Chronology of the shell bar section and a discussion on the ages of the Late Pleistocene lacustrine deposits in the paleolake Qarhan, Qaidam basin

Abstract

Shell bar, composed of abundant fossil shells of Corbicula fluminea müller and Corbicula largillierti philippi and located at the southeastern end (36°30′N, 96°12′E) of the paleolake Qarhan, is one of the most prominent features in the Qaidam basin. It is the highest site where such species of fossil shells have been found in the Late Pleistocene age. A 2.6-m-thick fresh profile was manually excavated to determine the formation ages and the scope of the high paleolake levels. Accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS), conventional radiocarbon dating, and sector inductively coupled plasma-mass spectroscopy ²³⁰Th methods were used to investigate the reliability and accuracy of dating results in different laboratories. Ages of various components (e.g. acid residual and acid soluble fraction of the organic matter) from the same sample were determined. Age differences of a variety of materials (e.g. organic matter, fossil shells, and salt crystals), and age differences at the same sampling position were evaluated. Dating shows that the AMS ages given by alkali residue and acid soluble fractions vary greatly, e.g., from 124.5 cm upwards. The dates given by the acid soluble fraction were normal. Down the column, the dates show a reverse pattern and those of alkali residues, especially the lower part of the section, show an unstable pattern. These imply that organic matter had been influenced by two separate processes. One possible explanation is that the alkali residual fraction most likely had been contaminated by dead carbon-bearing reworked material because the study section is located near the edge of the paleolake and could have been easily influenced by old eroded deposits. Another is that the acid soluble fraction could have been contaminated by upward-flowing groundwater containing soluble organic matter. The amount of this soluble organic material should be very small because the strongest age reversal is in the lower part, where the TOC content remains low, meaning that the change of soluble organic fraction alters neither TOC content nor the ?¹³C dramatically. It is concluded that a uniform mega-paleolake developed in the Qaidam basin in the northeastern Tibetan plateau between 39.7 and 17.5 ¹⁴C kaB.P. During the period when the high paleolake level of Qarhan was formed, the huge paleolake covered a vast area with dramatic lake level fluctuations. It is found that the ages determined may be influenced by either radioactive ¹⁴C variations of repeated deposition or content variations in the atmosphere. The ages given by fossil shells are 15–18 ka older than those given by organic matter. The large differences between the ages of fossil shells and organic matter might have resulted from the large water areas and huge water volume and the special location of the high-elevation Qaidam basin. This study also shows the reliability and accuracy of the ²³⁰Th dating method on the salt crystals but further study is needed to determine whether this method could be applied to the study area.

