Environmental risks of shale gas exploitation and solutions for clean shale gas production in China

Abstract

Shale gas is a relatively clean-burning fossil fuel, produced by hydraulic fracturing. This technology may be harmful to the environment; therefore, environmentally friendly methods to extract shale gas have attracted considerable attention from researchers. Unlike previous studies, this study is a comprehensive investigation that uses systematic analyses and detailed field data. The environmental challenges associated with shale gas extraction, as well as measures to mitigate environmental impacts from the source to end point are detailed, using data and experience from China’s shale gas production sites. Environmental concerns are among the biggest challenges in practice, mainly including seasonal water shortages, requisition of primary farmland, leakage of drilling fluid and infiltration of flowback fluid, oil-based drill cuttings getting buried underground, and induced seismicity. China’s shale gas companies have attempted to improve methods, as well as invent new materials and devices to implement cleaner processes for the sake of protecting the environment. Through more than 10-year summary, China’s clean production model for shale gas focuses on source pollution prevention, process control, and end treatment, which yield significant results in terms of resource as well as environmental protection, and can have practical implications for shale gas production in other countries, that can be duplicated elsewhere.

Graphical abstract

Keywords

shale gas / clean production / resource saving / environmentally friendly / China

References

[1] Baranzelli C, Vandecasteele I, Ribeiro Barranco R, Mari i Rivero I, Pelletier N, Batelaan O, Lavalle C (2015). Scenarios for shale gas development and their related land use impacts in the Baltic Basin, Northern Poland. Energy Policy, 84: 80–95

[2] Chen L, He M, Wang D, Zhang S, Yang F (2016). Discussion on pollution control technologies of fracturing waste water in fuling shale gas exploitation. Fine Spec Chem, 24: 26–31

[3] Chen Y, He L, Guan Y, Lu H, Li J (2017). Life cycle assessment of greenhouse gas emissions and water-energy optimization for shale gas supply chain planning based on multi-level approach: case study in Barnett, Marcellus, Fayetteville, and Haynesville shales. Energy Convers Manage, 134: 382–398

[4] Chen Z, Zheng Z, Li D, Chen H, Xu Y (2020). Continuous supercritical water oxidation treatment of oil-based drill cuttings using municipal sewage sludge as diluent. J Hazard Mater, 384: 121225

[5] Chongqing Provincial Water Resources Bureau (2018). Chongqing water resources bulletin, 2018. Available at Chongqing Government website

[6] Eaton T T (2013). Science-based decision-making on complex issues: Marcellus shale gas hydrofracking and New York City water supply. Sci Total Environ, (461–462): 158–169

[7] EIA (2018). Natural gas and the environment. Available at EIA website

[8] EIA (2015a). World Shale Resource Assessments. Available at MWR website

[9] EIA (2015b). China adds incentives for domestic natural gas production as imports increase- Today in Energy. Available at EIA website

[10] EPA (2012). Study of the Potential Impacts of Hydraulic Fracturing on Drinking Water Resources: Progress Report

[11] Estrada J M, Bhamidimarri R (2016). A review of the issues and treatment options for wastewater from shale gas extraction by hydraulic fracturing. Fuel, 182: 292–303

[12] Fan H (2016). Approaching jiaoshiba – focusing on geological environment impact assessment in the development of fuling shale gas field in chongqing. Hydrogeol. Eng. Geol, 171–172

[13] Gregory K B, Vidic R D, Dzombak D A (2011). Water management challenges associated with the production of shale gas by hydraulic fracturing. Elements, 7(3): 181–186

[14] Guizhou Provincial Water Resources Department (2018). Guizhou province water resources bulletin. Available at Guizhou Goverment website

[15] Guo Y, Zhang X, Wang Q, Chen H, Du X, Ma Y (2020). Temporal changes in vegetation around a shale gas development area in a subtropical karst region in southwestern China. Sci Total Environ, 701: 134769

[16] Gvakharia A, Kort E A, Brandt A, Peischl J, Ryerson T B, Schwarz J P, Smith M L, Sweeney C (2017). Methane, black carbon, and ethane emissions from natural gas flares in the Bakken Shale, North Dakota. Environ Sci Technol, 51(9): 5317–5325

[17] Holland A A (2013). Earthquakes triggered by hydraulic fracturing in south-central Oklahoma. Bull Seismol Soc Am, 103(3): 1784–1792

[18] Howarth R W, Santoro R, Ingraffea A (2011). Methane and the greenhouse-gas footprint of natural gas from shale formations. Clim Change, 106(4): 679–690

[19] Huang W (2019). Cost-reduction and Profit-increase Cases of Shale Gas Drilling Engineering. Beijing: Petroleum Industry Press (in Chinese)

