Marginalized Modern Architectural Heritage in Indonesia: The case of transformator huisje (gardu listrik) architecture of the Nederlandsche Indisch era

Abstract

This study is in order to implement the mandate of UNESCO (2003) on the documentation of architectural heritage of the modern period of the 19th-20th century, where in reality several typologies of architectural heritage are currently in a marginalized condition. As part of the history of modern architecture in Indonesia, transformator huisje (Dutch) or "gardu listrik" (Indonesian) which still exist today, are not widely known as buildings that have important values in the past. This study aims to reveal whether transformator huisje architecture is classified as Modern Heritage, by tracing its historical background. Architectural analysis of 61 transformator huisje was conducted to build a "genesis"—a scheme of origin—of transformator huisje which can explain how this type of architecture was formed in accordance with the values or principles of modern architecture. The study findings show that all design features of transformator huisje as buildings for machines are strong representations of Modern Architectural Heritage in Asia, especially the Dutch East Indies (Indonesia). In conclusion, with the finding that transformator huisje is categorized as Modern Architectural Heritage, a strategy is needed to maintain this type of architecture as evidence of modern civilization in Indonesia.

Keywords

Modern Architectural Heritage / transformator huisje / gardu listrik / Marginal architecture / Indonesia

References

[1] Abaas, Z.R. , 2020. Impact of development on Baghdad's urban microclimate and human thermal comfort. Alex. Eng. J. 59 (1), 275- 290.

[2] Abusaada, H. , Elshater, A. , 2021. Effect of people on placemaking and affective atmospheres in city streets. Ain Shams Eng. J. 12 (3), 3389- 3403.

[3] Alghamdi, N. , Alnaim, M.M. , Alotaibi, F. , Alzahrani, A. , Alosaimi, F. , Ajlan, A. , Alkhudhayri, Y.A. , Alshathri, A. , 2023. Documenting Riyadh city's significant modern heritage: a methodological approach. Buildings 13 (11), 1- 28.

[4] Alifragkis, S. , 2022. Economy, efficiency and the promenade deck. In: Myrogiannis, S., Repapis, C. (Eds.), Economics and Art Theory. Routledge, London.

[5] Almasifar, N. , Canbolat, T.Ö. , Akhavan, M. , González-Lezcano, R.A. , 2021. Proposing a new methodology for monument conservation "scope management" by the use of an analytic hierarchy process project management institute system and the ico-mos burra charter. Sustainability 13 (23), 1- 13.

[6] Artkan, M. , 2021. The use of ottoman architecture and islamic heritage as a consumption object in contemporary practices. J. Islam. Archit. 6 (4), 338- 348.

[7] Asiliskender, B. , 2008. Re-Creating urban form with industry: Turkish modernization and kayseri experience. In: van den Heuvel, D., Mesman, M., Quist, W., Lemmens, B. (Eds.), The Challenge of Change: Dealing with the Legacy of the Modern Movement. Proceedings of the 10th International DOCOMOMO Conference. IOS Press/Delft University Press, pp. 425-427.

[8] Baciu, D.C. , 2020. Sigfried Giedion's Chicago school: a midpoint in 150 Years of history. OSF Preprints June 1 .

[9] Batakoja, M. , Šerman, K. , 2023. Architecting nature: the pastoral genre in art museum design. A&U (Architektúra & urbanizmus) 57 (1-2), 22- 44.

[10] Bazazzadeh, H. , Nadolny, A. , Mehan, A. , Safaei, S.S.H. , 2021. The importance of flexibility in adaptive reuse of industrial heritage: learning from Iranian cases. Int. J. Conserv. Sci. 12 (1), 113- 128.

[11] Beekman, L.M.A. , Jonker, D.L. , Baker, G.J.T. , Lohr, H. , Ehrenvurg, H.H. , 1931. Vereeniging Van Directeuren Van Electriciteits-Bedrijven in Nederland. Centraal Bureau, Nach-tegaalspad(Association of Directors of Electricity Companies in the Netherlands).

[12] Bellaar Spruyt, J.G. , Bakker, G.J.T. , Beekman, L.M.A. , Lulofs, W. , Bloomhert, A. , 1926. De Ontwikkeling van De Electriciteitsvoorziening van Nederland.Tot Het Jaar 1925. (The Development of the Electricity Supply of the Netherlands. Up to the Year 1925). P.N. van Kampen & Zoon, Amsterdam.

[13] Boersma, M. , 2020. From material to infrastructure: germaine krull's métal. October 173 (1), 118- 142.

[14] Brito, M. , Sousa, T. , 2015. World primary energy production & consumption 1900-2010: what can Be learned from past trends? 12th International Conference on Energy for a Clean Environment 1-9. July 5-9, 2015. Lisboa, Portugal.

[15] Chudoba, M. , 2021. The Tall Building and Urban Space in light of two modernist case studies. Architecture in Finland 5 (1), 83- 97.

[16] Conrads, U. (Ed.), 1975. Programs and Manifestoes on 20th-Century Architecture. MIT Press, Massachusetts.

[17] Cunningham, A. , 2005. Modern Movement Heritage. Taylor & Francis e-Library.

[18] Curtis, W. , 1982. Modern Architecture since 1900. Paidon, London.

[19] Dill, A. , 2008. Large scale projects of the modern movementchanging or developing architectural genius? The challenge of change: dealing with the legacy of the modern movement. Proceedings of the 10th International DOCOMOMO Conference. IOS Press, pp. 255-258.

[20] Farhan, S. , Akef, V. , Nasar, Z. , 2020. The transformation of the inherited historical urban and architectural characteristics of Al-Najaf's Old City and possible preservation insights. FOAR (Frontiers of Architectural Research) 9 (4), 820- 836.

[21] Frampton, K. , 1908. Modern Architecture: A Critical History. Thames and Hudson, London.

[22] Fu, J. , Zhou, J. , Deng, Y. , 2021. Heritage values of ancient vernacular residences in traditional villages in Western Hunan, China: spatial patterns and influencing factors. Build. Environ. 188 (January) , 107473.

[23] GEBEO , 1929. Gemeenschappelijk Electriciteitsbedrijf Bandoeng en Omstreken G.E.B.E.O. Ter gelegenheid van het 10-jarig bestaan. (Joint Electricity Company Bandoeng and Surroundings G.E.B.E.O. On the Occasion of the 10th anniversary). N. V. Handelsvennootschap v/h MAINTZ & Co., Bandoeng.

[24] Gnatiuk, L. , 2022. Avant-Garde In Sacral Space 25 (0-1), 25- 33.

[25] Guimarães, N.L. , Fundarò, M. , 2023. Modern Heritage and the Architecture of Memories: a Study on the Castelo Branco Mausoleum in Fortaleza. Seven Editora.

[26] Gustafsson, C. , Ripp, M. , 2022. A metamodel for heritage-based urban recovery. Built Heritage 6 (29), 1- 24.

[27] Han, Y. , 2020. Organic architecture. J. Eng. Archit. 8 (2), 28- 31.

[28] Harrington, S. , Ćorović, A. , Obralić A. , 2022. Sarajevo heritage flashback: modernizing trends in architecture of Bosnia and Herzegovina at the beginning of the 20 th century. J. Archit., Arts and Heritage (JAH) 1 (2), 2822- 4378.

[29] Henket, H.J. , 2005. The icon and the ordinary. In: Cunningham, Allen (Ed.), Modern Movement Heritage. Taylor & Francis e-Library, London.

[30] Ivanova, K. , Kozlov, V. , Belomestnyh, S. , 2019. Preservation and development of historical heritage of gardens and parks in large European cities. IOP Conf. Ser. Mater. Sci. Eng. 667, 012034.

[31] Jones, Z.M. , Pappas, T. , 2023. Developing an identities-based approach to support more robust resilience and recovery in heritage planning and management. Built Heritage 7 (2), 1- 12.

[32] Kassem, A. , 2022. Rehearsing a performative theory for architecture. In: Creating through Mind and Emotions. CRC Press, pp. 61-69.

[33] Kurniawan, A.Y. , 2007. Perusahaan Listrik Masa Penjajahan Belanda(Laporan Kerja Praktek di Bagian Komunikasi PT. PLN (Persero) Distribusi Jawa Barat). UNIKOM. Source: https://repository.unikom.ac.id/8917/.

[34] Kurniawati, A. , 2018. Gardu dalam 'Struktur' Politik di Indonesia Sebentuk Pertemuan Historisisme, Strukturalisme Levi-Strauss dan Posmodernisme. Journal SASDAYA, Gadjah Mada Journal of Humanities.

[35] Kusno, A. , 2006. Guardian of memories: gardu in urban Java. J. Indonesia 81 (April 2006), 95-149. Cornell University Southeast Asia Program.

[36] Lang, L. , Liu, J. , Wang, S. , 2017. Understanding and assessing modern architectural heritage: value-oriented contextual interpretation based on dalian (China) case study. UIA 2017 Seoul World Architects Congress.

[37] Liu, R. , 2023. Revitalising Heritage-Christus Triumfatorkerk: A Dutch Postwar Reclamation. Master Thesis of TU Delft.

[38] Loos, A. , 1908. Ornament and crime. In: Design: Critical and Primary Sources, pp. 57-63.

[39] Malanima, P. , 2014. Energy in History. The Basic Environmental History, Environmental History. Springer International Publishing, Switzerland.

[40] Matanasi, P. , 2017. ANIEM: Menyetrum Hindia Belanda, Menyalakan Indonesia. Tirto.Id.

[41] Mehan, A. , 2023. Gio ponti and villa namazee: (De)listed modern heritage. Heritage 6 (2), 789- 801.

[42] Mehr, S.Y. , 2019. Analysis of 19th and 20th century conservation key theories in relation to contemporary adaptive reuse of heritage buildings. Heritage 2 (1), 920- 937.

[43] Mrazek, R. , 2006. Engineers of Happy Land. Perkembangan teknologi dan Nasionalisme di sebuah Koloni. (Engineers of Happy Land: Technology and Nationalism in a Colony). Yayasan Obor Indonesia, Jakarta.

[44] NIGM , 1913. Nederlandsch-indische gas-maatschappij ver slag over 1913. Netherlands East Indies Gas Company Report of 1913. M. WYT A ZONEN, Rotterdam.

[45] NIGM , 1938. Gedenkboek Nederlandsch-Indische Gas Maatschappij: 1863-1913 (Memorial Book of the Dutch East Indies Gas Company: 1863-1913). M. WYT A ZONEN, Rotterdam.

[46] Peters, R. , 2016. Death and the control of life in an Indonesian city. J. Humanit. Soc. Sci. Southeast Asia 2-3 (172), 310- 342.

[47] Richards, J. , 1962. Modern Architecture. Penguin Book, Baltimore.

[48] Roseau, N. , 2008. The obsolescence of the monument, the future of airport icons. In: van den Heuvel, Dirk, Mesman, Maarten, Quist, Wido, Lemmens, Bert (Eds.), The Challenge of Change: Dealing with the Legacy of the Modern Movement. IOS Press/-Delft University Press, pp. 87-92.

[49] Salim, P. , Hendrassukma, D. , 2023. Revitalization of cultural heritage building: the tugu kunstkring paleis. E3S Web of Conferences 426, 02039.

[50] Sejrup, J. , 2022. World-heritagizing Le corbusier's building for the national museum of western art in tokyo. In: Global Art in Local Art Worlds: Changing Hierarchies of Value, pp. 113-138.

[51] Sever, I.A. , Akbulak, D.Z. , 2020. The effects of the concept of minimalism on today's architecture, expectations after covid-19 pandemic. Int. J. Adv. Res. Rev 5 (9), 67- 85.

[52] Shchenkov, A.S. , Antonova, N.E. , 2021. Innovations in the language of contemporary culture and the problem of the preservation of cultural heritage. Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Architecture: Heritage, Traditions and Innovations(AHTI 2021) 600, 255-261. Ahti.

[53] Silvia, G.A. . Laporan Praktek Kerja Lapangan Di Bidang Komunikasi Hukum Dan Administrasi Divisi Humas PT. PLN (Persero) Jawa Barat Dan Banten. Report on Legal Communication and Administration of Public Relations Division of PT. PLN West Java and Banten). UNIKOM. Source. http://repository.unikom.ac.id/id/eprint/341.

[54] Siswanto, W. , Wibowo, P.S.R. , 2010. Standart Kontruksi Gardu Distribusi Dan Gardu Hubung Tenaga Listrik. (Construction Standards for Distribution Substations and Electric Power Switching Substations), fourth ed. PT.PLN (PERSERO), Jakarta.

[55] Smil, V. , 2000. Energy in the twentieth century: resources, conversions, costs, uses, and consequences. Annu. Rev. Energy Environ. 25 (1), 21- 51.

[56] Sofiah, A.N.K. , Hakim, A. , 2020. Sejarah PLTA Lamajan Pangalengan Sebagai Situs Peninggalan Belanda di Kabupaten Bandung Tahun 1925 (History of Lamajan Pangalengan Hydroelectric Power Plant as a Dutch Heritage Site in Bandung Regency in 1925). Historia Madania 4 (1), 129- 146.

[57] Sokołowicz, M.E. , Przygodzki, Z. , 2020. The value of ambiguous architecture in cities. The concept of a valuation method of 20th century post-socialist train stations. Cities 104 (39), 102786.

[58] Šourek, M. , 2020. Europe, Architecture, Shared Vision.

[59] Stanek, Ł. , 2020. Architecture in Global Socialism: Eastern Europe, West Africa, and the Middle East in the Cold War. Princeton University Press, Princeton.

[60] Suganda, H. , 2007. Jendela Bandung: Pengalaman Bersama Kompas. Penerbit Buku Kompas, Jakarta.

[61] Sutherland, H. , 2014. Urban Southeast Asia: Unity in Diversity. Sagepub, pp. 178-185.

[62] Taher Tolou Del, M.S. , Sedghpour, B.S. , Tabrizi, S.K. , 2020. The semantic conservation of architectural heritage: the missing values. Heritage Science 8 (1), 1- 13.

[63] Terenzi, G. , Fuso, E. , Sorace, S. , Costoli, I. , 2020. A case study of Modern Heritage building: base isolation seismic retrofit for preservation of its architectural distinguishing features. IOP Conf. Ser. Mater. Sci. Eng. 960, 032056.

[64] Torrent, H. , 2018. Modern heritage and the challenge of urban conservation: between singular buindings and the metamorphosis of the urban fabric. In: Tostões, Ana, Koselj, Nataša(Eds.), Metamorphosis. The Continuity of Change, pp. 140-148. Docomomo Slovenia, Ljubljana.

[65] Van den Heuvel, D. , Mesman, M. , Quist, W. , 2008. The Challenge of Change: Dealing with the Legacy of the Modern Movement: Proceedings of the 10th International DOCOMOMO Conference. IOS Press.

[66] Van Oers, R. , Haraguchi, S.E. , 2003. Identification and Documentation of Modern Heritage. The UNESCO World Heritage Centre, Paris.

[67] Warde, P. , 2007. Energy consumption in England and wales 1560-2000. Consiglio nazionale delle ricerche, Istituto di studi sulle società del Mediterraneo Naples. Energy Consumption 2. ISBN: 8880800825.

[68] Westerveld, D.J.A. , 1920. Een Belangrijke Beslissing voor Woning-bouwvereenigingen(an important decision for housing associations). Locale Belangen 7 (131), 451- 500.

[69] Wieszczek, K. , Lemes de Oliveira, F. , 2008. Rewriting the past: the demolition of modern buildings and monuments in postcommunist Poland. In: Van den Heuvel, Dirk, Mesman, Maarten, Quist, Wido, Lemmens, Bert (Eds.), The Challenge of Change: Dealing with the Legacy of the Modern Movement. Proceedings. IOS Press/Delft University Press.

[70] Yu, Y. , Chen, P. , Jiao, S. , 2019. Listing buildings of modern heritage in changsha, China. IOP Conf. Ser. Mater. Sci. Eng. 471 (8), 082010. IOP Publishing.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s). Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Higher Education Press and KeAi.