Optimal design strategy of traditional courtyard based on performance and data-driven method—A case study of Yanshen ancient town, China

Abstract

To address the insufficient integration of performance evaluation and contextual analysis in traditional architectural design, this paper proposes a design workflow that combines data-driven and performance-driven approaches, establishing a comprehensive operational pathway from typology selection and design generation to performance assessment. Using Yanshen Ancient Town, a cold region, as the study area, the research evaluates 18 traditional courtyard types and 8 brick kiln courtyard types. Benchmark models are selected based on the combined performance of PET (Physiological Equivalent Temperature) and MRT (Mean Radiant Temperature) indices. Subsequently, multiple performance indicators, including indoor and outdoor thermal comfort, indoor illuminance, and building energy consumption, are integrated into the analysis. Using a genetic algorithm, Pareto optimal solutions that meet performance requirements are iteratively optimized and filtered. Based on the learning rates and various evaluation indicators, XGBoost is ultimately selected to classify and predict the overall building performance. Results indicate that the model achieves an average prediction accuracy of 83.6%. Additionally, SHAP analysis of the independent variables in the algorithm reveals distinct influencing trends under different performance labels. The workflow demonstrates the feasibility of incorporating performance prediction in the early design stage of village courtyards, significantly enhancing the efficiency of feedback and follow-up between design decision-making and performance evaluation.

Keywords

Traditional courtyard / Performance and data-driven method / Generative design / Machine learning

References

[1] Abdallah, A.S.H. , Mohammad, D.A. , Ali, A.M.M. , 2019. The influence of different courtyard ratios in university buildings on their thermal performance during the hot period:(Faculties of Agriculture and Education, New Sohag University, Egypt as a case study). IOP Conf. Ser. Earth Environ. Sci. 397, 012019.

[2] Akbari, H. , Cherati, S.M. , Monazam, N.H. , Noguchi, M. , 2021. Effect of courtyards' geometrical parameters on climate adaptability and shading performance in hot-arid climate of Yazd(Iran). Sustain. Energy Technol. Assessments 48, 101594.

[3] Akhlaghinezhad, F. , Mohajerani, M. , Bagheri Sabzevar, H. , 2023. Optimizing courtyard design for thermal performance:a study on shadow and sunlight dynamics in traditional houses. International Journal of Urban Management and Energy Sustainability 5 (1), 31- 53.

[4] Al-Hafith, O. , Satish, B.K. , Bradbury, S. , De Wilde, P. , 2017. The Impact of Courtyard parameters on its shading level an experimental study in Baghdad, Iraq. Energy Proc. 134, 99- 109.

[5] Al-Shargabi, A.A. , Almhafdy, A. , Ibrahim, D.M. , Alghieth, M. , Chiclana, F. , 2022. Buildings' energy consumption prediction models based on buildings' characteristics:research trends, taxonomy, and performance measures. J. Build. Eng. 54, 104577.

[6] Amasyali, K. , El-Gohary, N.M. , 2018. A review of data-driven building energy consumption prediction studies. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 81, 1192- 1205.

[7] Andreou, E. , 2014. The effect of urban layout, street geometry and orientation on shading conditions in urban canyons in the Mediterranean. Renew. Energy 63, 587- 596.

[8] Azimi, Z. , Shafaat, A. , 2024. Proposing design strategies for contemporary courtyards based on thermal comfort in cold and semi-arid climate zones. Build. Environ. 266, 112150.

[9] Chatzipoulka, C. , Compagnon, R. , Kaempf, J. , Nikolopoulou, M. , 2018. Sky view factor as predictor of solar availability on building façades. Sol. Energy 170, 1026- 1038.

[10] Deng, Q. , Wang, G. , Wang, Y. , Zhou, H. , Ma, L. , 2021. A quantitative analysis of the impact of residential cluster layout on building heating energy consumption in cold IIB regions of China. Energy Build. 253, 111515.

[11] Diz-Mellado, E. , Ruiz-Pardo, Á. , Rivera-Gómez, C. , de la Flor, F.J.S. , Galán-Marıń C. , 2023. Unravelling the impact of courtyard geometry on cooling energy consumption in buildings. Build. Environ. 237, 110349.

