban design and planning for these reclaimed (bad) areas. The research concludes that urban and territorial design should and can integrate the inevitability of risk. This is necessary for developing approaches and strategies that offer some rethinking about “wicked” problems, long-term time horizons, radical imagination, dynamic representations, and minute territorial readings in contemporary urban planning.

Keywords

Bordeaux / risk and sustainability / urban and territorial design / urban development scenario construction / Venice / water management

References

[1] ARPAV (Veneto Environmental Protection Agency). 2006. Water Protection Plan (Piano di Tutela delle Acque). Veneto Environmental Protection Agency.

[2] Beck U.. (English translation 1992). Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity, 1986, Frankfurt a/M: Suhrkamp (Risikogesellschaft - Auf dem Weg in eine andere Moderne)

[3] Beck U.. Mostafavi M.. Social Inequality and Climate Change. Ecological Urbanism, 2010, Cambridge, MA and Baden, Switzerland: Harvard University Graduate School of Design, Lars Müller Publishers

[4] Bevilacqua P.. Bevilacqua P.. The Revolutions of Water. Irrigation and Transformation of Agriculture between the 18th and the 20th Century. History of Italian Agriculture in Contemporary Times, 1989, Venice: Marsilio 255-318 (Le rivoluzioni dell’acqua. Irrigazioni e trasformazioni dell’agricoltura tra Sette e Novecento)

[5] Bevilacqua P.. Venice and the Sea. A Planetary Metaphor, 1998, Rome: Donzelli (Venezia e le acque. Una metafora planetaria)

[6] Bianchi B.. Bevilacqua P.. The New Plain, the Landscape of Reclaimed Land in the Po Valley. History of Italian Agriculture in Contemporary Times, 1989, Venezia: Marsilio (La nuova pianura, Il paesaggio delle terre bonificate in area padana)

[7] Corboz A.. The Land as Palimpsest. Diogenes, 1983, 31(121): 12-34 10.1177/039219218303112102

[8] Cosgrove D.. Cosgrove D., Petts G.. Platonism and Practicality: Hydrology, Engineering and Landscape in Sixteenth-Century Venice. Water, Engineering and Landscape, 1990, New Delhi: CBS Publishers

[9] Department of Land Policies, Veneto Region. 2009. Regional Territorial Coordination Plan (PTCR, Piano Territoriale di Coordinamento Regionale). Veneto Region.

[10] EEA (European Environment Agency) - EUROSION. 2004. Five Meter Elevation Contour Line. http://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/data/five-meter-elevation-contour-line.

[11] Fabian L., Viganò P.. Extreme City. Climate Change and the Transformation of the Waterscape, 2010, Venice: IUAV Press

[12] Fuà G., Zacchia C.. Industrialization without Fractures, 1983, Bologna: Il Mulino (Industrializzazione senza fratture)

[13] Holling, C. S. 1973. Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics No. 4: 1–23.

[14] Indovina F.. The Diffuse City, 1990, Venice: Department of Social and Economic Analysis of Land (Dipartimento di Analisi Economica e Sociale del Territorio), IUAV (Istituto Universitario di Architettura di Venezia) (La città diffusa)

[15] Klein R. J. T., Nicholls R. J., Thomalla F.. Resilience to Natural Hazards: How Useful is This Concept?. Environmental Hazards, 2003, 5(1–2): 35-45 10.1016/j.hazards.2004.02.001

[16] Lefebvre H.. The Production of Space, 1974, Paris: Anthropos (La production de l’espace)

[17] Lynch K.. What Time is This Place?, 1972, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press

[18] Rittel, H. W. J., and M. M. Webber. 1973. Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning. Policy Sciences No. 4: 155–69.

[19] Sassen S.. Rosemann J., Sepulveda D.. Bridging the Ecologies of Cities and Nature. The New Urban Question, Urbanism beyond Neo-Liberalism, 2009, Rotterdam: Ifou

[20] Secchi, B. 1991. The Periphery (La periferia). Casabella No. 583.

[21] Secchi B.. Ferrario V., Sampieri A., Viganò P.. Isotropy vs. Hierarchy. Landscapes of Urbanism, Q5, 2011, Rome: Officina

[22] Soja E. W.. Seeking Spatial Justice, 2010, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press

[23] UNWCED Our Common Future, 1987, Oxford: Oxford University Press (Brundtland Report)

[24] Urban Planning Management Department of Bordeaux 2030 Greater Bordeaux, a Sustainable Metropolis, 2009, Bordeaux: Ville de Bordeaux (2030 Vers le Grand Bordeaux, une métropole durable)

[25] Urban Planning Management Department of Bordeaux. To Live in Bordeaux, a City of Action, 2011, Bordeaux: Ville de Bordeaux (Habiter Bordeaux, la ville-action)

[26] Viganò P.. Water and Asphalt: The Project of Isotropy in the Metropolitan Region of Venice. Architectural Design, 2008, 78(1): 34-39 10.1002/ad.606

[27] Viganò P.. The Territories of Urbanism. Design as Knowledge Producer, 2010, Rome: Officina (I territori dell’urbanistica - Il progetto come produttore di conoscenza)

[28] —. 2010b. Extreme City: A Design and a Research Theme. Introduction. In Extreme City - Climate Change and the Transformation of the Waterscape, edited by L. Fabian and P. Viganò. Venice: IUAV Press.

[29] —. 2011. The Project of Isotropy. In Landscapes of Urbanism, Q5, edited by V. Ferrario, A. Sampieri, and P. Viganò. Rome: Officina.

[30] Viganò P.. degli Uberti U., Lombardo T., Lambrecht G., Zaccariotto G.. Landscapes of Water, 2009, Pordenone: Risma (Paesaggi dell’acqua)