Transition Metal-Based Materials for Electrochemical and Photoelectrochemical Carbon-Free Nitrogen Cycling as H-Carrier

Abstract

Ammonia, as a carbon-free nitrogen-based hydrogen carrier, has attracted significant interest in addressing the approaching energy model innovation in light of its high hydrogen content, low cost, ease of storage, and transport. However, the additional energy consumption and environmental pollution caused by the traditional Haber–Bosch ammonia production and thermal ammonia catalytic cracking process enforce the exploration of clean and renewable ammonia cycling approaches. Electrochemical (EC) and photoelectrochemical (PEC) ammonia synthesis and oxidation for hydrogen generation have shown great potential for achieving an eco-friendly and sustainable green hydrogen economy. Exploring low-cost, highly active, and stable catalysts is pivotal for both EC and PEC systems to achieve efficient ammonia conversion properties. Transition metal-based catalysts (TMCs) have shown significant potential in EC and PEC catalytic systems because of their high catalytic activity, low cost, and excellent stability. We summarize the recent advanced progress of TMCs applied to EC and PEC ammonia synthesis and decomposition to hydrogen generation. Moreover, we discuss the challenges and perspectives on exploring transition metal-based materials in EC and PEC ammonia conversion. This review offers guidance for developing carbon-free nitrogen cycling as a hydrogen carrier.

Keywords

electrochemical / green hydrogen / nitrogen cycling / photoelectrochemical / transition metal-based materials

References

[1] C. Wang and D. Astruc, “Recent Developments of Nanocatalyzed Liquid-Phase Hydrogen Generation,” Chemical Society Reviews50 (2021): 3437-3484.

[2] C. Xia, Y. Li, M. Je, et al., “Nanocrystalline Iron Pyrophosphate-Regulated Amorphous Phosphate Overlayer for Enhancing Solar Water Oxidation,” Nano-Micro Letters14 (2022): 209.

[3] C. Xia, H. Wang, J. K. Kim, and J. Wang, “Rational Design of Metal Oxide-Based Heterostructure for Efficient Photocatalytic and Photoelectrochemical Systems,” Advanced Functional Materials31 (2021): 2008247.

[4] J. Y. Kim, S. H. Roh, C. Xia, U. Sim, and J. K. Kim, “MXene-Based Hybrid Materials for Electrochemical and Photoelectrochemical H₂ Generation,” Journal of Energy Chemistry93 (2024): 111-125.

[5] C. Pei, M.-C. Kim, Y. Li, et al., “Electron Transfer-Induced Metal Spin-Crossover at NiCo₂S₄/ReS₂ 2D–2D Interfaces for Promoting pH-Universal Hydrogen Evolution Reaction,” Advanced Functional Materials33 (2023): 2210072.

[6] O. Elishav, B. Mosevitzky Lis, E. M. Miller, et al., “Progress and Prospective of Nitrogen-Based Alternative Fuels,” Chemical Reviews120 (2020): 5352-5436.

[7] R. Kumar, A. Karkamkar, M. Bowden, and T. J. C. S. R. Autrey, “Solid-State Hydrogen Rich Boron–Nitrogen Compounds for Energy Storage,” Chemical Society Reviews48 (2019): 5350-5380.

[8] M. Asif, S. S. Bibi, S. Ahmed, et al., “Recent Advances in Green Hydrogen Production, Storage and Commercial-Scale Use via Catalytic Ammonia Cracking,” Chemical Engineering Journal473 (2023): 145381.

[9] D. R. MacFarlane, P. V. Cherepanov, J. Choi, et al., “A Roadmap to the Ammonia Economy,” Joule4 (2020): 1186-1205.

[10] B. Yang, W. Ding, H. Zhang, and S. Zhang, “Recent Progress in Electrochemical Synthesis of Ammonia from Nitrogen: Strategies to Improve the Catalytic Activity and Selectivity,” Energy & Environmental Science14 (2021): 672-687.

[11] C. Smith, A. K. Hill, and L. Torrente-Murciano, “Current and Future Role of Haber–Bosch Ammonia in a Carbon-Free Energy Landscape,” Energy & Environmental Science13 (2020): 331-344.

[12] F. Jiao and B. Xu, “Electrochemical Ammonia Synthesis and Ammonia Fuel Cells,” Advanced Materials31 (2019): 1805173.

[13] S. A. Lee, M. G. Lee, and H. W. J. S. C. M. Jang, “Catalysts for Electrochemical Ammonia Oxidation: Trend, Challenge, and Promise,” Science China Materials65 (2022): 3334-3352.

[14] C. Xia, Y. Li, H. Kim, et al., “A Highly Activated Iron Phosphate Over-Llayer for Enhancing Photoelectrochemical Ammonia Decomposition,” Journal of Hazardous Materials408 (2021): 124900.

[15] G. Zhang, J. Ruan, and T. Du, “Recent Advances on Photocatalytic and Electrochemical Oxidation for Ammonia Treatment From Water/Wastewater,” ACS ES&T Engineering1 (2021): 310-325.

[16] D.-K. Lim, A. B. Plymill, H. Paik, et al., “Solid Acid Electrochemical Cell for the Production of Hydrogen From Ammonia,” Joule4 (2020): 2338-2347.

[17] Z. Yan, M. Ji, J. Xia, and H. Zhu, “Recent Advanced Materials for Electrochemical and Photoelectrochemical Synthesis of Ammonia from Dinitrogen: One Step Closer to a Sustainable Energy Future,” Advanced Energy Materials10 (2020): 1902020.

[18] Y. Yao, J. Wang, U. B. Shahid, et al., “Electrochemical Synthesis of Ammonia from Nitrogen Under Mild Conditions: Current Status and Challenges,” Electrochemical Energy Reviews3 (2020): 239-270.

[19] L. Ouyang, J. Liang, Y. Luo, et al., “Recent Advances in Electrocatalytic Ammonia Synthesis,” Chinese Journal of Catalysis50 (2023): 6-44.

