Rationale for reconsidering current regulations restricting use of hybrids in orange juice

Abstract

Huanglongbing (HLB) is a disease that has devastated the Florida citrus industry, threatens the entire U.S. citrus industry, and globally is rapidly spreading. Florida’s citrus production is 90% sweet orange, which is quite sensitive to HLB. The heavy reliance on sweet orange for Florida citrus production makes the industry especially vulnerable to diseases that are damaging to this type of citrus. Furthermore, 90% of Florida oranges are used in producing orange juice that is defined by a federal regulation known as the “orange juice standard”, specifying that at least 90% of “orange juice” must be derived from Citrus sinensis. Genomic analyses definitively reveal that sweet orange is not a true species, but just one of many introgression hybrids of C. reticulata and C. maxima, with phenotypic diversity resulting from accumulated mutations in this single hybrid, the “sweet orange”. No other fruit industry is limited by law to such a narrow genetic base. Fortunately, there are new citrus hybrids displaying reduced sensitivity to HLB, and in some cases they produce juice, alone or in blends, that consumers would recognize as “orange juice”. Reconsidering current regulations on orange juice standards may permit use of such hybrids in “orange juice”, providing greater latitude for commercialization of these hybrids, leading to higher-quality orange juice and a more sustainable Florida orange juice industry.

References

[1] NASS (National Agricultural Statistics Service). Florida citrus statistics 2017-2018. https://www.nass.usda.gov/Statistics_by_State/Florida/Publications/Citrus/Citrus_Statistics/2017-18/fcs1718.pdf. (2019).

[2] Gottwald, T. R. Current epidemiological understanding of citrus huanglongbing. Annu. Rev. Phytopathol. 48, 119-139 (2010).

[3] Bové, J. M. Huanglongbing: a destructive, newly-emerging, century-old disease of citrus. J. Plant Pathol. 88, 7-37 (2006).

[4] Koger, C. Texas expands citrus greening quarantine area. The Packer https://www.thepacker.com/article/texas-expands-citrus-greening-quarantine-area (2019).

[5] CPDPP (Citrus Pest & Disease Prevention Program). History of huanglongbing in California. http://californiacitrusthreat.org/wp-content/themes/citrus/files/pdf/CP-146-1119-HLB-Timeline-Graphic_CCT.pdf. (2019).

[6] Singerman, A. Cost of production for processed oranges grown in Central Florida (Ridge), 2015/16. UF IFAS Extension Publication http://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/pdffiles/FE/FE100600.pdf (2017).

[7] Muraro, R. P. Summary of 2004-2005 citrus budget for the Central Florida (Ridge) production region. IFAS Extension Publication https://crec.ifas.ufl.edu/media/crecifasufl edu/economics/Central_Florida_Costs_Write-Up.pdf (2005).

[8] Singerman, A. & Useche, P. Impact of citrus greening on citrus operations in Florida. UF IFAS Extension Publication FE983 https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/pdffiles/FE/FE98300.pdf (2016).

[9] Court, C. D., Hodges, A. W., Rahmani, M. & Spreen, T. H. Economic contributions of the Florida citrus industry in 2015-16. UF/IFAS Economic Impact Analysis program https://fred.ifas.ufl.edu/pdf/economic-impactanalysis/Economic_Impacts_of_the_Florida_Citrus_Industry_2015_16.pdf (2017).

[10] Schneider, M. Florida orange juice processing is getting squeezed out of business. Orlando Sentinel https://www.orlandosentinel.com/business/os-bz-orange-juice-squeeze-20190910-peaghi3ay5ebhml6o4mftanofa-story.html (2019).

[11] Baldwin, E. et al. Effect of Liberibacter infection (Huanglongbing Disease) of citrus on orange fruit physiology and fruit/fruit juice quality: chemical and physical analyses. J. Agric Food Chem. 58, 1247-1262 (2010).

[12] NRC ( National Research Council ). Genetic vulnerability and crop diversity. in Managing Global Genetic Resources: Agricultural Crop Issues and Policies. 47-84 (National Academies of Science Press, Washington DC, 1993).

[13] Bruns, H. A. Southern corn leaf blight: a story worth retelling. Agron. J. 109, 1-7 (2017).

[14] Turner, R. S. After the famine: plant pathology, Phytophthora infestans, and the late blight of potatoes, 1845-1960. Historical Stud. Phys. Biol. Sci. 35, 341-370 (2005).

[15] Gretler, C. & Chasan, E. Big food rethinks farming to fight a lack of crop diversity. BNN Bloomberg https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/big-food-rethinks-farming-to-fight-a-lack-of-crop-diversity-1.1320445 (2019).

[16] Heslop-Harrison, J. S. & Schwarzacher, T. Domestication, genomics, and the future for banana. Ann. Bot. 100, 1073-1084 (2007).

[17] 2Blades Foundation . Major crop disease outbreaks. http://2blades.org/major-crop-disease-outbreaks/ (2018).

