Neglected vertical linkage: A study on the form of the canal network in the Huainan Salt Area during the Ming and Qing dynasties using space syntax measurements

Abstract

The Huainan Salt Area was the most essential salt production and trade base in ancient China. The government had strict control over the essential tax source region and left behind numerous official documents. However, when comparing with the modern surveying maps, we found that the boundaries between salt districts were unclear, which was obviously contradictory to the principle of independence between salt districts in official documents. Therefore, this study used the 1920s' historical map of the Huainan Area to extract vector data such as the canal and road networks and the location of salt settlements, and then used space syntax to describe the transportation network morphology and settlement distribution structure to respond to the contradictions with higher precision. It was found that at a 2000 m × 2000 m raster resolution, the measurements of the canal network were well correlated (p = 0.645, r = 30,000) with the salt settlement distribution. Moreover, the canal network was closer to a network-like than a tree-like structure, and vertical linkage emerged. The "government-supervised and merchant-managed" policy implemented in the Qing dynasty played an essential role, and it caused a big difference in the understanding of the salt industry system between folks and officials.

Keywords

Space syntax / Canal network / Salt settlement / Huainan Salt Area

References

[1] Al Sayed, K. , Turner, A. , Hillier, B. , Iida, S. , Penn, A. , 2014. Space Syntax Methodology. Bartlett School of Architecture, UCL, London.

[2] Bao, J. , 2014. Jiangsu Coast Salt Activity Geography and the Changes of Human-Land Relationship in Ming and Qing. Ph.D. Thesis. Fudan University, Shanghai (in Chinese).

[3] Bao, J. , 2021. The change stages and its local differences of ancient sea salt production technology in China. Res. Salt. Ind. His. 03, 3-14 (in Chinese).

[4] Borgatti, S.P. , Everett, M.G. , 2000. Models of core/periphery structures. Soc. Network. 21 (4), 375- 395.

[5] Chen, C. , 1986. Ao Bo Tu, Wenyuange Sikuquanshu. Taiwan Commercial Press, Taibei.

[6] Chen, S. , 1957. Stove households and salt production in the Ming Dynasty. J. Xiamen Univ. 1, 153-180 (in Chinese).

[7] Cheng, M. , 2008. Chronicle of the Lianghuai Sea Salt Industry:Yongzheng. National Library of China Publishing House, Beijing.

[8] Committee, J.P.L.C.C. , 1997. Jiangsu Provincial Chronicle: Salt Industry Chronicle. Nanjing: Jiangsu Science and Technology Press (in Chinese).

[9] Crompton, A. , Brown, F. , 2007. The double fractal structure of Venice. In: Paper Presented at the Proceedings of the Sixth International Space Syntax Symposium, Istanbul.

[10] Ding, J. , Wang, R. , 2023. Understanding the spatial pattern of historical Chinese rural settlements: a syntactical approach. J. Hum. Settlements West China 38 (5), 103-109 (in Chinese).

[11] Fei, X. , 2006. From the Soil. Shanghai People Press, Shanghai (in Chinese).

[12] Feng, D. , 2015. Huaiyang Water Conservancy Diagram. Guangling Book Company, Yangzhou.

[13] Feng, L. , 2023. Government and market in the evolution of the salt monopoly system in ancient China:based on research of the causal mechanism. J Dongbei Univ. Finance Econ. 1, 28-38 (in Chinese).

[14] Freeman, L.C. , 1977. A set of measures of centrality based on betweenness. Sociometry 40 (1), 35- 41.

[15] Guo, Z. , 1997. History of Chinese Salt Industry. People's Publishing House, Beijing (in Chinese).

[16] He, Y. , 2004. A review of research on the history of ancient Chinese salt industry in the 20th century. Res. Salt Ind. His. 02, 34-44(in Chinese).

[17] Hillier, B. , 1996. Space Is the Machine: a Configurational Theory of Architecture. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[18] Hillier, B. , Hanson, J. , 1984. The Social Logic of Space. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[19] Hillier, B. , Iida, S. , 2005. Network and psychological effects in urban movement. Paper Presented at the Proceedings of the Fifth International Space Syntax Symposium. Delft.

[20] Hillier, B. , Yang, T. , Turner, A. , 2012. Normalising least angle choice in Depthmap and how it opens new perspectives on the global and local analysis of city space. J. Space Syntax 3, 155- 193.

[21] Ji, C. , 2013. A Study on the Distribution and Changes of Salt Production Areas in Ancient China. China Book Press, Beijing (in Chinese).

[22] Li, L. , Li, X. , 2017. Evolvement of saltern authority settlements in Huai region of Jiangsu coastal area. Modern Urban Res. 12, 95-106 (in Chinese).

[23] Li, S. , 2000. Stove households, market merchants, and their interrelationships in the Qing Dynasty. Res. Salt Ind. His. 02, 3-9(in Chinese).

[24] Liao, Y. , 2019. Study on the Settlement System of Huainan Salt Area in Ming and Qing: Taking the Eight Districts of Taizhou Branch as the Inspection Center, MEng. Thesis. Southeast University, Nanjing (in Chinese).

[25] Lin, W. , 2003. The origin and historical role of the monopoly system in Ancient China: a study based on the salt monopoly system. Res. Salt Ind. His. 03, 9-17 (in Chinese).

[26] Lu, M. , 2022. The spatial structure research of Lishui based on space syntax. Arch. Cult. 05, 99-102 (in Chinese).

[27] Lu, M. , Zhang, Y. , 2022. Exploring urban street types and their impact on spatial people's aggregation in Nanjing. In: Paper presented at the Annual Conference Proceedings of the XXVIII International Seminar on Urban Form, Glasgow.

