Investigating visual stress within family and domestic violence refuges in Australia

Abstract

Family and domestic violence (FDV) is an issue that impacts on the health and well-being of women and children worldwide. Research shows that trauma-exposed individuals commonly experience heightened sensitivity to sensory triggers within the environmental milieu. Despite interest in trauma-informed design, the impact of visual stress has largely gone unexplored in the design of FDV refuges. This research utilises a novel visual stress analysis tool (ViStA) to examine the presence of potential visual stressors within two purpose-built FDV refuges in Australia. ViStA enables an assessment of visual stress, taking into account the complex interplay of size, spatial frequency, duty cycle, and contrast in the overall visual experience. Through an analysis of refuge images (n = 60), this study mapped the presence potential visual stressors. Through this analysis it was found that 'high contrast linear elements' were the most common potential visual stressors in both refuges. Common features among the spaces with the highest peak residuals were "perforated panelling" and "highly patterned surfaces". Additionally, visual stressors were able to be categorised into eight primary functional categories of architectural features. The exploratory nature of this research underlines its importance as a foundational step towards developing evidence-based design practices for trauma-informed environments.

Keywords

Visual stress / Family and domestic violence / Trauma-informed design / Refuge design / Neuroarchitecture

References

[1] American Psychiatric Association , 2022. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders: DSM-5-TR, fifth ed., text revision. American Psychiatric Association Publishing.

[2] Attwell, D. , Laughlin, S.B. , 2001. An energy budget for signaling in the grey matter of the brain. J. Cerebr. Blood Flow Metabol. 21, 1133- 1145.

[3] Baker, N. , Steemers, K. , 2019. Healthy Homes: Designing with Light and Air for Sustainability and Wellbeing. RIBA Publishing, London.

[4] Blankenship, S.L. , Botdorf, M. , Riggins, T. , Dougherty, L.R. , 2019. Lasting effects of stress physiology on the brain: Cortisol reactivity during preschool predicts hippocampal functional connectivity at school age. Dev. Cognit. Neurosci. 40, 100736.

[5] Bollo, C. , Donofrio, A. , 2022. Trauma-informed design for permanent supportive housing: four case studies from Seattle and Denver. Hous. Soc. 49 (3), 229- 250.

[6] Bucich, M. , Steel, Z. , Berle, D. , 2024. Posttraumatic stress disorder(PTSD) symptom profiles among people who have experienced abuse: findings from the NESARC-III study. Psychol. Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice & Policy 16 (1), 76- 85.

[7] Cody, M.W. , Jones, J.M. , Woodward, M.J. , Simmons, C.A. , Gayle Beck, J. , 2017. Correspondence between self-report measures and clinician assessments of psychopathology in female intimate partner violence survivors. J. Interpers Violence 32 (10), 1501- 1523.

[8] Cortese, B.M. , Schumann, A.Y. , Howell, A.N. , McConnell, P.A. , Yang, Q.X. , Uhde, T.W. , 2018. Preliminary evidence for differential olfactory and trigeminal processing in combat veterans with and without PTSD. NeuroImage. Clinical 17, 378- 387.

[9] Cross, D. , Fani, N. , Powers, A. , Bradley, B. , 2017. Neurobiological development in the context of childhood trauma. Clin. Psychol.: A Pub. Div. Clin. Psychol. Am. Psychol. Assoc. 24 (2), 111.

[10] Dekel, R. , Shaked, O.Z. , Ben-Porat, A. , Itzhaky, H. , 2019. Posttraumatic stress disorder upon admission to shelters among female victims of domestic violence: an ecological model of trauma. Violence Vict. 34 (2), 329- 345.

[11] Dekel, R. , Shaked, O. , Ben-Porat, A. , Itzhaky, H. , 2020. The interrelations of physical and mental health: self-rated health, depression, and PTSD among female IPV survivors. Violence Against Women 26(3/4), 379- 394.

[12] Dokkedahl, S. , Kristensen, T.R. , Elklit, A. , 2022. Can women shelters help reduce symptoms of PTSD and c-PTSD? Trajectories of PTSD symptom development following partner- and family-related violence. J. Interpers Violence 37 (23-24), NP22026- NP22046.

[13] Evans, B.J.W. , Stevenson, S.J. , 2008. The pattern glare test: a review and determination of normative values. Ophthalmic Physiol. Opt. 28 (4), 295- 309.

[14] Fedele, K.M. , Johnson, N.L. , Caldwell, J.C. , Shteynberg, Y. , Sanders, S.E. , Holmes, S.C. , Johnson, D.M. , 2018. The impact of comorbid diagnoses on the course of posttraumatic stress disorder symptoms in residents of battered women's shelters. Psychol. Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice and Policy 10 (6), 628- 635.

[15] Fernandez, D. , Wilkins, A.J. , 2008. Uncomfortable images in art and nature. Perception 37 (7), 1098- 1113.