[18] Morton, V. & Staub, T. A short history of fungicides. APSnet Feature www. http://www.davidmoore.org.uk/21st_Century_Guidebook_to_Fungi_PLATINUM/Assets/Printed_documents/MortonStaub_History_of_Fungicides.pdf (2008).

[19] Pedneault, K. & Provost, C. Fungus resistant grape varieties as a suitable alternative for organic wine production: benefits, limits, and challenges. Sci. Hortic. 208, 57-77 (2016).

[20] Stover, E., Inch, S., Richardson, M. & Hall, D. G. Conventional citrus of some scion/rootstock combinations show field tolerance under severe huanglongbing disease pressure. Hortscience 51, 127-132 (2016).

[21] FAOSTAT. Production: crops. http://www.fao.org/faostat/en/#data (2017).

[22] Futch, S. & Singerman, A. An inside look at Brazil’s citrus production practices. Citrus Ind. http://citrusindustry.net/2018/01/30/inside-look-brazils-citrus-production-practies/ (2018).

[23] Hearn, C. J. The evolution of citrus species-methods to develop new sweet orange cultivars. Proc. Fla State Hort. Soc. 107, 1-3 (1994).

[24] Torres, A. M., Soost, R. K. & Diedenhofen, U. Leaf isozymes as genetic markers in citrus. Am. J. Bot. 65, 869-881 (1978).

[25] Novelli, V. M., Cristofani, M., Souza, A. A. & Machado, M. A. Development and characterization of polymorphic microsatellite markers for the sweet orange (Citrus sinensis L. Osbeck.) . Genet. Mol. Biol. 29, 90-96 (2006).

[26] Wu, A. G. et al. Sequencing of diverse mandarin, pummelo and orange genomes reveals complex history of admixture during citrus domestication. Nat. Biotech. 7, 656-663 (2014).

[27] Wu, A. G. et al. Genomics of the origin and evolution of Citrus . Nature 554, 311-316 (2018).

[28] Statista. Per capita consumption of orange juice in the United States from 2000/2001 to 2017/2018 (in gallons). https://www.statista.com/statistics/895621/us-per-capita-consumption-of-orange-juice/ (2019).

[29] CFR. 21 CFR 146.135-Orange juice. Code of Federal Regulations https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2011-title21-vol2/pdf/CFR-2011-title21-vol2-sec146-135.pdf (1992).

[30] US Apple Assoc. Popular varieties. http://usapple.org/the-industry/apple-varieties/ (2019).

[31] Lamb, R. C., Aldwinckle, H. S., Way, R. D. & Terry, D. E. Liberty apple. HortScience 14, 757-758 (1979).

[32] USDA-FAS. Citrus: world markets and trade. https://apps.fas.usda.gov/psdonline/circulars/citrus.pdf (2020).

[33] A.I.J.N. Code of practice: reference guideline for orange juice. https://aijn.eu/en/reference-guidelines/oranges (2019).

[34] Tetrapak, Orange book. https://orangebook.tetrapak.com/chapter/standards-and-regulations (2020).

[35] Albrigo, L. G., Achor, D. S. & Russ, R. V. Low production of Ambersweet orange in Florida related to poor pollen production and germination. Proc. Fla State Hort. Soc. 114, 127-131 (2001).

[36] Bai, J., Baldwin, E., Hearn, J., Driggers, R. & Stover, E. Volatile profile comparison of USDA sweet orange-like hybrids versus ‘Hamlin’ and ‘Ambersweet’. HortScience 49, 1262-1367 (2014).

[37] Moshonas, M. G., Shaw, P. E. & Carte, R. D. Ambersweet orange hybrid: compositional evidence for variety classification. J. Agric Food Chem. 39, 1416-1421 (1991).

[38] Yu, Y. et al. Comparative analysis of juice volatiles in selected mandarins, mandarin relatives and other citrus genotypes. J. Sci. Food Agric 98, 1124-1131 (2018).

[39] Bai, J., Baldwin, E., Hearn, J., Driggers, R. & Stover, E. Volatile and nonvolatile flavor chemical evaluation of USDA orange-mandarin hybrids for comparison to sweet orange and mandarin fruit. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 141, 339-350 (2016).

[40] Feng, S., Suh, J. H., Gmitter, F. G. & Wang, Y. Differentiation between flavors of sweet orange (Citrus sinensis) and mandarin (Citrus reticulata) . J. Agric Food Chem. 66, 203-211 (2018).

[41] Grosser, J., Gmitter, F., Wang, Y. & Castle, B. Working toward better orange juice in the HLB world. Citrus Ind. http://citrusindustry.net/2019/05/17/working-toward-better-orange-juice-in-the-hlb-world/ (2019).

[42] Wang, Y. et al. Sugar Belle® shows potential in orange juice processing. Citrus Ind. http://citrusindustry.net/2019/09/16/sugar-belle-shows-potential-in-orange-juice-processing/ (2019).

[43] CFR. 27 CFR 4.23-Varietal (grape type) labeling. Code of Federal Regulations https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2011-title27-vol1/pdf/CFR-2011-title27-vol1-sec4-23.pdf (1996).