References

1. Bard E Arnold M Fairbanks R G et al. 1993 ²³⁰Th-²³⁴U and ¹⁴C ages obtainedby mass spectrometry on coralsRadiocarbon35191199
2. Chang F Q Zhang H C Chen Y et al. 2007 Stable isotopes of carbonate andfossil shells from the Shell Bar section of the paleolake Qarhan,Qaidam basinQuaternary Sciences27(3)427436 (in Chinesewith English abstract)
3. Chen K Z Bowler J M 1985 Sedimentaryfeature of the Qarhan Salt Lake in Qaidam basin and primary studyof its palaeoclimatic evolutionSciencein China (Series B)5463471 (in Chinese)
4. Chen K Z Bowler J M 1986 Late Pleistoceneevolution of salt lakes in the Qaidam basin, Qinghai Province, ChinaPalaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology54(1–4)87104
5. Chen K Z Bowler J M 1987 Evolutionof salt lakes in Late Pleistocene in Qaidam basin Qinghai Province,ChinaIn: The Sino–AustraliaCooperation Group. Article Collection of China–AustraliaQuaternary SymposiumBeijingScience Press8391 (in Chinese)
6. Colman S M Jones G A Rubin M et al. 1996 AMS radiocarbon analyses from LakeBaikal, Siberia: Challenges of dating sediments from a large, oligotrophiclakeQuaternary Science Reviews (QuaternaryGeochronology)15(7)669684. doi:10.1016/0277‐3791(96)00027‐3
7. Dai J S Ye X S Tang L J et al. 2003 Tectonic units and oil-gas potentialof the Qaidam basinChinese Journal of Geology38(3)29l296 (in Chinesewith English abstract)
8. Derbyshire E Shaw J Wang J T 1985 Paleomagnetic age of the borehole No.1of Dabuxun Lake, Qaidam basinJournal ofGlaciology and Geocryology7(3)227232 (in Chinese with English abstract)
9. Di H S Wang S G 1991 Research ofstructural evolution of Mesozoic and Cenozoic in the northern QaidambasinEarth Science--Journal of China Universityof Geosciences16(5)533539 (in Chinese with English abstract)
10. Geyh M A Grosjean M Nuñez L et al. 1999 Radiocarbon reservoir effect andthe timing of the Late–Glacial/Early Holocene humid phase inthe Atacama Desert (Northern Chile)QuaternaryResearch52(2)143153. doi:10.1006/qres.1999.2060
11. Huang Q Cai B Q 1987 Geochronologicalstudy on the sediments in Qarhan LakeIn: The Sino–Australia Cooperation Group. Article Collection of China–Australia Quaternary SymposiumBeijingSciencePress106114 (in Chinese)
12. Huang Q Chen K Z 1990 Palaeoclimaticfluctuation fashion of Qarhan Salt Lake in Qaidam basin in the past730 000 yearsQuaternary Sciences(3)205211 (in Chinese with English abstract)
13. Huang Y Chen Z Y Liu C E 2005 Comparison and analysis of temperaturechange between Chaidamu basin and northeast of Qinghai Province in43 yearsJournal of Qinghai University (NatureScience)23(3)5256 (in Chinese with English abstract)
14. Kang A Zhu X M Han D X et al. 2003 Quaternary sporopollen assemblagesand paleoclimatic fluctuation in the Qaidam basinGeological Bulletin of China22(1)1215 (in Chinese with English abstract)
15. Kitagawa H van der Plicht J 1998a A 40,000-yearvarve chronology from Lake Suigetsu, Japan: Extension of the radiocarboncalibration curveRadiocarbon40(1)505516
16. Kitagawa H van der Plicht J 1998b Atmosphereradiocarbon calibration to 45,000 yr B.P.: Late glacial fluctuationsand cosmogenic isotope productionScience27911871190. doi:10.1126/science.279.5354.1187
17. Lei G L Zhang H C Zhang W X et al. 2007 The Characteristic of grain-sizeand Sedimentation of Shell Bar section in Qaerhan Lake from QaidambasinActa Sedimentologica Sinica25(2)274282 (in Chinesewith English abstract)
18. Liang Q S Huang Q 1995 Salt-formingages of the Dabusun and Bieletan Regions in Qarhan Playa, QinghaiActa Sedimentologica Sinica13(3)126131 (in Chinese with Englishabstract)
19. Liu Z C Wang Y J Chen Y et al. 1998 Magnetostratigraphy and sedimentologicalderived geochronology of the Quaternary lacustrine deposits of a 3000 m thick sequence in the central Qaidam basin, western ChinaPalaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology140459473. doi:10.1016/S0031‐0182(98)00048‐0
20. Qiang M R Chen F H Zhang J W et al. 2005 Climatic changes documented bystable isotopes of sedimentary carbonate in Lake Sugan, northeasternTibetan Plateau of China, since 2 kaBPChineseScience Bulletin50(17)19301939. doi:10.1360/04wd0285
21. Ren G Y 1998 A finding of the influence of “Hard Water”on radiocarbon dating for lake sediments in Inner Mongolia, ChinaJournal of Lake Sciences10(3)8082 (in Chinese with Englishabstract)
22. Shi X H Zhao Y N Dai S et al. 2005 Research on climate of Qaidam basinsince 1961Journal of Desert Research25(1)123128 (in Chinesewith English abstract)
23. Wang J T Derbyshire E Zhang Y et al. 1985 Recent progress in study of theQuaternary of Qaidam basinChinese ScienceBulletin12936940 (in Chinese)
24. Wang J Huang Q H Bo C G et al. 2002 Tendency of the Quaternary climaticchange in Qaidam basin and its causal mechanismScientia Geographica Sinica22(1)3438 (in Chinese with English abstract)
25. Yang W Spencer R J Krouse H R et al. 1995 Stable isotopes of lake and fluidinclusion brines, Dabusun lake, Qaidam basin, western China: Hydrologyand paleoclimatology in arid environmentsPalaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology117(3)279290. doi:10.1016/0031‐0182(94)00126‐S
26. Yuan L W Chen Y Liu Z C 2003 Restudy on the orbital tuning time scaleof deep core in Qaidam basinJournal ofNanjing Normal University (Natural Science Edition)26(2)8793 (in Chinesewith English abstract)
27. Yuan L W Liu Z C Chen Y 2004 Paleoclimatic changes derived from naturalGamma-Logging Curve in Qaidam basin and its relation to the solarinsolationJournal of Glaciology and Geocryology26(3)298304 (in Chinesewith English abstract)
28. Zhang H C Chang F Q Li B et al. 2007a Branched aliphatic alkanes ofthe Late Pleistocene paleolake deposits from the Qaidam basin, NETibetan plateauChinese Science Bulletin52(9)12481256. doi:10.1007/s11434‐007‐0167‐3
29. Zhang H C Chen Y Fang H F et al. 2007b Climate background of modern cobiculafluminea and the stable isotopes of shells from the representativeareas in continental ChinaMarine Geology &Quaternary Geology27(3)7784 (in Chinese with English abstract)
30. Zhang H C Li B Yang M S et al. 2006a Dating paleosol and animal remainsin loess depositsRadiocarbon48(1)109116
31. Zhang H C Ming Q Z Lei G L et al. 2006b Dilemma of dating on lacustrinedeposits in a hyperarid inland basin of NW ChinaRadiocarbon48(2)18
32. Zhang P X Zhang B Z 1991 Preliminarystudy on paleoclimate and paleoenvironment of the Qaidam region sincethree million years agoScientia GeographicaSinica46(3)327335 (in Chinese with English abstract)