Placemaking for social cohesion and economic vitality: The role of urban design in transforming local markets in Pakistan

Abstract

In planning and design, the concept of “place” has always been fundamental. Current patterns show a greater emphasis on influencing and improving community dynamics through altering the “experience” and “feeling” of locations, especially in local commercial centers and markets that play an important role in the economic growth of cities. The research focuses on the significance of placemaking, a critical component in design, for boosting economic activity in the market(s) and simultaneously fostering a place for social engagement and cohesion. A mixed-methods approach was employed to strengthen the connection between placemaking and the local informal economy in urban areas. This research through a case study outlines the placemaking principle that can convert local commercial areas into more socially cohesive, diverse, and vibrant public spaces. It is recommended that this design-based study be instrumental for local and national marketplaces in Pakistan.

Keywords

Placemaking / Social interaction / Public spaces / Economic sustainability / Informal economy / Social growth

References

[1] Abrams, L. , 2007. Urban marketplaces and mobile vendors: the flea market in the metropolitan economy. In: A Case Study of Two Flea Markets: Aqueduct and Roosevelt Raceway Flea Markets.City University of New York.

[2] Benedict, M.A. , McMahon, E.T. , 2006. Green Infrastructure: Linking Landscapes and Communities. Island Press.

[3] Bluhm, R. , Krause, M. , 2022. Top lights: bright cities and their contribution to economic development. J. Dev. Econ. 157, 102880.

[4] Bourg, C.J. , Portes, A. , Castells, M. , Benton, L.A. , 1990. The informal economy: studies in advanced and less developed countries. Soc. Forces 68 (3), 969.

[5] Bruin, A.D. , Dupuis, A. , 2000. The dynamics of New Zealand's largest street market; the Otara flea market. Int. J. Sociol. Soc. Pol. 20, 52- 73.

[6] Calthorpe, P. , 1993. The Next American Metropolis: Ecology, Community, and the American Dream. Princeton Architectural Press.

[7] Chen, M. , Harvey, J. , Kihato, C. , Skinner, C. , 2018. Inclusive Public Spaces for Informal Livelihoods: a Discussion Paper for Urban Planners and Policy Makers. WIEGO, United Kingdom.

[8] Dittmar, H. , Ohland, G. , 2004. The new transit town: best practices in transit-oriented development. Island Press.

[9] Dovey, K. , 1991. Melbourne Docklands and the sense of place. Picking Winners: melbourne's urban development game. In: Melbourne: Social Justice Coalition.

[10] Dupre, K. , 2019. Trends and gaps in place-making in the context of urban development and tourism: 25 years of literature review. J. Place Manag. Dev. 12 (1), 102- 120.

[11] Finn, D. , 2014. DIY urbanism: implications for cities. J. Urbanism: Inte. Res. Placemaking Urban Sustain. 7 (4), 381- 398.

[12] Golkar, K. , 2011. Creating Sustainable Place: Reflections on Urban Design Theory. Uni Shahid Beheshti Publ, pp. 112-146.

[13] Grant, J. , 2002. Mixed use in theory and practice: Canadian experience with implementing a planning principle. J. Am. Plann. Assoc. 68 (1), 71- 84.

[14] Ha, N.H. , 2014. Buy, sell and chatter: a case analysis of a Lisbon Flea Market.

[15] Hassan, K. , Akbar, A. , Anwar, S. , 2022. Informal economy of Paksitan.

[16] Inch, A. , 2016. G Young and D Stevenson, the Ashgate Research Companion to Planning and Culture. SAGE Publications Sage UK, London, England.

[17] Iqbal, N. , 2022. Legalizing Street Business. The News.

[18] Irandoost, K. , Doostvandi, M. , Litman, T. , Azami, M. , 2019. Placemaking and the right to the city of urban poor: a case studyin Sanandaj, Iran. J. Place Manag. Dev. 12 (4), 508- 528.

[19] Jeffres, L.W. , Bracken, C.C. , Jian, G. , Casey, M.F. , 2009. The impact of third places on community quality of life. Appl. Res. Qual. Life 4, 333- 345.