[20] Y. Li, M.-C. Kim, C. Xia, et al., “A Natural Molecule-Driven Organometallic Conformal Overlayer for High Efficiency Photoelectrochemical Water Splitting,” Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy343 (2024): 123516.

[21] Y. Li, M. Je, J. Kim, et al., “Rational Nanopositioning of Homogeneous Amorphous Phase on Crystalline Tungsten Oxide for Boosting Solar Water Oxidation,” Chemical Engineering Journal438 (2022): 135532.

[22] S. Sun, Q. Jiang, D. Zhao, et al., “Ammonia as Hydrogen Carrier: Advances in Ammonia Decomposition Catalysts for Promising Hydrogen Production,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews169 (2022): 112918.

[23] R. Wang, K. Yang, C. Wong, et al., “Electrochemical Ammonia Recovery and Co-Production of Chemicals From Manure Wastewater,” Nature Sustainability7 (2024): 179-190.

[24] S. Sun, C. Dai, P. Zhao, et al., “Spin-related Cu–Co Pair to Increase Electrochemical Ammonia Generation on High-Entropy Oxides,” Nature Communications15 (2024): 260.

[25] S. Li, Y. Zhou, X. Fu, et al., “Long-Term Continuous Ammonia Electrosynthesis,” Nature629 (2024): 92-97.

[26] S. Ren, R. T. Gao, N. T. Nguyen, and L. Wang, “Enhanced Charge Carrier Dynamics on Sb₂Se₃ Photocathodes for Efficient Photoelectrochemical Nitrate Reduction to Ammonia,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition63 (2024): e202317414.

[27] E. E. Van Tamelen and D. A. J. J. O. T. A. C. S. Seeley, “Catalytic Fixation of Molecular Nitrogen by Electrolytic and Chemical Reduction,” Journal of the American Chemical Society91 (1969): 5194.

[28] Z. Wang, X. Hu, Z. Liu, G. Zou, G. Wang, and K. Zhang, “Recent Developments in Polymeric Carbon Nitride-Derived Photocatalysts and Electrocatalysts for Nitrogen Fixation,” ACS Catalysis9 (2019): 10260-10278.

[29] G. Qing, R. Ghazfar, S. T. Jackowski, et al., “Recent Advances and Challenges of Electrocatalytic N₂ Reduction to Ammonia,” Chemical Reviews120 (2020): 5437-5516.

[30] H. Li, D. Wu, J. Wu, W. Lv, Z. Duan, and D. Ma, “Graphene-Based Iron Single-Atom Catalysts for Electrocatalytic Nitric Oxide Reduction: A First-Principles Study,” Nanoscale16 (2024): 7058-7067.

[31] F. Varghese, B. V. Kabasakal, C. A. Cotton, et al., “A Low-Potential Terminal Oxidase Associated With the Iron-Only Nitrogenase From the Nitrogen-Fixing Bacterium Azotobacter Vinelandii,” Journal of Biological Chemistry294 (2019): 9367-9376.

[32] D. F. Harris, D. A. Lukoyanov, S. Shaw, et al., “Mechanism of N₂ Reduction Catalyzed by Fe-Nitrogenase Involves Reductive Elimination of H₂,” Biochemistry57 (2018): 701-710.

[33] T. Wu, W. Fan, Y. Zhang, and F. Zhang, “Electrochemical Synthesis of Ammonia: Progress and Challenges,” Materials Today Physics16 (2021): 100310.

[34] L. Tian, J. Zhao, X. Ren, X. Sun, Q. Wei, and D. Wu, “MoS₂-Based Catalysts for N₂ Electroreduction to NH₃—An Overview of MoS₂ Optimization Strategies,” ChemistryOpen10 (2021): 1041-1054.

[35] Y. Liu, X. Zhu, Q. Zhang, et al., “Engineering Mo/Mo₂C/MoC Heterointerfaces for Enhanced Electrocatalytic Nitrogen Reduction,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A8 (2020): 8920-8926.

[36] X. Yang, F. Ling, J. Su, et al., “Insights Into the Role of Cation Vacancy for Significantly Enhanced Electrochemical Nitrogen Reduction,” Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy264 (2020): 118477.

[37] L. Li, W. Yu, W. Gong, et al., “Sulfur-induced Electron Redistribution of Single Molybdenum Atoms Promotes Nitrogen Electroreduction to Ammonia,” Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy321 (2023): 122038.

[38] L. Zhang, X. Ji, X. Ren, et al., “Electrochemical Ammonia Synthesis via Nitrogen Reduction Reaction on a MoS₂ Catalyst: Theoretical and Experimental Studies,” Advanced Materials30 (2018): 1800191.

[39] H. Fei, R. Liu, J. Wang, et al., “Targeted Modulation of Competitive Active Sites Toward Nitrogen Fixation via Sulfur Vacancy Engineering Over MoS 2,” Advanced Functional Materials33 (2023): 2302501.

[40] H. Fei, T. Guo, Y. Xin, et al., “Sulfur Vacancy Engineering of MoS₂ via Phosphorus Incorporation for Improved Electrocatalytic N₂ Reduction to NH₃,” Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy300 (2022): 120733.

[41] Z. Feng, G. Li, X. Wang, et al., “FeS2/MoS2@RGO Hybrid Materials Derived from Polyoxomolybdate-Based Metal-Organic Frameworks as High-Performance Electrocatalyst for Ammonia Synthesis Under Ambient Conditions,” Chemical Engineering Journal445 (2022): 136797.

[42] X. Li, T. Li, Y. Ma, et al., “Boosted Electrocatalytic N₂ Reduction to NH₃ by Defect-Rich MoS₂ Nanoflower,” Advanced Energy Materials8 (2018): 1801357.

[43] G. Lin, Q. Ju, X. Guo, et al., “Intrinsic Electron Localization of Metastable MoS₂ Boosts Electrocatalytic Nitrogen Reduction to Ammonia,” Advanced Materials33 (2021): 2007509.