[20] Huo X, Jiao Y, Li Y, Yang Z, Luo F (2019). Current status of environmental protection and countermeasures of shale gas exploitation in southern Sichuan. Environ Prot Oil Gas Fields, 29: 1–3

[21] Kahrilas G A, Blotevogel J, Stewart P S, Borch T (2015). Biocides in hydraulic fracturing fluids: a critical review of their usage, mobility, degradation, and toxicity. Environ Sci Technol, 49(1): 16–32

[22] Li X M, Zhao B, Wang Z, Xie M, Song J, Nghiem L D, He T, Yang C, Li C, Chen G (2014). Water reclamation from shale gas drilling flow-back fluid using a novel forward osmosis-vacuum membrane distillation hybrid system. Water Sci Technol, 69(5): 1036–1044

[23] Liang R, Tong L, Xiang Q, Zhuang S, Zhou X (2014). Management of and proposals on environmental impact assessment (EIA) for shale gas development in China. Nat Gas Ind, 34: 135–140

[24] Liu C (2016). Research and practice of the key technologies for “green” drilling. Explor Eng (Rock & Soil Drill Tunneling), 43: 9–13

[25] Liu Y (2018). Key technologies for green development in the Fuling shale gas field. Pet Drill Tech, 46: 8–13

[26] Lu T, Hu M, Liu M, Ding C, Wang X (2016). On the impact of shale gas development on water resource and environment in Sichuan and Chongqing. Sci Technol Rev, 34: 51–56

[27] Lutz B D, Lewis A N, Doyle M W (2013). Generation, transport, and disposal of wastewater associated with Marcellus Shale gas development. Water Resour Res, 49(2): 647–656

[28] Macro Data on the Global Economy (2015). Cultivated land area per capita (index). Available at Sina website

[29] Mei X, Jin J, Wang C, He Y, Wang D, Zhang C (2017a). Practice and research of green development in Fuling Shale Gas Field. J Southwest Pet Univ Sci Ed, 19: 9–14

[30] Mei X, Wang C, Zhang S, Xiong D, Zhang C, He M (2017b). Main environmental risk analysis and countermeasure for shale gas mining in Fuling. Environmental Science and Management, 42: 63–66

[31] Mei X, Zhang S, Xiong D, Wang C, He M (2016). Impacts of Shale Gas Exploitation on Ecological Environmengt in Fuling and Countermeasures. J Southwest Pet Univ Sci Ed, 18: 7–12

[32] Milt A W, Armsworth P R (2017). Performance of a cap and trade system for managing environmental impacts of shale gas surface infrastructure. Ecol Econ, 131: 399–406

[33] Minstry of Water Resources of the People’s Republic of China (2018a). Water resources bulletin. Available at Ministry of Water Resources of the People’s Republic of China Website

[34] Minstry of Water Resources of the People’s Republic of China (2018b). Bulletin on flood and drought disasters in China. Available at Ministry of Water Resources of the People’s Republic of China Website

[35] Mohammad-Pajooh E, Weichgrebe D, Cuff G, Tosarkani B M, Rosenwinkel K H (2018). On-site treatment of flowback and produced water from shale gas hydraulic fracturing: a review and economic evaluation. Chemosphere, 212: 898–914

[36] Rich A, Grover J P, Sattler M L (2014). An exploratory study of air emissions associated with shale gas development and production in the Barnett Shale. J Air Waste Manag Assoc, 64(1): 61–72

[37] Roy A A, Adams P J, Robinson A L (2014). Air pollutant emissions from the development, production, and processing of Marcellus Shale natural gas. J Air Waste Manag Assoc, 64(1): 19–37

[38] Rozell D J, Reaven S J (2012). Water pollution risk associated with natural gas extraction from the Marcellus Shale. Risk Anal, 32(8): 1382–1393

[39] Shi Z, Xu Y, Shao Z, Sun J, Liu J, Ke Y (2019). Research and Application of Thermal-desorption Treatment of Oil-based Cuttings from Shale Gas Produtiion. Environ Prot Oil Gas F, 29: 37–40

[40] Sichuan Provincial Water Resources Department (2018). Sichuan water resources bulletin. Available at Sichuan Provincial Water Resources Department website

[41] Sun H, Wang C, Liu W, Xie Y (2017). Cleaner production in the Changning-Weiyuan national shale gas demonstration area. Nat Gas Ind, 37: 105–111

[42] Sun Y, Wang D, Tsang D C W, Wang L, Ok Y S, Feng Y (2019). A critical review of risks, characteristics, and treatment strategies for potentially toxic elements in wastewater from shale gas extraction. Environ Int, 125: 452–469