[16] Fernández-Fillol, C. , Pitsiakou, C. , Perez-Garcia, M. , Teva, I. , Hidalgo-Ruzzante, N. , 2021. Complex PTSD in survivors of intimate partner violence: risk factors related to symptoms and diagnoses. Eur. J. Psychotraumatol. 12 (1), 2003616.

[17] Field, D.J. , 1987. Relations between the statistics of natural images and the response properties of cortical cells. J. Opt. Soc. Am. 4 (12), 2379- 2394.

[18] Fleck-Henderson, A. , 2017. From movement to mainstream: a battered women's shelter evolves (1976-2017). Affilia: Fem.Inq. Soc. Work 32 (4), 476- 490.

[19] Gelbard-Sagiv, H. , Magidov, E. , Sharon, H. , Hendler, T. , Nir, Y. , 2018. Noradrenaline modulates visual perception and late visually evoked activity. Curr. Biol. 28 (14), 2239- 2249.e6.

[20] Gilbar, O. , Dekel, R. , Hyland, P. , Cloitre, M. , 2019. The role of complex posttraumatic stress symptoms in the association between exposure to traumatic events and severity of intimate partner violence. Child Abuse Neglect 98, 104174.

[21] Haigh, S.M. , Barningham, L. , Berntsen, M. , Coutts, L.V. , Hobbs, E.S. , Irabor, J. , Lever, E.M. , Tang, P. , Wilkins, A.J. , 2013. Discomfort and the cortical haemodynamic response to coloured gratings. Vis. Res. 89, 47- 53.

[22] Jonker, I.E. , Lako, D.A.M. , Beijersbergen, M.D. , Sijbrandij, M. , van Hemert, A.M. , Wolf, J. , 2019. Factors related to depression and post-traumatic stress disorder in shelter-based abused women. Violence Against Women 25 (4), 401- 420.

[23] Juricevic, I. , Land, L. , Webster, M.A. , Wilkins, A. , 2010. Visual discomfort and natural image statistics. Perception 39 (7), 884- 899.

[24] Karatzias, T. , Hyland, P. , Bradley, A. , Cloitre, M. , Roberts, N.P. , Bisson, J.I. , Shevlin, M. , 2019. Risk factors and comorbidity of ICD-11 PTSD and complex PTSD: findings from a trauma-exposed population based sample of adults in the United Kingdom. Depress. Anxiety 36 (9), 887- 894.

[25] Khanade, K. , Rodriguez-Paras, C. , Sasangohar, F. , Lawley, S. , 2018. Investigating Architectural and Space Design Considerations for Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) Patients. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting 62 (1), 1722- 1726.

[26] Kulkarni, S.J. , Stylianou, A.M. , Wood, L. , 2019. Successful rules reduction implementation process in domestic violence shelters: from vision to practice. Soc. Work 64 (2), 147- 156.

[27] Laricchiuta, D. , Panuccio, A. , Picerni, E. , Biondo, D. , Genovesi, B. , Petrosini, L. , 2023. The body keeps the score: the neurobiological profile of traumatized adolescents. Neurosci. Biobehav.Rev. 145, 105033.

[28] Le, A.T.D. , Payne, J. , Clarke, C. , Kelly, M.A. , Prudenziati, F. , Armsby, E. , Penacchio, O. , Wilkins, A.J. , 2017. Discomfort from urban scenes: metabolic consequences. Landsc. Urban Plan 160, 61- 68.

[29] Majewski, K. von , Kraus, O. , Rhein, C. , Lieb, M. , Erim, Y. , Rohleder, N. , 2023. Acute stress responses of autonomous nervous system, HPA axis, and inflammatory system in posttraumatic stress disorder. Transl. Psychiatry 13 (1), 36.

[30] Marti-Marca, A. , Vilà-Balló A. , Cerda-Company, X. , Ikumi, N. , TorresFerrus, M. , Caronna, E. , Gallardo, V.J. , Alpuente, A. , Torralba Cuello, M. , Soto-Faraco, S. , Pozo-Rosich, P. , 2023. Exploring sensory sensitivity, cortical excitability, and habituation in episodic migraine, as a function of age and disease severity, using the pattern-reversal task. J. Headache Pain 24 (1), 104.

[31] Mead, H.K. , Beauchaine, T.P. , Shannon, K.E. , 2010. Neurobiological adaptations to violence across development. Dev. Psychopathol. 22 (1), 1.

[32] Mitcheltree, H. , Sunikka-Blank, M. , 2023. Identifying a research gap in relation to family and domestic violence accommodation design within Victoria, Australia: a systematic review. Front.Architect. Res. 12, 209- 221.

[33] Mueller-Pfeiffer, C. , Schick, M. , Schulte-Vels, T. , O'Gorman, R. , Michels, L. , Martin-Soelch, C. , Blair, J.R. , Rufer, M. , Schnyder, U. , Zeffiro, T. , Hasler, G. , 2013. Atypical visual processing in posttraumatic stress disorder. Neuroimage: Clinical 3, 531.