[44] H. Cheng, L. X. Ding, G. F. Chen, L. Zhang, J. Xue, and H. J. A. M. Wang, “Molybdenum Carbide Nanodots Enable Efficient Electrocatalytic Nitrogen Fixation Under Ambient Conditions,” Advanced Materials30 (2018): 1803694.

[45] Y. Ma, T. Yang, H. Zou, et al., “Synergizing Mo Single Atoms and Mo₂C Nanoparticles on CNTs Synchronizes Selectivity and Activity of Electrocatalytic N₂ Reduction to Ammonia,” Advanced Materials32 (2020): 2002177.

[46] Y. Wan, Z. Wang, J. Li, and R. Lv, “Mo₂C-MoO₂ Heterostructure Quantum Dots for Enhanced Electrocatalytic Nitrogen Reduction to Ammonia,” ACS Nano16 (2022): 643-654.

[47] C. Zhang, Z. Wang, J. Lei, L. Ma, B. I. Yakobson, and J. M. Tour, “Atomic Molybdenum for Synthesis of Ammonia with 50% Faradic Efficiency,” Small18 (2022): 2106327.

[48] U. Baeck, D. N. Nguyen, M. Choi, et al., “Boosting Hole Migration through Oxygen Species–Functionalized Graphene Interlayer for Organic-Based Optoelectronic Devices With Enhanced Efficiency and Long-Term Durability,” Applied Surface Science615 (2023): 156383.

[49] D. N. Nguyen, T. K. C. Phu, J. Kim, et al., “Interfacial Strain-Modulated Nanospherical Ni₂P by Heteronuclei-Mediated Growth on Ti₃C₂ T_X MXene for Efficient Hydrogen Evolution,” Small18 (2022): 2204797.

[50] B. Fang, X. Wang, S. Zhang, et al., “Boosting Electrochemical Nitrogen Fixation via Regulating Surface Electronic Structure by CeO₂ Hybridization,” Small20 (2024): 2310268.

[51] E. Skúlason, T. Bligaard, S. Gudmundsdóttir, et al., “A Theoretical Evaluation of Possible Transition Metal Electro-catalysts for N₂ Reduction,” Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics14 (2012): 1235-1245.

[52] H. Q. Xie, X. Zheng, Q. Y. Feng, et al., “Single-Step Synthesis of Fe−Fe₃O₄ Catalyst for Highly Efficient and Selective Electrochemical Nitrogen Reduction,” Chemsuschem15 (2022): e202200919.

[53] X. Zhu, J. Zhao, L. Ji, et al., “FeOOH Quantum Dots Decorated Graphene Sheet: An Efficient Electrocatalyst for Ambient N₂ Reduction,” Nano Research13 (2020): 209-214.

[54] H. Zhu, X. Ren, X. Yang, X. Liang, A. Liu, and G. Wu, “Fe-Based Catalysts for Nitrogen Reduction Toward Ammonia Electrosynthesis under Ambient Conditions,” SusMat2 (2022): 214-242.

[55] H. Du, C. Yang, W. Pu, L. Zeng, and J. Gong, “Enhanced Electrochemical Reduction of N2 to Ammonia over Pyrite FeS2 With Excellent Selectivity,” ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering8 (2020): 10572-10580.

[56] J. Li, S. Chen, F. Quan, et al., “Accelerated Dinitrogen Electroreduction to Ammonia via Interfacial Polarization Triggered by Single-Atom Protrusions,” Chemistry (Weinheim An Der Bergstrasse, Germany)6 (2020): 885-901.

[57] M. Wang, S. Liu, T. Qian, et al., “Over 56.55% Faradaic Efficiency of Ambient Ammonia Synthesis Enabled by Positively Shifting the Reaction Potential,” Nature Communications10 (2019): 341.

[58] M. I. Ahmed, L. J. Arachchige, Z. Su, D. B. Hibbert, C. Sun, and C. Zhao, “Nitrogenase-Inspired Atomically Dispersed Fe–S–C Linkages for Improved Electrochemical Reduction of Dinitrogen to Ammonia,” ACS Catalysis12 (2022): 1443-1451.

[59] Y. Wang, W. Cheng, P. Yuan, et al., “Boosting Nitrogen Reduction to Ammonia on FeN₄ Sites by Atomic Spin Regulation,” Advancement of Science8 (2021): 2102915.

[60] X. Wang, Y. Zhao, L. Wang, et al., “Regulating the Electronic Configuration of Supported Iron Nanoparticles for Electrochemical Catalytic Nitrogen Fixation,” Advanced Functional Materials32 (2022): 2111733.

[61] R. Zhao, G. Wang, Y. Mao, et al., “Li-intercalation Boosted Oxygen Vacancies Enable Efficient Electrochemical Nitrogen Reduction on Ultrathin TiO₂ Nanosheets,” Chemical Engineering Journal430 (2022): 133085.

[62] T. Wu, W. Kong, Y. Zhang, et al., “Greatly Enhanced Electrocatalytic N₂ Reduction on TiO₂ via V Doping,” Small Methods3 (2019): 1900356.

[63] H. Chen, T. Wu, X. Li, et al., “Modulating Oxygen Vacancies of TiO₂ Nanospheres by Mn-Doping to Boost Electrocatalytic N₂ Reduction,” ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering9 (2021): 1512-1517.

[64] Y. Wen, J. Liu, F. Zhang, et al., “Mesoporous MnO₂ Nanosheets for Efficient Electrocatalytic Nitrogen Reduction via High Spin Polarization Induced by Oxygen Vacancy,” Nano Research16 (2023): 4664-4670.

[65] J. Kang, X. Chen, R. Si, et al., “Activating Bi p-Orbitals in Dispersed Clusters of Amorphous BiO_X for Electrocatalytic Nitrogen Reduction,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition62 (2023): e202217428.

[66] I. Goyal, N. C. Kani, S. A. Olusegun, et al., “Metal Nitride as a Mediator for the Electrochemical Synthesis of NH₃,” ACS Energy Letters9 (2024): 4188-4195.

[67] J. Long, S. Chen, Y. Zhang, et al., “Direct Electrochemical Ammonia Synthesis From Nitric Oxide,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition59 (2020): 9711-9718.