[43] Tang Y, Jinchuan Z, Qin Z, Pengyu L (2010). Hydraulic fracturing of shale gas Wells and its application analysis. Nat gas Ind, 30: 33–39

[44] Tang Z (2016). A brief analysis of the application and practice of factory operation mode in shale gas development in weiyuan. China Pet Chem Ind Stand Qual, 36: 78–79

[45] Van de Graaf T, Haesebrouck T, Debaere P (2018). Fractured politics? The comparative regulation of shale gas in Europe. J Eur Public Policy, 25(9): 1276–1293

[46] Vengosh A, Jackson R B, Warner N, Darrah T H, Kondash A (2014). A Critical Review of the Risks to Water Resources from Unconventional Shale Gas Development and Hydraulic Fracturing in the United States. Environ Sci Technol, 48(15): 8334–8348

[47] Wan F (2019). Research on plugging technology for surface casing drilling of changing shale gas. Drill & Prod Technol, 42: 28–31

[48] Wan F, Liu H, Qi Y (2018). Environmental surface driling on well pad N213. Drill & Prod Technol, 41: 13–15

[49] Wan Z, Huang T, Craig B (2014). Barriers to the development of China’s shale gas industry. J Clean Prod, 84: 818–823

[50] Wang C Q, Jin J Z, Lin X Y, Xiong D M, Mei X D (2017). A study on the oil-based drilling cutting pyrolysis residue resource utilization by the exploration and development of shale gas. Environ Sci Pollut Res, 24: 17816–17828

[51] Wang Q, Zhu D, Xia G, Zeng G, Li X, Chen H, Wei L, Liu Y (2018). Technological series supporting the “green-development” of shale gas in China: a case study. Nat Gas Ind, 38: 125–130

[52] Warner N R, Christie C A, Jackson R B, Vengosh A (2013). Impacts of shale gas wastewater disposal on water quality in western Pennsylvania. Environ Sci Technol, 47(20): 11849–11857

[53] Wei Y, Wang S, Ma Q, Wu W, Lu X, Yan X (2018). Waste water management in Sichuan Changning-Weiyuan shale gas field. Chem Eng Oil Gas, 47(4): 113–119

[54] Wu X, Xia J, Guan B, Liu P, Ning L, Yi X, Yang L, Hu S (2019a). Water scarcity assessment based on estimated ultimate energy recovery and water footprint framework during shale gas production in the Changning play. J Clean Prod, 241: 118312

[55] Wu X, Xia J, Guan B, Yan X, Zou L, Liu P, Yang L, Hong S, Hu S (2019b). Water availability assessment of shale gas production in the Weiyuan play, China. Sustain, 11(3)

[56] Xia H, Bao K, Wang Y, Zhou C, Yang Y (2019). An Integrated Drilling Cuttings Utilization Technique in the South Pingqiao Block of the Fuling Shale Gas Field. Pet Drill Tech, 47: 63–67

[57] Xie X, Zhang T, Wang M, Huang Z (2019). Impact of shale gas development on regional water resources in China from water footprint assessment view. Sci Total Environ, 679: 317–327

[58] Xiong D, Zhang S, Feng B, Wang C, Mei X, Zhang C (2016a). Present status analysis of environmental protection in exploration and development of fuling shale gas. J Xi’an Shiyou Univ Nat Sci Ed, 31: 48–53

[59] Xiong Y, Liu Y, Liu Y, Wu W, Dai Y, Chen N (2016b). Recycling disposal technology and application of shale gas fracturing flowback fluid in Changning-Weiyuan area. Chem Eng Oil Gas, 45: 51–55

[60] Yang D, Yu Y, Liang R, Yuan J (2019). Development progress and environmental protection status in China’s key shale gas construction areas and suggestions. Mod Chem Ind, 39: 1–6

[61] Yang H, Huang X, Yang Q, Tu J, Li S, Yang D, Xia H, Flower R J, Thompson J R (2015). Water requirements for shale gas fracking in Fuling, Chongqing, Southwest China. Energy Procedia, 76: 106–112

[62] Yunnan Provincial Water Resources Department (2018). Yunnan water resources bulletin. Available at wcd.yn.gov.cn website

[63] Zhang X, Sun A Y, Duncan I J (2016). Shale gas wastewater management under uncertainty. J Environ Manage, 165: 188–198

[64] Zhong Y, Fang J (2017). Environmental protection during the development of fuling national shale gas production demonstration area. China Petrochem, 34–35

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the National Key Technology R & D Program of China (No. 2011ZX05028-002). The authors acknowledge colleagues from the PetroChina Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration and Development for their help with this study.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2020 Higher Education Press