Effects of sub-/super-critical CO₂ on the fracture-related mechanical characteristics of bituminous coal

Abstract

Injecting carbon dioxide CO₂ into a coal seam is an important way to improve coalbed methane recovery and to store geological carbon. The fracture mechanical characteristics of bituminous coal determine the propagation and evolution of cracks, which directly affect CO₂ storage in coal seams and the efficiency of resource recovery. This study applied CO₂ adsorption and three-point bending fracture experiments using bituminous coal samples in a gaseous state (4 MPa), subcritical state (6 MPa), and supercritical state (8 and 12 MPa) to investigate the influence of CO₂ state and anisotropy on the fracture-related mechanical response of bituminous coal. The results show that the change in mechanical properties caused by CO₂ adsorption is CO₂ state-dependent. The supercritical CO₂ adsorption at 8 MPa causes the largest decrease in the mode-I fracture toughness (K_IC), which is 63.6% lower than the toughness before CO₂ adsorption. The instability characteristics of bituminous coal show the transformation trend of “sudden-gradual-sudden fracture”. With or without CO₂ adsorption, the order of the K_IC associated with three types of bituminous coal specimens is crack-divider type > crack-arrester type > crack-short transverse type. Phenomenologically, the fracture toughness of bituminous coal is positively correlated with its specific surface area and total pore volume; the toughness is negatively correlated with its average pore size.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

energy development / CO₂ geological storage / rock mechanics / bituminous coal

References

[1] Agartan E, Trevisan L, Cihan A, Birkholzer J, Zhou Q L, Illangasekare T H (2015). Experimental study on effects of geologic heterogeneity in enhancing dissolution trapping of supercritical CO₂.Water Resour Res, 51(3): 1635–1648

[2] Avnir D, Jaroniec M (1989). An isotherm equation for adsorption on fractal surface of heterogeneous porous materials.Langmuir, 5(6): 1431–1433

[3] Brunauer S, Deming L S, Deming W S, Teller E (1940). On a theory of the van der Waals adsorption of gases.J Am Chem Soc, 62(7): 1723–1732

[4] Chandler M R, Meredith P G, Brantut N, Crawford B R (2016). Fracture toughness anisotropy in shale.J Geophys Res Solid Earth, 121(3): 1706–1729

[5] Chareonsuppanimit P, Mohammad S A, Robinson R L, Gasem K A M (2014). Modeling gas-adsorption induced swelling and permeability changes in coals.Int J Coal Geol, 121: 98–109

[6] Chen K, Liu X F, Nie B S, Zhang C P, Song D Z, Wang L K, Yang T (2022). Mineral dissolution and pore alteration of coal induced by interactions with supercritical CO₂.Energy, 248: 123627

[7] Chen T Y, Feng X T, Zhang X W, Cao W D, Fu C J (2014). Experimental study on mechanical and anisotrpic propertiesof black shale. Chin J Rock Mech Eng, 33 (9): 1772–1779 (in Chinese)

[8] Cheng L, Li D, Wang W, Liu J (2021). Heterogeneous transport of free CH₄ and free CO₂ in dual-porosity media controlled by anisotropic in situ stress during shale gas production by CO₂ flooding: implications for CO₂ geological storage and utilization.ACS Omega, 6(40): 26756–26765

[9] Czerw K, Baran P, Szczurowski J, Zarębska K (2021). Sorption and desorption of CO₂ and CH₄ in vitrinite- and inertinite-rich polish low-rank coal.Nat Resour Res, 30(1): 543–556

[10] Farmer I W, Pooley F D (1967). A hypothesis to explain the occurrence of outbursts in coal, based on a study of West Wales outburst coal.Int J Rock Mech Min Sci Geomech Abstr, 4(2): 189–193

[11] Feng G, Kang Y, Chen F, Liu Y W, Wang X C (2018). The influence of temperature on mixed-mode (I+II) and mode-II fracture toughness of sandstone.Eng Fract Mech, 189: 51–63

[12] Feng G, Kang Y, Meng T, Hu Y Q, Li X H (2017). The influence of temperature on mode I fracture toughness and fracture characteristics of sandstone.Rock Mech Rock Eng, 50(8): 2007–2019

[13] Feng G, Kang Y, Sun Z D, Wang X C, Hu Y Q (2019). Effects of supercritical CO₂ adsorption on the mechanical characteristics and failure mechanisms of shale.Energy, 173: 870–882

[14] Feng G, Kang Y, Wang X C, Hu Y Q, Li X H (2020c). Investigation on the failure characteristics and fracture classification of shale under Brazilian test conditions.Rock Mech Rock Eng, 53(7): 3325–3340

[15] Feng G, Wang X C, Kang Y, Zhang Z T (2020a). Effect of thermal cycling-dependent cracks on physical and mechanical properties of granite for enhanced geothermal system.Int J Rock Mech Min Sci, 134: 104476

[16] Feng G, Wang X C, Wang M, Kang Y (2020b). Experimental investigation of thermal cycling effect on fracture characteristics of granite in a geothermal-energy reservoir.Eng Fract Mech, 235: 107180

[17] Gao M Z, Xie J, Gao Y N, Wang W Y, Li C, Yang B G, Liu J J, Xie H P (2021). Mechanical behavior of coal under different mining rates: a case study from laboratory experiments to field testing.Int J Min Sci Technol, 31(5): 825–841

[18] Gao M Z, Zhang J G, Li S W, Wang M, Wang Y W, Cui P F (2020). Calculating changes in fractal dimension of surface cracks to quantify how the dynamic loading rate affects rock failure in deep mining.J Cent South Univ, 27(10): 3013–3024

[19] Guo P Y, Gu J, Su Y, Wang J, Ding Z W (2021b). Effect of cyclic wetting–drying on tensile mechanical behavior and microstructure of clay-bearing sandstone.Int J Coal Sci Technol, 8(5): 956–968

[20] Guo Y X, Zhao Y H, Wang S W, Feng G R, Zhang Y J, Ran H Y (2021a). Stress-strain-acoustic responses in failure process of coal rock with different height to diameter ratios under uniaxial compression.J Cent South Univ, 28(6): 1724–1736

[21] Hedges S W, Soong Y, Jones J R M, Harrison D K, Irdi G, Frommell E, Dilmore R, White C (2007). Exploratory study of some potential environmental impacts of CO₂ sequestration in unmineable coal seams.Int J Environ Pollut, 29(4): 457–473

[22] Heng S, Yang C H, Guo Y T, Wang C Y, Wang L (2015). Influence of bedding planes on hydraulic fracture propagationin shale formations. Chin J Rock Mech Eng, 34 (2): 228–237 (in Chinese)

[23] Hou L L, Liu X J, Liang L X, Xiong J, Zhang P, Xie B, Li D Q (2020). Investigation of coal and rock geo-mechanical properties evaluation based on the fracture complexity and wave velocity.J Nat Gas Sci Eng, 75: 103133

[24] Hu J J, Xie H P, Sun Q, Li C B, Liu G K (2021). Changes in the thermodynamic properties of alkaline granite after cyclic quenching following high temperature action.Int J Min Sci Technol, 31(5): 843–852

[25] Jin J F, Yuan W, Wu Y, Guo Z Q (2020). Effects of axial static stress on stress wave propagation in rock considering porosity compaction and damage evolution.J Cent South Univ, 27(2): 592–607

[26] Kataoka M, Obara Y, Kuruppu M (2015). Estimation of fracture toughness of anisotropic rocks by semi-circular bend (SCB) tests under water vapor pressure.Rock Mech Rock Eng, 48(4): 1353–1367

[27] Keboletse K P, Ntuli F, Oladijo O P (2021). Influence of coal properties on coal conversion processes-coal carbonization, carbon fiber production, gasification and liquefaction technologies: a review.Int J Coal Sci Technol, 8(5): 817–843

[28] Kong X G, He D, Liu X F, Wang E Y, Li S G, Liu T, Ji P F, Deng D Y, Yang S R (2022). Strain characteristics and energy dissipation laws of gas-bearing coal during impact fracture process.Energy, 242: 123028

[29] Kuruppu M D, Obara Y, Ayatollahi M R, Chong K P, Funatsu T (2014). ISRM-suggested method for determining the mode I static fracture toughness using semi-circular bend specimen.Rock Mech Rock Eng, 47(1): 267–274

[30] Lampert A (2019). Over-exploitation of natural resources is followed by inevitable declines in economic growth and discount rate.Nat Commun, 10(1): 1419

[31] Li Y J, Song L H, Tang Y J, Zuo J P, Xue D J (2022). Evaluating the mechanical properties of anisotropic shale containing bedding and natural fractures with discrete element modeling.Int J Coal Sci Technol, 9(1): 18

[32] Liao Z W, Liu X F, Song D Z, He X Q, Nie B S, Yang T, Wang L K (2021). Micro-structural damage to coal induced by liquid CO₂ phase change fracturing.Nat Resour Res, 30(2): 1613–1627

[33] Liu B, Zhao Y X, Zhang C, Zhou J L, Li Y T, Sun Z (2021a). Characteristic strength and acoustic emission properties of weakly cemented sandstone at different depths under uniaxial compression.Int J Coal Sci Technol, 8(6): 1288–1301