[68] Z. Ren, H. Zhang, S. Wang, B. Huang, Y. Dai, and W. Wei, “Nitric Oxide Reduction Reaction for Efficient Ammonia Synthesis on Topological Nodal-Line Semimetal Cu₂ Si Monolayer,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A10 (2022): 8568-8577.

[69] J. Meng, C. Cheng, Y. Wang, Y. Yu, and B. Zhang, “Carbon Support Enhanced Mass Transfer and Metal-Support Interaction Promoted Activation for Low-Concentrated Nitric Oxide Electroreduction to Ammonia,” Journal of the American Chemical Society146 (2024): 10044-10051.

[70] L. Zhang, J. Liang, Y. Wang, et al., “High-Performance Electrochemical NO Reduction into NH₃ by MoS₂ Nanosheet,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition133 (2021): 25467-25472.

[71] G. Meng, M. Jin, T. Wei, et al., “MoC Nanocrystals Confined in N-doped Carbon Nanosheets Toward Highly Selective Electrocatalytic Nitric Oxide Reduction to Ammonia,” Nano Research15 (2022): 8890-8896.

[72] T. Muthusamy, S. Sethuram Markandaraj, and S. Shanmugam, “Nickel Nanoparticles Wrapped in N-Doped Carbon Nanostructures for Efficient Electrochemical Reduction of NO to NH₃,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A10 (2022): 6470-6474.

[73] D. Dhanabal, S. S. Markandaraj, and S. Shanmugam, “Transition Metal Nanoparticle-Embedded Nitrogen-Doped Carbon Nanorods as an Efficient Electrocatalyst for Selective Electroreduction of Nitric Oxide to Ammonia,” ACS Catalysis13 (2023): 9136-9149.

[74] J. Liang, H. Chen, T. Mou, et al., “Coupling Denitrification and Ammonia Synthesis via Selective Electrochemical Reduction of Nitric Oxide over Fe₂O₃ Nanorods,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A10 (2022): 6454-6462.

[75] G. Meng, T. Wei, W. Liu, et al., “NiFe Layered Double Hydroxide Nanosheet Array for High-Efficiency Electrocatalytic Reduction of Nitric Oxide to Ammonia,” Chemical Communications58 (2022): 8097-8100.

[76] V. Rosca, M. Duca, M. T. de Groot, and M. T. M. Koper, “Nitrogen Cycle Electrocatalysis,” Chemical Reviews109 (2009): 2209-2244.

[77] T. Hu, C. Wang, M. Wang, C. M. Li, and C. Guo, “Theoretical Insights Into Superior Nitrate Reduction to Ammonia Performance of Copper Catalysts,” ACS Catalysis11 (2021): 14417-14427.

[78] G.-F. Chen, Y. Yuan, H. Jiang, et al., “Electrochemical Reduction of Nitrate to Ammonia via Direct Eight-Electron Transfer Using a Copper–Molecular Solid Catalyst,” Nature Energy5 (2020): 605-613.

[79] Y. Wang, W. Zhou, R. Jia, Y. Yu, and B. Zhang, “Unveiling the Activity Origin of a Copper-Based Electrocatalyst for Selective Nitrate Reduction to Ammonia,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition59 (2020): 5350-5354.

[80] T. K. C. Phu, W. T. Hong, H. Han, et al., “Conformal Surface Intensive Doping of Low-Valence Bi on Cu₂O for Highly Efficient Electrochemical Nitrate Reduction to Ammonia Production,” Materials Today76 (2024): 52-63.

[81] K. Fan, W. Xie, J. Li, et al., “Active Hydrogen Boosts Electrochemical Nitrate Reduction to Ammonia,” Nature Communications13 (2022): 7958.

[82] Z.-Y. Wu, M. Karamad, X. Yong, et al., “Electrochemical Ammonia Synthesis via Nitrate Reduction on Fe Single Atom Catalyst,” Nature Communications12 (2021): 2870.

[83] S. Zhang, J. Wu, M. Zheng, et al., “Fe/Cu Diatomic Catalysts for Electrochemical Nitrate Reduction to Ammonia,” Nature Communications14 (2023): 3634.

[84] Y. Lee, J. Theerthagiri, N. Yodsin, et al., “Mitigating Intraphase Catalytic-Domain Transfer via CO₂ Laser for Enhanced Nitrate-to-Ammonia Electroconversion and Zn-Nitrate Battery Behavior,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition63 (2024): e202413774.

[85] L. Zhou, X. Chen, S. Zhu, et al., “Two-Dimensional Cu Plates With Steady Fluid Fields for High-Rate Nitrate Electroreduction to Ammonia and Efficient Zn-Nitrate Batteries,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition63 (2024): e202401924.

[86] J. Kim, Y. E. Kim, M. Je, et al., “A Conformal Titanyl Phosphate Amorphous Overlayer for Enhancing Photoelectrochemical Hydrogen Peroxide Production,” Journal of Energy Chemistry86 (2023): 399-408.

[87] W. Ye, M. Arif, X. Fang, M. A. Mushtaq, X. Chen, and D. Yan, “Efficient Photoelectrochemical Route for the Ambient Reduction of N₂ to NH₃ Based on Nanojunctions Assembled from MoS₂ Nanosheets and TiO₂,” ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces11 (2019): 28809-28817.

[88] X. Li, W. Fan, D. Xu, J. Ding, H. Bai, and W. Shi, “Boosted Photoelectrochemical N₂ Reduction over Mo₂C In Situ Coated With Graphitized Carbon,” Langmuir36 (2020): 14802-14810.

[89] M. A. Mushtaq, M. Arif, X. Fang, et al., “Photoelectrochemical Reduction of N₂ to NH₃ Under Ambient Conditions Through Hierarchical MoSe₂ @G-C₃N₄ Heterojunctions,” Journal of Materials Chemistry A9 (2021): 2742-2753.

