A new form-evolving approach for adaptive tree-like structures using feature region principal stress lines method

Abstract

This paper introduces a concept that adapts natural tree growth mechanisms through an adaptive, hierarchical subdivision of the in-plane design domain, utilizing principal stress lines (PSLs) extracted from feature regions (FRPSLs). The approach integrates architectural interactive design with structural logic, enabling the creation of free-form tree-like structures. A naturally curved tree-like structure is obtained through the superimposition of these patterns and iterative form evolution, with the final shape representing the outward expression of internal forces. Unlike traditional form-finding methods that rely solely on external vertical loading or single load conditions, this method considers vertical plus bidirectional horizontal forces by applying them to generate PSLs patterns. A naturally curved tree-like structure is obtained through the superimposition of these patterns and iterative form evolution, with the final shape representing the outward expression of internal forces. Numerical examples and design cases demonstrate that the proposed method effectively balances aesthetic needs with structural performance, offering a new approach for generating free-form tree-like structures. The results highlight its potential to provide more architectural alternatives with asymmetric, curvilinear forms without compromising structural integrity.

Keywords

Tree-like structure / Form-evolving / Natural growth / Principal stress lines / Feature region / In-plane design domain

References

[1] Akbarzadeh, M. , Van Mele, T. , Block, P. , 2016. Three-dimensional graphic statics: initial explorations with polyhedral form and force diagrams. Int. J. Space Struct. 31(2-4), 217- 226.

[2] Ancelin, P. , Courbaud, B. , Fourcaud, T. , 2004. Development of an individual tree-based mechanical model to predict wind damage within forest stands. For. Ecol. Manag. 203 (1-3), 101- 121.

[3] Arslan SelÇuk, S. , Gülle, N.B. , Mutlu AvinÇ G. , 2022. Tree-like structures in architecture: revisiting frei otto's branching columns through parametric tools. Sage Open12 (3).

[4] Bejan, A. , 2000. Shape and Structure, from Engineering to Nature, first ed. Cambridge University Press, London.

[5] Breseghello, L. , Naboni, R. , 2022. Toolpath-based design for 3D concrete printing of carbon-efficient architectural structures. Addit. Manuf. 56, 102872.

[6] Cascone, F. , Faiella, D. , Tomei, V. , et al., 2021. Stress lines inspired structural patterns for tall buildings. Eng. Struct. 229, 111546.

[7] Couder, Y. , 2001. Patterns with open branches or closed networks: growth in scalar or tensorial fields. In: Branching in Nature: Dynamics and Morphogenesis of Branching Structures, from Cell to River Networks. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, pp. 1-22.

[8] Coudert, Y. , Harris, S. , Charrier, B. , 2019. Design principles of branching morphogenesis in filamentous organisms. Curr. Biol. 21, R1149- R1162.

[9] Dixit, S. , Stefańska, A. , 2023. Bio-logic, a review on the biomimetic application in architectural and structural design. Ain Shams Eng. J. 14 (1), 101822.

[10] Dixit, S. , Stefańska, A. , Musiuk, A. , 2021. Architectural form finding in arboreal supporting structure optimisation. Ain Shams Eng. J. 12 (2), 2321- 2329.

[11] Dutta, G.S. , Steuernagel, L. , Meiners, D. , 2020. Generative design solutions for free-form structures based on biomimicry. In: Simulation Science: Second International Workshop, SimScience 2019, Clausthal-Zellerfeld, May 8-10, 2019, Revised Selected Papers 2. Springer International Publishing, pp. 122-134.

[12] Engel, H. , 2007. Structure Systems, third ed. Hatje Cantz, Stuttgart, pp. 1-16 (Original work published 1968). pp. 16-42.

[13] Gombrich, E.H. , 1994. The Sense of Order: a Study in the Psychology of Decorative Art. Phaidon Press, New York, pp. 1-32.

[14] Guo, K. , Huang, C. , Miao, Y. , et al., 2022. Leaf morphogenesis: the multifaceted roles of mechanics. Mol. Plant 15 (7), 1098- 1119.

[15] Hallé F. , 2001. Branching in plants. In: Branching in Nature: Dynamics and Morphogenesis of Branching Structures, from Cell to River Networks. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, pp. 23-40.

[16] Hannezo, E. , Scheele, C.L.G.J. , Moad, M. , et al., 2017. A unifying theory of branching morphogenesis. Cell 171 (1), 242- 255.

[17] Helliwell, D.R. , 1989. Tree roots and the stability of trees. Arboric. J. 13, 243- 248.

[18] Horsfield, K. , Woldenberg, M.J. , 1986. Branching ratio and growth of tree-like structures. Respir. Physiol. 63 (1), 97- 107.

[19] Huerta, S. , 2006. Structural design in the work of Gaudi. Archit.Sci. Rev. 49 (4), 324- 339.

[20] Jiang, B. , Zhang, J. , Ohsaki, M. , 2022. Optimization of branching structures for free-form surfaces using force density method. J.Asian Architect. Build Eng. 21 (4), 1458- 1471.

[21] Kolodziejczyk, M. , 1992. Verzweigungen mit Fäden: einige Aspekte der Formbildung mittels Fadenmodellen. Verzweigungen, Natürliche Konstruktionen-Leichtbau in Architektur und Natur 4, 101- 126.

[22] Lee, J. , Van Mele, T. , Block, P. , 2018. Disjointed force polyhedra. Comput. Aided Des. 99, 11- 28.

[23] Li, Z. , Lee, T.U. , Xie, Y.M. , 2025. Interactive 3D structural design in virtual reality using preference-based topology optimization. Comput. Aided Des. 180, 103826.

[24] Lindenmayer, A. , 1968. Mathematical models for cellular interactions in development I. Filaments with one-sided inputs. J.Theor. Biol. 18 (3), 280- 299.

[25] Loong, C.N. , Dimitrakopoulos, E.G. , 2023. Modal properties of fractal sympodial trees: insights and analytical solutions using a group tree modeling approach. Appl. Math. Model. 115, 127- 147.

[26] Mandelbrot, B.B. , 1982. The Fractal Geometry of Nature, 2nd prt.edition. Times Books, New York, pp. 156-164.

[27] Mattheck, C. , 1990. Why they grow, how they grow: the mechanics of trees. Arboric. J. 14 (1), 1- 17.

[28] Mattheck, C. , 1991. Trees: the Mechanical Design, first ed.Springer, Berlin.

[29] Mattheck, C. , 1998. Design in Nature: Learning from Trees. Springer Science & Business Media.

[30] Mattheck, C. , Bethge, K. , 1998. The structural optimization of trees. Naturwissenschaften 85 (1), 1- 10.

[31] Mattheck, C. , Kubler, H. , 1997. Wood-the Internal Optimization of Trees. Springer Series in Wood Science.

[32] Menges, A. , Ahlquist, S. (Eds.), 2011. Computational Design Thinking, first ed. Wiley, pp. 10-29.

[33] Mezzadri, F. , Bouriakov, V. , Qian, X. , 2018. Topology optimization of self-supporting support structures for additive manufacturing. Addit. Manuf. 21, 666- 682.

[34] Michell, A.G.M. , 1904. LVIII. The limits of economy of material in frame-structures. London, Edinburgh Dublin Phil. Mag. J. Sci. 8 (47), 589- 597.

[35] Österlund, T. , 2013. Design possibilities of emergent algorithms for the adaptive lighting system. Nordic Journal of Architectural Research (1), 159- 184.

[36] Otto, F. , Rasch, B. , 1996. Finding Form: towards an Architecture of the Minimal, third ed. Axel Menges, Stuttgart.

[37] Pastrana, R. , Ohlbrock, P.O. , Oberbichler, T. , et al., 2023. Constrained form-finding of tensionecompression structures using automatic differentiation. Comput. Aided Des. 155, 103435.

[38] Peng, X. , 2016. Structural topology optimization method for morphogenesis of dendriforms. Open J. Civ. Eng. 6 (4), 526.

[39] Prusinkiewicz, P. , Hammel, M. , Hanan, J. , et al., 1996. L-systems: from the theory to visual models of plants. Proceedings of the 2nd CSIRO Symposium on Computational Challenges in Life Sciences. Citeseer 3, 1- 32.