[28] Lu, R. , 1997. Shu Yuan Za Ji, vol. 12. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing.

[29] Ni, Z. , Ge, C. , Liu, F. , 2022. A study on the cultural representation of the water environment space in traditional commercial settlements in southern Yangtze River Region: taking Lili, Tongli and Wuzhen as examples. J. Hum. Settlements West China 37(5), 24-29 (in Chinese).

[30] Niu, Y. , 2016. A study on the spatial interaction and evolution of traditional Huai salt industry and urban system from the perspective of spatiotemporal gradient network. In: Paper Presented at the 2016 China Urban Planning Annual Conference, Shenyang (in Chinese).

[31] Pan, J. , 1954. A Survey of the River Defense Working, vol. 3. Taipei:Taiwan Student Book Company (in Chinese).

[32] Pu, X. , Dong, Y. , 2018. Review of quantitative research on the pattern of traditional village settlement in China. Arch. Cult. 08, 59-61 (in Chinese).

[33] Ramzy, N.S. , 2016. Morphological logic in historical settlements:space syntax analyses of residential districts at Mohenjo-Daro, Kahun and Ur. Urban Des. Int. 21 (1), 41- 54.

[34] Sabidussi, G. , 1966. The centrality index of a graph. Psychometrika 31 (4), 581- 603.

[35] Shan, Q. , 2015. Chronicle of the Lianghuai Sea Salt Industry:Jiaqing. Guangling Book Company, Yangzhou.

[36] Sun, Y. , 2015. New Compilation of Xia River Water Conservancy. Guangling Book Company, Yangzhou.

[37] Tan, Q. , 1982. The Historical Atlas of China. China Cartographic Publishing House, Beijing (in Chinese).

[38] Tuotuo , 1977a. History of the Song: Ambition 135th, vol. 182. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing.

[39] Tuotuo , 1977b. History of Song: Biography of Hao Bin, vol. 170. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing.

[40] Turner, A. , 2001. Angular analysis. Paper Presented at the Proceedings of the 3rd International Symposium on Space Syntax, Atlanta.

[41] Turner, A. , 2007. From axial to road-centre lines: a new representation for space syntax and a new model of route choice for transport network analysis. Environ. Plann. Plann. Des. 34 (3), 539- 555.

[42] Wang, S. , 2008. Chronicle of the Lianghuai Sea Salt Industry:Qianlong, vol. 18. National Library of China Publishing House, Beijing.

[43] Wu, F. , Li, L. , 2020. A study on the spatial distribution of people flow in historical ancient cities based on the efficiency of spatial composition: taking the main commercial streets of Pingyao Ancient City for instance. J. Hum. Settlements West China 35(3), 61-68 (in Chinese).

[44] Wu, H. , 2013. Grass-roots populace and illegal salt—research on illegal salt circulation in two Huai in the Qing Dynasty. Res. Salt Ind. His. 04, 29-41 (in Chinese).

[45] Xia, X. , 2017. Research of Development of Urban Areas with Salt Fields in Qing Dynasty. Ph.D. Thesis. Liaoning Normal University, Dalian (in Chinese).

[46] Xie, K. , 1996. Chronicle of the Lianghuai Sea Salt Industry: Kangxi. Taiwan Student Book Company, Taibei.

[47] Xu, P. , 2015. Chronicles of the Salt Transportation Department of the Two Huai Rivers: Hongzhip. Guangling Book Company, Yangzhou.

[48] Xu, Y. , Rollo, J. , Esteban, Y. , 2021. Evaluating experiential qualities of historical streets in Nanxun Canal town through a space syntax approach. Buildings 11 (11), 544.

[49] Xu, Y. , Rollo, J. , Jones, D.S. , Esteban, Y. , Tong, H. , Mu, Q. , 2020. Towards sustainable heritage tourism: a space syntax-based analysis method to improve tourists' spatial cognition in Chinese historic districts. Buildings 10 (2), 29.

[50] Yang, X. , Chen, X. , 2000. In: Xun, D. (Ed.), Chronicle of the Lianghuai Sea Salt Industry: Jiajing. China Local Records Publishing, Beijing.

[51] Yun, J. , Liu, H. , 2023. Spatial syntax analysis of the evolution of the water system and garden distribution relationship in Suzhou:13th—20th centuries. Buildings 13 (7), 1703.

[52] Zeng, Y. , 1984. History of Chinese Salt Policy. Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House, Shanghai (in Chinese).

[53] Zhang, X. , 2020. Research on the impact of ming and qing salt policy reform on the space of salt production settlements in Huainan. In: Paper Presented at the 2020 Academic Annual Conference of China Architecture Society, Shenzhen (in Chinese).

[54] Zhang, X. , Zhao, K. , 2024. Evolution of sea salt settlement system under the action of government control: a case study of two Huai salt region in the Ming and Qing dynasties. City Plann. Rev. 48 (3), 115-122 (in Chinese).

[55] Zhao, E. , 1927. The Draft of Qing History, vol. 123.

[56] Zhao, K. , Zhang, X. , 2023. Research on the spatial evolution of salt field settlements in Huainan under the influence of the salt economy. New Arch. 01, 147-151 (in Chinese).

[57] Zhou, Y. , 1817. Dongtai County Annals, vol. 10.

[58] Zuo, B. , Gu, N. , Gu, X. , 1993. Research on salt policy in the Qing dynasty. Res. Salt Ind. His. 2, 16-29 (in Chinese).

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s). Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Higher Education Press and KeAi.