[90] T. He, S. K. Matta, and A. Du, “Single Tungsten Atom Supported on N-Doped Graphyne as a High-Performance Electrocatalyst for Nitrogen Fixation Under Ambient Conditions,” Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics21 (2019): 1546-1551.

[91] M. A. Mushtaq, A. Kumar, G. Yasin, et al., “3D Interconnected Porous Mo-Doped WO3@CdS Hierarchical Hollow Heterostructures for Efficient Photoelectrochemical Nitrogen Reduction to Ammonia,” Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy317 (2022): 121711.

[92] S. Wang, L. Shi, X. Bai, Q. Li, C. Ling, and J. Wang, “Highly Efficient Photo-/Electrocatalytic Reduction of Nitrogen into Ammonia by Dual-Metal Sites,” ACS Central Science6 (2020): 1762-1771.

[93] W. Wang, S. Zhang, Y. Liu, et al., “Integration of Fe₂O₃-based Photoanode and Atomically Dispersed Cobalt Cathode for Efficient Photoelectrochemical NH₃ Synthesis,” Chinese Chemical Letters32 (2021): 805-810.

[94] Y. J. Jang, A. E. Lindberg, M. A. Lumley, and K.-S. Choi, “Photoelectrochemical Nitrogen Reduction to Ammonia on Cupric and Cuprous Oxide Photocathodes,” ACS Energy Letters5 (2020): 1834-1839.

[95] F. Xu, F. Wu, K. Zhu, et al., “Boron Doping and High Curvature in Bi Nanorolls for Promoting Photoelectrochemical Nitrogen Fixation,” Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy284 (2021): 119689.

[96] Y. Bai, H. Bai, K. Qu, et al., “In-Situ Approach to Fabricate BiOI Photocathode with Oxygen Vacancies: Understanding the N₂ Reduced Behavior in Photoelectrochemical System,” Chemical Engineering Journal362 (2019): 349-356.

[97] S. Sethuram Markandaraj, T. Muthusamy, and S. Shanmugam, “Electrochemical Reduction of Nitric Oxide With 1.7% Solar-to-Ammonia Efficiency Over Nanostructured Core-Shell Catalyst at Low Overpotentials,” Advancement of Science9 (2022): 2201410.

[98] L. Chen, D. Shen, B. Li, et al., “The Efficient Electrocatalytic and Photocatalytic Reduction of Nitric Oxide Into Ammonia Over 0D/3D G-C₃N₄ Quantum Dots/3DOMM-TiO_2-x Heterojunction,” Ceramics International49 (2023): 23129-23139.

[99] N. C. Kani, A. Prajapati, and M. R. Singh, “Sustainable Routes for Photo-Electrochemical Synthesis of Ammonia Using Various Nitrogen Precursors,” ACS ES&T Engineering2 (2022): 1080-1087.

[100] H. E. Kim, D. H. Wi, J. S. Lee, and K.-S. Choi, “Photoelectrochemical Nitrate and Nitrite Reduction Using Cu₂O Photocathodes,” ACS Energy Letters9 (2024): 1993-1999.

[101] H. Liu, J. Park, Y. Chen, et al., “Electrocatalytic Nitrate Reduction on Oxide-Derived Silver With Tunable Selectivity to Nitrite and Ammonia,” ACS Catalysis11 (2021): 8431-8442.

[102] J. Ding, Y. Lyu, H. Zhou, et al., “Efficiently Unbiased Solar-to-Ammonia Conversion by Photoelectrochemical Cu/C/Si-TiO₂ Tandems,” Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy345 (2024): 123735.

[103] F. Wang, Q. Ding, J. Ding, Y. Bai, H. Bai, and W. Fan, “Frustrated Lewis Pairs Boosting Photoelectrochemical Nitrate Reduction Over ZnIn₂S₄/BiVO₄ Heterostructure,” Chemical Engineering Journal450 (2022): 138260.

[104] F. Wang, Q. Ding, Y. Bai, H. Bai, S. Wang, and W. Fan, “Fabrication of an Amorphous Metal Oxide/p-BiVO 4 Photocathode: Understanding the Role of Entropy for Reducing Nitrate to Ammonia,” Inorganic Chemistry Frontiers9 (2022): 805-813.

[105] S. Zhou, K. Sun, J. Huang, et al., “Accelerating Electron-Transfer and Tuning Product Selectivity Through Surficial Vacancy Engineering on CZTS/CdS for Photoelectrochemical CO₂ Reduction,” Small17 (2021): 2100496.

[106] C. Yan, J. Huang, K. Sun, et al., “Cu₂ZnSnS₄ Solar Cells With Over 10% Power Conversion Efficiency Enabled by Heterojunction Heat Treatment,” Nature Energy3 (2018): 764-772.

[107] S. Zhou, K. Sun, C. Y. Toe, et al., “Engineering a Kesterite-Based Photocathode for Photoelectrochemical Ammonia Synthesis from NO X Reduction,” Advanced Materials34 (2022): 2201670.

[108] M. Xu, F. Xu, K. Zhu, et al., “Atomic Layer Deposition Technique Refining Oxygen Vacancies in TiO₂ Passivation Layer for Photoelectrochemical Ammonia Synthesis,” Composites Communications29 (2022): 101037.

[109] N. C. Kani, J. A. Gauthier, A. Prajapati, et al., “Solar-Driven Electrochemical Synthesis of Ammonia Using Nitrate With 11% Solar-to-fuel Efficiency at Ambient Conditions,” Energy & Environmental Science14 (2021): 6349-6359.

[110] K. Chu, Y.-P. Liu, Y.-B. Li, Y.-L. Guo, and Y. Tian, “Two-dimensional (2D)/2D Interface Engineering of a MoS₂/C₃N₄ Heterostructure for Promoted Electrocatalytic Nitrogen Fixation,” ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces12 (2020): 7081-7090.

[111] Y. Liu, Y. Luo, Q. Li, J. Wang, and K. Chu, “Bimetallic MnMoO₄ with Dual-Active-Centers for Highly Efficient Electrochemical N₂ Fixation,” Chemical Communications56 (2020): 10227-10230.