[40] Prusinkiewicz, P. , Lindenmayer, A. , 1996. The Algorithmic Beauty of Plants, Electronic ed. Springer-Verlag, New York, pp. 21-50.Originally published 1990.

[41] Reis, A.H. , 2006. Constructal theory: from engineering to physics, and how flow systems develop shape and structure. Appl. Mech.Rev. 59 (5), 269- 282.

[42] Rian, I.M. , Sassone, M. , 2014. Tree-inspired dendriforms and fractallike branching structures in architecture: a brief historical overview. Frontiers of Architectural Research 3 (3), 298- 323.

[43] Rodriguez, M. , De Langre, E. , Moulia, B. , 2008. A scaling law for the effects of architecture and allometry on tree vibration modes suggests a biological tuning to modal compartmentalization. Am. J. Bot. 95 (12), 1523- 1537.

[44] Sánchez-Sánchez, J. , Escrig Pallarés, F. , Rodríguez-León M.T. , 2014. Reciprocal tree-like fractal structures. Nexus Netw. J. 16, 135- 150.

[45] Schek, H.J. , 1974. The force density method for form finding and computation of general networks. Comput. Methods Appl.Mech. Eng. 3 (1), 115- 134.

[46] Shen, Y. , D'Acunto, P. , Ohlbrock, P.O. , 2023. EquilibriumSolver_VectorDifference: release 1.00 beta. GitHub. Available: github.YuchiSHEN/EqSolver_VectorDifferenceMethod.git.

[47] Sze, M. , 1963. The Mustard Seed Garden Manual of Painting (Chieh Tzu Yüan Hua Chuan). Princeton University Press, pp. 51-100(Original work published 1679-1701).

[48] Tam, K.M.M. , Mueller, C.T. , 2017. Additive manufacturing along principal stress lines. 3D Print. Addit. Manuf. 4 (2), 63- 81.

[49] Thompson, D. , 1992. On Growth and Form: the Complete Revised Edition. Dover Publications, New York.

[50] Uçar, M.C. , Kamenev, D. , Sunadome, K. , et al., 2021. Theory of branching morphogenesis by local interactions and global guidance. Nat. Commun. 12, 6830.

[51] Von Buelow, P. , 2007. A geometric comparison of branching structures in tension and in compression versus minimal paths.In: Proceedings of the International Association of Shell and Spatial Structures. Venice, Italy, December 2007.

[52] Xie, Y.M. , 2022. Generalized topology optimization for architectural design. Architectural Intelligence 1 (1), 2.

[53] Xu, C. , Wang, Z. , Li, B. , et al., 2021. Form-finding and shape optimization of bio-inspired branching structures based on graphic statics. In: Structures, vol. 29. Elsevier, pp. 392-407.

[54] Yu, Z. , Dai, H. , Shi, Z. , 2022a. Designing truss in architecture: method and applications based on clustering algorithms and principal stress lines. Comput. Aided Des. 151, 103330.

[55] Yu, Z. , Dai, H. , Shi, Z. , 2022b. Structural form-finding of bending components in buildings by using parametric tools and principal stress lines. Frontiers of Architectural Research 11 (3), 561- 573.

[56] Zhang, N. , Zhang, L.C. , Chen, Y. , et al., 2019. Local barycenter based efficient tree-support generation for 3D printing. Comput. Aided Des. 115, 277- 292.

[57] Zhao, Z. , Kang, Z. , Zhang, T. , et al., 2024a. Topology optimization algorithm for spatial truss based on numerical inverse hanging method. J. Constr. Steel Res. 219, 108764.

[58] Zhao, Z. , Liang, B. , Liu, H. , 2018. Topology establishment, form finding, and mechanical optimization of branching structures. J.Braz. Soc. Mech. Sci. Eng. 40, 539.

[59] Zhao, Z. , Yu, D. , Zhang, T. , et al., 2022. Intelligent design algorithm for branching structures based on updated force density method. J. Build. Eng. 57, 104858.

[60] Zhao, Z. , Zhang, T. , Wang, B. , et al., 2024b. Integrated design algorithm for branching structures. Mech. Base. Des. Struct.Mach. 52 (8), 5290- 5307.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of KeAi Communications Co. Ltd.