[20] Kee, T. , 2018. Sustainable place-making in Hong Kong: transforming urban crisis to urban renewal opportunities. US China Educ. Rev. 8 (2), 47- 66.

[21] Khuong, N.V. , Shabbir, M.S. , Sial, M.S. , Khanh, T.H.T. , 2021. Does informal economy impede economic growth? Evidence from an emerging economy. J. Sustain. Finance Invest. 11 (2), 103- 122.

[22] Lak, A. , Kheibari, S.Z. , 2020. Towards a framework for facilitating the implementation of tactical urbanism practices: assessment criteria in the place-making approach in Iran. Geoforum 115, 54- 66.

[23] Lindemann, J.F. , 2019. TheBlackAgrarian Imaginary: Race, Food, and the Production of Space in. Cornell University, Cleveland, Ohio.

[24] Lu, Y. , 2016. Creating a successful wayfinding system: lessons learned from Springfield, Massachusetts.

[25] Markusen, A. , 2013. Artists work everywhere. Work Occup. 40 (4), 481- 495.

[26] McCann, E.J. , 2002. The cultural politics of local economic development: meaning-making, place-making, and the urban policy process. Geoforum 33 (3), 385- 398.

[27] McCrohan, K.F. , Smith, J.D. , 1987. Consumer participation in the informal economy. J. Acad. Market. Sci. 15, 62- 68.

[28] Moosvi, A. , 2021. Street vending: an introduction and overview.

[29] Morales, A. , 2009. Public markets as community development tools. J. Plann. Educ. Res. 28 (4), 426- 440.

[30] Morales, A. , Balkin, S. , Persky, J. , 1995. The value of benefits of a public street market: the case of Maxwell Street. Econ. Dev. Q. 9 (4), 304- 320.

[31] Muljarijadi, B. , Thio, R. , 2008. Economic Valuation of Urban Informal Activities: Case Study of Flea Markets in Bandung Municipality. Retrieved from.

[32] Nicodemus, A.G. , 2013. Fuzzy vibrancy: creative placemaking as ascendant US cultural policy. Cult. Trends 22(3-4), 213- 222.

[33] Nipu, N.J. , 2021. Transforming a Typical Flea Market into a More Vital Third Place through Expressions of Cultural Diversity. The University of Texas at Arlington.

[34] Petrescu, M. , Bhatli, D. , 2013. Consumer behavior in flea markets and marketing to the Bottom of the Pyramid. J. Manag. Res. 13 (1), 55- 63.

[35] Poth, C. , Munce, S.E. , 2020. Commentary-Preparing today's researchers for a yet unknown tomorrow: promising practices for a synergistic and sustainable mentoring approach to mixed methods research learning. Int. J. Mult. Res. Approaches 12 (1).

[36] Schilling, J. , Logan, J. , 2008. Greening the Rust Belt: a green infrastructure model for right-sizing America's shrinking cities. J. Am. Plann. Assoc. 74 (4), 451- 466.

[37] Sukasta, K.A.G. , 2020. Placemaking in Tanah Abang: between dimensions and intensity of pedestrian ways. Int. J. Livable Space 5 (1), 1- 10.

[38] Suryanto, M.E. , Adianto, J. , Gabe, R.T. , 2020. Accommodating the informal economy in public space. Urbani Izziv 31 (1), 89- 100.

[39] Tribune , 2022. Experts for gauging street economy contribution. The Express Tribune.

[40] Wichowsky, A. , Gaul-Stout, J. , McNew-Birren, J. , 2023. Creative placemaking and empowered participatory governance. Urban Aff. Rev. 59 (6), 1747- 1774.

[41] Winikoff, T. , 1995. Places not spaces: placemaking in Australia: envirobook pub.

[42] Zulfiqar, F. , Butt, F.K. , 2021. Street Vending and Survival of the Underprivileged. Pakistan Institute of Development Economics.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s). Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Higher Education Press and KeAi.