[112] G. Peng, J.-W. Zhao, J. Wang, et al., “Crystal Structures of Molybdenum Borides Dictate Electrocatalytic Ammonia Synthesis Efficiency,” Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy338 (2023): 123020.

[113] Y. Wang, X. Cui, J. Zhao, et al., “Rational Design of Fe–N/C Hybrid for Enhanced Nitrogen Reduction Electrocatalysis under Ambient Conditions in Aqueous Solution,” ACS Catalysis9 (2019): 336-344.

[114] X. Yang, Y. Tian, S. Mukherjee, et al., “Constructing Oxygen Vacancies via Engineering Heterostructured Fe₃C/Fe₃O₄ Catalysts for Electrochemical Ammonia Synthesis,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition62 (2023): e202304797.

[115] M. Guo, L. Fang, L. Zhang, et al., “Pulsed Electrocatalysis Enabling High Overall Nitrogen Fixation Performance for Atomically Dispersed Fe on TiO₂,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition62 (2023): e202217635.

[116] B. Yan, S. Hu, C. Bu, et al., “TiO₂ /CeO₂ Frame With Enriched Oxygen Vacancies and Hetero-Interfaces for Efficient Electrochemical N₂ Reduction,” Chemcatchem15 (2023): e202300076.

[117] J. Kang, X. Chen, R. Si, et al., “Activating Bi p- Orbitals in Dispersed Clusters of Amorphous BiO_X for Electrocatalytic Nitrogen Reduction,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition135 (2023): e202217428.

[118] B. H. Ko, B. Hasa, H. Shin, Y. Zhao, and F. Jiao, “Electrochemical Reduction of Gaseous Nitrogen Oxides on Transition Metals at Ambient Conditions,” Journal of the American Chemical Society144 (2022): 1258-1266.

[119] Z. Wu, Y. Liu, D. Wang, et al., “Cu@Co with Dilatation Strain for High-Performance Electrocatalytic Reduction of Low-Concentration Nitric Oxide,” Advanced Materials36 (2024): 2309470.

[120] X. Fu, X. Zhao, X. Hu, et al., “Alternative Route for Electrochemical Ammonia Synthesis by Reduction of Nitrate on Copper Nanosheets,” Applied Materials Today19 (2020): 100620.

[121] J. Wang, C. Cai, Y. Wang, et al., “Electrocatalytic Reduction of Nitrate to Ammonia on Low-Cost Ultrathin CoO_X Nanosheets,” ACS Catalysis11 (2021): 15135-15140.

[122] Y. Jia, Y.-G. Ji, Q. Xue, et al., “Efficient Nitrate-to-Ammonia Electroreduction at Cobalt Phosphide Nanoshuttles,” ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces13 (2021): 45521-45527.

[123] Y. Wang, L. Zhang, Y. Niu, et al., “Boosting NH₃ Production From Nitrate Electroreduction via Electronic Structure Engineering of Fe 3C Nanoflakes,” Green Chemistry23 (2021): 7594-7608.

[124] X. Fan, L. Xie, J. Liang, et al., “In Situ Grown Fe₃O₄ Particle on Stainless Steel: A Highly Efficient Electrocatalyst for Nitrate Reduction to Ammonia,” Nano Research15 (2022): 3050-3055.

[125] R. Jia, Y. Wang, C. Wang, Y. Ling, Y. Yu, and B. Zhang, “Boosting Selective Nitrate Electroreduction to Ammonium by Constructing Oxygen Vacancies in TiO₂,” ACS Catalysis10 (2020): 3533-3540.

[126] F. Lei, W. Xu, J. Yu, et al., “Electrochemical Synthesis of Ammonia by Nitrate Reduction on Indium Incorporated in Sulfur Doped Graphene,” Chemical Engineering Journal426 (2021): 131317.

[127] Y. Liu, H. Bai, Q. Zhang, et al., “In-Situ Decoration of Unsaturated Cu Sites on Cu₂O Photocathode for Boosting Nitrogen Reduction Reaction,” Chemical Engineering Journal413 (2021): 127453.

[128] Y. Bai, J. Lu, H. Bai, et al., “Understanding the Key Role of Vanadium in p-type BiVO4 for Photoelectrochemical N₂ Fixation,” Chemical Engineering Journal414 (2021): 128773.

[129] D. Liu, S. Peng, L. Qiao, et al., “Rational Design of Cocatalyst for Highly Improved Ammonia Production from Photoelectrochemical Nitrate Reduction,” Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy351 (2024): 123980.

[130] H. Bai, F. Wang, Q. Ding, et al., “Construction of Frustrated Lewis Pair Sites in CeO₂–C/BiVO₄ for Photoelectrochemical Nitrate Reduction,” Inorganic Chemistry62 (2023): 2394-2403.

[131] X. Li, W. Fan, Y. Bai, et al., “Photoelectrochemical Reduction of Nitrate to Ammonia Over CuPc/CeO2 Heterostructure: Understanding the Synergistic Effect Between Oxygen Vacancies and Ce Sites,” Chemical Engineering Journal433 (2022): 133225.

[132] J. Chen, H. Ren, K. Wu, et al., “Boosting Hydrogen Production of Ammonia Decomposition via the Construction of Metal-Oxide Interfaces,” Chinese Journal of Structural Chemistry43 (2024): 100236.

[133] K. Ogasawara, M. Miyazaki, K. Miyashita, et al., “Ammonia Decomposition Over Water-Durable Hexagonal BaTiO₃−XN_y-Supported Ni Catalysts,” Advanced Energy Materials13 (2023): 2301286.

[134] Z. Cao and L. Fan, “Functional Biological Anode as Electron Acceptor for Direct Oxidation of Ammonia Nitrogen to N2 in an Anaerobic Single-Chamber Reactor,” Journal of Cleaner Production382 (2023): 135413.

[135] S. Kalyuzhnyi, M. Gladchenko, A. Mulder, and B. Versprille, “DEAMOX—New Biological Nitrogen Removal Process Based on anaerobic Ammonia Oxidation Coupled to Sulphide-Driven Conversion of Nitrate Into Nitrite,” Water Research40 (2006): 3637-3645.