[12] Du, J. , Sun, C. , Xiao, Q. , Chen, X. , Liu, J. , 2020. Field assessment of winter outdoor 3-D radiant environment and its impact on thermal comfort in a severely cold region. Sci. Total Environ. 709, 136175.

[13] El Bat, A.M.S. , Romani, Z. , Bozonnet, E. , Draoui, A. , Allard, F. , 2023. Optimizing urban courtyard form through the coupling of outdoor zonal approach and building energy modeling. Energy 264, 126176.

[14] Evins, R. , Pointer, P. , Vaidyanathan, R. , Burgess, S. , 2012. A case study exploring regulated energy use in domestic buildings using design-of-experiments and multi-objective optimisation. Build. Environ. 54, 126- 136.

[15] Han, J. , Li, X. , Li, B. , Yang, W. , Yin, W. , Peng, Y. , Feng, T. , 2023. Research on the influence of courtyard space layout on building microclimate and its optimal design. Energy Build. 289, 113035.

[16] Hakimazari, M. , Baghoolizadeh, M. , Sajadi, S.M. , Kheiri, P. , Moghaddam, M.Y. , Rostamzadeh-Renani, M. , et al., 2024. Multi-objective optimization of daylight illuminance indicators and energy usage intensity for office space in Tehran by genetic algorithm. Energy Rep. 11, 3283- 3306.

[17] Huang, Z. , Liu, Y. , Pan, C. , Wang, Y. , Yu, H. , He, W. , 2022. Energy-saving effects of yard spaces considering spatiotemporal activity patterns of rural Chinese farm households. J. Clean. Prod. 355, 131843.

[18] Ilbeigi, M. , Ghomeishi, M. , Dehghanbanadaki, A. , 2020. Prediction and optimization of energy consumption in an office building using artificial neural network and a genetic algorithm. Sustain. Cities Soc. 61, 102325.

[19] Ibrahim, Y. , Kershaw, T. , Shepherd, P. , Elkady, H. , 2022. Multi-objective optimisation of urban courtyard blocks in hot arid zones. Sol. Energy 240, 104- 120.

[20] Jamei, E. , Ossen, D.R. , Seyedmahmoudian, M. , Sandanayake, M. , Stojcevski, A. , Horan, B. , 2020. Urban design parameters for heat mitigation in tropics. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 134, 110362.

[21] Jiang, F. , Ma, J. , Webster, C.J. , Li, X. , Gan, V.J. , 2023. Building layout generation using site-embedded GAN model. Autom. ConStruct. 151, 104888.

[22] Jiang, Z. , Gao, W. , Yao, W. , 2023. Research on the wind environment in an enclosed courtyard:effect of the opening position, size and wind angle. Urban Clim. 52, 101737.

[23] Krüger, E.L. , Minella, F.O. , Matzarakis, A. , 2014. Comparison of different methods of estimating the mean radiant temperature in outdoor thermal comfort studies. Int. J. Biometeorol. 58, 1727- 1737.

[24] Kaseb, Z. , Rahbar, M. , 2022. Towards CFD-based optimization of urban wind conditions:comparison of Genetic algorithm, Particle Swarm Optimization, and a hybrid algorithm. Sustain. Cities Soc. 77, 103565.

[25] Liu, K. , Xu, X. , Huang, W. , Zhang, R. , Kong, L. , Wang, X. , 2023. A multi-objective optimization framework for designing urban block forms considering daylight, energy consumption, and photovoltaic energy potential. Build. Environ. 242, 110585.

[26] Lila, A. , Jabi, W. , Lannon, S. , 2021. Predicting solar radiation with Artificial Neural Network based on urban geometrical classification. Building Simulation 2021 17, 902- 909.

[27] Mahdavinejad, M. , Shaeri, J. , Nezami, A. , Goharian, A. , 2024. Comparing universal thermal climate index (UTCI) with selected thermal indices to evaluate outdoor thermal comfort in traditional courtyards with BWh climate. Urban Clim. 54, 101839.

[28] Makki, M. , Navarro-Mateu, D. , Showkatbakhsh, M. , 2022. Decoding the architectural genome:multi-objective evolutionary algorithms in design. Technology|Architecture+ Design 6 (1), 68- 79.