[34] Nuamah, J. , Rodriguez-Paras, C. , Sasangohar, F. , 2021. Veterancentered investigation of architectural and space design considerations for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). HERD 14 (1), 164- 173.

[35] Olshausen, B.A. , Field, D.J. , 1996. Natural image statistics and efficient coding. Netw. Comput. Neural Syst. 7 (2), 333- 339.

[36] Owen, C. , Crane, J. , 2022. Trauma-informed design of supported housing: a scoping review through the lens of neuroscience. Int.J. Environ. Res. Publ. Health 19 (21), 14279.

[37] Penacchio, O. , Wilkins, A.J. , 2015. Visual discomfort and the spatial distribution of fourier energy. Vis. Res. 108, 1- 7.

[38] Raise-Abdullahi, P. , Meamar, M. , Vafaei, A.A. , Alizadeh, M. , Dadkhah, M. , Shafia, S. , Ghalandari-Shamami, M. , Naderian, R. , Samaei, S.A. , Rashidy-Pour, A. , 2023. Hypothalamus and posttraumatic stress disorder: a review. Brain Sci. 13 (7), 1010.

[39] Rosen, J.B. , Schulkin, J. , 2022. Hyperexcitability: from normal fear to pathological anxiety and trauma. Front. Syst. Neurosci. 16, 727054.

[40] Sardinha, L. , Maheu-Giroux, M. , Stöckl, H. , Meyer, S.R. , GarcíaMoreno, C. , 2022. Global, regional, and national prevalence estimates of physical or sexual, or both, intimate partner violence against women in 2018. Lancet 399, 803- 813.

[41] Shaked, O. , Dekel, R. , Ben-Porat, A. , Itzhaky, H. , 2021. Predicting changes in PTSD and depression among female intimate partner violence survivors during shelter residency: a longitudinal study. Psychol. Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice & Policy 13 (3), 349- 358.

[42] Sherin, J.E. , Nemeroff, C.B. , 2011. Post-traumatic stress disorder: the neurobiological impact of psychological trauma. Dialogues Clin. Neurosci. 13 (3), 263.

[43] Strasburger, H. , Rentschler, I. , Jüttner, M. , 2011. Peripheral vision and pattern recognition: a review. J. Vis. 11 (5), 13.

[44] Valentine, C. , 2024. The impact of architectural form on physiological stress: a systematic review. Front. Comput. Sci. 5.

[45] Valentine, C. , Mitcheltree, H. , 2024. Architecture and bioethics: investigating the ethical implications of recent advances in the field of neuroarchitecture. Intell. Build. Int. 16 (1), 3- 9.

[46] Valentine, C. , Steffert, T. , Mitcheltree, H. , Steemers, K. , 2024. Architectural neuroimmunology: a pilot study examining the impact of biophilic architectural design on neuroinflammation. Buildings 14 (5), 1292.

[47] White, S.J. , Sin, J. , Sweeney, A. , Salisbury, T. , Wahlich, C. , Montesinos Guevara, C.M. , Gillard, S. , Brett, E. , Allwright, L. , Iqbal, N. , Khan, A. , Perot, C. , Marks, J. , Mantovani, N. , 2024. Global prevalence and mental health outcomes of intimate partner violence among women: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Trauma Violence Abuse 25 (1), 494- 511.

[48] WHO , 2021. Violence Against Women Prevalence Estimates, 2018.Global, Regional and National Prevalence Estimates for Intimate Partner Violence Against Women and Global and Regional Prevalence Estimates for Non-partner Sexual Violence Against Women. World Health Organization, Geneva. (Accessed 3 October 2024).

[49] Wilkins, A.J. , 1995. Visual Stress. Oxford University Press, p. 124.

[50] Wilkins, A. , Nimmo-Smith, I. , Tait, A. , McManus, C. , Della Sala, S. , Tilley, A. , Arnold, K. , Barrie, M. , Scott, S. , 1984. A neurological basis for visual discomfort. Brain 107(Pt 4), 989- 1017.

[51] Wilkins, A.J. , Penacchio, O. , Leonards, U. , 2018. The built environment and its patterns: a view from the vision sciences. J.Sustain. Des. Appl. Res. Innovat. Eng. Built Environ. 6 (1), 5.

[52] Yoshii, T. , Oishi, N. , Ikoma, K. , Nishimura, I. , Sakai, Y. , Matsuda, K. , Yamada, S. , Tanaka, M. , Kawata, M. , Narumoto, J. , Fukui, K. , 2017. Brain atrophy in the visual cortex and thalamus induced by severe stress in animal model. Sci.Rep. 7, 12731.

[53] Zukerman, G. , Fostick, L. , Ben-Itzchak, E. , 2018. Early automatic hyperarousal in response to neutral novel auditory stimuli among trauma-exposed individuals with and without PTSD: an ERP study. Psychophysiology 55(11), e13217.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Authors. Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of KeAi Communications Co. Ltd.