[136] R. Rohani, I. I. Yusoff, N. Khairul Zaman, et al., “Ammonia Removal From Raw Water by Using Adsorptive Membrane Filtration Process,” Separation and Purification Technology270 (2021): 118757.

[137] V. Cechetto, L. Di Felice, J. A. Medrano, C. Makhloufi, J. Zuniga, and F. Gallucci, “H2 Production via Ammonia Decomposition in a Catalytic Membrane Reactor,” Fuel Processing Technology216 (2021): 106772.

[138] V. Cechetto, C. L. Struijk, L. Di Felice, A. W. N. de Leeuw den Bouter, and F. Gallucci, “Adsorbents Development for Hydrogen Cleanup from Ammonia Decomposition in a Catalytic Membrane Reactor,” Chemical Engineering Journal455 (2023): 140762.

[139] S. Guida, C. Potter, B. Jefferson, and A. Soares, “Preparation and Evaluation of Zeolites for Ammonium Removal From Municipal Wastewater through Ion Exchange Process,” Scientific Reports10 (2020): 12426.

[140] M. E. Mugwili, F. B. Waanders, V. Masindi, and E. Fosso-Kankeu, “Effective Removal of Ammonia From Aqueous Solution Through Struvite Synthesis and Breakpoint Chlorination: Insights Into the Synergistic Effects of the Hybrid System,” Journal of Environmental Management334 (2023): 117506.

[141] Y. Ji, J. Bai, J. Li, et al., “Highly Selective Transformation of Ammonia Nitrogen to N₂ Based on a Novel Solar-Driven Photoelectrocatalytic-Chlorine Radical Reactions System,” Water Research125 (2017): 512-519.

[142] Y. Wu, W. Tian, Y. Zhang, et al., “Nanobubble Technology Enhanced Ozonation Process for Ammonia Removal,” Water14 (2022): 1865.

[143] T.-L. Chen, L.-H. Chen, Y. J. Lin, C.-P. Yu, H.-W. Ma, and P.-C. Chiang, “Advanced Ammonia Nitrogen Removal and Recovery Technology Using Electrokinetic and Stripping Process Towards a Sustainable Nitrogen Cycle: A Review,” Journal of Cleaner Production309 (2021): 127369.

[144] J. H. Cho, J. Ma, and S. Y. Kim, “Toward High-Efficiency Photovoltaics-Assisted Electrochemical and Photoelectrochemical CO₂ Reduction: Strategy and Challenge,” Exploration3 (2023): 20230001.

[145] M. J. Bezdek, S. Guo, and P. J. Chirik, “Coordination-Induced Weakening of Ammonia, Water, and Hydrazine X–H Bonds in a Molybdenum Complex,” Science354 (2016): 730-733.

[146] R. Chen, R. Wang, X. Lu, et al., “NH3 to H2, Exploration from Pyrolytic Key Materials to Device Structure Design,” Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry134 (2024): 1-16.

[147] N. J. Bunce and D. Bejan, “Mechanism of Electrochemical Oxidation of Ammonia,” Electrochimica Acta56 (2011): 8085-8093.

[148] J. Łuczak and M. Lieder, “Nickel-Based Catalysts for Electrolytic Decomposition of Ammonia Towards Hydrogen Production,” Advances in Colloid and Interface Science319 (2023): 102963.

[149] P. Gao, “Progress of Ammonia Electro-oxidation Catalysts for Direct Ammonia Alkaline Fuel Cells,” Highlights in Science, Engineering and Technology43 (2023): 340-349.

[150] V. Rosca and M. T. M. Koper, “Electrocatalytic Oxidation of Ammonia on Pt(111) and Pt(100) Surfaces,” Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics8 (2006): 2513.

[151] Y. Tian, Z. Mao, L. Wang, and J. Liang, “Green Chemistry: Advanced Electrocatalysts and System Design for Ammonia Oxidation,” Small Structures4 (2023): 2200266.

[152] X. Xi, Y. Fan, K. Zhang, et al., “Carbon-Free Sustainable Energy Technology: Electrocatalytic Ammonia Oxidation Reaction,” Chemical Engineering Journal435 (2022): 134818.

[153] J. Yao, M. Zhou, D. Wen, Q. Xue, and J. Wang, “Electrochemical Conversion of Ammonia to Nitrogen in Non-Chlorinated Aqueous Solution by Controlling pH Value,” Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry776 (2016): 53-58.

[154] A. J. Medford, A. Vojvodic, J. S. Hummelshøj, et al., “From the Sabatier Principle to a Predictive Theory of Transition-Metal Heterogeneous Catalysis,” Journal of Catalysis328 (2015): 36-42.

[155] T. Lan, Y. Zhao, J. Deng, J. Zhang, L. Shi, and D. Zhang, “Selective Catalytic Oxidation of NH 3 over Noble Metal-Based Catalysts: State of the Art and Future Prospects,” Catalysis Science & Technology10 (2020): 5792-5810.

[156] L. Li, L. Zhao, Z. Ma, C. Li, J. Duan, and W. Wang, “Ce_0.5Zr_0.5O₂ Solid Solutions Supported Co-Ni Catalyst for Ammonia Oxidative Decomposition to Hydrogen,” Chemical Engineering Journal475 (2023): 146355.

[157] Y. Song, H. Li, M. Xu, et al., “Infiltrated NiCo Alloy Nanoparticle Decorated Perovskite Oxide: A Highly Active, Stable, and Antisintering Anode for Direct-Ammonia Solid Oxide Fuel Cells,” Small16 (2020): 2001859.

[158] Q. Su, L. Gu, Y. Yao, et al., “Layered Double Hydroxides Derived Nix(MgyAlzOn) Catalysts: Enhanced Ammonia Decomposition by Hydrogen Spillover Effect,” Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy201 (2017): 451-460.