[34] Liu C R, Tang Y F, Wang H Q, Liu Z Q, Yang S, Li C J, Jin W T (2022a). Comparison of life cycle performance of distributed energy system and conventional energy system for district heating and cooling in China.J Cent South U, 29(7): 2357–2376

[35] Liu J, Xie L, Elsworth D, Gan Q (2019a). CO₂/CH₄ competitive adsorption in shale: implications for enhancement in gas production and reduction in carbon emissions.Environ Sci Technol, 53(15): 9328–9336

[36] Liu J, Yao Y, Liu D, Elsworth D (2017). Experimental evaluation of CO₂ enhanced recovery of adsorbed-gas from shale.Int J Coal Geol, 179: 211–218

[37] LiuK D, LiuQ S, ZhuY G(2013). Experimental study of coal considering directivity effect of bedding plane under Brazilian splitting and uniaxial compression. Chin J Rock Mech Eng, 32: 308–315 (in Chinese)

[38] Liu S M, Li X L, Wang D K, Zhang D M (2021b). Experimental study on temperature response of different ranks of coal to liquid nitrogen soaking.Nat Resour Res, 30(2): 1467–1480

[39] Liu X F, Nie B S (2016). Fractal characteristics of coal samples utilizing image analysis and gas adsorption.Fuel, 182: 314–322

[40] Liu X F, Song D Z, He X Q, Nie B S, Wang L K (2019c). Insight into the macromolecular structural differences between hard coal and deformed soft coal.Fuel, 245: 188–197

[41] Liu X F, Wang L K, Kong X G, Ma Z T, Nie B S, Song D Z, Yang T (2022d). Role of pore irregularity in methane desorption capacity of coking coal.Fuel, 314: 123037

[42] Liu X F, Zhang C L, Nie B S, Zhang C P, Song D Z, Yang T, Ma Z T (2022c). Mechanical response and mineral dissolution of anthracite induced by supercritical CO₂ saturation: influence of saturation time.Fuel, 319: 123759

[43] Liu X, Song D, He X, Wang Z, Zeng M, Deng K (2019b). Nanopore structure of deep-burial coals explored by AFM.Fuel, 246: 9–17

[44] Liu Z Y, Wang G, Li J Z, Li H X, Zhao H F, Shi H W, Lan J L (2022b). Water-immersion softening mechanism of coal rock mass based on split Hopkinson pressure bar experiment.Int J Coal Sci Technol, 9(1): 61

[45] Ma Q, Tan Y L, Liu X S, Zhao Z H, Fan D Y, Purev L (2021). Experimental and numerical simulation of loading rate effects on failure and strain energy characteristics of coal-rock composite samples.J Cent South U, 28(10): 3207–3222

[46] Mabuza M, Premlall K, Daramola M O (2022). Modelling and thermodynamic properties of pure CO₂ and fue gas sorption data on South African coals using Langmuir, Freundlich, Temkin, and extended Langmuir isotherm models.Int J Coal Sci Technol, 9(1): 45

[47] Mandile A J, Hutton A C (1995). Quantitative X-ray diffraction analysis of mineral and organic phases in organic-rich rocks.Int J Coal Geol, 28(1): 51–69

[48] Masoudian M S, Airey D W, El-Zein A (2013). A chemo-poro-mechanical model for sequestration of carbon dioxide in coalbeds.Geotechnique, 63(3): 235–243

[49] Masoudian M S, Airey D W, El-Zein A (2014). Experimental investigations on the effect of CO₂ on mechanics of coal.Int J Coal Geol, 128–129: 12–23

[50] Nikolenko P V, Epshtein S A, Shkuratnik V L, Anufrenkova P S (2021). Experimental study of coal fracture dynamics under the influence of cyclic freezing–thawing using shear elastic waves.Int J Coal Sci Technol, 8(4): 562–574

[51] Niu Q H, Cao L W, Sang S X, Wang W, Zhou X Z, Yuan W, Ji Z M, Chang J F, Li M Y (2021). Experimental study on the softening effect and mechanism of anthracite with CO₂ injection.Int J Rock Mech Min Sci, 138: 104614

[52] Niu Q, Cao L, Sang S, Zhou X, Wang W, Yuan W, Ji Z M, Wang H C, Nie Y (2020). Study on the anisotropic permeability in different rank coals under influences of supercritical CO₂ adsorption and effective stress and its enlightenment for CO₂ enhance coalbed methane recovery.Fuel, 262: 116515

[53] Omotilewa O J, Panja P, Vega-Ortiz C, McLennan J (2021). Evaluation of enhanced coalbed methane recovery and carbon dioxide sequestration potential in high volatile bituminous coal.J Nat Gas Sci Eng, 91: 103979

[54] Pan Z J, Connell L D (2007). A theoretical model for gas adsorption-induced coal swelling.Int J Coal Geol, 69(4): 243–252

[55] Patel M J, May E F, Johns M L (2016). High-fidelity reservoir simulations of enhanced gas recovery with supercritical CO₂.Energy, 111: 548–559

[56] Perera M S A, Ranjith P G, Viete D R (2013). Effects of gaseous and super-critical carbon dioxide saturation on the mechanical properties of bituminous coal from the Southern Sydney Basin.Appl Energy, 110: 73–81

[57] Pfeiferper P, Avnir D (1983). Chemistry in noninteger dimensions between two and three. I. Fractal theory of heterogeneous surfaces.J Chem Phys, 79(7): 3558–3565

[58] Qiu L M, Liu Z T, Wang E Y, He X Q, Feng J J, Li B L (2020). Early-warning of rock burst in coal mine by lowfrequency electromagnetic radiation.Eng Geol, 279: 105755

[59] Ranathunga A S, Perera M S A, Ranjith P G, Bui H (2016). Super-critical CO₂ saturation-induced mechanical property alterations in low rank coal: an experimental study.J Supercrit Fluids, 109: 134–140

[60] Ranjith P G, Perera M S A (2012). Effects of cleat performance on strength reduction of coal in CO₂ sequestration.Energy, 45(1): 1069–1075

[61] Raza A, Gholami R, Rezaee R, Rasouli V, Rabiei M (2019). Significant aspects of carbon capture and storage – a review.Petroleum, 5(4): 335–340

[62] Say N P, Yücel M (2006). Energy consumption and CO₂ emissions in Turkey: empirical analysis and future projection based on an economic growth.Energy Policy, 34(18): 3870–3876

[63] Sing K S W, Everett D H, Haul R A W, Moscou L, Pierotti R A, Rouquerol J, Siemieniewska T (1985). Reporting physisorption data for gas/solid systems with special reference to the determination of surface area and porosity.Pure Appl Chem, 57(4): 603–619

[64] Souley Agbodjan Y, Liu Z, Wang J, Yue C, Luo Z (2022). Modeling and optimization of a multi-carrier renewable energy system for zero-energy consumption buildings.J Cent South U, 29(7): 2330–2345

[65] Sun Z D, Feng G, Song X M, Meng T, Zhu D F, Huo Y M, Wang Z L (2022). Effects of CO₂ state and anisotropy on the progressive failure characteristics of bituminous coal: an experimental study. Chin J Rock Mech Eng, 41(11): 70–81 (in Chinese)

[66] Tan L H, Ren T, Yang X H, He X Q (2018). A numerical simulation study on mechanical behaviour of coal with bedding planes under coupled static and dynamic load.Int J Min Sci Technol, 28(5): 791–797

[67] WuP F, LiangW G, CaoM T, Yang J F, LiL (2017). Experimental investigation on model I fracture characteristics of coal in different stratification orientation. Chin J Undergr Sp Eng.,13(Supp.2): 538–545 (in Chinese)

[68] Yin H, Zhou J P, Jiang Y D, Xian X F, Liu Q L (2016). Physical and structural changes in shale associated with supercritical CO₂ exposure.Fuel, 184: 289–303

[69] Zagorščak R, Thomas H R (2018). Effects of subcritical and supercritical CO₂ sorption on deformation and failure of high-rank coals.Int J Coal Geol, 199: 113–123

[70] Zhang G L, Ranjith P G, Li Z S, Gao M Z, Ma Z Y (2021a). Long-term effects of CO₂-water-coal interactions on structural and mechanical changes of bituminous coal.J Petrol Sci Eng, 207: 109093

[71] Zhang H, Hu Z C, Xu Y, Fu X X, Li W, Zhang D F (2021c). Impacts of long-term exposure to supercritical carbon dioxide on physicochemical properties and adsorption and desorption capabilities of moisture-equilibrated coals.Energy Fuels, 35(15): 12270–12287

[72] Zhang Y B, Yao X L, Liang P, Wang K X, Sun L, Tian B Z, Liu X X, Wang S Y (2021b). Fracture evolution and localization effect of damage in rock based on wave velocity imaging technology.J Cent South U, 28(9): 2752–2769

[73] Zhao P, He B, Zhang B, Liu J (2022). Porosity of gas shale: is the NMR-based measurement reliable?.Petrol Sci, 19(2): 509–517

[74] Zhao Y X, Gong S, Hao X J, Peng Y, Jiang Y D (2017). Effects of loading rate and bedding on the dynamic fracture toughness of coal: laboratory experiments.Eng Fract Mech, 178: 375–391

Acknowledgments

This study has been partially funded by Youth Program of National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 51904195) and the School Fund of Taiyuan University of Technology and Science (No. 20182008). These supports are gratefully acknowledged.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2023 Higher Education Press