[29] Makki, M. , Showkatbakhsh, M. , Tabony, A. , Weinstock, M. , 2019. Evolutionary algorithms for generating urban morphology:variations and multiple objectives. Int. J. Architect. Comput. 17 (1), 5- 35.

[30] Martinelli, L. , Matzarakis, A. , 2017. Influence of height/width proportions on the thermal comfort of courtyard typology for Italian climate zones. Sustain. Cities Soc. 29, 97- 106.

[31] Mirabi, E. , Akrami Abarghuie, F. , 2023. Investigating the climateadaptive design strategies of residential earth-sheltered buildings in Iran. Int. J. Build. Pathol. Adapt. 41 (5), 1029- 1048.

[32] Mi, J. , Hong, B. , Zhang, T. , Huang, B. , Niu, J. , 2020. Outdoor thermal benchmarks and their application to climate-responsive designs of residential open spaces in a cold region of China. Build. Environ. 169, 106592.

[33] Mostafavi, F. , Tahsildoost, M. , Zomorodian, Z.S. , Shahrestani, S.S. , 2024. An interactive assessment framework for residential space layouts using pix2pix predictive model at the early-stage building design. Smart and Sustainable Built Environment 13 (4), 809- 827.

[34] Nasrollahi, N. , Hatami, M. , Khastar, S.R. , Taleghani, M. , 2017. Numerical evaluation of thermal comfort in traditional courtyards to develop new microclimate design in a hot and dry climate. Sustain. Cities Soc. 35, 449- 467.

[35] Othman, H.A.S. , Alshboul, A.A. , 2020. The role of urban morphology on outdoor thermal comfort:the case of Al-Sharq CityeAz Zarqa. Urban Clim. 34, 100706.

[36] Park, K. , Ergan, S. , Feng, C. , 2024. Quality assessment of residential layout designs generated by relational Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs). Autom. ConStruct. 158, 105243.

[37] Pilechiha, P. , Norouziasas, A. , Ghorbani Naeini, H. , Jolma, K. , 2022. Evaluation of occupant's adaptive thermal comfort behaviour in naturally ventilated courtyard houses. Smart and Sustainable Built Environment 11 (4), 793- 811.

[38] Razmi, A. , Rahbar, M. , Bemanian, M. , 2022. PCA-ANN integrated NSGA-III framework for dormitory building design optimization:energy efficiency, daylight, and thermal comfort. Appl. Energy 305, 117828.

[39] Reveshti, A.M. , Khosravirad, E. , Rouzbahani, A.K. , Fariman, S.K. , Najafi, H. , Peivandizadeh, A. , 2024. Energy consumption prediction in an office building by examining occupancy rates and weather parameters using the moving average method and artificial neural network. Heliyon 10 (4), 25307.

[40] Rivera-Gómez, C. , Diz-Mellado, E. , Galán-Marıń C. , López-Cabeza, V. , 2019. Tempering potential-based evaluation of the courtyard microclimate as a combined function of aspect ratio and outdoor temperature. Sustain. Cities Soc. 51, 101740.

[41] Rodríguez-Algeciras, J. , Tablada, A. , Chaos-Yeras, M. , De la Paz, G. , Matzarakis, A. , 2018. Influence of aspect ratio and orientation on large courtyard thermal conditions in the historical centre of Camagüey-Cuba. Renew. Energy 125, 840- 856.

[42] Rosso, F. , Ciancio, V. , Dell'Olmo, J. , Salata, F. , 2020. Multi-objective optimization of building retrofit in the Mediterranean climate by means of genetic algorithm application. Energy Build. 216, 109945.

[43] Sahnoune, S. , Benhassine, N. , 2023. Winter thermal comfort of a typical courtyard geometry in a semi-arid climate. Journal of Green Building 18 (1), 95- 117.

[44] Satrio, P. , Mahlia, T.M.I. , Giannetti, N. , Saito, K. , 2019. Optimization of HVAC system energy consumption in a building using artificial neural network and multi-objective genetic algorithm. Sustain. Energy Technol. Assessments 35, 48- 57.

[45] Soflaei, F. , Shokouhian, M. , Abraveshdar, H. , Alipour, A. , 2017. The impact of courtyard design variants on shading performance in hot-arid climates of Iran. Energy Build. 143, 71- 83.

[46] Sözen, I. , Oral, G.K. , 2019. Outdoor thermal comfort in urban canyon and courtyard in hot arid climate:a parametric study based on the vernacular settlement of Mardin. Sustain. Cities Soc. 48, 101398.

[47] Shaeri, J. , Yaghoubi, M. , Aflaki, A. , Habibi, A. , 2018. Evaluation of thermal comfort in traditional houses in a tropical climate. Buildings 8 (9), 126.

[48] Tabadkani, A. , Aghasizadeh, S. , Banihashemi, S. , Hajirasouli, A. , 2022. Courtyard design impact on indoor thermal comfort and utility costs for residential households:comparative analysis and deep-learning predictive model. Front. Archi. Res. 11 (5), 963- 980.

[49] Taleghani, M. , Tenpierik, M. , van den Dobbelsteen, A. , 2014. Indoor thermal comfort in urban courtyard block dwellings in The Netherlands. Build. Environ. 82, 566- 579.

[50] Teshnehdel, S. , Soflaei, F. , Shokouhian, M. , 2020. Assessment of solar shading performance of courtyard houses in desert climate of Kashan, Iran. Architect. Eng. Des. Manag. 16 (6), 473- 492.

[51] Vaezizadeh, F. , Rashidisharifabad, S. , Afhami, R. , 2016. Investigating the cooling effect of living walls in the sunken courtyards of traditional houses in Yazd. Eur. J. Sustain. Dev. 5 (2), 27- 27.

[52] Venhari, A.A. , Tenpierik, M. , Taleghani, M. , 2019. The role of sky view factor and urban street greenery in human thermal comfort and heat stress in a desert climate. J. Arid Environ. 166, 68- 76.

[53] Veisi, O. , Shakibamanesh, A. , 2022. Analysis of solar radiation towards optimization and location of the urban blocks in the neighborhood units. Environ. Sci. Sustain. Develop. 7 (1), 66- 90.

[54] Veisi, O. , Fadaee, N. , Rahbar, M. , Ebadi, H. , 2021. Daylight optimization and energy retrofit by using proportionate automated louvers in home-based offices (case study:a house in Tehran, Iran). Inter. Confer. Applied Energy 2021 21, 1- 6.

[55] Wu, R. , Fang, X. , Brown, R. , Liu, S. , Zhao, H. , 2023. Establishing a link between complex courtyard spaces and thermal comfort:a major advancement in evidence-based design. Build. Environ. 245, 110852.

[56] Xu, L. , Peng, C. , 2020. Integration of completely passive cooling and heating systems with daylighting function into courtyard building towards energy saving. Appl. Energy 266, 114865.

[57] Yuan, C. , Adelia, A.S. , Mei, S. , He, W. , Li, X.X. , Norford, L. , 2020. Mitigating intensity of urban heat island by better understanding on urban morphology and anthropogenic heat dispersion. Build. Environ. 176, 106876.

[58] Yuan, T. , Hong, B. , Qu, H. , Liu, A. , Zheng, Y. , 2023. Outdoor thermal comfort in urban and rural open spaces:a comparative study in China's cold region. Urban Clim. 49, 101501.

[59] Zang, Y. , Liu, Y. , Yang, Y. , Woods, M. , Fois, F. , 2020. Rural decline or restructuring? Implications for sustainability transitions in rural China. Land Use Policy 94, 104531.

[60] Zhu, J. , Feng, J. , Lu, J. , Chen, Y. , Li, W. , Lian, P. , Zhao, X. , 2023. A review of the influence of courtyard geometry and orientation on microclimate. Build. Environ. 236, 110269.

[61] Zhao, M. , Mehra, S.R. , Künzel, H.M. , 2022. Energy-saving potential of deeply retrofitting building enclosures of traditional courtyard houses—A case study in the Chinese Hot-Summer-Cold-Winter zone. Build. Environ. 217, 109106.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s). Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Higher Education Press and KeAi.