[159] F. He, Q. Gao, Z. Liu, et al., “A New Pd Doped Proton Conducting Perovskite Oxide with Multiple Functionalities for Efficient and Stable Power Generation From Ammonia at Reduced Temperatures,” Advanced Energy Materials11 (2021): 2003916.

[160] Y.-J. Shih, Y.-H. Huang, and C. P. Huang, “In-Situ Electrochemical Formation of Nickel Oxyhydroxide (NiOOH) on Metallic Nickel Foam Electrode for the Direct Oxidation of Ammonia in Aqueous Solution,” Electrochimica Acta281 (2018): 410-419.

[161] R. Wang, H. Liu, K. Zhang, G. Zhang, H. Lan, and J. Qu, “Ni(II)/Ni(III) Redox Couple Endows Ni Foam-Supported Ni2P With Excellent Capability for Direct Ammonia Oxidation,” Chemical Engineering Journal404 (2021): 126795.

[162] C. E. Myers, H. F. Franzen, and J. W. Anderegg, “X-Ray Photoelectron Spectra and Bonding in Transition-Metal Phosphides,” Inorganic Chemistry24 (1985): 1822-1824.

[163] C. Jo, S. Surendran, M.-C. Kim, et al., “Meticulous Integration of N and C Active Sites in Ni2P Electrocatalyst for Sustainable Ammonia Oxidation and Efficient Hydrogen Production,” Chemical Engineering Journal463 (2023): 142314.

[164] Y. Zhang, D. Ma, Y. Lei, et al., “Markedly Enhanced Hydrogen Production in Wastewater via Ammonia-Mediated Metal Oxyhydroxides Active Sites on Bifunctional Electrocatalysts,” Nano Energy117 (2023): 108896.

[165] W. Wan, Y. Zhao, S. Wei, et al., “Mechanistic Insight Into the Active Centers of Single/Dual-Atom Ni/Fe-Based Oxygen Electrocatalysts,” Nature Communications12 (2021): 5589.

[166] J. Fu, J. Dong, R. Si, et al., “Synergistic Effects for Enhanced Catalysis in a Dual Single-Atom Catalyst,” ACS Catalysis11 (2021): 1952-1961.

[167] H. Zhang, H. Wang, L. Zhou, et al., “Efficient and Highly Selective Direct Electrochemical Oxidation of Ammonia to Dinitrogen Facilitated by NiCu Diatomic Site Catalysts,” Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy328 (2023): 122544.

[168] W. Xu, D. Du, R. Lan, et al., “Electrodeposited NiCu Bimetal on Carbon Paper as Stable Non-Noble Anode for Efficient Electrooxidation of Ammonia,” Applied Catalysis B: Environment and Energy237 (2018): 1101-1109.

[169] M. Zhu, Y. Yang, S. Xi, et al., “Deciphering NH₃ Adsorption Kinetics in Ternary Ni–Cu–Fe Oxyhydroxide Toward Efficient Ammonia Oxidation Reaction,” Small17 (2021): 2005616.

[170] M. Zhang, H. Li, X. Duan, et al., “An Efficient Symmetric Electrolyzer Based on Bifunctional Perovskite Catalyst for Ammonia Electrolysis,” Advancement of Science8 (2021): 2101299.

[171] Y. Feng, L. Huang, Z. Xiao, et al., “Temporally Decoupled Ammonia Splitting by a Zn–NH₃ Battery With an Ammonia Oxidation/Hydrogen Evolution Bifunctional Electrocatalyst as a Cathode,” Journal of the American Chemical Society146 (2024): 7771-7778.

[172] M. Zhang, P. Zou, G. Jeerh, B. Sun, M. Walker, and S. Tao, “Oxygen Vacancy-Rich La_0.5 Sr_1.5 Ni_0.9 Cu_0.1 O_4–δ as a High-Performance Bifunctional Catalyst for Symmetric Ammonia Electrolyzer,” Advanced Functional Materials32 (2022): 2204881.

[173] T. Elysabeth, K. Mulia, M. Ibadurrohman, E. L. Dewi, and Slamet, “A Comparative Study of CuO Deposition Methods on Titania Nanotube Arrays for Photoelectrocatalytic Ammonia Degradation and Hydrogen Production,” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy46 (2021): 26873-26885.

[174] C. Yan and L. Liu, “Sn-Doped V2O5 Nanoparticles as Catalyst for Fast Removal of Ammonia in Air via PEC and PEC-MFC,” Chemical Engineering Journal392 (2020): 123738.

[175] F. Li, L. Sun, Y. Liu, et al., “A ClO -Mediated Photoelectrochemical Filtration System for Highly-Efficient and Complete Ammonia Conversion,” Journal of Hazardous Materials400 (2020): 123246.

[176] Y. Qu, X. Song, X. Chen, X. Fan, and G. Zhang, “Tuning Charge Transfer Process of MoS2 Photoanode for Enhanced Photoelectrochemical Conversion of Ammonia in Water Into Gaseous Nitrogen,” Chemical Engineering Journal382 (2020): 123048.

[177] Y. Zhang, Y. Ji, J. Li, et al., “Efficient Ammonia Removal and Toxic Chlorate Control by Using BiVO₄/WO₃ Heterojunction Photoanode in a Self-Driven PEC-Chlorine System,” Journal of Hazardous Materials402 (2021): 123725.

[178] L. Wu, D. Tang, J. Xue, et al., “Competitive Non-Radical Nucleophilic Attack Pathways for NH₃ Oxidation and H₂O Oxidation on Hematite Photoanodes,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition61 (2022): e202214580.

[179] L. Wu, Q. Li, K. Dang, et al., “Highly Selective Ammonia Oxidation on BiVO₄ Photoanodes Co-Catalyzed by Trace Amounts of Copper Ions,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition63 (2024): e202316218.

[180] L. Wu, Q. Li, K. Dang, et al., “Highly Selective Ammonia Oxidation on BiVO₄ Photoanodes Co-Catalyzed by Trace Amounts of Copper Ions,” Angewandte Chemie International Edition136 (2024): e202316218.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2025 The Author(s). Exploration published by Henan University and John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd.